logo
Libya's broken healthcare system drives locals to migrate

Libya's broken healthcare system drives locals to migrate

Time of India5 days ago
AP Image
Libya's healthcare crisis has a sad, new face. It is that of a tired 7-year-old girl, Sohan Aboulsoud, who suffers from cystic fibrosis, an inherited genetic disorder. Her family couldn't get treatment for Sohan in Libya so they decided to dare the oft-deadly, illicit journey by boat to Italy in search of help on June 25.
When Sohan's mother, Khawla Nail, shared the photo of her exhausted daughter on a smuggler's boat online, it went viral on social media and was picked up by a number of media outlets.
A day later, dozens of families with children who also suffer from cystic fibrosis protested in the Libyan city of Tripoli. They demanded access to medication and the creation of diagnostic centers in Libya. The lack of such services threatens lives, they said.
Since the overthrow of Libyan dictator Muammar Gaddafi in 2011, Libya has been stuck in political chaos. Since 2014, Libya has been split in two, with opposing governments located in the east and west of the country. A UN-backed administration known as the Government of National Unity, or GNU, is based in Tripoli in the west — where Sohan's family is from. Its rival, known as the House of Representatives, is based in the east, in Tobruk.
At various times over the last decade, each government has tried — and failed — to wrest control from the other.
The ensuing instability has impacted the country's healthcare system so that advanced hospitals are not being built and certain medicines are scarce or unavailable. In December 2021, a report by the World Health Organization found that in the southern and eastern regions of Libya, about a third of all facilities were "not functional," while 73 percent and 47 percent respectively were "partially functional."
Libyan families desperate
For the past seven years, Sohan's family has paid for private lab tests in neighboring Tunisia and ordered medication through private pharmacies. Without this medication, Sohan would not have been able to survive until today.
"I submitted her file to the Libyan health authorities more than once but the response was always, there's no budget," Sohan's mother told DW. "Everything was expensive, complicated and beyond our reach.
And I watched my daughter's condition deteriorate before my eyes. We exhausted every option for help in Libya."
According to documents obtained by DW, more than 60 Libyan families have officially submitted requests to the Libyan Ministry of Health asking for cystic fibrosis treatment, a life-threatening illness that impacts the lungs, the digestive system and other organs. The documents include names and national ID numbers.
Mahmoud Abu Dabbous, head of the National Organization for Organ Donation Support in Libya, said that Sohan's family was not the first that decided to risk the perilous journey, to Europe in search of healthcare. "It is a grave indicator of Libya's failure to meet basic health needs," Abu Dabbous said.
Around 10 days ago, Sohan, her mother and her stepfather boarded an overcrowded boat filled with Libyan families. "We didn't leave because we wanted to migrate, it was because illness doesn't wait," Sohan's mother said.
Many other irregular migrants are less successful on their journey from Libya or Tunisia toward Europe. According to the International Organization for Migration's Missing Migrants Project, more than 63,000 have died or have gone missing since 2014. The actual number is most likely significantly higher as reliable data is often unavailable.
Libyan government offers words, no action
Once the family had arrived on Italy's Lampedusa island, which is around 420 km (260 miles) by boat from Zuwara on Libya's western coast, a frequent launching point for smuggling operations, the family was housed in a shelter, one without air conditioning.
"Sohan's disease, cystic fibrosis, does not tolerate heat or dehydration, even a slight drop in fluids could send her into intensive care," her mother explained.
By then though Sohan's pictures had gone viral on social media, prompting Libya's GNU to issue a message saying it would cover the costs of the girl's treatment in Italy.
"But they only contacted us once, then everything stopped. No official has called since and no concrete steps have been taken," Sohan's mother told DW.
DW's attempts to contact the Libyan Ministry of Health for clarification were unsuccessful and at the time of publication, there had been no response.
That comes as no surprise to Tarik Lamloum, head of the Libyan human rights organization Beladi. In his experience, Libyan government support often ends after one initial political comment. The GNU reaction didn't come" out of a sustained sense of responsibility," he told DW.
It was due to the social media furore, he speculated.
He's also worried that Sohan's story could provide a troublesome example for other families in similar stress. "One family already contacted me after the story went viral, asking about the journey's details and whether it could be repeated," he told DW. "Instead of glorifying a case in which a family had to cross the sea, the state should have provided care within the country," he concluded.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Nearly 800 Gazans killed in recent weeks seeking aid, says UN
Nearly 800 Gazans killed in recent weeks seeking aid, says UN

