&w=3840&q=100)
Is it safe to eat seafood in Kerala? How the sinking of a cargo ship brought concerns to the coast
Following sinking of cargo ship off the Kerala coast, worries over potential pollution, ranging from oil to tiny plastic pellets,have raised questions about the long-term impact on marine life and the safety of seafood in the region. Image for Representation. AFP
A recent capsize of a cargo ship off the Kerala coast has triggered fresh fears for the state's delicate marine ecosystem.
Last week, MSC ELSA 3, a Liberian-flagged container ship travelling from Vizhinjam port to Kochi, capsized near Alappuzha. The vessel was carrying 640 containers—some of which, the Coast Guard says, included 'hazardous cargo' that has now started washing ashore. Inside the ship's tanks were also large amounts of fuel, sparking fears about a major oil spill.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
While officials have denied any confirmed oil spill so far, concerns are far from over. Worries over potential pollution, ranging from oil to tiny plastic pellets known as nurdles, continue to grow, with questions being raised about the long-term impact on marine life and the safety of seafood in the region.
So, how serious is the damage? What steps are authorities taking? And most importantly, can you still safely eat fish from the Kerala coast? Here's what we know so far.
How difficult is it to manage an oil spill?
The MSC ELSA 3 was carrying a significant amount of fuel—at least 84.44 metric tonnes of diesel and 367 metric tonnes of furnace oil, according to the Coast Guard.
Though officials have ruled out a major spill, the director of Hyderabad-based Indian National Centre for Ocean Information Services (INCOIS) Dr T M Balakrishnan Nair, on Wednesday confirmed that there were traces of oil along the Alappuzha coast.
'Our six-member team has found small patches of oil slick along the coast. These are bunker oil used in ships. As the oil spill has been contained almost, we do not expect a massive oil slick. However, it would continue to appear on the southern Kerala coast in the coming days also. Everything depends upon how much oil has leaked out from the ship,' he told the Indian Express.
The Liberian container vessel MSC ELSA 3 sank off the coast of Kerala on Sunday. It contained at least 84.44 metric tonnes of diesel and 367 metric tonnes of furnace oil. Image courtesy: PTI
Earlier, a simulation conducted by the agency suggested that if all the diesel and furnace oil from the vessel were to leak into the sea, there was a high chance it would drift towards the Kerala coast, specifically the stretch between Alappuzha and Thiruvananthapuram.
Managing oil spills is no easy task. Each incident behaves differently depending on the type and volume of oil released. Cleanup operations are often expensive, labour-intensive, and can stretch on for months.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
In the case of MSC ELSA 3, experts say it's critical to stop the oil from reaching the shoreline.
'Oil smothering could threaten sensitive marine species and disrupt fishing activities, particularly affecting artisanal fishers in coastal regions. If the spill spreads, it may harm marine productivity, especially during the monsoon, a critical period for pelagic fish breeding and growth. This could have lasting consequences for fisheries,' Grinson George, director of Kochi-based Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute (CMFRI), told The Times of India.
Meanwhile, authorities say their top priorities include recovering the oil, retrieving containers adrift at sea, and removing those that have washed up on beaches. July 3 has been set as the deadline for completing oil recovery efforts.
Plastic shipwreck sparks worry about pollutants
Even as authorities monitor for a possible oil spill, another threat has already started washing ashore—pollutants from the cargo itself.
Several containers from the sunken MSC ELSA 3 have broken loose and made landfall, bringing with them plastic pellets, chemicals, and potentially hazardous materials.
In recent days, beaches in Thiruvananthapuram, such as Thumba and Kochuveli, have seen large amounts of nurdles, small plastic pellets used in the production of plastic goods. These can be mistaken for food by marine life and are extremely difficult to clean up once they spread, reports _The News Minute.
_
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
🚨 Eco-Disaster Unfolding in India
Millions of plastic pellets (nurdles) are washing up on Kerala's shores after the MSC ELSA3 shipwreck.
🐢 Marine life is choking.
🌍 Ecosystems are at risk.
👣 Humans aren't far behind.
This is a global wake-up call.#NurdleSpill #PlasticCrisis… pic.twitter.com/CRWrh5TUco — Paulose Jacob Peter (@Anand02908794) May 28, 2025
INCOIS has predicted that nurdles may drift along a stretch of 84 nautical miles off the Kovalam coast by May 29. As per an update by the INCOIS on May 26, 30 tonnes of cargo have been floating in the sea, while 45 tonnes have reached the shore. Around 25 tonnes of cargo have either evaporated or dispersed.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
A recent yet-to-be-published study has already raised alarms about the region's vulnerability.
'Incidents like this will cause the presence of microplastics in commercially available fish to go beyond the permissible levels. Bioaccumulation of these pollutants in our body will have long-term impacts,' Dr Shaju SS, assistant professor at the Department of Chemical Oceanography at Cochin University of Science and Technology, told The News Minute.
