This show hasn't been seen on a Melbourne stage for 40 years. Now it's back
Samson and Delilah ★★★
Melbourne Opera, Palais Theatre, June 1
Samson and Delilah is the quintessential grand opera – large scale, spectacular (with many choruses and two ballets) and requiring superb singers. Melbourne Opera's production – and music lovers should be grateful yet again for their vision and determination – unfortunately really had only the last.
The staging was deeply underplayed – deliberately so, according to the director's program notes, to emphasise psychological aspects (budget constraints might have been relevant). For me, it didn't work. The sets were far too minimalist, the lighting not even that, though Rose Chong's costumes were a highlight. The stage was divided into three, with the singers in front, the orchestra behind – which considerably reduced its impact – and the chorus above and behind them.
The outstanding contribution came from the principals, Deborah Humble and Rosario La Spina, and the chorus (which is always outstanding). La Spina's huge, sweet tenor was ideal for Samson, but the biggest moments belong to the mezzo Delilah, and Humble relished them: sensitive, seductive, superb. Simon Meadows, Jeremy Kleeman and Eddie Muliaumaseali'i were splendid in the minor roles, while conductor Raymond Lawrence was sympathetic to composer and singers.
The opera, which Camille Saint-Saëns (himself quite familiar with marital problems) takes from the Old Testament, tells of the Israelite leader who is seduced and betrayed by the vengeful Philistine Delilah. First performed in 1877, it was slow to bloom because of its biblical theme, but became immensely popular worldwide.
Loading
For the shortcomings, director Suzanne Chaundy – a leading force in so many of the company's recent triumphs, especially its series of Wagner operas – must take chief responsibility. The production was almost introverted, especially the climax where the blinded Samson pulls down the temple of the Philistine god Dagon, killing thousands. The bacchanal would scarcely have offended a women's temperance union. When Delilah came on stage brandishing Samson's shorn locks (the secret of his strength, symbolising his vow to God), they looked more like a dead possum.
Yet, despite imperfections, Melbourne's first Samson and Delilah in 40 years was a real pleasure.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
2 days ago
- Perth Now
Nelly and Ashanti parent differently
Nelly and Ashanti take very different approaches to parenting. The 50-year-old singer already had Shawn, Chanelle, Sydney and Cornell before he and his wife welcomed son KK into the world 11 months ago, and while he is a more-hands off dad, Ashanti admitted she is "very mama bear-ish" and has a lot of concerns. She told People magazine: "For me, obviously this is my first child. "We have to boil everything and sanitise everything. Everything has to be organic. His sheets are organic, his socks, food-grade silicone, everything. I'm just very, very protective." Nelly said: "I think I understand a little bit more about children. They learn more on their own." The Hot in Herre hitmaker thinks Ashanti, 43, is "motherly overprotective" but he is more "safety overprotective" and insisted it is important for parents not to do everything for their children. He said: "I know if they don't learn certain things by the time they reach a certain age, we're going to pay for that, I promise you. And it's going to backfire on us in a big way." He jokingly added: "Right now I know she's loving it, but that boy turns 17 or 18, she going to be like, 'Why is he acting like this?' And I'm going to ask [Ashanti's mom and manager, Tina Douglas] for that video of him being three. And I'm going to say, 'You see this right here when he used to...'" But despite their different approaches to parenting, Nelly thinks Ashanti is a "great" mom to their son. He said: "I have no complaints. I wish all mothers could see the way that she get down a little bit. You wish every kid had that type of love." In their reality series, Nelly and Ashanti: We Belong Together, Nelly told of how his family struggled financially and he wants to give his son a better life. He said: "I'm just trying to be a better father than I had. And don't get it twisted, I love my father, but I've been through a lot." But he noted that, with Tina, Ashanti has "some tough shoes to fill". His wife laughed: "Yeah, Momager is a whole different beast. I'm very grateful."
