Tennessee's new death penalty drug sparks concerns ahead of first scheduled execution in years
Gov. Bill Lee paused all executions in April 2022 after discovering issues with the state's death penalty protocol and the drugs it used in executions. He ordered the Tennessee Department of Correction to create a new death penalty protocol, which was completed in December 2024.
However, critics like Stacy Rector, executive director of Tennesseans for Alternatives to the Death Penalty have argued the new protocol is even worse than before.
RELATED | Death row inmates sue state over new lethal injection protocol
'Tennessee struggled with the drugs that were previously being used and has now switched to one that is also problematic,' Rector said.
Tennessee chose pentobarbital, a single drug commonly used to treat insomnia in humans, as its new lethal injection drug. In higher doses, it can be fatal. Several states, and formerly the federal government, have used it to execute inmates since around 2010.
However, the drug is controversial. This past January, the U.S. Department of Justice ditched the drug after a years-long investigation rose concerns pentobarbital could cause 'unnecessary pain and suffering.'
According to Tennesseans for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, some people put to death with pentobarbital experienced pulmonary edema, which causes the sensation of drowning and pain.
SEE ALSO | Tennessee's new death penalty protocol: What's different
'The pentobarbital did not adequately anesthetize these individuals, so they were experiencing this sensation of being water boarded, and that, according to the DOJ, is a violation of the 8th Amendment protections against cruel and unusual punishment,' Rector said.
Several Tennessee death row inmates are now suing the state over its new death penalty protocol. In the lawsuit, they argued pentobarbital has been shown to 'pose a high risk of a torturous death.'
'It's riskier now, and this risk is not simply theoretical, folks,' Kelley J. Henry, a supervisory assistant federal public defender, said. 'They make it seem as if a lethal injection is a medical procedure. It's not. It's poison.'
In addition, some expressed concerns if something were to go wrong during an execution under the new protocol, the public likely wouldn't find out because the new protocol is more secretive than the last.
'I think all citizens, regardless of your opinions of the death penalty, should have deep concern about the government shielding itself from accountability from the public this way,' Rector said.
Death row inmate Oscar Smith will be the first prisoner executed under the state's new protocol on Thursday, May 22. Smith brutally murdered his estranged wife, Judy Robird Smith, and her sons Chad Burnett and Jason Burnett in Nashville on Oct. 1, 1989.
Inmates whose crimes were committed before Jan. 1, 1999, can choose between the lethal injection and the electric chair under Tennessee law.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Wire
18-06-2025
- Business Wire
Smile Power Week Highlights Dangerous Trend of DIY Dentistry
NASHVILLE, Tenn.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Governor Bill Lee, in collaboration with the Tennessee Charitable Care Network (TCCN), has officially proclaimed June 16-20, 2025, as " Smile Power Oral Health Week." Smile Power Week recognizes the importance of good oral health to a healthy smile and life, and celebrates the critical care that charitable dental clinics throughout the state provide to tens of thousands of Tennesseans each year. This year, oral health leaders across the state are raising awareness of the dangerous trend of do-it-yourself (DIY) dentistry. Recent reports have detailed cases where individuals used superglue to reattach broken crowns, extracted their own teeth with pliers, or tried to move their teeth with fishing wire or rubber bands. These methods can cause permanent nerve damage, serious infection, and even damage to adjacent teeth. According to research, more than 3 in 10 Tennesseans avoid smiling because of the condition of their teeth, and 1 in 5 adults experience anxiety due to the condition of their mouth and teeth. A healthy smile isn't just cosmetic - it's essential to self-esteem, employability, and overall health. When access to care feels out of reach, people understandably try to take matters into their own hands - but often end up doing more harm than good in the process. Dr. Michele Blackledge-Polk, DDS, Director of Dental Services at Neighborhood Health, sees cases like this in her clinic far too often. 'I had a patient the other day who had gotten braces from someone who was not a trained professional, and her teeth had moved so fast that I had to tell her the only thing that's holding your teeth in now is the wire,' said Dr. Blackledge-Polk. 'I took the wire off, and of course, it's loosey-goosey. She's upset, and I'm having to tell her there's nothing for us to do. We can't save them, we can't glue them back in. What she did before has now created a bigger issue.' Getting patients to understand the risks is critical, Blackledge-Polk emphasized. 'I think the biggest thing is trying to get patients to understand that we're not the bad guys, we're not hating on the people that are doing this. But I do really want you to think about the risks you are taking, because there are no short-term fixes in dentistry,' she added. 'If you're worried about finding or affording proper dental care, know that there are so many community resources and programs that can help - all you have to do is ask.' Charitable clinics such as Neighborhood Health and dozens of others across the state are one such resource. With the support of community partners, including Delta Dental of Tennessee and many others, these clinics are able to provide reduced- and no-cost care to patients who would not otherwise be able to access it. In 2024, charitable dental clinics provided 51,861 oral health services to 31,096 Tennesseans, from routine preventive care and cleanings to fillings, emergency tooth extractions, oral surgeries, and restorative dental care. "Charitable dental clinics across Tennessee are doing extraordinary work every day - restoring not just oral health, but dignity, confidence, and hope,' said Jeff Ballard, President and CEO of Delta Dental of Tennessee. 'We are proud to stand alongside them - during Smile Power Week and all year long. A healthy smile is important, but I can't emphasize enough - you don't have to do it yourself.' For more information about Smile Power Week and to find a clinic in your community, visit About Delta Dental of Tennessee Delta Dental of Tennessee is the state's largest independent dental benefits carrier with 1.5 million lives covered. As part of the Delta Dental Plans Association, Delta Dental of Tennessee members have access to the largest dental network in the nation, with more than 206,000 providers serving more than 558,000 locations. With the simple mission of ensuring healthy smiles, Delta Dental of Tennessee works hard to help members of the communities it serves. Along with its corporate foundation, Smile180, Delta Dental of Tennessee donated more than $4.0 million in funding and in-kind services to over 100 organizations in 2024. About the Smile180 Foundation Smile180 reflects the transformative power of a healthy smile to turn someone's life around. The Smile180 Foundation supports Tennessee's dental colleges, children's hospitals, free and reduced-cost dental clinics, and other like-minded charities.
