Uvalde DA sues Border Patrol to allow agents to testify in Robb Elementary case
The Brief
Uvalde DA files suit to get Border Patrol agents to testify
DA says agents' testimony is "essential" in cases against former Uvalde CISD officers
Pete Arredondo, Adrian Gonzales charged with multiple counts of child endangerment
UVALDE, Texas - The Uvalde District Attorney is suing the U.S. Border Patrol in an effort to get agents to testify in criminal cases related to the May 2022 mass shooting at Robb Elementary.
What we know
Christina Mitchell, the district attorney for the 38th Judicial District, filed the suit on May 9 in the US District Court for the Western District of Texas.
The lawsuit asks for judgment and relief under the Administrative Procedure Act to get the U.S. Customs and Border Protection to allow three agents to testify in the trials of former police chief Pete Arredondo and officer Adrian Gonzales with Uvalde CISD.
Arredondo and Gonzales are both facing multiple counts of felony child endangerment related to their actions during the shooting.
In the filing, DA Mitchell says that the three agents' testimony is "essential to the pending Texas criminal prosecution", as two of them participated in killing the gunman and the third was present in the hallway during most of the incident.
The filing also says that the request is the "culmination of District Attorney Mitchell's good faith efforts to reasonably accommodate the CBP," adding that 188 Border Patrol employees were involved in the response and that the DA had initially asked for the cooperation of 18 of those employees.
Read the full lawsuit below:
Click to open this PDF in a new window.
Dig deeper
Arredondo and Gonzales were indicted by a grand jury in June 2024, more than two years after the shooting.
The indictment for Arredondo lists 10 counts of abandoning/endangering a child.
Each count named a child survivor. The indictment claims Arredondo, "by act and omission, intentionally, knowingly, recklessly and with criminal negligence," placed the children in "imminent danger of bodily injury, death, physical impairment and mental impairment."
The indictment accuses Arredondo of failing to identify the incident as an active shooter situation, instead calling SWAT which caused delays. The indictment also claims he failed to follow the active shooter plan developed by the school district by not establishing a command center and by prioritizing evacuation of students over stopping the shooter.
READ MORE: New details for arrests of Pete Arredondo, another former Uvalde school officer
Arredondo attempted to have the charges thrown out, claiming he was improperly charged and has been scapegoated for the botched response.
Gonzales, who was among the first officers to arrive at the scene, has been indicted on 29 counts of abandoning or endangering a child. He is accused of abandoning his training and not confronting the shooter, even after hearing gunshots as he stood in a hallway.
Each charge against Gonzales and Arredondo carries up to two years in jail if convicted. Both have pled not guilty.
The backstory
The shooting at Robb Elementary was one of the worst school shootings in United States history.
The Department of Justice released a nearly 600-page report detailing the 'cascading failures' by law enforcement on May 24, 2022.
READ MORE: 'I don't want to die,' student tells 911 dispatcher from Uvalde school during mass shooting
Nearly 150 U.S. Border Patrol agents, 91 state police officers, school and city police responded to the scene, but waited for 77 minutes before entering the classroom and killing the 18-year-old shooter.
The report talked about the vast array of problems, from failed communication and leadership, to the inadequate training and technology used by police.
READ MORE: Uvalde marks one year since deadly Robb Elementary mass shooting
A private investigator hired by the city cleared Uvalde city police of missteps. Austin-based investigator Jesse Prado presented his findings and stated the department did not commit any wrongdoing or violate any policy.
Several families of Uvalde victims have filed federal and state lawsuits against law enforcement, social media and online gaming companies and the gun manufacturer that made the rifle the gunman used.
Uvalde City Council recently approved a $2 million settlement with the families of the victims. As a part of the agreement, city leaders promised higher standards and "enhanced training" for current and future police, as well as a memorial to the victims, resources to support mental health and the upkeep of the children's graves.
19 Robb Elementary students were killed in the shooting.
Xavier Javier Lopez, 10
Amerie Jo Garza, 10
Uziyah Garcia, 8
Rojelio Torres, 10
Annabell Guadalupe Rodriguez, 10
Nevaeh Bravo, 10
Makenna Lee Elrod, 10
Eliahana 'Elijah Cruz' Torres, 10
Eliana 'Ellie' Garcia, 9
Alithia Ramirez, 10
Jacklyn "Jackie" Cazares, 9
Jayce Carmelo Luevanos, 10
Jailah Nicole Silguero, 11
Jose Flores Jr, 10
Alexandria "Lexi" Aniyah Rubio, 10
Maite Yuleana Rodriguez, 10
Tess "Tessy" Marie Mata, 10
Maranda Gail Mathis, 11
Layla Salazar, 10
Fourth-grade co-teachers 48-year-old Irma Garcia and 44-year-old Eva Mireles were also killed. Family members said at the time that both died trying to protect their students.
