'Marking the close' explained in 5 points: Trick inside Jane Street's alleged manipulation playbook
Group LLC, a US-based global proprietary trading powerhouse, which allegedly manipulated the Indian derivatives market, employed a strategy called 'Marking the close' on the Nifty index options.
Here is a 5-point explainer on how this strategy works and why it is illegal:
1)
Any option contract has an underlying stock, and its premium moves with the price of the underlying stock. For Instance, HDFC Bank's CALL option premium will rise if the stock price of HDFC Bank rises while its PUT option premium will rise with a fall in its price.
2)
The logic can be extended to the index options, too. For instance, if the Nifty index moves higher, then the Nifty CALL option premium increases and the same is the case with the Bank Nifty. For index options, the underlying is the index itself, which in turn is a basket of stocks.
3)
How Options premiums work
Option premiums are calculated based on stock/index's current price vis-a-vis the strike price. Strike price is the price at which you exercise the option.
So Premiums are high when they are at-the-money or in-the-money.
-- In-the-money (ITM) call option:
Current price is higher than strike price
-- In-the-money put option -
Current price is lower than strike price
-- At-the-money (ATM) call/put option:
Current price is close to strike price
4)
On expiry days, OTM (Out of the Money) options are cheap because they are likely to expire worthless. ATM options are most volatile because they near the strike price and anything can happen. But for ITM options, they are fully loaded and available at a premium.
Read More:
Sebi may widen Jane Street probe to other indices, exchanges: Report
For an options trader, the catch lies in the transition of premiums if he can buy a cheap OTM option for 50 paisa or a rupee and then watch it grow to Rs 10, 20 or even 100 in a matter of a few hours. Traders with deep pockets can make this possible and Jane Street's deep pockets seem to have that kind of money.
5)
On the expiry day, you buy all the cheap Index OTM options on one hand and on the other hand, you either buy or sell the index underlying constituents to an extent where the options start to move in your favor. Sophisticated traders can do it by just buying or selling heavyweight stocks of the index.
Traders can buy all the cheap options before 3 pm and after that, they can accordingly make orders worth crores of rupees in the heavyweight stocks.
It can be done through algorithms which know the exact quantity, price and time, which makes computation of the expiry closing price easy, as the closing price is the weighted average of the last 30 minutes.
The algorithms know the closing price which in turn makes your position favourable.
Also Read:
Jane Street Fallout: Zerodha's Nithin Kamath flags risk to brokers and stock exchanges
Why is it illegal?
Market regulator Sebi holds this as an unfair, deceptive, and manipulative practice that violates its norms.
Sebi's 105-page order holds that Jane Street made unlawful gains through this. Jane Street has refuted these allegations and has said that it will engage with the regulators.
(
Disclaimer
: Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of Economic Times)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
Trade unions forum calls for Bharat Bandh against govt policies tomorrow
A forum of 10 central trade unions and their associates has called for a 'Bharat Bandh' on Wednesday to oppose the 'anti-worker, anti-farmer and anti-national pro-corporate policies of the government'. The forum on Monday said preparations for the bandh have been taken up in earnest by unions in all sectors of formal and informal/unorganised economy. 'More than 25 crore workers are expected to take part in the strike. Farmers and rural workers will also join the protest across the country,' said Amarjeet Kaur from All India Trade Union Congress (AITUC). Harbhajan Singh Sidhu from Hind Mazdoor Sabha (HMS) said banking, postal, coal mining, factories and state transport services will be affected due to the strike. Apart from AITUC, Indian National Trade Union Congress (INTUC), HMS, Centre of Indian Trade Unions (CITU), All India United Trade Union Centre (AIUTUC), Trade Union Coordination Centre (TUCC), Self Employed Women's Association (SEWA), All India Central Council of Trade Unions (AICCTU), Labour Progressive Federation (LPF) and United Trade Union Congress (UTUC) are part of the forum. In a statement, the workers' union forum said it had last year submitted a charter of 17 demands to Labour Minister Mansukh Mandaviya.. It alleged that the government has not been conducting the annual labour conference for the last 10 years and continues to take decisions in contravention to the interest of labour force, attempting to impose the four new labour codes to weaken collective bargaining, to cripple union activities and to favour employers in the name of 'ease of doing business'. The forum also alleged that the economic policies are resulting in increased unemployment, rising prices of essentials, decrease in wages, cut in social sector spending in education, health, basic civic amenities, and all these are leading to more inequalities and miseries for poor, people of lower income group as well as the middle class. 