Gary Lineker among 500 media figures urging BBC to reinstate Gaza documentary
The broadcaster removed Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone from BBC iPlayer pending a 'due diligence' exercise after it emerged that the film's 14-year-old narrator was the son of a deputy agriculture minister in the territory's Hamas-run government.
Critics of the programme, including dozens of prominent Jewish journalists, condemned a failure of commissioning standards and questioned whether the BBC had paid any member of Hamas as part of the filming of the documentary.
A letter, sent on Wednesday to the BBC executives Samir Shah, Tim Davie and Charlotte Moore and seen by the Guardian, describes the film as 'an essential piece of journalism, offering an all-too-rare perspective on the lived experiences of Palestinians'.
The letter claims that some criticism of the documentary is based on 'racist assumptions and weaponisation of identity', and that the deputy agriculture minister and father of the teenage narrator is a civil servant concerned with food production.
'This broad-brush rhetoric assumes that Palestinians holding administrative roles are inherently complicit in violence – a racist trope that denies individuals their humanity and right to share their lived experiences,' it says.
The UK government proscribed the military wing of Hamas as a terrorist organisation in 2006, and in 2021 also proscribed the Islamist movement's political wing. There are civil servants in Gaza not involved in political activities, some of whom worked for the government before Hamas took over the territory.
The letter also claims that criticism levelled against Abdullah, the 14-year-old narrator, disregarded 'core safeguarding principles', adding that children 'must not be held responsible for the actions of adults, and weaponising family associations to discredit a child's testimony is both unethical and dangerous'.
The BBC documentary was based on nine months of footage filmed in the run-up to last month's Israel-Gaza ceasefire, with three children among the main characters. It was produced by an independent company, Hoyo Films.
The Bafta-winning director Jasleen Kaur Sethi, who signed the letter, said: 'At the heart of this film are children surviving a war zone and as documentary-makers we have a sacrosanct duty to protect them. The campaign to discredit this film has dehumanised them and shamefully risked putting their lives and safety in danger.'
Lineker, who signed the letter and is the BBC's best-paid star, announced last year that he would step down as host of Match of the Day. He has previously been criticised for wading into politics, including condemnation of government immigration policy, and has been a staunch defender of the BBC.
Other signatories include the actor Khalid Abdalla, the Bridgerton star India Amarteifio, the novelist Max Porter, the director Ken Loach, the photographer Misan Harriman, the comedian Jen Brister, the presenter Ayo Akinwolere and the writer and actor Asim Chaudhry. The Guardian understands 10 current BBC staff have also signed.
Last week, the BBC received a letter signed by 45 prominent Jewish journalists and members of the media demanding the programme be taken down. Signatories included the former BBC One controller Danny Cohen, the former BBC governor Ruth Deech, the EastEnders actor Tracy-Ann Oberman and the Strike producer Neil Blair.
Phil Rosenberg, the director of the Board of Deputies of British Jews, called for an independent inquiry into the broadcaster earlier this week, saying he was concerned by the its 'credulous' approach to Hamas.
A spokesperson for the BBC pointed the Guardian to two statements on its corrections and clarifications page saying it was conducting further due diligence with the production company. The documentary will not be available on iPlayer while investigations continue.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
25 minutes ago
- The National
Dates of Donald Trump's September state visit to UK confirmed
The US president will be accompanied by his wife, First Lady Melania Trump, on his state visit to the UK from September 17 to 19, Buckingham Palace said. DONALD Trump will be hosted by the King and Queen at Windsor Castle during his unprecedented second state visit to the UK in September. This will be Trump's second state visit to the UK – an unprecedented gesture towards an American leader, having previously been feted by a state visit in 2019. The House of Commons will not be sitting at the time of Trump's visit as it will be in recess for party conference season, meaning the president will not be able to address Parliament as French President Emmanuel Macron did during his state visit this week. READ MORE: Anas Sarwar left red-faced as Labour-run council orders no Alexander Dennis buses However, the House of Lords will be sitting. A senior minister insisted the timing of the trip was a matter for Buckingham Palace, rather than an attempt by the Government to avoid potential embarrassment over a parliamentary address. Treasury chief secretary Darren Jones said: 'I don't know why the particular dates were chosen by the Palace. 'Of course, state visits are organised by the Palace, not by the Government or Parliament.' Former Commons speaker John Bercow (below) opposed Trump appearing in Parliament during his first term in office and 20 MPs have signed a motion resisting an invitation being issued this time around. Jones told ITV's Good Morning Britain the Government was 'looking forward to welcoming' Trump. 