Perth Now
7 days ago
- Perth Now
Nelly and Ashanti 'peed in his grandmother's Chanel purse'
Nelly and Ashanti's baby boy peed in his grandmother's Chanel purse. The loved up couple - who had an on-off relationship together for over a decade from 2003 before reconciling in 2023 - have 10-month-old son Kareem, aka KK, together and the proud parents joked he already has "some aim" at the worse times. Speaking to E! News, Nelly - who has Chanelle, 30, and Cornell, 25, with Channetta Valentine - was asked what he'd learnt from being a parent before, and quipped: "Don't get peed on! "I learned from my first son - I've been shot in the eye before! It's not cool, not cool. "But she knows what I'm talking about now! When I first was telling her about it she had no clue. "Between her and his grandmother's purse... the boy got some aim!" Ashanti, 44, burst out laughing, and revealed KK "shot" into her mother Tina's Chanel purse. She joked: "He made a permanent dent!" Despite the awkward moments, both stars are open to the idea of having more children in the future. Ashanti said: "I think we both wanna kinda grow a family. it's funny, when I was younger I was like, 'I want six kids! Six!' " In the meantime, the loved up couple are sharing their lives on screen in new reality show Nelly and Ashanti: We Belong Together. Nelly, 50, revealed he let his wife - whom he secretly married after their reunion - decide whether or not their son should feature on the programme. He explained: "When it came to KK, that was definitely her decision, her being a new mother and the anxiety of putting it out there, showing your first child to the world. "Hopefully we can inspire [people]!" Meanwhile, Ashanti wants fans to know that they're not sugarcoating or exaggerating their life for the sake of the show. She added: "I hope the fans get that we are just authentically, organically living our lives. It's not, like, 'for the cameras!' "These are our lives, we have careers, we're newly married, we have our first child together, he already has kids!"
Perth Now
24-06-2025
- Perth Now
Brandon Flynn cast as James Dean
Brandon Flynn will play James Dean in a new biopic. The 13 Reasons Why actor has been cast as the late legendary star in Willie and Jimmy Dean, writer-director Guy Guido's upcoming film, which is based on William Bast's 2006 memoir Surviving James Dean, in which he alleged he had a love affair with the Hollywood icon at the University of California, Los Angeles. Brandon, 31, has praised the script for humanising his character and showing an understanding of who he really was. He told The Hollywood Reporter: 'James Dean is like the known unknown. His short life left behind just three films, a mountain of photographs and a cultural mythology we keep trying to decode. This script is a beautiful attempt at truthfully understanding who he really was — not just the icon, but the man. "It highlights how Hollywood has historically forced LGBTQ people into performance, even in their personal lives. 'This story dares to present James Dean as a man with real, complex relationships, and I think there's power in that truth." The script is set from the first meeting between the two men to James' death in September 1955 and Guy is delighted to have Brandon on board. He said: 'This is not a traditional biopic. It's a tender and sometimes tragic story about two young men who found each other in a time and place where being seen — truly seen — came at a cost. Brandon Flynn brings both the fire and vulnerability this role demands. I couldn't imagine anyone more perfect to explore and play out the complexities of James Dean.' The fimmaker, who spoke to William in 2011, four years before his death at the age of 84, previously told how he felt "drawn" to the author's "unique story". He told The Hollywood Reporter: 'I have been a fan and historian of James Dean since I was 18 years old, so I knew about his 'friend' Willie, even when information about their relationship was straight-washed by the Hollywood machine. 'As a filmmaker, I love telling the story of a celebrity's life in their coming-of-age period. As a gay man, I was particularly drawn to Bast's unique story.' In the book, William claimed he and the Hollywood legend become roommates, close friends and eventually lovers during their time at the UCLA's theatre programme when the pair were 19. The author - who also wrote James Dean: A Biography in 1956 - claimed the fling was kept private in an effort to protect the actor's flourishing Hollywood career, though he hoped he could reunite with his supposed forbidden lover one day. However, the writer's dream of a relationship was cruelly taken away from him when the Rebel Without a Cause star died in a car accident at the age of 24 in 1955.