First Post

time5 hours ago

  • First Post

Nearly 800 Gazans killed in recent weeks seeking aid, says UN

Israel began easing a more than two-month total blockade of aid in late May. Since then, a new US- and Israel-backed organisation called the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) has effectively sidelined the territory's vast UN-led aid delivery network read more Women embrace, while mourning loved ones, during the funeral of Palestinians killed by Israeli fire yesterday, as they sought aid in northern Gaza, according to Gaza's health ministry, at Al-Shifa Hospital, in Gaza City. Reuters Ten Palestinians were reported killed Friday while waiting for rations in Gaza, adding to nearly 800 similar deaths in the last six weeks, according to the UN, with Israel's army saying it issued new instructions to troops following repeated reports of fatalities. Friday's reported violence came as negotiators from Israel and the Palestinian militant group Hamas were locked in indirect talks in Qatar to try to agree on a temporary ceasefire in the more than 21-month conflict. Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Thursday he hoped a deal for a 60-day pause in the war could be struck in the coming days, and that he would then be ready to negotiate a more permanent end to hostilities. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Hamas has said the free flow of aid is a main sticking point in the talks, with Gaza's more than two million residents facing a dire humanitarian crisis of hunger and disease amid the grinding conflict. Israel began easing a more than two-month total blockade of aid in late May. Since then, a new US- and Israel-backed organisation called the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) has effectively sidelined the territory's vast UN-led aid delivery network. There are frequent reports of Israeli forces firing on people seeking aid, with Gaza's civil defence agency saying 10 Palestinians were killed Friday while waiting at a distribution point near the southern city of Rafah. 'Unacceptable' The UN, which refuses to cooperate with GHF over concerns it was designed to cater to Israeli military objectives, said Friday that 798 people have been killed seeking aid between late May and July 7, including 615 'in the vicinity of the GHF sites'. 'Where people are lining up for essential supplies such as food and medicine, and where… they have a choice between being shot or being fed, this is unacceptable,' UN rights office spokeswoman Ravina Shamdasani told reporters in Geneva. Israel's military did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Friday's deaths, but has previously accused militants of firing at civilians in the vicinity of aid centres. Asked about the UN figures, the military said it had worked to minimise 'possible friction' between aid seekers and soldiers, and that it conducted 'thorough examinations' of incidents in which 'harm to civilians who arrived at distribution facilities was reported'. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'Instructions were issued to forces in the field following lessons learned,' it added in a statement. GHF called the UN report 'false and misleading', claiming that 'most deadly attacks on aid sites have been linked to UN convoys'. Mahmud Bassal, spokesman for Gaza's civil defence agency, told AFP that Israeli forces killed 45 people overall in the territory on Friday. Media restrictions in Gaza and difficulties accessing many areas mean AFP is unable to independently verify tolls and details provided by the agency and other parties. Truce talks In Gaza's south, a witness said Israeli tanks were seen near Khan Yunis, reporting 'intense gunfire, intermittent air strikes, artillery shelling, and ongoing bulldozing and destruction of displacement camps and agricultural land'. Israel's military said troops were operating in the area against 'terrorist infrastructure sites, both above and below ground'. Hamas has said that as part of a potential truce deal it was willing to release 10 of the hostages taken during its attack on Israel on October 7, 2023, which sparked the Gaza war. Netanyahu, who is under pressure to end the war after mounting military losses, said that would leave 10 living hostages still in captivity. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'I hope we can complete it in a few days,' he said of the initial ceasefire agreement and hostage release in an interview with US outlet Newsmax. 'We'll probably have a 60-day ceasefire, get the first batch out, then use the 60-day ceasefire to negotiate an end to this.' Netanyahu has said that a key condition of any deal is that Hamas first gives up its weapons and its hold on Gaza, warning that failure to do so on Israel's terms would lead to further conflict. Another issue holding up a deal is disagreement on the number of Palestinian prisoners to be released in exchange for hostages, Foreign Minister Gideon Saar has said. Hamas has said it wants 'real guarantees' for a lasting truce and Israel's full withdrawal from Gaza, and that it opposes any Israeli moves to push Palestinians into 'isolated enclaves'. The group's 2023 attack on Israel led to the deaths of 1,219 people, most of them civilians, according to an AFP tally based on Israeli figures. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Out of 251 hostages seized in the attack, 49 are still held in Gaza, including 27 the Israeli military says are dead. At least 57,823 Palestinians, most of them civilians, have been killed since the start of the war, according to the health ministry in Hamas-run Gaza.

