Quebec to seek leave to appeal school board reform ruling to Supreme Court of Canada
A spokesperson for Quebec's justice minister confirmed this week the province will appeal a ruling from the Quebec Court of Appeal rendered in April.
That ruling upheld a Quebec Superior Court decision from August 2023 which found the province's law abolishing school boards violates linguistic minority education rights, guaranteed in Section 23 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
The law, known as Bill 40, was adopted in February 2020 and transformed French schools boards, which were governed by elected commissioners, into service centres run by a board of directors overseen by the province.
The Court of Appeal said last month that the law 'radically alters the mission of these school service centres compared to school boards.'
The law's measures affecting English school boards were stayed pending the outcome of the court challenge.
As Quebec is now seeking to appeal again, spokesman Julien Garon says the government has no further comment.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 31, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Montreal Gazette
3 hours ago
- Montreal Gazette
Letters: Give the OQLF a reason to investigate
Maybe it's time to overwhelm the Office québécois de la langue française with a flood of complaints about English signage — call it peaceful bureaucratic resistance. If the agency is going to micromanage every sign, let them chase shadows. And once the absurdity reaches a peak, people should alert international media. Let the world see how language policy can tip into parody. Lois Baron, Montreal Not the time for language complaints Re: ' Spike in service complaints to OQLF ' (The Gazette, July 4) Quebec's medical system cries out from a lack of funds, and now the education system will see much-needed services affected after the government ordered at least $570 million in cuts. Plus, seeing as we eagerly encourage tourists to come boost our economy, we need to be at minimum bilingual. In these circumstances, how can the OQLF be justified? It is time to give Montreal a break and allow it and its population to survive. Sandra Sterling, Snowdon Bilingual signs boost water safety Re: ' There have been five drownings near Verdun beach in last four years ' (The Gazette, June 25) It is alarming that in Quebec, protecting French from a sea of English apparently includes endangering the well-being of English-speaking Montrealers and tourists. After two tragic drowning deaths recently at Verdun beach, the local TV news showed several apparently French-only signs at beaches along with Raynald Hawkins, the Lifesaving Society's executive director for Quebec, declaring that all beach visitors should follow water safety instructions. Along with French-only provincial road signs, one wonders if unilingual safety signs may have had a part in some deaths and injuries over the years. George McArthur, Montreal Other options for Alzheimer's patients Re: ' Canada is falling behind on treatments for Alzheimer's disease ' (Opinion, June 26) Hope is a dangerous thing, and although we should welcome treatments for insidious and devastating diseases such as Alzheimer's, we shouldn't let enthusiasm cloud our judgment. The scores we should be looking at for these new drugs — clinical improvements in cognitive scores — have barely shown more significance than placebo, and we still don't know how long the benefits persist. Not to mention high dropout rates in trials due in part to side effects such as brain swelling. Factor in the price of over $20,000 per year, and there are other interventions that are more cost efficient for patients in our publicly funded health-care system. Aylon Wisbaum, pharmacist, Côte-St-Luc Respect from U.S. in the cards Re: ' Canadian mistrust of the U.S. remains high, new poll finds ' (NP Montreal, July 3) I play online bridge against players from all over the world. You get to play two deals against new opponents, who then move on to other opponents. When they arrive, I always chat: 'Hello from Montreal, bonne chance.' I've been amazed at how many Americans reply: 'We love you, I didn't vote for him, ' or words to that effect. Gary Bernstein, N.D.G. Submitting a letter to the editor Letters should be sent by email to letters@ We prioritize letters that respond to, or are inspired by, articles published by The Gazette. If you are responding to a specific article, let us know which one. Letters should be sent uniquely to us. The shorter they are — ideally, fewer than 200 words — the greater the chance of publication. Timing, clarity, factual accuracy and tone are all important, as is whether the writer has something new to add to the conversation. We reserve the right to edit and condense all letters. Care is taken to preserve the core of the writer's argument. Our policy is not to publish anonymous letters, those with pseudonyms or 'open letters' addressed to third parties. Letters are published with the author's full name and city or neighbourhood/borough of residence. Include a phone number and address to help verify identity; these will not be published. We will not indicate to you whether your letter will be published. If it has not been published within 10 days or so, it is not likely to be.