'The government has abandoned the welfare state status of the country. It is working in the interest of foreign and Indian corporates, and it is evident from the policies being pursued vigorously,' said the forum. Referring to the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls in Bihar, the forum said: 'The attack on democratic rights continues more vigorously by this ruling regime and now the attempt to de-franchise the migrant workers is being designed, beginning with Bihar as an immediate case. The misuse of constitutional bodies is rampant to suppress voices of opposition, the enactments in some states to control and criminalise mass movements is on the cards; the Public Security Bill in Maharashtra and similar enactments in the state of Chhattisgarh, Madhya Pradesh etc are the pointers. Now the attempt to snatch citizenship is on the cards.' Trade unions have been fighting against 'privatisation of public sector enterprises and public services, policies of outsourcing, contractorisation and casualisation of workforce', it said. The four labour codes that have been passed by Parliament are meant to 'suppress and cripple the trade union movement, increase working hours, snatch workers' right to collective bargaining, right to strike, and decriminalise violation of labour laws by employers', the statement said. The Samyukta Kisan Morcha and joint front of agricultural workers unions have extended support to the July 9 banch call and decided to make massive mobilsations in rural India, the union leaders said. Trade unions had earlier observed similar nationwide strikes on November 26, 2020, March 28-29, 2022 and on February 16 last year.
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
Rahul Gandhi questions govt silence on ‘manipulation' by Jane Street
Lok Sabha Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi on Monday accused the Central government of making the rich richer and pushing ordinary investors to the brink of ruin by being silent on 'manipulation' by big players in the futures and options (F&O) market. Gandhi said he had predicted the loopholes in the F&O market. 'I clearly said in 2024 — the F&O market has become a playground for 'big players', and small investors' pockets are continuously being drained,' he said. 'Now SEBI itself is admitting that Jane Street manipulated thousands of crores. Why did SEBI remain silent for so long? At whose behest was the Modi government sitting with its eyes closed? And how many more big sharks are still shorting retail investors? In every case, it's clear — the Modi government is making the rich richer and pushing ordinary investors to the brink of ruin,' Gandhi said in a post on X. He tagged a September 24, 2024 post in which he had said: 'Uncontrolled F&O trading has grown 45x in 5 years. 90% of small investors have lost Rs 1.8 lakh crore in three years.' 'SEBI must reveal the names of the so-called 'Big Players' making a killing at their expense,' he said. Reacting to Gandhi's post, the BJP accused the Congress MP of 'peddling fear and misinformation' about the stock market. BJP IT department head Amit Malviya said the very action of SEBI banning a global entity, 'which Gandhi is trying to sensationalise', is clear evidence that strong regulatory action is being taken to protect small investors. If SEBI were silent, as Gandhi claims, then there would be no investigation, no ban, and no headline; his entire allegation collapses right there, Malviya said. Congress media and publicity chief Pawan Khera alleged corruption in the market and said SEBI has to answer a lot of questions. On Thursday, SEBI ordered the impounding of `4,843.57 crore in alleged unlawful gains made by Jane Street through manipulative trading. The market regulator also prohibited the firm from engaging in any securities transactions until the recovery of the alleged illegal gains is completed.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Capgemini acquires WNS for $3.3bn to scale up expertise
