GAA fans all asking the same question after Kilkenny v Tipperary incident
There was plenty of needle between the sides, particularly in the second half. Tipperary were reduced to 14 men when Darragh McCarthy was shown a second yellow card for a challenge on Kilkenny goalkeeper Eoin Murphy.
But many fans felt Kilkenny should also have been reduced to 14 men for a challenge on Andrew Ormond with a few minutes of the second half to go.
Mikey Carey was shown a yellow card for the challenge, but replays appeared to show it was the hurl of Paddy Deegan that connected with the helmet of Ormond.
A number of people took to social media to have their say on the decision, with one person saying: "Any hurley that makes contact with helmet is a straight red card."
Another said: "That's some joke, Andy Ormond hit in the back of the head with the Hurley, had to be a red card."
Someone else asked: "How has James Owens not given a red card there?"
One other person stated: "He's made contact with the head … how is it not a red card? The biggest issue hurling has at the moment is the inconsistency in the application of basic rules."
Tipperary ran out winners by 4-20 to 0-30 and will now face Munster rivals Cork in the decider back at Croke Park on Sunday, July 20.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The 42
an hour ago
- The 42
AUNZ finalise squad for Lions clash, Brumbies name ex-Connacht wing
LES KISS HAS confirmed his final AUNZ Invitational XV squad for Saturday's clash with the British and Irish Lions in Adelaide. Ex-Ireland assistant coach Kiss, who will succeed Joe Schmidt as Wallabies boss next year, will lead the AUNZ side for what will be the Lions' final warm-up game before their three-Test series against Australia. Many of the names in the AUNZ group had already been announced but the finalised 30-man squad has now been confirmed. New Zealand internationals David Havili, Shannon Frizell, Shaun Stevenson, Ngani Laumape, Hoskins Sotutu, and Folau Fakatava are among the stars, while there are several Wallabies involved, including Marika Koroibete, Lukhan Salakai-Loto, and Pete Samu. Among the final crop of players confirmed are Chiefs tighthead prop George Dyer and a number of players who have already impressed against the Lions in recent warm-up games, such as Waratahs wing Darby Lancaster and Reds back row Joe Brial. Advertisement AUNZ Invitational XV squad: Aidan Ross, AJ Lam, Angus Blyth, Brandon Paenga-Amosa, Daniel Botha, Darby Lancaster, David Havili, Folau Fakatava, George Dyer, Harry McLaughlin-Phillips, Hoskins Sotutu, Jeffery Toomaga-Allen, Jock Campbell, Joe Brial, Joey Walton, Joshua Fusitu'a, Kalani Thomas, Kurt Eklund, Lachlan Anderson, Lukhan Salakai-Loto, Mac Grealy, Marika Koroibete, Matt Philip, Ngani Laumape, Pete Samu, Richie Asiata, Seru Uru, Shannon Frizell, Shaun Stevenson, Tane Edmed. Former Connacht wing Ben O'Donnell. James Crombie / INPHO James Crombie / INPHO / INPHO Meanwhile, Brumbies boss Stephen Larkham has named his matchday 23 to face the Lions on Wednesday in Canberra. Flanker Tom Hooper returns to the side having played off the bench for the Wallabies against Fiji on Sunday, while speedy wing Corey Toole, scrum-half Ryan Lonergan, openside Rory Scott, centre David Feliuai, and loosehead Lington Ieli are all part of the starting XV having recently trained with Joe Schmidt's national squad. Former Connacht wing Ben O'Donnell, who was with the Irish province from 2020 until 2022, starts on the right wing in what will be his final Brumbies appearance before joining French D2 club Aurillac. Tom Hooper's younger brother, Lachie, is set for his Brumbies debut off the bench, as is prop Cameron Orr. Brumbies (v Lions): 15. Andy Muirhead 14. Ben O'Donnell 13. Ollie Sapsford 12. David Feliuai 11. Corey Toole 10. Declan Meredith 9. Ryan Lonergan (captain) 1. Lington Ieli 2. Lachlan Lonergan 3. Rhys van Nek 4. Lachie Shaw 5. Cadeyrn Neville 6. Tom Hooper 7. Rory Scott 8. Tuaina Taii Tualima Replacements: 16. Liam Bowron 17. Cameron Orr 18. Feao Fotuaika 19. Lachie Hooper 20. Luke Reimer 21. Harrison Goddard 22. Jack Debreczeni 23. Hudson Creighton
Irish Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Farrell names eight Ireland players in Lions team as he opts for strong side
Andy Farrell has named eight Ireland players in his strongest British and Irish Lions team yet, with Wednesday's clash against the ACT Brumbies in Canberra looking like a rehearsal for the first Test against Australia. Maro Itoje will captain the side, partnering with Joe McCarthy in the second row. The starting XV includes several players considered to be first choice, such as half-backs Jamison Gibson-Park and Finn Russell. Adding some flair from the bench are back-rower Henry Pollock and versatile playmaker Marcus Smith. Both England stars have the chance to demonstrate their readiness to face the Wallabies on 19 July. Pollock was set to start in Saturday's shaky 21-10 win over the New South Wales Waratahs but pulled out shortly before kick-off due to a tight calf. He has since recovered from the injury. The all-Irish centre pairing of Bundee Aki and Garry Ringrose has been selected, while Blair Kinghorn will make his first start at full-back after joining the squad late due to his Top 14 commitments with Toulouse. Tommy Freeman and James Lowe are tipped to take up the wing positions against Australia in Brisbane, both featuring in the line-up, with Mack Hansen providing additional back-three cover from the bench against his former Super Rugby franchise. Ellis Genge, the standout loosehead prop on tour, and Tadhg Furlong, a three-time Lions tourist, will be starting on either side of the scrum. Furlong is looking to regain his match-fitness after a season plagued by calf and hamstring injuries. Dan