The Source
Information in this report comes from court paperwork and previous reporting by FOX 7 Austin.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
2 hours ago
- Fox News
2 arrested at LA home linked to Iranian 'human smuggling hub': CBP
Federal officials arrested two people on Friday at a Los Angeles house tied to a suspected Iranian human smuggling network said to have been "repeatedly used to harbor illegal entrants linked to terrorism." Customs and Border Protection (CBP) announced the arrests in an X post on Friday, saying that the operation was part of a broader national security effort involving multiple federal agencies. "CBP executed a federal search warrant today at a human smuggling hub in Los Angeles tied to national security threats," the agency said. "Two individuals were arrested during the operation, which was led by CBP's Special Response Team with support from Border Patrol tactical units and Air and Marine Operations." The detentions follow the arrests of seven Iranian nationals at the same location earlier last week, CBP said, adding that the suspects were on the FBI Terror Watchlist and connected to an Iranian human trafficking hub. "The location has been repeatedly used to harbor illegal entrants linked to terrorism," CBP said. Officials did not identify the two suspects taken into custody at the home on Friday. "Under @POTUS, CBP is taking aggressive action to shut down smuggling networks and remove national security threats before they can do harm," the agency said. CBP did not immediately respond to a request for more information from Fox News Digital.
Fox News
a day ago
- Fox News
2 arrested at LA home linked to Iranian 'human smuggling hub': CBP
Federal officials arrested two people on Friday at a Los Angeles house tied to a suspected Iranian human smuggling network said to have been "repeatedly used to harbor illegal entrants linked to terrorism." Customs and Border Protection (CBP) announced the arrests in an X post on Friday, saying that the operation was part of a broader national security effort involving multiple federal agencies. "CBP executed a federal search warrant today at a human smuggling hub in Los Angeles tied to national security threats," the agency said. "Two individuals were arrested during the operation, which was led by CBP's Special Response Team with support from Border Patrol tactical units and Air and Marine Operations." The detentions follow the arrests of seven Iranian nationals at the same location earlier last week, CBP said, adding that the suspects were on the FBI Terror Watchlist and connected to an Iranian human trafficking hub. "The location has been repeatedly used to harbor illegal entrants linked to terrorism," CBP said. Officials did not identify the two suspects taken into custody at the home on Friday. "Under @POTUS, CBP is taking aggressive action to shut down smuggling networks and remove national security threats before they can do harm," the agency said. CBP did not immediately respond to a request for more information from Fox News Digital.
Boston Globe
2 days ago
- Boston Globe
Government wants to execute Teresa Youngblut after Vermont shooting that killed border agent, her lawyer says
The government holds Youngblut responsible in the death of a US border agent and for that, her lawyer disclosed on Tuesday, the government wants to execute her. At 21, Youngblut is the youngest and probably most unlikely known member of what appears to be Advertisement The members are called Zizians, after its purported leader, Steven Barth, Youngblut's public defender, said in US District Court in Burlington that federal death penalty charges will be lodged against his client in what he called 'short order.' He declined to elaborate when surrounded by reporters after Tuesday's routine hearing, a position of 'no comment' he has maintained since Youngblut first appeared in court in January, days after her companion, Felix Bauckholt, and Border Patrol agent David 'Chris' Maland died in a hail of gunfire that the government says began when Youngblut drew a gun after a traffic stop and started firing. Advertisement The apparent decision by federal prosecutors to seek the death penalty against Youngblut isn't a surprise. In a February memo announcing the moratorium against seeking federal death penalty charges under the Biden administration was over, Attorney General Youngblut was wounded in the gunfire, which began after Border Patrol agents pulled over the car she was driving on Interstate 91 in Vermont's Northeast Kingdom, about 10 miles south of the Canadian border. The government says Bauckholt, a German national who identified as female and went by the name of Ophelia, began drawing a weapon but was shot dead by an agent before she could fire. So far, Youngblut has been charged with using a firearm while 'assaulting, resisting and opposing, impeding, intimidating, and interfering with a US Border Patrol agent while he was engaged in official duties.' The government's charging document also charges that Youngblut 'carried, brandished and discharged a firearm.' But, to date, prosecutors have not explicitly said Youngblut fired the shot that killed Maland. Last month, officials from US Customs and Border Protection released a The summary said the lone agent who returned fire discharged 'approximately eight rounds.' So far, the government has remained tight-lipped about whether Youngblut shot Maland. Advertisement But that distinction won't make a difference if the government moves to seek the death penalty, according to David P. Hoose, a Massachusetts attorney who has worked on 17 death penalty cases, 15 of them federal and most of them in New England. Hoose, a partner at Strehorn, Ryan & Hoose in Northampton, said that in If, for argument's sake, prosecutors can't definitively assert that Youngblut fired the fatal shot, Hoose said, 'it creates additional hurdles for prosecutors and maybe some qualms in a juror looking for a reason not to give the death penalty.' As for finding jurors in mostly liberal Vermont willing to sentence someone to death, that's another potential hurdle for prosecutors, Hoose said. Vermont last executed someone in 1954, and the state outlawed capital punishment in 1972. Polls show most Vermonters oppose capital punishment. The US attorney's office in Vermont, which is prosecuting Youngblut, has said it was Youngblut's parents have attended their daughter's hearings, but have declined to speak to reporters. Last year, they Advertisement They seemed to be onto something. Records show Youngblut and Maximilian Snyder, who Like other members of the Zizian cult, Youngblut and Snyder, 22, who attended the University of Oxford, were good students with bright futures that were extinguished shortly after they got involved in the cult. Now they both face the prospect of landing on death row. Prosecutors in California are It seems the road from the comforts of affluence and privilege and one of the best high schools in the country to death row is not as long as one might think. Squeaky Fromme, who tried to kill a president, was released from prison after 34 years. Teresa Youngblut faces bleaker prospects. Kevin Cullen is a Globe columnist. He can be reached at
