Furious India eyes response to Pakistan after Kashmir attack
New Delhi suspended a water-sharing treaty, announced the closure of the main land border crossing with Pakistan, downgraded diplomatic ties and withdrew visas for Pakistanis on Wednesday night, just over 24 hours after gunmen killed 26 men in Indian-administered Kashmir.
And then on Thursday, New Delhi said it had suspended visas services "with immediate effect" and ordered all Pakistani nationals to leave the country, with the exception of remaining diplomats.
Experts say that a military response may still be in the pipeline, with some speculating that a response may come within days while others say weeks.
New Delhi accuses Islamabad of supporting "cross-border terrorism" -- claims Pakistan denies -- and police in Kashmir identified two Pakistani nationals among the three alleged gunmen.
India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi vowed on Thursday to punish all those responsible "to the ends of the Earth".
Relations between the nuclear-armed neighbours have sunk to their lowest level in years and some fear New Delhi's diplomatic moves may just be an opening salvo.
"This attack is going to take... relations a long way back to the dark days," said International Crisis Group analyst Praveen Donthi.
"Given the Narendra Modi government's security approach, they might resort to kinetic (military) measures in the next couple of weeks, because they believe in projecting a strong security state."
Pakistan held a rare national security meeting on Thursday after New Delhi's punitive diplomatic measures.
- 'Escalation' -
The killings have shocked India because they were a dramatic shift targeting civilians and the area's vital tourism industry, rather than more common smaller-scale attacks against Indian security forces.
Hindu pilgrims have been targeted in the past, but direct attacks on the tourist trade that underpins much of the local economy are much rarer.
"A major attack in a tourist area does constitute a break from the past," said Ajai Sahni, a counter-terrorism expert at the New Delhi-based Institute for Conflict Management.
Sahni suggested there had been "an unwritten contract" not to attack the general tourism trade "because virtually everyone" in Kashmir is directly or indirectly dependent on tourism.
For New Delhi, the 3.5 million tourists who it says visited Kashmir in 2024 -- mostly domestic visitors -- illustrated what officials called "normalcy and peace" returning to the troubled region after a massive crackdown in 2019.
"One of the reasons this attack might have happened is because the government started linking the numbers of tourists... to this narrative of normalcy," Donthi said.
"The militants finally changed their attack. Usually, they don't attack tourists and civilians... And this is going to mark an escalation in the conflict."
The 2019 crackdown followed Modi's decision to cancel Kashmir's partial autonomy and impose direct control from New Delhi.
US-based analyst Michael Kugelman said he believed the shift meant India would therefore also likely respond with military force.
"I would argue that the combination of the scale of this attack as well as the targeting -- the fact that civilians were hit -- that suggests to me that there is a strong likelihood of some type of Indian military retaliation," he said.
"I don't necessarily think that such a response would come quickly. I suspect that New Delhi will want to take some time, some days to review a range of possible retaliations."
- 'Covert options available' -
India has taken its time to respond to past attacks.
The worst attack in recent years in Indian-run Kashmir was at Pulwama in 2019, when insurgents rammed a car packed with explosives into a police convoy, killing 40 and wounding 35.
Indian fighter jets carried out air strikes on Pakistani territory 12 days later, a raid that came against the backdrop of campaigning for India's general elections.
Action taken by India so far is limited.
The now-suspended Indus Water Treaty shares critical water between the two countries -- but is more a paper agreement and India has no major means of restricting flow downstream to Pakistan.
The closure of the border crossing at the Attari-Wagah frontier is also significant, although there are rarely large numbers who cross.
The border crossing hosts a hugely popular evening ritual, where crowds gather to cheer on soldiers as they goose-step in a chest-puffing theatrical show that has largely endured through innumerable diplomatic flare-ups.
Sahni said any potential military response was "ill-advised".
"There have been military responses in the past," he said.