Bengaluru: India's French connection is growing stronger. French IT services firm Capgemini, which has more than half of its 3.4 lakh employees in India, is acquiring one of the country's business process management (BPM) pioneers, WNS, for $3.3 billion. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The move is seen as an attempt to bring strong technology expertise, especially AI, into BPM services to be able to offer enterprises much more comprehensive solutions. This acquisition comes a decade after Capgemini acquired Igate, another India-based IT company, for $4 billion. The WNS deal underscores India's growing importance in Capgemini's global strategy. Over 44,000 of WNS' 65,000 employees are based in India. WNS, founded in 1996 and which is listed on the New York Stock Exchange, counts United Airlines, Aviva, M&T Bank, Centrica and McCain Foods among its key customers. It was initially established as a captive business process and back-office unit of British Airways. In 2002, Warburg Pincus acquired a majority stake, leading to WNS becoming an independent entity. WNS will add $1.2 billion to Capgemini's revenue of about 22.1 billion euro last fiscal. The two together will have an operating margin of about 13.6%. Capgemini will acquire WNS for a cash consideration of $76.5 per share, reflecting a premium of 17% over the closing price on July 3. Explaining the rationale of the acquisition, Capgemini CEO Aiman Ezzat said enterprises are rapidly adopting generative AI and agentic AI to transform their operations end-to-end, and business process services will be the showcase for agentic AI. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The acquisition, he said, will "provide the group with the scale and vertical sector expertise to capture that rapidly emerging strategic opportunity created by the paradigm shift from traditional BPS to agentic AI-powered Intelligent Operations. " Keshav R Murugesh, CEO of WNS, said, "By combining our deep domain and process expertise with Capgemini's global reach, cutting-edge GenAI and agentic AI capabilities, a robust partner ecosystem, and advanced technology platforms, we are creating a powerful proposition that accelerates enterprise reinvention. WNS' complementary portfolio of horizontal and industry-specific solutions will significantly enhance Capgemini's rapidly growing business services footprint, enabling next-generation, data-driven operations across sectors. " WNS has delivered an average constant currency revenue growth of over 9% over the past three fiscal years, reaching $1.2 billion in revenue in the 2025 financial year with an operating margin of 18.7%. The transaction will position Capgemini as one of the key players in digital BPS. With combined digital BPS revenues of 1.9 billion in 2024, Capgemini will be better equipped to support clients in their end-to-end business and technology transformation journeys. WNS also helps Capgemini expand more into the US and UK. Currently, about 51% of its revenue comes from Continental Europe. Phil Fersht, CEO of IT consulting firm HfS Research, said that from a competitive perspective, another potential big win for Capgemini is its new positioning against the Big 4 (Deloitte, PwC, EY, and KPMG), which have traditionally dominated consulting and technology services. "With WNS's operational expertise integrated into its offerings, Capgemini could deliver end-to-end transformation services that the Big 4 cannot – and at lower price points. In some cases, like procurement services, Capgemini acquires a well-established strategic sourcing capability built on WNS's 2017 Denali acquisition, strengthening Capgemini's F&A and procurement capabilities." Fersht said he would expect Murugesh to stay in the company in the short term to work on the transition with Capgemini leadership, but it may eventually opt to turn to the vast BPO leadership of Kevin Campbell, who recently joined Capgemini through the Syniti acquisition. "Campbell was one of the original pioneers of merging BPO and IT services when he led that function during Accenture's growth years," Fersht noted. Ramkumar Ramamoorthy, partner in Catalincs and former Cognizant India CMD, said the acquisition is a profound validation of how much technology is front-and-centre for the reimagination of business operations and processes, more so in the context of generative AI and agentic AI. "While traditional IT companies have organically built their BPO businesses to several billions of dollars in revenue, specialist BPO companies have struggled to build out their technology capabilities. In many cases, even acquisitions have not come to their rescue," he said. Capgemini anticipates achieving revenue synergies in the range of 100 million to 140 million on a run-rate basis by 2027 end.