Sheehan has been selected as hooker. Tom Curry, usually an unstoppable force, has struggled to hit his stride Down Under but has been given the openside role in a back row that includes Ollie Chessum, who provides a crucial line-out option. Jack Conan is set to play at number eight, with Chessum likely providing second-row cover should Itoje or McCarthy suffer injuries, given that flankers Josh van der Flier and Pollock are named on the bench. The starting XV comprises eight players from Ireland, five from England and two from Scotland, with no room for Welsh openside Jac Morgan in the 23-man squad. The Brumbies, who reached the Super Rugby semi-finals before losing 37-17 to the Chiefs on June 14, are the toughest team the Lions will face in Australia outside of the Tests. Head coach Farrell acknowledged the challenge ahead, saying: "In 2013 the Brumbies beat the Lions in Canberra and this year they were the leading Australian team in Super Rugby – so we are fully aware of the challenge in front of us,". He also highlighted the special occasion for Mack Hansen, who will be returning to his home town to represent the Lions against some of his former team-mates. Lions line-up: B Kinghorn (Toulouse/Scotland); T Freeman (Northampton Saints/England), G Ringrose (Leinster Rugby/Ireland), B Aki (Connacht Rugby/Ireland), J Lowe (Leinster Rugby/Ireland); F Russell (Bath Rugby/Scotland), J Gibson-Park (Leinster Rugby/Ireland); E Genge (Bristol Bears/England), D Sheehan (Leinster Rugby/Ireland), T Furlong (Leinster Rugby/Ireland), M Itoje (Saracens/England, capt), J McCarthy (Leinster Rugby/Ireland), O Chessum (Leicester Tigers/England), T Curry (Sale Sharks/England), J Conan (Leinster Rugby/Ireland). Substitutes: R Kelleher (Leinster Rugby/Ireland), A Porter (Leinster Rugby/Ireland), W Stuart (Bath Rugby/England), J van der Flier (Leinster Rugby/Ireland), H Pollock (Northampton Saints/England), A Mitchell (Northampton Saints/England), M Smith (Harlequins/England), M Hansen (Connacht Rugby/Ireland).
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
‘What a day' – Emotional Sharlene Mawdsley embraces boyfriend Michael Breen after Tipperary pip Kilkenny in semi classic
SHARLENE Mawdsley joked her first visit to Croke Park won't be her last after cheering on boyfriend Michael Breen as Tipperary defeated Kilkenny. It was a nip and tuck affair all the way with the Premier 4 Afterwards she congratulated Breen for helping his side grind out the win Credit: @mikeybreeno 4 She captioned this pre-match snap of the parade 'What a day' Credit: @sharlenem1 Afterwards the corner-back posted a photo on Breen captioned it: "First time in Croke Park is it?" To which the sprinter replied: "And not my last!" Tipperary went down to 14 men when Darragh McCarthy was shown a second yellow card for wrapping keeper Eoin Murphy across the knuckles with his hurl with 12 minutes left. But Oisín O'Donoghue's wonderstrike at the death fired Tipp back to the showpiece for the first time since 2019 - and boss Liam Cahill Read More On GAA He said: 'It was a bit of a blow at the time but look, I think it really ignited the rest of the players on the field. 'Look, it's misfortune, the second yellow. By the rule book it's there, as a second yellow. We had no complaints with it at all. 'Just disappointed for Darragh, he commits to everything. I suppose just before that we probably had really discussed getting Oisín in at that time. 'Lo and behold, Darragh was coming off alright but we can't get Oisín in to replace him. Again, the impact of our bench coming in had a big bearing on today's game. Most read in GAA Hurling 'I really thought they gave us huge energy. Tynan in particular was superb when he came on. Obviously, Oisín and Noel as usual, giving us that calming influence. Just happy, as I said, that the job is done now. 'We try and turn the page as quick as we can and look forward to two weeks' time.' RTE viewers loved Noel McGrath's post-match interview from accidental F-bomb to hilarious gag Cahill's tenure as Tipp boss was under huge fire when they failed to win a game in the Munster SHC last year. But his pleas for patience have paid off, and he hailed his players for taking them back to the biggest day of all against all the odds as McCarthy, John McGrath and Jason Forde fired first half goals against the Cats. He said: 'It's been difficult to navigate over the last two years from my perspective, I won't deny that. A huge change was required, it's starting to come through now. 'As I said, it's all down to the players. And to be fair, the alignment with our county board off the field as well. 4 Amazingly, Cork and Tipp have never met in an All-Ireland hurling decider before 4 Tipperary hadn't played in Croke Park since 2019 'These fellas set really high standards for themselves to be fair and they committed to that. We have a really tight group. I know every manager says that when they sit in front of you guys after a win. "It takes a lot of work to create that because if you haven't everybody on the same wavelength, days like today just don't happen. 'I mean not just players, I mean the backroom team we have, the people that support them. We're a unit that keeps things really tight and we have one another's back. 'That's what really makes it proud for me is that when you can create something like that and the tests come like they came today outside there at Croke Park. "The players usually find the answers. Just thrilled as I said to be in the final. 'The game was exciting, it was probably a very much mistake-ridden game as well which probably led to a lot of the excitement with the number of mistakes that were in it. "We have a lot to do to make sure that we're in a position to go forward and try and take on Cork in two weeks' time.'