'We benefit in terms of our economy and our defence and national security capabilities by continuing our very historic and important relationship with the United States of America, whoever is president,' he said. In February this year, Prime Minister Keir Starmer presented the US president with a letter from the King as he invited him for the visit during a meeting at the White House. As the pair were sat next to each other in the Oval Office, Starmer handed the president the personal invitation, later saying 'this is truly historic and unprecedented'. After reading it, Trump said it was a 'great, great honour', adding 'and that says at Windsor – that's really something'. In the letter, Charles suggested he and the president might meet at Balmoral or Dumfries House in Scotland first before the much grander state visit. However, it is understood that, although all options were explored, there were logistical challenges surrounding an informal visit, with complexities in both the King and Mr Trump's diaries meaning a private meeting was not possible over the course of the summer months. This week, a senior Police Scotland officer said the cost of policing a visit by Trump will be 'considerable' and that the force will look to secure extra funding. It emerged on Wednesday that the force was in the early stages of planning for a visit at the end of this month, which is likely to see the president visit one or both of his golf clubs in Aberdeenshire and Ayrshire and require substantial policing resources and probably units to be called in from elsewhere in the UK. Precedent for second-term US presidents who have already made a state visit is usually tea or lunch with the monarch at Windsor Castle, as was the case for George W Bush and Barack Obama. The late Queen hosted Trump during his first state visit. News of the plans for the September visit comes days after the King wrote to Trump to express his 'profound sadness' after catastrophic flooding killed nearly 90 people in Texas. Charles 'offered his deepest sympathy' to those who lost loved ones over the July Fourth weekend, the British Embassy in Washington said. Back in March, Trump sent the King his 'best wishes' and 'good health' in a phone call with Starmer after Charles spent a brief period in hospital after experiencing temporary side effects from his cancer treatment. The September state visit comes after Charles visited Canada back in May where he opened the nation's parliament. Many Canadians saw the King's two-day visit to Ottawa as a symbol of support for the country that has faced the unwanted attention of Trump's trade war against his neighbour and threats to annex Canada. This week, French president Macron and his wife Brigitte were hosted by the King and Queen during his three-day state visit. Macron's itinerary included a glittering state banquet at Windsor Castle, a carriage ride through the historic Berkshire town and a ceremonial welcome. The state dinner was attended by the Queen, the Prince and Princess of Wales, the Prime Minister and senior members of the Cabinet.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Labour politicians fail to declare all-expenses-paid trip to Israel
Five MPs, alongside Labour peer Luciana Berger, were taken on an all-expenses-paid trip to Israel and Palestine in May by the lobbying group Labour Friends of Israel (LFI) where they posed for a photo with Israeli president Isaac Herzog, who has backed the genocide of Palestinians. Speaking at a press conference 10 days after the Hamas attack of October 7, Herzog said: 'It is an entire nation out there that is responsible.' The group of politicians also met Israeli deputy foreign minister Sharren Haskel, leader of the opposition Yair Lapid and IDF reserve major general Yair Golan, according to Declassified UK. READ MORE: 'Humanitarian city' will be concentration camp, says ex-Israel prime minister Two of the MPs who took part – Jon Pearce and Mark Sewards – have registered the trip and put its value at £2600. Peter Prinsley, Kevin McKenna and Cat Eccles have all failed to do so. This week, an LFI parliamentary delegation visited Israel & Palestine as we marked 600 days since 7 Oct 2023. We called for a renewed ceasefire & hostage deal, unrestricted humanitarian aid to Gazans, an end to Hamas rule, and progress towards a two-state solution and regional… — Labour Friends of Israel (@_LFI) May 30, 2025 In a statement following the visit, Pearce, chair of the LFI, said: 'It's more important than ever for British Members of Parliament to visit Israel and Palestine to show solidarity and hear directly from people on the ground.' He added: 'We left the region more convinced than ever of the need to secure the release [of] the remaining 58 hostages, massively increase humanitarian aid into Gaza, and see Hamas relinquish control of Gaza.' READ MORE: Six children among 10 people killed by Israel at water collection point It comes as pressure mounts on Israel over brutal war crimes in Palestine, as it emerged this weekend that Israeli soldiers killed six children who were collecting water at a humanitarian aid point. Elsewhere, fury is mounting – including within Israel itself – over plans to force Palestinians into a concentration camp on the ruins of the city of Rafah. Former Israeli prime minister Ehud Olmert told The Guardian: 'If they [Palestinians] will be deported into the new 'humanitarian city', then you can say that this is part of an ethnic cleansing.' In a post on social media, the LFI set out how it visited Jerusalem, Ramallah and Tel Aviv and Kibbutz Kfar Aza in the south of the country as well as the site of the massacre at the Nova music festival. The Kibbutz was among the places which came under attack from Hamas on October 7.