"They have been drummed up to have been these great successes. They had not achieved any significant outcomes -- and there is a wide range of covert options available."
ash-pjm/pbt
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indianapolis Star
an hour ago
- Indianapolis Star
Immigrants helped build Indianapolis, leaving their unique marks on the fabric of the city
When Kanwal Prakash "KP" Singh moved to Indianapolis in 1967 he was one of only two Sikhs in the city. Singh had arrived in the United States from India two years earlier to pursue a master's degree in city planning at the University of Michigan. A job opportunity brought him to Indianapolis, which had a reputation as uncultured and unwelcoming — even as leaders worked to overcome a legacy of intolerance and ties to the Ku Klux Klan. Nearly 60 years later, Indianapolis continues to attract new residents from around the globe. Those new citizens include more than 15,000 other Sikh families in the metro area. 'That's one small ethnic group. You have to then multiply the same kind of increase and progress of the entire Indian community, the Mexican community — people from all over the world," Singh said. "I have had the pleasure to be not just a distant witness but to be a part of it." A recent Indiana University report shows international immigration has driven population growth in Indiana since 2008. U.S. Census Bureau data reveals Marion County was home to 128,590 foreign-born (naturalized and those classified as not a U.S. citizen) residents in 2023. More than half — 74,180 — came in the last 15 years. Most of the new arrivals hail from Latin American countries (52.7%), followed by Asia (22.7%) and Africa (18.6%). Since the city's establishment in the 1820s, Indianapolis has been a magnet for immigrants seeking opportunity and refuge. But many faced bigotry based on their ethnicity and religion. Those hostilities often were driven by residents who feared changes their new neighbors brought with them. 'Indianapolis was a majority White, Protestant city and you had the prejudices that went along with that," said Marion County historian Steven Barnett. "If you weren't part of that, essentially, the majority group, you might not be allowed to participate. They may not be hired. You may not be allowed in social organizations. You might not be allowed even in restaurants or other businesses. There was no overt violence. They just weren't accepted.' Still, with time and familiarity, immigrant families — and their customs, businesses and contributions — slowly blended into the fabric of the city. Some left indelible marks on Indianapolis, helping shape the city as it is today. The imprint of immigrants is found in architecture, such as the Scottish link to Mile Square and the German Athenaeum; street names; houses of worship; the ethnic cuisine of the International Marketplace; and celebrations highlighting the many heritages co-existing in the city. But a new wave of anti-immigrant sentiments is erupting in Indianapolis and across the U.S., which once celebrated its role as a cultural melting pot, in a surge of nativism. Under the direction of President Donald Trump, federal agencies are enacting policies to restrict immigration under an "America first" banner, while also targeting immigrants already in the country — including families, laborers and students. The long-simmering political push-and-pull over diversity and inclusion has spilled into the streets, giving way to volatility in some places. Recent high-profile immigration crackdowns are capturing the world's attention as masked federal agents are recorded detaining people on city streets, at courthouses and workplaces. The situation boiled over in Los Angeles in June after the president deployed the California National Guard and U.S. Marines to quell protests calling for abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. The policy decision is one of many factors that drove millions of Americans opposed to the Trump administration's tactics into the streets in June for nationwide counter protests. The story of Indianapolis and immigration begins more than two centuries ago in a remote, swampy woods near where Fall Creek meets White River. Commissioners appointed by the Indiana General Assembly picked the site. An immigrant platted the new town. Born in Scotland, Alexander Ralston arrived in Indiana in the early 1820s. He'd assisted Major Pierre Charles L'Enfant with the surveying for Washington, D.C. Ralston was hired, along with Englishman Elias Fordham, to do the same work for the new city that would be called Indianapolis. Chronicles of the city's origin credit Ralston with designing the map of the Mile Square, which consisted of a center square and four intersecting streets. He stayed to make Indianapolis his home until his death in 1827. Over time, Indianapolis attracted pioneers from other states, including African Americans migrating from the South. Also coming to the city were Germans, Irish, Italians, Syrians, Africans, Asian and Latino immigrants. The first major wave of immigration in the 1830s and 1840s included the Germans and Irish, said historian Barnett. Many came for work. Others sought to escape economic hardships or oppression in their homelands. German-speaking people sought new opportunities, refuge from crop failure and liberty from oppression stemming from militarism to stamp