Woman Wants To Access Dead Son's 'Frozen Semen'. Bombay High Court Steps In
Mumbai:
The Bombay High Court, in an interim order, has directed a city-based fertility centre to preserve the frozen semen of a dead man pending hearing of a petition by his mother who wants to use the fluid to continue the family line.
The woman moved the HC after the fertility centre refused to release the frozen semen to her as the man, in his consent forms, had sought for the sperm carrying fluid to be discarded post-death. The man had chosen to freeze his semen when he was undergoing chemotherapy, a cancer treatment.
A bench of Justice Manish Pitale on June 25 noted that if the frozen semen of the dead man is discarded pending hearing of the plea, then it would become infructuous. The court posted the petition for further hearing on July 30.
"In the meanwhile, as an interim direction, the fertility centre is directed to ensure safe-keeping and storage of the frozen sample of the dead, during pendency of the petition," the court ordered.
The bench noted that the petition raises important questions with regard to the manner in which the semen of a person is to be preserved after his death under provisions of the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021.
The court pointed out that in the present case, the man was unmarried at the time of his death in February.
The woman, in her plea, argued her son had, without consulting family members, in his consent forms agreed to have the frozen semen discarded if he dies.
After his death, the mother sought the Mumbai-based fertility centre to provide access to transfer the sample to a Gujarat-based IVF centre for future course of action.
The fertility centre, however, refused and asked the mother to obtain authorization from court under the new Act, which seeks to regulate and supervise assisted reproductive technology (ART) clinics. The legislation also aims to ensure ethical practices, prevent misuse, and protect the rights of individuals seeking ART services.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Indian Express
2 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Maternity leave can be included in bond period: Madras High Court
MADURAI: The Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court directed the state government to return the educational certificates of a doctor, which were withheld on the ground that she had gone on maternity leave without completing the mandatory two-year service done by postgraduate doctors. A bench of justices G R Swaminathan and K Rajasekar observed that the 12-month maternity period should be counted as part of the bond period. The judges made the observation while allowing an appeal filed by the doctor, E Krithikaa, challenging an order passed by a single judge rejecting her previous petition. During the admission to MS (General Surgery) at Thanjavur Government Medical College, Krithikaa signed a bond for the sum of Rs 40 lakh with an undertaking that upon completion of the three-year course, she would serve the government for at least two years. She was also required to submit her original certificates. After graduating in August 2019, she served as an assistant surgeon at Thittakudi GH for a year and went on maternity leave. Saying that she did not complete the bonded service period, the authorities refused to return her certificates, a decision upheld by the single judge. Hearing her appeal, the division bench cited several SC judgments declaring that every woman has a fundamental right to maternity benefits. The judges referred to various provisions of the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961, especially section 27, which stated that provisions of the Act shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in any contract of service. Thus, the bench said the bond condition should give way to the rights conferred on women under the Act. It added that though the doctor is not a regular government employee, she is entitled to the same treatment.