798 dead near Gaza aid centres in six weeks, says UN
798 dead near Gaza aid centres in six weeks, says UN

India Today

time8 hours ago

  • India Today

798 dead near Gaza aid centres in six weeks, says UN

The UN rights office said on Friday it had recorded at least 798 killings within the past six weeks at aid points in Gaza run by the US and Israeli-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation and near convoys run by other relief GHF uses private US security and logistics companies to get supplies into Gaza, largely bypassing a UN led system that Israel alleges has let Hamas-led militants loot aid shipments intended for civilians. Hamas denies the the deaths of hundreds of Palestinian civilians trying to reach the GHF's aid hubs in zones where Israeli forces operate, the United Nations has called its aid model "inherently unsafe" and a violation of humanitarian impartiality standards. "(From May 27) up until the seventh of July, we've recorded 798 killings, including 615 in the vicinity of the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation sites, and 183 presumably on the route of aid convoys," UN rights office (OHCHR) spokesperson Ravina Shamdasani told a media briefing in GHF, which began distributing food packages in Gaza in late May after Israel lifted an 11-week aid blockade, told Reuters the UN figures were "false and misleading". It denies that deadly incidents have occurred at its sites."The fact is the most deadly attacks on aid site have been linked to UN convoys," a GHF spokesperson said."Ultimately, the solution is more aid. If the UN (and) other humanitarian groups would collaborate with us, we could end or significantly reduce these violent incidents."The Israeli army told Reuters in a statement that it was reviewing recent mass casualties and that it had sought to minimise friction between Palestinians and the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) by installing fences and signs and opening additional WOUNDSThe OHCHR said it based its figures on sources such as information from hospitals in Gaza, cemeteries, families, Palestinian health authorities, NGOs and its partners on the of the injuries to Palestinians in the vicinity of aid distribution hubs recorded by the OHCHR since May 27 were gunshot wounds, Shamdasani said."We've raised concerns about atrocity crimes having been committed and the risk of further atrocity crimes being committed where people are lining up for essential supplies such as food," she the GHF assertion that the OHCHR figures are false and misleading, Shamdasani said: "It is not helpful to issue blanket dismissals of our concerns - what is needed is investigations into why people are being killed while trying to access aid."Israel has said its forces operate near the relief aid sites to prevent supplies falling into the hands of militants it has been fighting in the Gaza war triggered by the Hamas-led cross-border attack on October 7, GHF said on Friday it had delivered more than 70 million meals to Gaza Palestinians in five weeks, and that other humanitarian groups had "nearly all of their aid looted" by Hamas or criminal gangs. The UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs has previously cited instances of violent pillaging of aid, and the UN World Food Programme said last week that most trucks carrying food assistance into Gaza had been intercepted by "hungry civilian communities".There is an acute shortage of food and other basic supplies 21 months into Israel's military campaign in Gaza, during which much of the enclave has been reduced to rubble and most of its 2.3 million inhabitants displaced.- Ends

Gautam Adani Reveals Plans To Build AI-First Affordable Healthcare Ecosystem
Gautam Adani Reveals Plans To Build AI-First Affordable Healthcare Ecosystem