out revolutions in the 1840s. In Indianapolis, they became influential in business and art. German architects designed many monuments and buildings throughout the city. Before the potato famine swept through Ireland, Irish immigrants began arriving in the 1830s to help construct the Central Canal, said Barnett. They also helped build railroads making the city a transportation hub with an identity as the 'Crossroads of America.' More Irish immigrants followed to escape the potato famine. After the Civil War, Indianapolis saw the arrival of Italians and other Eastern European ethnic groups through the end of the 19th Century, according to Barnett. Jewish settlers also found a home in the city, as did a large Arab community, mostly consisting of people with Syrian ancestry. They came in search of a better life, he said. Some of the immigrants made money and returned home. Others stayed, settling into various parts of the growing city. They carried with them their language, cuisine, art, cultural traditions and religious practices. Some even recruited other relatives and families to join them in Indiana. From a cultural standpoint, the German community maintained a strong thread in the fabric of the city's identity. "The Soldiers and Sailors Monument in Monument Circle — that's probably the most outstanding expression of German art and monumental monumental sculptures. It's just a very strong expression of a German-style monuments," Barnett said. "A lot of architecture in the city was evocative of German culture." World War I, however, created new challenges for German-speaking people and gave rise to anti-German sentiments, Barnett said. In response, families and individuals changed their last names to distance themselves from Germany, so did heritage organizations. "The German population," Barnett said, "tried to show that 'we're more American' than the Americans." Das Deutsche Haus — which translates to The German House in English — became the Athenaeum. The historic landmark, which opened in 1898 and is known for its German Renaissance Revival architecture, remains a prominent landmark. By the early 1900s, several charitable organizations were working in Indianapolis to assist immigrants. During this time, Eastern Europeans from Slovenia, Croatia and Germany began settling on the west side between White River and Speedway, Barnett said. In the neighborhood of Haughville, an ironworks attracted immigrants in search of work. New churches and religious institutions, such as the former Holy Trinity Catholic Church, opened to serve immigrant communities planting roots in Indianapolis. A Romanian Orthodox church opened on West 16th Street. Additionally, the Slovenian National Home opened in 1918 as a social club where dances, concerts, sports and card games took place for East European immigrants. It remains active today. The area south of downtown — near Kosher-inspired deli Shapiro's Delicatessen — became home to a mix of people of Jewish descent, Protestants, Catholics and African Americans. The current wave of nativism — a political policy that prioritizes native-born citizens over immigrants and typically involves restricting immigration — resembles prior anti-immigrant episodes, Barnett said. Nativism rose in the 1850s and continued in various ways including a resurgence of the Klan after World War I. Much like today, immigrants were accused of taking American jobs and criticized for speaking their native languages. Historian Jill Weiss Simins wrote in an 2024 blog that the Klan wrapped its anti-immigrant, anti-Catholic, and anti-semitic rhetoric in so-called America First patriotism and Christian righteousness. As many as one in four Hoosiers were members. Klan members, Simins wrote, saw white supremacy in the U.S. as under attack and believed it was their sacred duty to protect white domination. 'For the Midwestern Klan, the main obstacle to this goal was not African Americans. Many Indiana towns had small numbers of Black residents, and there were plenty of institutionalized practices and laws in place by the 1920s to suppress African Americans," she wrote. "The Klan helped to keep these as standard practice. However, they saw immigrants, mainly Catholics but also Jews, as the main threat to a White, Protestant America." Spanish-speaking immigrants were among the newest wave of people seeking opportunities in Indianapolis. Primarily from Mexico, they began settling along West Washington Street in the mid-1980s, Barnett said. The corridor, where signs in Spanish are still common, was the first in the city to see economic development through Mexican restaurants and businesses. Weather also played a role in attracting Latino immigrants. After destructive winds struck the city in the 1990s, Barnett said Latino construction workers soon arrived to help rebuild. Some remained. The city's Latino population has diversified as people from other Spanish-speaking countries moved to Indianapolis. Asians also have made the city home as locally based, global companies such as Eli Lilly & Co. provided job opportunities. When city officials tout Indianapolis now, they often point to the International Marketplace. The neighborhood centered along Lafayette Road between 30th and 46th streets is home to more than 75 culturally diverse restaurants and businesses. In a single strip mall on West 38th Street, adventurous diners can find restaurants