The ship was also carrying 640 containers, which also included 13 marked as 'hazardous cargo' and 12 containing calcium carbide.
Kerala holds emergency expert meet after Liberian ship sinks near shore, bans fishing, deploys pollution control teams. PTI
The Kerala State Disaster Management Authority has issued a public warning, urging people not to approach any containers washed up on shore, as calcium carbide can trigger dangerous exothermic reactions if it comes into contact with water and can cause explosions, Shaju told the outlet.
The Coast Guard has responded by deploying clean-up vessels and conducting aerial surveillance to track the spread of pollutants. Authorities have also deployed 108 personnel onshore for container recovery and cleanup.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
'Thirty-eight people have been deployed in Thiruvananthapuram, Alappuzha, and Kollam, linked directly to DDMA (District Disaster Management Authority). District Collectors are actively coordinating response efforts. Fifty containers have been traced across seven sites. Efforts are underway to retrieve them within two days,' Capt Abul Kalam Azad, Nautical Advisor to the Union Government, said.
Is it safe to eat seafood?
So far, yes.
Despite the concerns surrounding the sunken vessel and potential pollutants, experts say there is no need to panic, at least not yet.
The Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute (CMFRI) and the State Fisheries Department are actively monitoring the situation. Regular water sampling is underway, and authorities are closely tracking any signs of contamination.
Speaking to Kerala-based outlet Mathrubhumi News, CMFRI Director Dr Grinson George said there's currently no reason to avoid eating seafood as fish from the affected area are not entering the market. Fishing is currently banned in the immediate vicinity of the wreck.
CMFRI Director Dr Grinson George said there's currently no reason to avoid eating seafood as fish from the affected area are not entering the market. Fishing is currently banned in the immediate vicinity of the wreck. File image/PTI
The outlet also cited food safety experts who noted that unless there's confirmed leakage, the situation shouldn't raise alarm. Even in the event of some leakage, the vast volume of seawater could help dilute any harmful substances before they pose a widespread threat.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
As of now, agencies continue to test seawater quality and collect samples. The Fisheries Department is expected to issue official guidance once the scientific assessments are complete.
With input from agencies
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
5 hours ago
- First Post
UK aviation authorities review Air India plane crash report as families seek answers
UK's Air Accidents Investigation Branch announced that it is investigating the preliminary Air India plane crash report released by its Indian counterpart. British AAIB is part of the investigatory process since it involves the death of 52 British nationals on board. read more The United Kingdom's Air Accidents Investigation Branch on Saturday announced that it is in the process of reviewing the preliminary report released by its Indian counterpart on the London-bound Air India plane crash. The report released by the Indian Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) on Saturday is based on the initial findings of their probe into the crash that took place in Ahmedabad, killing all but one of the 242 passengers and crew. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD It is pertinent to note that the British AAIB is part of the investigatory process since it involves the death of 52 British nationals on board. 'The UK AAIB welcomes the publication of this preliminary report, which is a summary of factual information uncovered so far by the AAIB India investigation,' UK AAIB said in a 'The UK AAIB are in the process of reviewing this preliminary report in detail and remains in communication with AAIB India. The UK AAIB has 'expert' status in the Indian safety investigation. By international protocols, release of information on the investigation rests solely with the Indian authorities,' it furthered. The UK watches the investigation closely The 15-page preliminary investigation report into the devastating crash revealed that the fuel-control switches of the two engines moved from the "run" to the "cutoff" position within the space of one second. This led to the immediate loss of altitude, eventually leading to the crash. In the cockpit voice recording, one of the pilots was heard asking the other why he had cut off the fuel. The other said that he didn't. Meanwhile, the UK-based families who have lost their loved ones in the June 12 crash have called for a mechanism of expert representation in the investigatory process. Keystone Law, which is currently advising over 20 of these families in the case welcomed the report stating that it defined the 'area of investigation,' around the fuel control switches. 'The families now understand there is a more defined area of investigation, but one of their bigger concerns is that they are excluded from this safety investigation,' said James Healy-Pratt, Aviation Partner at Keystone. 'Ideally, there should be some mechanism for which there can be expert representation for those families that can feed into the combined safety work that's going on. And don't forget, it's an international product. It's not only the Indian AAIB, the British AAIB has been helping, as have the Americans. So ideally, the families should have some form of input into that,' he said. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD It is pertinent to note that the Indian AAIB report is a preliminary one and it would take months for the final report to come out. The investigation in the case is still ongoing. With inputs from the PTI.