Edmonton Journal
6 hours ago
- Edmonton Journal
Demetrios Nicolaides: Alberta investing in education to meet booming enrolment
Alberta's government and the Alberta Teachers' Association (ATA) share the same goal: providing a world-class education to Alberta's next generation. It's a goal I am proud to work on alongside the ATA. Article content Yet in a recent op-ed, ATA president Jason Schilling says he believes Alberta's government is 'playing politics with education rather than focusing on what matters.' I strongly disagree with that characterization, as I believe our investments into Alberta's education system present a much different reality. Article content Article content Article content Many of the challenges our education system is facing today stem directly from the dramatic increase of people who moved to Alberta in recent years. In 2020-21, Alberta had roughly 735,000 students, and some school boards were even looking at closing schools due to lack of enrolment. As of today, there are nearly 826,000 students and counting. Article content Article content Our solutions: $8.6 billion to build and renovate more than 130 schools, creating 200,000 more student spaces. Thirty-three of those school construction projects have been sped up through our new innovative funding model. This is on top of the millions we have invested to build prefabricated classrooms to address the need for more classroom space now. I find it hard to characterize these investments as a 'failure to fund public education for growth,' as Mr. Schilling put it. I have heard loud and clear that something needs to be done to ensure the growing needs of students are met in classrooms, such as tailored programing for students with increased learning needs or supports for students that are learning English as a second language. My response: an historic $9.9 billion for Alberta's education system. This generational investment includes $1.6 billion for schools to address increasingly complex classrooms and will help ensure each student is supported as they engage with Alberta's world-class education system. Article content Article content Alberta's government is making significant investments in education to support student success. We're expanding school spaces and addressing the complex learning needs of students. To reduce distractions, we've banned cellphones in classrooms. We're also responding to the concerns of parents and protecting young students by ensuring they aren't exposed to inappropriate sexual content in school libraries. Article content Our updated funding model ensures school boards receive the resources they need, and we're refocusing the curriculum on essential skills like reading, writing, and financial literacy. But rather than just talk about it — let's have the results speak for themselves Article content In a recent Programme for International Student Assessment report, Alberta's students excelled in all areas of testing in math, reading, science and creative thinking. In Canada, Alberta ranked first in reading and science, and second in math. Internationally, Alberta ranked second in reading and science, and seventh in math. In financial literacy, Alberta students received the highest score in Canada and internationally. In creative thinking, Alberta students received the highest score in Canada. Internationally, Canada was only outperformed by Singapore.
Ottawa Citizen
7 hours ago
- Ottawa Citizen
Spears: How official languages absurdity shuts down information at the NCC
Article content Unable to translate tens of thousands of pages into both languages when the original documents and records were only in one, the NCC had to take down the whole section of its website that offered these records to the public. Article content So, what is it that so urgently needs translation? The NCC handles more than 100 access requests a year, often numbering hundreds of pages apiece. Here's an example. I asked about fixing the roof of the official residence at Harrington Lake and got back 256 pages with a lot like this one: Article content 'Any membrane placed on the existing wood plank sheathing or on any material directly attached to the existing wood plank sheathing shall feature vapour permeability properties to allow for any moisture within the existing roof assembly to be released to the exterior.' Article content There follows some discussion of roof membrane options (FT synthetics, hydra breathable; or Titanium PSU self-adhered underlayment, high temp). Article content Article content Also insulation: BP Esgard resistance roof insulator, an inch thick in a rigid wood fibre panel, or Gutex Multitherm 40 mm wood fibre board. Article content Do we really need that sort of thing translated? And remember, this is a document that I alone asked for, so it's not clear who the translation job would be serving. (On the plus side, I could learn a lot of French vocabulary about roofing.) Article content Of course NCC documents come in many forms. Some look like this expense spreadsheet for Rideau Cottage: 'STY pest control as per quote dated March 11, 2022 240.00.' Article content There are also vast numbers of emails in which employee A asks employee B whether her team is free to meet on Thursday. Article content The public service is an email-generating machine, pages and pages, mostly informal notes in one language only. Article content The new ruling is that the Canadian public needs all this — including the dross — in both official languages if it's going to be made available on a website. Failing that, public access must be shut down. Which it now has been. Article content Article content Wrong approach. Article content My house is 100 years old. No level floors or square angles are left, and it will never be perfect. But I don't tear it down and pretend this is an improvement. You don't destroy something for being imperfect — except that the government of Canada has now done so. Article content This means the public can't see useful federal documents because no one has translated into both languages 'Gutex Multitherm 40 mm' or 'Titanium PSU self-adhered underlayment.' For a one-time, non-controversial roof repair. Article content
