
'Marking the close' explained in 5 points: Trick inside Jane Street's alleged manipulation playbook
Group LLC, a US-based global proprietary trading powerhouse, which allegedly manipulated the Indian derivatives market, employed a strategy called 'Marking the close' on the Nifty index options.
Here is a 5-point explainer on how this strategy works and why it is illegal:
1)
Any option contract has an underlying stock, and its premium moves with the price of the underlying stock. For Instance, HDFC Bank's CALL option premium will rise if the stock price of HDFC Bank rises while its PUT option premium will rise with a fall in its price.
2)
The logic can be extended to the index options, too. For instance, if the Nifty index moves higher, then the Nifty CALL option premium increases and the same is the case with the Bank Nifty. For index options, the underlying is the index itself, which in turn is a basket of stocks.
3)
How Options premiums work
Option premiums are calculated based on stock/index's current price vis-a-vis the strike price. Strike price is the price at which you exercise the option.
So Premiums are high when they are at-the-money or in-the-money.
-- In-the-money (ITM) call option:
Current price is higher than strike price
-- In-the-money put option -
Current price is lower than strike price
-- At-the-money (ATM) call/put option:
Current price is close to strike price
4)
On expiry days, OTM (Out of the Money) options are cheap because they are likely to expire worthless. ATM options are most volatile because they near the strike price and anything can happen. But for ITM options, they are fully loaded and available at a premium.
Read More:
Sebi may widen Jane Street probe to other indices, exchanges: Report
For an options trader, the catch lies in the transition of premiums if he can buy a cheap OTM option for 50 paisa or a rupee and then watch it grow to Rs 10, 20 or even 100 in a matter of a few hours. Traders with deep pockets can make this possible and Jane Street's deep pockets seem to have that kind of money.
5)
On the expiry day, you buy all the cheap Index OTM options on one hand and on the other hand, you either buy or sell the index underlying constituents to an extent where the options start to move in your favor. Sophisticated traders can do it by just buying or selling heavyweight stocks of the index.
Traders can buy all the cheap options before 3 pm and after that, they can accordingly make orders worth crores of rupees in the heavyweight stocks.
It can be done through algorithms which know the exact quantity, price and time, which makes computation of the expiry closing price easy, as the closing price is the weighted average of the last 30 minutes.
The algorithms know the closing price which in turn makes your position favourable.
Also Read:
Jane Street Fallout: Zerodha's Nithin Kamath flags risk to brokers and stock exchanges
Why is it illegal?
Market regulator Sebi holds this as an unfair, deceptive, and manipulative practice that violates its norms.
Sebi's 105-page order holds that Jane Street made unlawful gains through this. Jane Street has refuted these allegations and has said that it will engage with the regulators.
(
Disclaimer
: Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of Economic Times)
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Hindustan Times
27 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
ICC appoints Sanjog Gupta as its new CEO
Indian media mogul Sanjog Gupta was on Monday named the new Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the Jay Shah-led International Cricket Council (ICC), replacing Australian Geoff Allardice, who stepped down before the Champions Trophy earlier this year citing personal reasons. ICC appoints Sanjog Gupta as its new CEO.(Disney Star) Gupta, who was serving as the CEO (Sports & Live Experiences) at JioStar, will be taking charge of his new role with immediate effect. He will be the seventh CEO of the ICC, which said it received more than 2,500 applications from 25 countries from which 12 candidates were shortlisted. "Candidates ranged from leaders associated with sport's governing bodies to senior corporate executives from across sectors," the ICC said. The names were forwarded to the Nominations Committee comprising ICC deputy chairman Imran Khwaja, ECB chairman Richard Thompson, SLC president Shammi Silva and BCCI secretary Devajit Saikia. They recommended Gupta for the role which was approved by ICC chairman Jay Shah. "Sanjog Gupta has been a driving force behind the transformation of sports broadcasting in India and globally," the ICC said. The governing body also noted Gupta's role in establishing and expanding other leagues such as the Pro Kabaddi League and the Indian Super League (football) while promoting global events like Premier League and Wimbledon. "Sanjog has played a pivotal role in shaping the continued growth of marquee Cricket properties such as ICC events & IPL, establishing domestic sports leagues like PKL and ISL, furthering the popularity of global sporting events such as Premier League and Wimbledon and scaling the business across consumer and commercial objectives," it said. Shah said Gupta's experience in sports strategy and commercialisation will be vital for the ICC. "Sanjog brings extensive experience in sports strategy and commercialisation, which will be invaluable for the ICC," he said. "His deep understanding of the global sports as well as M&E landscape combined with his continued curiosity about the cricket fan's perspective and passion for technology will prove essential in our ambition to grow the game in the coming years." Gupta succeeds Allardice who had quit in January this year after a four-year tenure. It was widely speculated that the 57-year-old Allardice's decision to leave was triggered, in major part, by the ICC Board's unhappiness with his failure to present a "clear picture" of Pakistan's lack of preparedness to host the Champions Trophy. Gupta said he is looking forward to contributing to the next phase of cricket. He began his career as journalist and joined Star India (now JioStar) in 2010. Over the years, he held multiple leadership roles in content, programming and strategy before becoming Head of Sports at Disney and Star India in 2020. Gupta was appointed CEO of JioStar Sports in November 2024 following the merger of Viacom18 and Disney Star. The post of ICC's CEO has been previously held by David Richards, Malcolm Speed and Allardice from Australia, David Richardson and Haroon Lorgat from South Africa and Indian-born Manu Sawhney.