NDTV

time13 hours ago

  • NDTV

Gautam Adani Reveals Plans To Build AI-First Affordable Healthcare Ecosystem

Mumbai: Gautam Adani on Friday revealed plans to build an AI-first, multidisciplinary healthcare ecosystem that integrates affordability, scalability, and global best practices, as he shared his vision for transforming healthcare in India. Speaking at the 5th Annual Conference of the Society for Minimally Invasive Spine Surgery - Asia Pacific (SMISS-AP) in Mumbai, he called for a complete system-wide redesign to meet the needs of the future. Mr Adani, who heads the ports-to-energy conglomerate, said three years ago, on his 60th birthday, his family pledged Rs 60,000 crore towards healthcare, education, and skill development. "We did not enter healthcare because it lacked momentum. We entered because the momentum was not enough," he said. "The pace of change was out of step with the urgency of future demands. As the landscape unfolded, one truth stood out - healthcare does not need incremental upgrades. It needs a system-wide redesign. Not an evolution but a revolution rooted in intelligence as well as empathy." Citing low back pain as a leading cause of disability in India - a crisis more widespread than diabetes or heart disease - he said: "If we are to carry the full weight of our national ambition, we must first heal the spine of our people." He urged the assembled global gathering of spine surgeons and specialists to become not only medical leaders but nation-builders. Honoured to address the brilliant minds at the Annual Conference of the Society for Minimally Invasive Spine Surgery. To the world, they are spine surgeons. To their patients, they are something far greater. They restore dignity, hope and movement. And, in doing so, hold up the… — Gautam Adani (@gautam_adani) July 11, 2025 Referring to the previously announced Adani Healthcare Temples - large, 1,000-bed integrated medical campuses to be established first in Ahmedabad and Mumbai - Mr Adani said they would be "world-class, affordable, AI-first healthcare ecosystems" and would comprise "modular, scalable infrastructure of the kind that can expand rapidly in the face of pandemics or emergencies." He added that these campuses would serve as centres of excellence for clinical care, research and academic training, guided by the Mayo Clinic's global expertise in design, medical infrastructure and innovation. "We are here to build India's healthcare for tomorrow and a system that is integrated, intelligent, inclusive and inspired," he said. The industrialist laid out a vision for a future-ready healthcare system focused on five core principles - integrated care that breaks traditional silos, modular and scalable infrastructure, technologically enabled education with a focus on robotics and AI, stronger investment in nursing and paramedical training, and human-centric insurance models that prioritise patients over paperwork. Mr Adani also called upon medical entrepreneurs to explore bold new frontiers - from AI-powered spinal diagnostics to rural surgical units and global centres for robotic spinal care. "We are investing in modular, scalable infrastructure of the kind that can expand rapidly in the face of pandemics or emergencies. We are championing the creation of large, world-class healthcare institutes that bring together innovation, patient care, and applied learning under one roof," he said. He went on to stress that academic training must evolve. "So, our focus is on fostering doctors who not only heal but also lead with skills in robotics, AI, systems thinking, and healthcare management. Their education must go beyond anatomy to include empathy, ethics, and enterprise." Drawing on his own journey from diamond trading in Mumbai to building India's largest private port in Mundra, he said, "The spine you save today may belong to the engineer who builds tomorrow's bridges, the scientist who invents the next vaccine, or the entrepreneur who powers our next billion-dollar company." India's healthcare system has made significant strides in recent years, but formidable challenges persist. Government and WHO-aligned analysis shows India currently has just 20.6 doctors, nurses and midwives per 10,000 people - far below the WHO benchmark of 44.5 per 10,000. This shortage is compounded by a stark rural-urban imbalance - around 74 per cent of doctors practice in urban areas, leaving rural communities especially underserved. These gaps are reflected in overburdened clinics, rising out-of-pocket spending and reliance on unqualified providers in remote regions. Closing these gaps-and meeting India's universal health goals-demands more than incremental updates. It requires a full-scale redesign of how care is delivered, financed, staffed and scaled across diverse geographies. With a Rs 60,000 crore family commitment already pledged towards healthcare, education and skill development, the Adani Group's entry into healthcare is part of a broader national mission. "India cannot rise if her people cannot stand. And her people cannot stand without you," Mr Adani told the assembled specialists. "Let us build the backbone of a great nation."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store