Indian Express
4 hours ago
- Indian Express
Gurugram engineer falls asleep at the wheel, rams into 2 men: How sleeplessness affects your brain
Increasingly, we are hearing reports of people falling asleep while driving with terrible consequences as they hit unsuspecting people and even endanger their own lives. The latest case is of a Gurugram-based civil engineer, who was arrested for ramming into two men, including a law student, after he fell asleep while behind the wheel. Falling asleep at the wheel is a dangerous consequence of a fatigued or sleep-deprived brain. 'When we are sleep-deprived, the brain experiences 'microsleeps' — brief, involuntary episodes of sleep that can last a few seconds. During these moments, a driver can lose awareness and control, even with eyes open. The brain's prefrontal cortex, responsible for attention, decision-making, and alertness, becomes less active, impairing our ability to stay focused or respond quickly to road conditions,' says Dr Vinit Suri, senior consultant, Neurology, Indraprastha Apollo Hospitals, Delhi. The brain's sleep-wake cycle, governed by the circadian rhythm, also plays a critical role. Driving during low circadian alertness periods — such as late at night or early morning — increases the risk of drowsiness. 'Neurochemicals like adenosine, which build up during waking hours, signal sleep pressure to the brain; without rest, this pressure continues to mount, further weakening alertness. The reticular activating system (RAS), which helps keep us awake, starts to underperform when fatigued, making it harder to stay aroused. At the same time, the thalamus — a relay centre for sensory and motor signals — becomes less responsive, reducing awareness of surroundings,' explains Dr Suri. Drowsiness also suppresses activity in the brain's region responsible for vigilance and perception. 'Furthermore, a monotonous driving environment with little stimulation accelerates the decline in brain alertness. In essence, when the brain is too tired, its ability to prioritize staying awake over sleep fails, making it override even conscious efforts to stay alert,' says Dr Suri. A night's lack of sleep of less than six hours has been found to impair vigilance, reduce reaction time and decrease decision-making abilities in a similar way to alcohol consumption, according to Dr Aditya Gupta, Director, Neurosurgery & Cyberknife, Artemis Hospital, Gurugram. What are warning signs? Warning signs like frequent yawning, heavy eyelids, or drifting lanes should never be ignored. 'To prevent such cognitive shutdowns while driving, adequate sleep, regular breaks and avoiding driving during drowsy hours are essential. Fatigue behind the wheel is not a sign of weakness — it is a neurological warning that must be taken seriously,' he says. Patients with obstructive sleep apnoea may also have excessive daytime drowsiness, resulting in naps while driving and hence a history of heavy snoring should be taken, and if required, a sleep study too. What should you watch out for? 'We also caution against too much dependence on stimulants such as coffee or energy drinks. These can give a transient boost to alertness but cannot substitute for the brain's requirement for sleep,' says Dr Gupta. When their action wears off, sleep can hit one suddenly and uncontrollably. To avoid drowsy driving, he suggests getting 7–8 hours of sleep prior to long driving, resting breaks every two hours and not driving during the circadian low points. 'In the event of extreme exhaustion, the only solution is to stop and take a rest,' he adds.
New Indian Express
5 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Abortions in Kerala rise 76% over nine years
KOLLAM: Kerala has recorded an over 76% jump in abortion cases over a nine-year period, given the improved access to reproductive healthcare, according to data with the Health Management Information System (HMIS) portal. The state reported 30,037 abortions in 2023-24, compared to 17,025 in 2014-15, marking a 76.43% increase. In the latest period, 21,282 abortions were conducted in private hospitals, while government hospitals accounted for only 8,755 cases, indicating a growing reliance on private healthcare facilities. The data includes both spontaneous and induced abortions. In 2023-24, the state reported 20,179 induced abortions and 9,858 spontaneous abortions. In 2014-15, abortion procedures were almost evenly split between public and private hospitals, with 8,324 and 8,701 cases respectively. However, since 2015-16, private hospitals have consistently recorded a higher share of cases. From 2015-16 to 2024-25, Kerala reported a total of 1,97,782 abortion cases, of which only 67,004 were in government hospitals. Private hospitals accounted for 1,30,778 cases during this period. The report also noted a steady rise in induced abortions over the period under under review, reflecting better access to reproductive healthcare. Health experts, however, express concern over the increasing dependence on private hospitals and stress the need to strengthen the public health sector. Speaking to TNIE, Dr Leema, senior gynaecologist at the Women and Children Hospital, Thiruvananthapuram, said more patients now prefer private institutions due to better facilities and enhanced privacy. 'Medical termination of pregnancy (MTP) is a high-risk procedure,' said Leema. 'It is high time govt invested in better infra' 'Under the MTP (Amendment) Act, 2021, the permissible abortion limit has been extended from 20 to 24 weeks. Most women seeking abortions today are aware of their rights. They trust private hospitals for better operational care, post-procedure support, and, importantly, privacy — something often lacking in government institutions. Women today don't want to take risks with their lives and naturally lean towards private care,' she said. Dr Pandu R, senior gynaecologist at Kannur MCH, said it is high time the government invested in better infrastructure to regain public trust.