New Indian Express
6 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Plastic pellets, untreated sewage pose threat at Papanasam beach in Varkala
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM: With the annual 'Vavu Bali' ritual just days away, pollution at the Papanasam beach in Varkala has sparked serious concern among devotees and the Janardhana Swamy Temple authorities. Nurdles (tiny plastic pellets) from the MSC Elsa 3 shipwreck and unchecked sewage discharge from nearby hotels and resorts continue to pollute the beach, posing a health hazard and creating severe inconvenience for tourists and pilgrims. The temple authorities, who oversee the ritual arrangements, have expressed their worry over the unhygienic conditions of the beach. 'The stench from the polluted water and the plastic nurdles washing ashore have made it difficult for devotees arriving to offer bali,' said a temple official. 'We hope the authorities will act swiftly to clean up the area before the Vavu Bali on July 24,' the official added. Local residents say that none of the authorities, including the Dewaswom Board, Varkala municipality, and district administration, are taking up the responsibility to address the pollution issues at the beach frequented by thousands every day. Hospital ward councillor K Anil Kumar echoed the concerns, stating that the beach is in no condition to host a major spiritual event. 'The restaurants and resorts on the cliff continue to discharge raw sewage directly into the water. No serious cleanup was undertaken last year either, despite the large turnout of devotees. The dispute between departments on who is responsible for cleaning up the beach every year has worsened the situation,' he said. Meanwhile, Papanasam ward councillor P Ajayakumar maintained that daily cleaning efforts are underway. 'Fire department personnel and volunteers have been consistently removing plastic nurdles from the shore. We will intensify the cleanup and make all necessary arrangements to ensure that the ritual is conducted smoothly,' he said.
Hindustan Times
6 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
‘What good is this': Kin of Air India crash victims struggle to find meaning in AAIB report
One month after losing his daughter, son-in-law and three grandchildren in the Air India crash, Anil Vyas struggled to find meaning in the preliminary investigation report that detailed fuel switches and flight recorder data but stopped short, as preliminary investigations customarily do, from offering a conclusive explanation for why 260 people died. Relatives mourning by the coffins of victims, who were killed in the Air India flight AI171 crash. (Dibyangshu Sarkar/AFP File) "What good is this report to us now? It won't bring back my daughter, her husband, or their children," said Vyas over the loss of Dr Komi Vyas, her husband Dr Prateek Joshi and their three children aged 5, 5 and 8. The Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau's 15-page preliminary report, released on Saturday, provided precise technical details about Flight 171's final moments after it took off from Ahmedabad on June 12, but it did not provide the closure the families of the dead were seeking. The preliminary report has not satisfied Imtiaz Ali, who lost his younger brother Javed Ali Syed along with his wife and two children, aged 6 and 4, in the crash. "A lot of questions still remain in our minds," he said, declining to assign blame. 'The report hasn't given us a satisfactory conclusion to the cause yet. This was just preliminary, it had a fair bit of details and information, but the cause, the real reason why the plane went down, is not clear.' Ali questioned the circumstances surrounding the fuel switch movements while defending the flight crew. 'I do not want to blame the pilots; they were not drunk, and they were seasoned experienced pilots. I also find it hard to believe the pilot would lie at that last moment at the brink of death that he did not turn off the fuel switch. The question then is that how did the switch go off.' "There is a big difference between the possibility that one of the pilots turned the switch off and that one of them actually did it; I want to reserve my judgment till it is conclusive," he said. The Syed family were British citizens who had come to Mumbai to visit family and celebrate Eid. On their way back home, they took a detour to Ahmedabad for a direct flight to London, but never made their destination. Aakash Patel, 33, whose wife Jayshree died in the crash just months after their January wedding, said he had not yet read the report. The couple had been separated while awaiting visa processing for Jayshree to join him in London. "I spoke to her at 1.33 pm, right after she boarded. Moments later, my relatives called with the devastating news of the crash," Patel said. To be sure, preliminary reports often are a reflection of the data and information that investigators are working with and rarely make conclusive statements about the triggers for a disaster. The report cites cockpit voice recordings capturing one pilot asking the other why he had cut off fuel, with the colleague denying he had done this. It did not identify which pilot made the statement or offer a transcript of the audio. Legal representatives for victims' families raised concerns about potential aircraft system failures based on the preliminary findings. Stewarts, a London law firm representing families of more than 20 passengers, said the report suggested pilots were unaware that fuel had been cut off. "Our reading of the preliminary report is that the pilots were not aware that the fuel had been cut off, indicating that neither pilot had purposefully flipped the cut-off switches," the firm said. 'The factual information raises a troubling spectre that this accident may have been caused by uncommanded fuel cut off, suggesting a possible failure in the Boeing systems.' Stewarts has partnered with US aviation law firms to pursue potential claims against American defendants, including Boeing. Ali urged authorities to continue investigating thoroughly. "The government, Air India and other authorities should look into it more, so the families of the victims can get a sense of closure. I want to believe the answer is out there; however long it will take to find, I will wait."
