Court rules Ace Magashule's assistant cannot be tried in asbestos case as her extradition is unlawful
Image: File
The Bloemfontein High Court ruled that former Free State premier Ace Magashule's personal assistant, Moroadi Cholota, cannot be tried in the R255 million asbestos case, as her extradition from the United States of America was unlawful.
Judge Philip Loubser on Tuesday found Cholota's extradition was unlawful due to the lack of a lawful extradition request by the South African executive. 'This court does not have the power to try you. You are free to leave,' the judge told Cholota.
Cholota was one of the 18 accused in the high-profile trial where the accused are facing a host of charges relating to alleged fraud, corruption, and money laundering. All of the accused had pleaded not guilty and vehemently denied any involvement in the allegations against them.
A trial-within-a-trial was held to establish whether Cholota's extradition was lawful after she had contested it by way of a special plea.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
The request for the extradition from the United States to South Africa was made by the Director of Public Prosecutions in the Free State.
The judge stated that this request was not lawfully executed and thus it is not valid. Cholota was studying in the United States at the time of her extradition.
The NPA, meanwhile, said it is studying the judgment.
zelda.venter@inl.co.za
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
28 minutes ago
- IOL News
South Africa's broken contract: Can the ANC rebuild public trust
THE African National Congress (ANC), once regarded as a beacon of hope and liberation, finds itself weathering a storm of public disillusionment, mounting discontent, and a profound crisis of trust. Scandals ebb and flow, snaring presidents and premiers, metro mayors and ward councillors, and a dizzying cast of tenderpreneurs and middlemen, argues the writer. SOUTH Africa stands on the precipice of a new political era. This is more than the familiar narrative of post-liberation disillusionment; the African National Congress (ANC), the once-mighty vehicle of emancipation and hope, now limps under the burden of mistrust, public anger, and existential doubt. The symptoms are everywhere: declining electoral fortunes, widespread cynicism, fractious leadership battles, and an unmistakable sense that the party's 'social contract' with the South African people lies in intensive care, some would say moments from flatlining. The stakes, for both the ANC and the nation, could not be higher. The language of social contract theory might feel abstract, but in the South African context, it is brutally tangible. The promise was that liberation would bring dignity, prosperity, and justice. Thirty years after the first democratic elections, those promises look hollow to millions still bravely enduring squalor, joblessness, and the daily humiliations of service failures. When the lights flicker out, taps run dry, or the police arrive three hours late, if at all. What contracts are those, if not between leaders and the led? But the contract is more than the sum of service delivery failures or even GDP figures. It was underpinned by trust: an ingrained belief, however often betrayed, that the ANC ultimately stood on the side of the people. Today, that trust is ruptured. Survey after survey shows confidence in the ANC and politicians in general, scraping historic lows. This is not regular attrition, the ebbing of natural support that occurs after the initial enthusiasm of liberation fades. It is a collapse profound enough that every word, every gesture, and every whispered rumour about an ANC leader is greeted with volcanic suspicion. One might hope that such an acute crisis would inspire humility and honest reckoning. Instead, a pattern has emerged: reflexive defensiveness, accusations of media conspiracy, endless references to 'due process,' and the worn tactic of whataboutism, the claim that 'we are no worse than the others.' Far from reassuring the public, these postures fan the flames of mistrust. From Parliament to press conferences and talk radio, the ANC's public defenders sound increasingly tone deaf, and at times, outright contemptuous of the public's anger. This defensiveness grows particularly sharp whenever corruption is raised, a tragically routine occurrence in our politics. Faced with a new scandal, the institutional reflex is to question the motives of accusers, cry foul at the timing, or trot out the tired line that 'no charges have been laid.' The word 'alleged' does a mountain of heavy lifting. Such postures