Maui housing conversion endeavor stalls
The plan, proposed via Senate Bill 378, recently stalled in the House and failed to meet a Thursday procedural deadline needed for passage this year.
However, the idea put forth in the bill could still lead to new affordable housing that is less costly to produce while also adding vibrancy and historical character to communities 20 months after a wildfire in Lahaina destroyed around 3, 500 homes.
'Out of the tragedy has come the opportunity to be very bullish about the fact that when Lahaina is rebuilt we can take the opportunity to create housing where the jobs are going to be, ' said Sen. Angus McKelvey, who introduced the bill with six other backers.
McKelvey, who lost his home in the fire, did not propose buying land zoned for commercial use in Lahaina, but believes property owners in the West Maui town could rebuild what they lost and include homes above businesses that return.
'What's old is new again, ' said McKelvey (D, West Maui-Maalaea-South Maui ). 'This was how our towns were built on Maui back in the plantation days.'
Don 't miss out on what 's happening !
Stay in touch with breaking news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. It 's FREE !
Email 28141 Sign Up By clicking to sign up, you agree to Star-Advertiser 's and Google 's and. This form is protected by reCAPTCHA.
SB 378 advanced fairly deep into this year's legislative session without public opposition. Despite stalling, the bill is not completely dead because it could be passed in 2026 in the second half of the 2025-2026 biennium. There is also a view among some stakeholders that creating a law from SB 378 isn't necessary to realize the intent of the measure.
The bill proposes to form a working group to identify commercial or mixed-use properties on Maui that a state agency could buy and partly turn into affordable housing.
'By locating housing near workplaces, redevelopment supports worker retention, fosters community connections, and alleviates traffic congestion, thereby improving overall quality of life, ' the bill states. 'Additionally, reusing existing structures reduces environmental and financial costs associated with new construction while expediting the delivery of housing options, as many units are already built and ready for conversion.'
The working group under the bill would be led by the board chair of the Hawaii Housing Finance and Development Corp., a state agency that helps finance development of affordable housing.
HHFDC's board chair would head the proposed seven-member panel. Other members would include the director of Maui County's Department of Housing, the president of the Realtors Association of Maui and two Maui County residents with expertise, respectively, in redevelopment and mixed-use property financing.
Alice Lee, chair of the Maui County Council, endorsed SB 378 in written testimony.
'Following the 2023 Maui wildfires, there is an urgent need to develop housing in Maui County to ensure an adequate housing inventory for displaced residents and the broader community, ' Lee wrote. 'Mixed-use developments allow residents to live near where they work and access essential services, helping to create vibrant, sustainable communities while reducing traffic congestion.'
The Maui Chamber of Commerce also expressed strong support, and encouraged lawmakers to have work proceed without delay.
'The Chamber recognizes the critical need for more housing and understands that many individuals prefer to live close to their workplaces, making mixed-use developments a mutually beneficial solution, ' the organization said in written testimony. 'In light of the severe housing shortage in both the State and Maui County, we fully support measures that promote, rather than hinder, the development of housing for our residents.'
HHFDC Director Dean Minakami also supports the bill, and said in written testimony that the effort has the potential to expand Maui's supply of affordable housing.
The agency has some experience acquiring commercial real estate for residential use on Maui under an effort that began before the wildfire and was altered to provide fire survivors with a place to live in 2024.
This project also was directed by the Legislature, which in May 2023 appropriated funding for HHFDC to buy a former 175-room hotel in Kihei that in recent decades had been used as a Christian missionary training center.
Initially, the intent was for HHFDC to acquire the former Maui Sun Hotel so that Maui County could convert the property to teacher housing, affordable workforce housing and prekindergarten classrooms after major renovations.
Instead, HHFDC bought what was most recently known as Haggai Institute for $38 million and began housing wildfire survivors in August after completing renovations to what is now named Hale 'o La 'ie.
SB 378 sought to have the working group submit recommendations by the end of this year ahead of being dissolved shortly thereafter.