serving Ethiopian, Peruvian, Mexican, Indian and Chinese cuisine. The area is indicative of Indianapolis's beginnings as a Midwest cultural gateway, said Mary Clark, the International Marketplace Coalition's executive director. "This is who we are. Embrace it. Accept it," Clark said. "We just have to get through the next four years and it'll be all good again." Indiana also has attracted many Burmese Americans. Elaisa Vahnie, president and CEO of the Burmese American Community Institute, said 40,000 Burmese Americans began arriving as political refugees in the early 1990s. About 30,000 settled in Indianapolis. Many call Perry Township home, but some are moving to other neighborhoods, said Vahnie, whose great uncle John Mang Tling was the first Burmese immigrant to settle in Indianapolis. One Sunday in June, Singh and more than 4,000 people of the Sikh faith from across the Midwest gathered at the Gurdwara Sikh Satsang of Indianapolis on Southeastern Avenue to celebrate the 75th Barsi of Baba Prem Singhjee. The Gurdwara, a Sikh place of worship, is home to Indiana's oldest and largest Sikh congregation. To become part of their community immigrants must interact and partner with their neighbors, said Singh, who added he's seen Indianapolis become more receptive to different cultures. Initially, Singh said he was denied restaurant service because of his turban, a sacred garment. He experienced housing and police discrimination, and was treated as a curiosity by a former newspaper. But he saw opportunity in each incident. 'The more such incidents happened the more I felt I needed to be here instead of moving to another town,' he said. 'Maybe I had a role to play.' In the decades since, Singh has become a community leader and advocate for diversity. 'The climate has changed enormously,' he said, 'I have been very dedicated to that — to every citizen counting." As part of the June celebration many Sikhs engaged in the practice of selfless service, a major pillar of their faith. They gathered 30,000 bottles of water for Wheeler Mission and collected food for Gleaners Food Bank of Indiana. They fellowshipped, ate together and hosted a high priest who has visited Indianapolis several times as the city's profile grows in India. Sisters Simran Kaur, 19, and Tamanna Kaur, 18, were born and raised in Indianapolis. They said it wasn't always easy growing up in the city, but they've come to embrace their identity as American Sikhs. With the city's growing diversity, they now see a future here. "It's pretty to look at — you know, all the cultures and then all of them coming together ... I think it's awesome," Tamanna said. "I wouldn't want to leave here. I see myself here."
Yahoo
15 hours ago
- Yahoo
Dalai Lama confirms he will have a successor after his death
Exiled Tibetan spiritual leader the Dalai Lama has confirmed he will have a successor, putting to rest speculation over whether the 600-year-old institution will end when he dies. In a video message keenly-awaited by his followers, he said only the trust that he founded could appoint his successor and "no-one else has any authority to interfere in this matter". According to Tibetan tradition, Dalai Lamas are "reincarnated" after they die. China annexed Tibet in 1950 and the current Dalai Lama lives in exile in India, making succession a highly contentious issue. Beijing rejected the statement, saying his successor would be from inside China and must be approved by the government. Hundreds of followers gathered on Wednesday to hear the long-awaited announcement in the Indian town of Dharamshala where the Dalai Lama lives. The Dalai Lama Library and Archive centre, where the video message was broadcast, resembled a sea of maroon with monks from all over the world in attendance. "I am affirming that the institution of the Dalai Lama will continue," the Dalai Lama's statement said. He reiterated that "the Gaden Phodrang Trust, the Office of His Holiness the Dalai Lama... should accordingly carry out the procedures of search and recognition in accordance with past tradition". Who is the Dalai Lama and why does he live in exile? Dharamshala is holding the Dalai Lama's milestone 90th birthday celebrations which began on Monday - his birthday according to the Tibetan lunar calendar - and will conclude on 6 July, his official birthday. Celebrations will be attended by more than 7,000 guests, including a number of Indian ministers. Hollywood actor Richard Gere, a long-time follower, is also taking part. In the past, the Nobel Peace Prize-winning spiritual head of Tibetan Buddhism had been torn between whether to continue with the post of Dalai Lama or not. A few years ago, he said his successor might be a girl, or that there might be no successor at all. But in recent years, he had also said that if there was widespread support among Tibetans-in-exile for the post - which there is - then it would continue and his office would choose a successor. He has always insisted that his successor must be born outside China and his reiteration of the same on Wednesday did not go down well with Beijing. A Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson said that the Dalai Lama's reincarnation must comply with Chinese laws and regulations as well as "religious rituals and historical conventions" and would need to be approved by Beijing. Even though the Dalai Lama has always advocated a "middle way" to