might have sufficed in a bygone era, when the titanic legacy of struggle leaders shielded the party from day-to-day controversies. No longer. Today's South African public watches and listens, smartphones in hand and an ocean of cynicism in their hearts, interpreting every defensive press release as yet more evidence of rot. The more the ANC hides behind 'process,' the more the public perceives an instinct to protect itself, not the country. Let us be honest about the scale of the problem. Over three decades, almost every layer of party and state bureaucracy has been implicated. Scandals ebb and flow, snaring presidents and premiers, metro mayors and ward councillors, and a dizzying cast of tenderpreneurs and middlemen. From the arms deal to state capture, PPE looting, Eskom and Transnet heists to Nkandla, Phala Phala and now Constantia, the scale defies imagination. In province after province, ANC rhetoric about renewal grows stale as cadres survive 'stepping aside' periods only to return, emboldened, to looting perches. Many in the ANC's upper echelons object, 'not all of us are corrupt!' That is true. But it is also beside the point. Corruption does not require entire parties to be dirty, just a critical mass of silence and risk aversion. It thrives in organisational cultures built to obscure rather than expose, to close ranks rather than open windows. What emerges is less a party than a syndicate of opportunity, locked in by networks of patronage and fear. The upshot is paralysis: everyone is protecting someone, and no one is leading. Part of the ANC's failure is its inability (often, outright refusal) to see itself as the public now sees it. The culture of impunity is so entrenched that what the party considers routine 'comradely' behaviour of deploying legal deflections, rallying round implicated figures, most South Africans experience as open disdain. Nowhere is this clearer than when 'step aside' resolutions become revolving doors rather than exits. Or when whistleblowers and reformer voices within the ANC itself are labelled traitors to 'party unity.' Unity, it seems, has become a code word for not rocking the boat, for not pursuing justice if it might disturb the consort of allies and networks upon which the party's internal power balances rest. In the public's eyes, this is less about due process and more about delaying justice indefinitely. The longer the leadership argues that 'the law must run its course,' the clearer it is to an angry electorate that the party will only move when its back is to the wall. It is fashionable among ANC spokespersons to insist on the sanctity of due process, the need for investigations to be completed, for 'facts to emerge.' Yet South Africans have witnessed enough commissions of inquiry, of investigation, of endless reporting, to recognise the tactic for what it is: a shield. Commissions buy time, exhaust scrutiny, and present a veneer of activity where there is none. The public demand is not for kangaroo courts. Rather, for the party to act transparently and decisively, rather than retreat behind endless deferral. Real step changes in trust are possible only when the ANC itself draws and enforces boundaries. Imagine the difference if every member credibly accused, pending completion of disciplinary or legal processes, were immediately removed from leadership positions and denied access to public funds. Imagine if financial disclosures, lifestyle audits, and procurement records were published proactively, rather than under duress. Any party serious about renewal requires a culture of voluntary transparency and unflinching leadership accountability, not endless recitations of 'innocent until proven guilty' inside a system where prosecution is so often stymied by capacity, interference, or sheer intimidation. Trust will only return when opaque process is replaced by public action. It bears saying: the ANC's defensive mode is not passive but actively alienating. Each attempt to downplay, deflect, or reframe allegations signals to South Africans that the party's priority is not public trust, but internal management. It is an offensive gesture, in the original sense, an affront to the desperate hopes and daily struggles of ordinary people whose lives have improved little, if at all, since posture is not only fatal for the party; it is dangerous for democracy. When citizens lose all faith that corrupt leaders will pay any price, the path opens to despair on one hand, or populist strongmen on the other. Dangerous actors harvest the wreckage of failed renewal to offer simple, violent alternatives. The longer the ANC persists in