Senators on March 4 voted 25-0 to send the bill to the House of Representatives for consideration. On March 14 the House Committee on Housing voted 7-0 vote to send the bill to the House Finance Committee for consideration, though no further action was taken, which prevents the bill from passing this year.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
10 minutes ago
- NBC News
Natural disaster victims would get six months of mortgage relief under Senate bill
LOS ANGELES — Natural disaster survivors would be eligible for six months of mortgage relief under a bill introduced Thursday by two senators whose states have been ravaged by wildfires and floods. The Mortgage Relief for Disaster Survivors Act would apply to homeowners with federally backed loans in areas declared disasters since Jan. 1 without accumulating interest or penalties during the six-month period. Borrowers could apply for additional six-month extensions. 'Earlier this year, we watched as families in Los Angeles were devastated by wildfires, and to date, many homeowners are still struggling to rebuild from this disaster,' said Sen. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., who is co-sponsoring the bill. 'As natural disasters become more frequent due to climate change, it is critical that we pave a path to stability for homeowners in times of crisis,' he added. Parts of Schiff's former congressional district in Southern California were devoured in January when the Eaton Fire tore through Altadena, destroying nearly 6,000 homes and killing at least 19 people. His co-sponsor is Sen. Michael Bennet, D-Colo., whose state was ravaged by the 2021 Marshall Fire, which damaged or destroyed some 1,200 homes in Boulder County. 'Coloradans know all too well how difficult it is to pick up the pieces and move forward after catastrophic wildfires,' Bennet said. 'When mounting financial and emotional costs of recovery weigh on families, they should be able to take time to put their lives back together and rebuild their homes.' House members who represent Altadena, Pacific Palisades and Malibu in California introduced a companion bill this year that would provide 180 days of mortgage relief without penalties or late fees. The pause would apply only to federally backed loans. Nonfederal lenders are not required to offer payment reprieves to homeowners in disaster zones. But after the Palisades and Eaton fires, more than 400 lenders agreed to a 90-day pause without reporting the missed payments to credit agencies. Eaton Fire survivor Freddy Sayegh said he took advantage of the program after heavy smoke damage prevented him from returning to his Altadena home. He has since moved his family seven times and incurred thousands of dollars of unforeseen costs for food, clothing and other immediate needs. Some of the costs were covered by insurance, but much of the money came out of his pocket while he awaits compensation. He dipped into his savings when the 90 days were over and paid his delinquent mortgage in a lump sum, fearing he would incur fees or be forced to refinance. 'It actually placed a lot of pressure to come up with three months all at once,' he said. 'There's a lot of people who don't have three months of savings.' In Texas, where cataclysmic flooding that began July 2 caused an estimated $240 million in damage, officials announced a 90-day foreclosure moratorium that prohibits mortgage companies from initiating or completing foreclosures in Kerr County, the area hardest hit by the disaster. According to the Mortgage Bankers Association, delinquencies nearly doubled nationally in March compared with the same time last year, up 21% from 12%. In California, wildfire-related delinquencies peaked in March at 4,100 and fell to 2,240 in June, according to the data tracking company ICE Mortgage Technology. The trend follows a pattern seen after other natural disasters, in which delinquencies spike in the months immediately following catastrophes and gradually level out over the next 18 to 24 months, said Andy Walden, head of mortgage and housing market research at Intercontinental Exchange, the parent company of ICE Mortgage Technology. 'It takes time for many homeowners to untangle finances while dealing with the emotional and logistical aftermath of losing their homes,' he said. 'From navigating insurance claims to working with FEMA, borrowers often need time to stabilize. Foreclosure moratoriums introduced after major disasters often give families the breathing room they need to recover.' Former Altadena resident Keni 'Arts' Davis stared down at a 10-year mortgage when his home of nearly four decades was destroyed. He has moved six times since then, finally landing close to the neighborhood he loved so much. Much of his recovery journey included negotiating with his insurance company to pay off his mortgage, rather than borrowing or seeking an extension. 'It might have meant financial ruin,' he said. He intends to rebuild by cobbling together the money through savings and microloans that are sometimes just $500. He said that the mortgage relief bills sound good on paper but that their timing leaves something to be desired. 'My grandmother would have said it's a day late and a dollar short,' he said. 'We're all just depending on any help we can get to make it one day to the next.'