resolve the status of Tibet - genuine self-rule within China - Beijing regards him as a separatist. It says the standard of living of people in Tibet has greatly improved under its rule and denies suppressing their human rights and freedom of expression. A dam ignited rare Tibetan protests. They ended in beatings and arrests, BBC finds Dalai Lama furore reignites Tibet 'slave' controversy How China's boarding schools are silencing Tibet's language The Dalai Lama's message "affirming that the continuation of the institution" has been welcomed by his followers. Tsayang Gyatso, a 40-year-old businessman, said that for most Tibetans, the announcement is "a great relief and a moment of happiness". "I always had a belief that the reincarnation will come. But having heard it from His Holiness, I feel elated," he told the BBC in Dharamshala. Mr Gyatso, who had travelled from Delhi, said he felt "blessed to be here in person to witness His Holiness's birthday". He said there was "a lot of propaganda from China on the appointment of the next Dalai Lama" which made him fear that the appointment process could be corrupted "but all that has been put to rest by His Holiness's announcement". Robert Barnett, a Tibet scholar at the School of Oriental and African Studies in London, told the BBC that the Dalai Lama's "message is indirect signalling" to China. "He's signalling two things here. One is he's going to decide on his reincarnation, not China. And the other is he's showing China that he's made this decision through a kind of popular - almost democratic - process of asking the community whether they want his institution to continue." That's a signal to China that his legitimacy is based on consent and not on force, Prof Barnett said. Experts, however, say China is also expected to name its own Dalai Lama. Dibyesh Anand, professor of International Relations at the University of Westminster, said, "After a period of a few months or a few years, they will have their own proteges identify a small boy as the next Dalai Lama and impose that. Of course, a majority of Tibetans are going to reject it and the majority of people in the world are going to make fun of it. But remember China has immense authority in terms of resources so they will try to impose that." Youdon Aukatsang, an MP in the Tibetan parliament-in-exile, told the BBC that "despite all these years of trying to control the hearts and minds of Tibetan people inside Tibet", Beijing has "completely failed". A Dalai Lama chosen by China, she says, "will not be recognised, not only by the Tibetans but the world will not recognise it because China doesn't have the legitimacy to find the future Dalai Lama". "We are concerned but we know that irrespective of our concern, China will come up with their own Dalai Lama, we will call it the Chinese-recognised Dalai Lama. I am not worried that Dalai Lama will have any credibility in the Tibetan world or the Buddhist world." China 'coercing Tibetans into mass labour camps'
Politico
16 hours ago
- Politico
New York Dems line up to defend Mamdani from Trump — even if they don't endorse him
The president began lashing out at Mamdani the day after the June 24 primary. He's since labeled Mamdani a 'communist' and questioned his citizenship status, with some MAGA-aligned commentators attacking the Muslim candidate's faith. Mamdani — who was born to Indian parents in Uganda — was naturalized as an American citizen in 2018. Now, New York Gov. Kathy Hochul and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries have in recent days pushed back on broadsides from the president, a former New Yorker. 'I don't care if you're the President of the United States, if you threaten to unlawfully go after one of our neighbors, you're picking a fight with 20 million New Yorkers — starting with me,' Hochul wrote in a post on X Tuesday, alongside a video of Trump implying Mamdani could be in the country illegally. Trump continued his tirade against Mamdani on Wednesday. 'As President of the United States, I'm not going to let this Communist Lunatic destroy New York. Rest assured, I hold all the levers, and have all the cards,' Trump wrote on Truth Social. 'I'll save New York City, and make it 'Hot' and 'Great' again, just like I did with the Good Ol' USA! Trump's post prompted a response from Jeffries, who on Sunday said he wasn't ready to back the candidate. 'Stop lying about Assemblyman Mamdani,' Jeffries wrote on X Wednesday. 'He is neither a communist nor a lunatic. And New York City doesn't need to be saved by a wannabe King. Besides, you are too busy destroying America with your One Big Ugly Bill to do anything else.' The White House acknowledged a request for comment on the pushback but did not immediately provide one. Mamdani has also cast the attacks from Trump as both a distraction from his message and a foreboding sign for how Trump is treating immigrants. 'He said that I should be deported, he said that I should be denaturalized, and he said those things about me — someone who stands to be the first immigrant mayor of this city in generations, someone who would also be the first Muslim and the first South Asian mayor in this city's history — less so because of who I am, because of where I come from, because of how I look or how I speak, and more so because he wants to distract from what I fight for,' he said at a Wednesday labor rally in Manhattan.