talking only to itself, the more space it leaves for demagogues who promise to 'clean up' by fire rather than by law. Is it too late? Has the rupture of trust between the ANC and South Africa reached a point of no return? The honest answer: there is little time left, but history offers no certainties. Political parties the world over have rebuilt credibility after scandal if they have the courage to do so. But it requires the opposite of what we have seen: not defensive rhetoric, but proactive self-cleansing. It means the party actively inviting in outside scrutiny, establishing independent ethics authorities, and exposing its dirtiest laundry without waiting for courts, commissions, or foreign headlines to force the issue. The next generation must rise to demand, not request, the retirement of those tainted by corruption or implicated in cover-ups. There is no substitute for boldness: a public reckoning, a clean sweep of compromised leaders, and an end to the charade in which 'unity' means protecting the worst among the best. Real renewal is brutally hard. It will come at a cost. Alliances will crack, careers will end, and the party may split or shrink. But the alternative is slow death, not just for the ANC, but for the legitimacy of the country's entire political order. What can the ANC do right now? Launch independent, transparent inquiries: Proactively invite multi-stakeholder, independent commissions to investigate internally. Publicise findings. Proactively invite multi-stakeholder, independent commissions to investigate internally. Publicise findings. Publish lifestyle audits and financial records: Normalise voluntary transparency for all ANC politicians, not just when the law requires. Normalise voluntary transparency for all ANC politicians, not just when the law requires. Swift action against accused leaders: Remove from office any leader credibly implicated in corruption, regardless of seniority or political cost. Remove from office any leader credibly implicated in corruption, regardless of seniority or political cost. Prioritise youth and women leaders untainted by patronage: Entrust renewal to those who have not benefited from or been complicit in the existing networks of graft . Entrust renewal to those who have not benefited from or been complicit in the existing networks of graft Engage the public honestly: Communicate openly about the rot, the cost, and the plan to fix it, even at the expense of short-term popularity. South Africans are not fools. They recognise that corruption is not unique to the ANC or to this country. The issue is not the presence of some bad apples; it is the refusal to clear out the rot before it infects the whole orchard. Every day the ANC spends defending the indefensible is another day closer to irrelevance. Irreversible, final, and richly deserved. If, against the odds, the party can rediscover humility, courage, and the will to act brutally, decisively, and with a seriousness commensurate with the crisis, it might yet reclaim some trust. But time is running out, and the ICU monitor is beeping. The next actions, not words, not commissions, but actions, will decide whether the ANC lives to write a new chapter of service, or fades into history's shadows, remembered only for what it squandered. The choice is theirs. The patience of the people is not. (Dube is a political economist, businessman, and social commentator on Ukhozi FM. His views don't necessarily reflect those of the Sunday Tribune and IOL. Read more of his articles here:
The Citizen
28 minutes ago
- The Citizen
July best-sellers: Hilux, Ranger and D-Max dominate top three
South Africa's perianal top-three bakkies ended the record month as the country's overall best-selling vehicles. South Africa's monthly vehicle sales registered more than 50 000 unit sales in July with a total offset of 51 383, it's highest since October 2019. In addition to cracking the 50 000 unit mark for the first time since January 2017's 50 333, the July figures by the National Association of Automobile Manufacturers of South Africa (Naamsa) represented an uptake of 15.6% on July last year's 44 452. NOW READ: July new vehicle sales cross 50 000 units for new record 'We are encouraged by the sustained positive momentum in new vehicle sales, which clearly underscores the resilience of South African consumers and the strategic importance of a stable macro-economic policy environment,' Naamsa CEO Mikel Mabasa said. 