Economic Times
36 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Tariff worries, Trump's BRICS swipe spark worst rupee fall in three weeks
The Indian rupee slumped on Monday as uncertainty about U.S. tariff policies resurfaced with President Donald Trump's threat of a fresh 10% levy on BRICS countries compounding pressure on the local currency alongside peers like South African rand and Chinese yuan. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads The Indian rupee slumped on Monday as uncertainty about U.S. tariff policies resurfaced with President Donald Trump 's threat of a fresh 10% levy on BRICS countries compounding pressure on the local currency alongside peers like South African rand and Chinese over U.S. trade policies dented risk sentiment across the board, pushing Asian currencies and equities into the red while U.S. equity futures pointed to a weak return from the long rupee had declined to a low of 86.0275 per U.S. dollar during the session but pared losses to close at 85.85 per U.S. dollar, down 0.5% on the day, its worst performance since mid-June, when it traded in the shadow of a military conflict between Israel and a social media post, President Donald Trump said the U.S. would start delivering tariff letters from 12:00 pm ET (1600 GMT) on a separate post, he rolled out a wholly new tariff policy, calling for countries "aligning themselves with the Anti-American policies" of the BRICS developing nations to be charged an extra 10% tariff, with no exceptions to be was not immediately clear if Trump's tariff threat would derail trade talks with India and other BRICS nations. The South African rand fell 1% after Trump's threat while the offshore Chinese yuan was down 0.2%.The absence of progress on trade negotiations over the weekend has come as a negative surprise for markets with Trump's BRICS remark especially hurting the rupee, said Dilip Parmar, a foreign exchange research analyst at HDFC expects the Reserve Bank of India to step in to support the rupee if volatility remains elevated due to uncertainty on U.S. trade the day, traders also pointed to strong dollar demand from a large local private bank which pressured the local currency.A fall below the 85.80 level triggered stop-losses and accentuated the day's move, a trader at a state-run bank said. He expects the currency to weaken to 86.50 in the near-term in the absence of positive developments on the trade front.


Economic Times
36 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Stock market update: Nifty Realty index advances 0.08%
NEW DELHI: The Nifty Realty index closed on a positive note on Monday. ADVERTISEMENT Shares of Brigade Enterprises Ltd.(up 1.71 per cent), Prestige Estates Projects Ltd.(up 1.09 per cent), Macrotech Developers Ltd.(up 0.68 per cent) and Phoenix Mills Ltd.(up 0.48 per cent) ended the day as top gainers in the pack. On the other hand, Raymond Ltd.(down 1.39 per cent), Oberoi Realty Ltd.(down 1.35 per cent), Anant Raj Ltd.(down 0.59 per cent), DLF Ltd.(down 0.42 per cent) and Sobha Ltd.(down 0.26 per cent) finished as the top losers of the day. The Nifty Realty index closed 0.08 per cent up at 972.75. Benchmark NSE Nifty50 index ended up 0.3 points at 25461.3, while the BSE Sensex stood up 9.61 points at 83442.5. Among the 50 stocks in the Nifty index, 22 ended in the green, while 28 closed in the red. ADVERTISEMENT Shares of JP Power, PC Jeweller, RattanIndia Power, Vodafone Idea and YES Bank were among the most traded shares on the NSE. Shares of J G Chemicals, PC Jeweller, Laxmi Goldorna House, Zota Healthcare and Sirca Paints hit their fresh 52-week highs in today's trade, while Dreamfolks Services, Sadhana Nitro, SKIL Infrastructure, Stampede Cap(DVR)and Globe Civil Projects hit their fresh 52-week lows. ADVERTISEMENT (You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel)