Underachievement of working class boys needs urgent strategy
Speaking in the Commons, Mr Rushworth said: 'What concerns me most is not just the data, but the absence of outrage and lack of urgency.
'It wasn't always this way. In the 1970s and 80s, it was girls who were lagging behind, and the government rightly took action to improve outcomes for girls – introducing targeted support, challenging curriculum bias, expanding grammar schools for girls and promoting girls access to Stem (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Maths).
'And these were not small tweaks, they were deliberate strategic interventions, and they worked. Now that the situation is reversed with boys persistently underachieving, where is the strategy?
'I'm not talking about a general strategy to address deprivation or educational disadvantage, but a specific evidence-based deliverable strategy around boys and young men, which addresses the gender based aspects of underachievement.'
During the debate on educational attainment of boys, Mr Rushworth said a 'coded message in our current curriculum is that society values academic excellence over development of technical skills'.
He went on to say: 'I believe we urgently need a national strategy for boys' attainment – cross-party, evidence-based and rooted in fairness.
'It should invest in teacher training that recognises gender bias and engages boys more effectively.
'It should embed social emotional learning throughout the curriculum, especially in early years and transition stages, expand vocational and technical pathways, recognising different routes to success, promote leadership opportunities for boys in school life, and, most importantly, ensure transparent gender disaggregated data to hold ourselves accountable nationally and locally.'
He added: 'I don't want boys in Bishop Auckland or in Bootle, Barry or Basingstoke to feel like the system has no place for them. I want them to feel seen, supported and believed in, because when we raise the floor for those who are struggling, we lift the whole classroom.'
Labour's Helen Hayes, chairwoman of the education select committee, said there is 'a need for a strategic approach to this', but it is a 'complex' area.
She told MPs: 'We know that white British boys, black Caribbean boys, and mixed white and black Caribbean boys eligible for free school meals, have particularly low levels of attainment, as do those from Gypsy-Roma or travellers of Irish heritage.'
'Men still earn more on average, with the gender pay gap growing over time, so this is an area of policy that requires complex and nuanced consideration,' she added.
Education minister Catherine McKinnell said: 'We know that on average boys have lower attainment than girls, and as a Government we are determined to understand and address the drivers behind this, because all children should have the opportunity to achieve and thrive in their education.'
She added that a Schools White Paper will be published in the autumn and the Government is working alongside Sir Hamid Patel and Estelle Morris on an inquiry into the 'barriers to attainment for white working-class children'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
21 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Cleverly vs Rayner is no sideshow – it's an audition
Kemi's reshuffle faces that classic Opposition conundrum: how do you build a cabinet of all the talents when you've got no talent? The answer: James Cleverly. Tough. Egotistical. Simply irresistible. When his name flashed up on TV – 'Cleverly to shadow Rayner' – he probably punched the air and cried: 'The boys are back in town!' This is the kind of self-confident, political jock who gives his penis not only a name but a military rank. Lieutenant Colonel Big Jim thrust his way into the Commons, presumably looking for some MPs to congratulate him – but found the benches sparse. 'Twas the last day before recess and the subject was Birmingham bin collections, so there were just 15 in the chamber, including four Gaza independents and Jeremy Corbyn (dressed, out of solidarity, in a binman's waterproof jacket). Cleverly said hello to a whip and left. A pity, because the subject is fascinating. Unions accuse Labour-run Brum of cutting workers' wages, and Unite has suspended Angela Rayner's membership for backing the council. It's akin to when the Kronstadt sailors turned on the Bolsheviks, having discovered that the Left in power can be every bit as mean and nasty as the upper class. It's also a preview of future public sector strikes thanks to the Treasury's fiscal rules. Hence Rayner is privately arguing for tax rises rather than cuts, along with action to address the impact of mass migration. As the rubbish piles higher, the only alternative – and I wouldn't put it past Labour – is to give the rats the vote. Rayner is as clever as Cleverly, and the prospect of the two arguing at the despatch box might be Kemi's best move yet – though it carries risk. Cleverly would like to be Tory leader some day, preferably tomorrow; so he'll revel in the exposure. Rayner is equally ambitious, and the rebellion among Left-wing MPs, along with the spectre of a Corbynite party, strengthens her hand. A year ago, Starmer planned to govern as a centrist: balance the books, unleash business. But the economy refuses to grow, however much the Chancellor shouts at it, and the welfare mutiny has put redistribution back on the agenda. One can imagine the parliamentary Left turning on Starmer, with Rayner – goddess of social housing – as their preferred candidate. Cleverly vs Rayner is no sideshow. It's an audition. Till then, the few MPs still around are packing bags, ordering taxis. Soon the palace will empty but for the ghosts of dead kings and Maggie, the Speaker's tortoise (he also has a parrot called Boris and cats called Attlee and Clem). The Chancellor gave a final discourse on her 'three pillars' to running the economy at a gentle Lords committee, which was a nice way to round off the term. At one point, she appeared to put her head in her hands. Behind her, the cameras caught me with my head lolling back, mouth open, snoring like a dog. Till my phone pinged. Latest reshuffle news: Alan Mak is out. The world tilted on its axis; I felt a great disturbance in the force. There was little left to live for but to file a suggested headline: 'MAK THE KNIFED.' Job done, back to sleep.
The Guardian
21 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Starmer under pressure from cabinet to recognise Palestinian statehood
Keir Starmer is under pressure from cabinet ministers for the UK to immediately recognise Palestine as a state, as the global outcry grew over Israel's killing of starving civilians in Gaza. The prime minister is understood to have been urged by a number of senior ministers in different cabinet meetings over recent months that the UK should take a leading role in issuing recognition. The UK plans to formally acknowledge Palestine as part of a peace process, but only in conjunction with other western countries and 'at the point of maximum impact' – without saying what that would be. However, there has been a growing sense of desperation and horror inside the Labour cabinet over Israel's killing of starving Palestinian civilians in Gaza, and its attacks on humanitarian agencies, in recent weeks. 'We say that recognising Palestinian statehood is a really important symbol that you can only do once. But if not now, then when?' one cabinet minister said. Earlier this month, nearly 60 Labour MPs demanded the UK immediately recognises Palestine as a state, after Israel's defence minister announced plans to force all residents of Gaza into a camp on the ruins of Rafah. Israel is facing intensifying international condemnation for its actions in Gaza, with the UN secretary general, António Guterres, warning that the 'last lifelines keeping people alive [in the strip] are collapsing'. Emmanuel Macron, the French president, told British parliamentarians in a visit this month that a two-state solution was 'the only way' to build peace and stability in the region. However, diplomats say he has faced resistance from allies such as Britain and Canada over his push. France and Saudi Arabia are co-chairing a rescheduled international conference at the UN in New York later this month to discuss postwar plans for Gaza and preparations for formally acknowledging Palestine. The UK foreign secretary, David Lammy, who said he felt 'appalled, sickened' by the scenes of starving Palestinians being shot as they sought food, said the UK would 'play its part' in reaching a two-state solution for the Middle East, including working with the French. 'We said we wanted that to be part of a process. But we have had no process. What we have had is mayhem and conflict. There has been no process to attach that recognition to,' he told the BBC on Tuesday. 'Why do we say that? It's because we don't just want to recognise symbolically, we want to recognise as a way of getting to the two states that sadly many are trying to thwart at this point in time. 'But there is a live debate and discussion and let me restate again my belief in two states, and two states in which Palestinians have their dignity and freedom and Israel has its security for its people. We will do all we can to achieve that in time.' In an unusual Commons intervention on Gaza, the health secretary, Wes Streeting, on Tuesday called for recognition of the state of Palestine 'while there's still a state of Palestine left to recognise'. He criticised the 'intolerable' attack by Israel on the World Health Organization's staff residence and main warehouse in Deir al-Balah on Monday, which had compromised its operations in Gaza. 'I deplore Israel's attacks on healthcare workers as well as other innocent civilians trying to access healthcare or vital aid. These actions go well beyond legitimate self-defence and undermine the prospects for peace,' he told MPs. 'I sincerely hope that the international community can come together, as the foreign secretary has been driving towards, to make sure that we see an end of this war but also that we recognise the state of Palestine while there is a state of Palestine left to recognise.' Streeting is understood to be among the cabinet ministers who have pushed for recognition of Palestine in recent cabinet meetings. The justice secretary, Shabana Mahmood, and the Northern Ireland secretary, Hilary Benn, are also understood to have brought up the issue. At the Commons liaison committee on Monday, the prime minister said the situation in Gaza was 'intolerable' as he repeated the UK's commitment to recognising a Palestinian state 'at a time most conducive to the prospects of peace' in the region. Israel has been fighting Hamas in the Gaza Strip since the Palestinian militant group's deadly attack on Israel in October 2023. A US-backed proposal for a 60-day ceasefire is being discussed at talks in Doha.
The National
27 minutes ago
- The National
Scottish Water hits back at UK minister Steve Reed's pollution claim
Labour's Environment Secretary Steve Reed said in a Channel 4 interview last night that pollution levels in Scotland are 'worse than they are in England'. In response, Scotland's Climate Secretary Gillian Martin has written a letter hitting out at the 'misleading' comments and saying it is "clear that Scotland has a higher performance". But now, Scottish Water – the publicly owned utility company that provides water and wastewater services in Scotland – has also responded to Reed's comments. "Scottish Water is the UK's top performing water company and most trusted utility in the UK according to the Customer Service Institute,' a spokesperson told The National. READ MORE: 'Twinned with Epstein Island' sign put up at Donald Trump's Aberdeenshire golf course "In addition to producing world-class drinking water, the independent regulator, Sepa, says 87% of water bodies in Scotland are either good or excellent, the highest proportion ever.' They added: "The Cunliffe Report also makes clear that 'Scotland has a greater number of water bodies achieving 'good' status compared to England and Wales'" The final report from the Independent Water Commission led by Sir Jon Cunliffe was published this week. It found that 66% of Scotland's water bodies are of good ecological status compared with 16.1% in England and 29.9% in Wales. Although, the report does note that this is, in part, due to Scotland having a much lower population density.