'This performance reflects more than short-term consumption – it signals the sector's confidence in the country's broader economic trajectory'. July Top 10 brands Out of the country's 10 best-selling brands, the top three remained unchanged from June, with Toyota placing ahead of Suzuki on 12 694 versus 6 257, and Volkswagen third on 5 738. Swapping places for fourth and fifth, Hyundai finished ahead of Ford on 3 161 compared to 2 877, while Great Wall Motors (GWM) maintained its sixth position on 2 436. Taking seventh, Isuzu swapped places with Chery with its 2 427 versus 2 160, while Kia improved by three position to re-enter the top 10 on 1 891. Mahindra rounded the top 10 off on 1 441. July Top 50 Best-Sellers Toyota Hilux – 3 120 Ford Ranger – 2 168 Isuzu D-Max – 2 002 Toyota Corolla Cross – 1 949 Suzuki Swift – 1 872 Chery Tiggo 4 Pro – 1 604 Hyundai Grand i10 – 1 464 Toyota Starlet – 1 322 Suzuki Fronx – 1 220 Kia Sonet – 1 103 GWM Haval Jolion – 1 102 Toyota Fortuner – 984 Suzuki Ertiga – 980 Nissan Magnite – 790 Mahindra Pik Up – 783 Volkswagen Polo – 758 Toyota Rumion – 757 Toyota Starlet Cross – 757 Toyota Vitz – 753 Volkswagen T-Cross – 702 Toyota Urban Cruiser – 677 Toyota HiAce – 614 Toyota Land Cruiser 70-series – 585 Omoda C5 – 524 GWM Haval H6 – 521 Mahindra XUV 3X0 – 511 Hyundai Exter – 499 Renault Kwid – 465 Suzuki S-Presso – 445 Jetour Dashing – 437 Chery Tiggo 7 Pro – 405 Suzuki Baleno – 401 GWM P Series – 395 Nissan Navara – 393 Renault Triber – 391 Renault Kiger – 385 Hyundai i20 – 381 Volkswagen Amarok – 381 Volkswagen Polo Sedan – 346 Suzuki Jimny – 318 Ford Everest – 300 Omoda C5 X – 289 Toyota Land Cruiser Prado – 287 Jetour X70 Plus – 280 Citroën C3 – 259 Volkswagen Tiguan – 240 Kia Pegas – 237 Hyundai H100 – 237 Ford Territory – 230 Suzuki Eeco – 228 ALSO READ: New vehicle sales finish first half of 2025 on a noteworthy high
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
Fuel price adjustments: Relief for petrol users, but diesel prices rise
South African motorists will experience a mixed bag of fuel price changes as petrol prices decrease while diesel costs rise. Image: Tumi Pakkies / Independent Newspapers While there will be some relief at the pumps for motorists using petrol-powered vehicles, diesel users will have to fork out more for the fuel. According to a statement from the Central Energy Fund, which acts on behalf of the Department of Mineral Resources and Energy (DMRE) in South Africa, the following price adjustments takes place from August 6: Both Grades of Petrol 93 & 95(ULP & LRP) 28,00 cents per litre decrease in retail price Diesel 0.05% Sulphur (65,00) cents per litre increase in wholesale price Diesel 0.005% Sulphur (63,00) cents per litre increase in wholesale price Illuminating Paraffin (Wholesale) (32,00) cents per litre increase in wholesale price Illuminating Paraffin (SMNRP) (43,00) cents per litre increase in the Single Maximum National Retail price (SMNRP) Maximum Retail Price for LPGAS 69,00 cents per kilogram decrease in the maximum retail price The statement said the fuel price adjustments were due to the decrease in the average international product prices for petrol whilst the prices for diesel and illuminating paraffin increased during the period under review. The CEF also said the Rand appreciated against the US Dollar during the period under review, on average, when compared to the previous period. The average Rand/US Dollar exchange ratef or the period 27 June 2025 to 31 July 2025 was 17.7653 compared to 17.8443 during the previous period. 'This led to a lower contribution to the Basic Fuel Prices on petrol,diesel and illuminating paraffin by 4.444 c/l, 5.014 c/l, 4.779c/l respectively.' Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading Meanwhile IOL reports that Minister of Mineral and Petroleum Resources, Gwede Mantashe, has revealed that a new programme has been set up to tackle petrol stations that are selling adulterated fuel across the country. The country has been struggling with widespread fuel adulteration and illegal smuggling for several years, costing the country around R 3.6 billion annually. According to the South African Revenue Service (SARS), criminals are mixing diesel with cheaper substances like paraffin and under-declaring fuel imports to evade taxes. In response, government agencies, including SARS and the police, have stepped up joint operations in recent years, shutting down illegal depots and seizing millions of litres of contaminated diesel. However, the problem still persists. In a recent parliamentary reply, Mantashe revealed that the Department has established a fuel sampling and testing programme. The minister added that the department also conducts both random and scheduled fuel sampling and testing to verify compliance. THE MERCURY