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Minister rejects claim that recognition of Palestine state could breach international law
A minister has denied claims that Sir Keir Starmer could risk breaching international law with his pledge to recognise Palestine as a state. Nearly 40 members of the House of Lords, including prominent UK lawyers, made the claims in a letter to Attorney General Lord Hermer letter, first reported by The Times, argues that Sir Keir's promise to recognise Palestine in September - unless Israel takes "substantive steps" to end the situation in Gaza - may breach international law as the territory may not meet the criteria for statehood under the Montevideo Convention, a treaty signed in 1933. But speaking to Wilfred Frost on Sky News Breakfast, small business minister Gareth Thomas said he did not believe the move, which has been condemned by Israel, would breach international law because the UK has not signed the Montevideo Convention. He pointed out that 140 countries have already recognised Palestine as a state. Mr Thomas said: "I respect the views of those lawyers, but in the end, recognition of a state is a political judgement. "And we've been very clear that our judgement is that the Palestinians have an inalienable right to statehood; that now is the right time to say publicly that we will recognise the state of [Palestine] unless Israel agrees to end the appalling violence that we're seeing in Gaza at the moment, and commits to a two state solution." He added: "And the ceasefire that can enable the huge amounts of aid we need to get aid and to feed the people of Gaza and commits to no annexation of land in the West Bank. Otherwise, we will recognise, at the UN General Assembly in September." Read more: Canadian Prime Minister saying his country would also recognise Palestine as a state pending certain conditions - including that the Palestinian Authority commits to fundamentally reforming its governance, and holds general elections in 2026 in which Hamas can play no part. But in their letter to Lord Hermer, 38 peers said Palestine "does not meet the international law criteria for recognition of a state, namely, defined territory, a permanent population, an effective government and the capacity to enter into relations with other states". They said there was no certainty over the borders of Palestine and no single government, while also pointing out that Hamas and Fatah are enemies. Lord Hermer has previously insisted that a commitment to international law "goes absolutely to the heart" of the government's approach to foreign policy. Read more from Sky News:Airlines furious after another technical glitch cancels flights Among the respected lawyers who have signed the letter are Lord Pannick - who represented the previous government at the Supreme Court over its Rwanda scheme - as well as KCs Lord Verdirame and Lord Faulks. Some of Parliament's most prominent Jewish voices, including crossbench peer Baroness Deech, Labour's Lord Winston and the Conservatives' Baroness Altmann, have also put their name to the letter. Israel has condemned the UK's decision, with the foreign ministry arguing it "constitutes a reward for Hamas and harms efforts to achieve a ceasefire in Gaza and a framework for the release of hostages".
2 hours ago
Search for answers after Texas' deadly floods brings lawmakers to devastated Hill Country
KERRVILLE, Texas -- Texas lawmakers will take their search for answers following the deadly July 4 floods to the heart of the devastation in Kerr County, where local officials were expected to face questions over their response to the disaster that swept away homes and campers along the Guadalupe River. The hearing Thursday is the first time a panel of lawmakers is visiting the hard-hit Texas Hill Country since the floods, which killed at least 136 people. Most were in Kerr County, including 27 young campers and counselors at Camp Mystic, an all-girls summer camp. Among those invited to testify were local leaders who have defended their preparations and response to the fast-rising waters. Residents will also be given the chance to address lawmakers. The hearing comes as authorities have begun publicly releasing records and audio — including 911 calls — that have provided new glimpses into the escalating danger and chaos in the early hours of the July Fourth holiday. They include panicked and confused messages from residents caught in trees as well as families fleeing with children from homes with water creeping up to the knees. 'People are dying,' one woman tells a 911 operator in call logs released by nearby Kendall County. She says she had a young relative at a church camp in Kerr County who was stranded along with his classmates because of the high waters. 'I don't want them to get stuck in a low-water crossing. And what are they going to do? They have like 30 kids," the woman says. Kerr County officials have denied several Texas Public of Information requests filed by The Associated Press for 911 calls and body-camera footage related to the floods. Lawmakers have had to address flood relief amid a busy 30-day legislative special session that has included a highly-partisan sprint by Republicans to redraw the state's maps to pick up five more seats in the U.S. House. Republican Gov. Greg Abbott added flood relief and disaster preparedness to the agenda items shortly after calling a special session in June. He also included redrawing the state's maps after receiving pressure from President Donald Trump, who has said he wants Texas Republicans to squeeze five additional seats. House Democrats have launched a series of protests that have involved fleeing the state to meet with Democratic governors to try and stop Republican redistricting. As the minority party in both chambers, the caucus has few options and lawmakers face up to $500 a day for walking out after they broke a quorum in 2021. Party leaders have said they will not engage in other legislative business until the legislature addresses flood relief. Lawmakers have filed bills to provide funding for early warning systems, improve emergency communications and strengthen flood infrastructure in flood-prone areas. Residents along the Guadalupe River have said they were caught off guard and had no warning when rainfall struck. Kerr County does not have a warning system along the river after several missed opportunities by state and local agencies to finance one. Abbott and Texas Republicans have signaled no appetite for assigning blame for the disaster or second-guessing decisions by local officials, who have described the scale of the disaster as one that no one could have saw coming. At the first hearing by Texas lawmakers this month, Texas' chief emergency management official called for better accreditation for county response officials. Democrats, meanwhile, have questioned if officials had done enough to provide sufficient infrastructure for flood-prone areas in rural counties.