Scottish Sun
2 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Labour chiefs in hypocrisy row after ordering NO buses from Alexander Dennis as firm faces closure
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) SCOTTISH Labour-run Edinburgh Council failed to buy a single bus from closure-threatened Alexander Dennis for the last three years, we can reveal. The party were last night labelled hypocrites after using bus orders from Labour-run Manchester to attack the SNP's failures to support the business. Sign up for the Politics newsletter Sign up 4 The Alexander Dennis site at Camelon, near Falkirk Credit: PA 4 Anas Sarwar had criticised SNP inaction over the future of Alexander Dennis Credit: Getty However, it has emerged that after coming to power in the Capital, council bus firm Lothian Buses failed to make a single order from the company. Lothian Buses is the single largest taxpayer-owned bus operator in Scotland. Scottish Tory transport spokeswoman and Lothian MSP, Sue Webber, said the figures were a 'major source of embarrassment for Anas Sarwar'. She said: 'He has been at pains to demand more support for the under-threat workforce at Alexander Dennis but his own council in Edinburgh haven't lifted a finger for years. Find out what's really going on Register now for our free weekly politics newsletter for an insightful and irreverent look at the (sometimes excruciating) world of Scottish Politics. Every Thursday our hotshot politics team goes behind the headlines to bring you a rundown of key events - plus insights and gossip from the corridors of power, including a 'Plonker' and 'Star' of the Week. Sign up now and make sure you don't miss a beat. The politicians would hate that. SIGN UP FOR FREE NOW 'The Scottish Labour leader must urgently ask his councillors in Edinburgh why they have turned their backs on this firm, which now looks set to leave Scotland.' Figures from Lothian Buses, Scotland's largest council-run bus firm, show 180 buses were purchased from the company between 2018 and 2022. The SNP and Scottish Labour ran Edinburgh council between 2017 and 2022 in a power-sharing deal. Scottish Labour's shock win in Hamilton stuns establishment as SNP face 'false' campaign blast But at the council elections in 2022, ex-party chief Cammy Day seized total control of the city by cutting a deal with Scottish Lib Dem and Tory councillors to block the SNP and Scottish Greens from power. But Lothian said not a single order had been made to Alexander Dennis by the bus operator since Scottish Labour took over as a minority administration. Instead 43 new buses were ordered from other manufacturers in 2023. Alexander Dennis has said it needs around 70 orders this year and 300 next year to stay open in Scotland. 4 Andy Burnham, the mayor of Greater Manchester, had ordered 160 buses from Alexander Dennis Credit: PA 4 Scottish Tory transport spokeswoman Sue Webber said the news was "embarrassing" for Mr Sarwar Credit: Alamy A Scottish Government source slammed Labour for 'playing politics'. They said: 'While the Scottish Government explores all options to secure the future of Alexander Dennis in Scotland, the Labour Party have been focused on playing politics. 'This proves that Labour are not serious, they are more concerned with soundbites and social media videos than actually governing and Anas Sarwar is clearly unfit to be First Minister.' Last week 80 jobs were axed at Fife-based Greenfold Systems which builds parts for Alexander Dennis in the latest blow to Scotland's home-grown bus manufacturing. Figures obtained by The Scottish Sun show major bus firms in Scotland have bought hundreds of buses from Alexander Dennis in the last five years. Stagecoach said they had ordered more than 1,000 buses from the company in the last five years, with a further 669 going to other manufacturers. First Bus said it had 200 electric buses from the firm in operation across Scotland, with 84 from other companies. McGills refused to give figures but said it had reduced its orders from Alexander Dennis due to issues with their electric models. They said before the pandemic when all of their buses ran on diesel, Alexander Dennis vehicles made up over 50 per cent of their fleet. A Lothian Bus spokesman said: 'All vehicle procurement decisions are based on an extensive range of factors including product compatibility with Lothian's evolving fleet strategy.' A Scottish Labour spokeswoman added: 'Scottish Labour is clear that we want to make sure that government contracts support Scottish industry and Scottish jobs. 'While the SNP sends contracts to China and Turkey, Anas Sarwar is convening a summit with Mayors from across the UK to discuss how we boost domestic bus manufacturing businesses, including at iconic firms like Alexander Dennis.' An Edinburgh Council spokesman said: "The Council has no involvement in procurement of vehicles for Lothian Buses. This is decided by the Lothian Buses Board."