Yahoo
18-06-2025
- Yahoo
Smile Power Week Highlights Dangerous Trend of DIY Dentistry
Oral health leaders raise awareness of the risks of do-it-yourself dentistry and the safe and accessible alternatives NASHVILLE, Tenn., June 18, 2025--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Governor Bill Lee, in collaboration with the Tennessee Charitable Care Network (TCCN), has officially proclaimed June 16-20, 2025, as "Smile Power Oral Health Week." Smile Power Week recognizes the importance of good oral health to a healthy smile and life, and celebrates the critical care that charitable dental clinics throughout the state provide to tens of thousands of Tennesseans each year. This year, oral health leaders across the state are raising awareness of the dangerous trend of do-it-yourself (DIY) dentistry. Recent reports have detailed cases where individuals used superglue to reattach broken crowns, extracted their own teeth with pliers, or tried to move their teeth with fishing wire or rubber bands. These methods can cause permanent nerve damage, serious infection, and even damage to adjacent teeth. According to research, more than 3 in 10 Tennesseans avoid smiling because of the condition of their teeth, and 1 in 5 adults experience anxiety due to the condition of their mouth and teeth. A healthy smile isn't just cosmetic - it's essential to self-esteem, employability, and overall health. When access to care feels out of reach, people understandably try to take matters into their own hands - but often end up doing more harm than good in the process. Dr. Michele Blackledge-Polk, DDS, Director of Dental Services at Neighborhood Health, sees cases like this in her clinic far too often. "I had a patient the other day who had gotten braces from someone who was not a trained professional, and her teeth had moved so fast that I had to tell her the only thing that's holding your teeth in now is the wire," said Dr. Blackledge-Polk. "I took the wire off, and of course, it's loosey-goosey. She's upset, and I'm having to tell her there's nothing for us to do. We can't save them, we can't glue them back in. What she did before has now created a bigger issue." Getting patients to understand the risks is critical, Blackledge-Polk emphasized. "I think the biggest thing is trying to get patients to understand that we're not the bad guys, we're not hating on the people that are doing this. But I do really want you to think about the risks you are taking, because there are no short-term fixes in dentistry," she added. "If you're worried about finding or affording proper dental care, know that there are so many community resources and programs that can help - all you have to do is ask." Charitable clinics such as Neighborhood Health and dozens of others across the state are one such resource. With the support of community partners, including Delta Dental of Tennessee and many others, these clinics are able to provide reduced- and no-cost care to patients who would not otherwise be able to access it. In 2024, charitable dental clinics provided 51,861 oral health services to 31,096 Tennesseans, from routine preventive care and cleanings to fillings, emergency tooth extractions, oral surgeries, and restorative dental care. "Charitable dental clinics across Tennessee are doing extraordinary work every day - restoring not just oral health, but dignity, confidence, and hope," said Jeff Ballard, President and CEO of Delta Dental of Tennessee. "We are proud to stand alongside them - during Smile Power Week and all year long. A healthy smile is important, but I can't emphasize enough - you don't have to do it yourself." For more information about Smile Power Week and to find a clinic in your community, visit ## About Delta Dental of Tennessee Delta Dental of Tennessee is the state's largest independent dental benefits carrier with 1.5 million lives covered. As part of the Delta Dental Plans Association, Delta Dental of Tennessee members have access to the largest dental network in the nation, with more than 206,000 providers serving more than 558,000 locations. With the simple mission of ensuring healthy smiles, Delta Dental of Tennessee works hard to help members of the communities it serves. Along with its corporate foundation, Smile180, Delta Dental of Tennessee donated more than $4.0 million in funding and in-kind services to over 100 organizations in 2024. About the Smile180 Foundation Smile180 reflects the transformative power of a healthy smile to turn someone's life around. The Smile180 Foundation supports Tennessee's dental colleges, children's hospitals, free and reduced-cost dental clinics, and other like-minded charities. View source version on Contacts Ann Waller Curtis / Sign in to access your portfolio
Yahoo
13-06-2025
- Yahoo
Health center named for ‘ghost doctor' serves thousands of patients in Nashville
NASHVILLE, Tenn. (WKRN) — The Matthew Walker Comprehensive Health Center upholds the legacy of a doctor once known as the 'ghost surgeon' by serving thousands of patients every year. 'Last year was a stellar year, we were almost at 19,000 patients, compared to about 17,000 patients in 2023, and so we're continuing to grow,' said Katina Beard, CEO of Matthew Walker Comprehensive Health Center. The health center has two locations in addition to their main building in North Nashville, which is where Dr. Temicka Logan's career came full circle, serving dental patients in her own hometown. 'I am from Nashville, born and raised,' she said. 'I had braces in high school and I just loved how it shaped my teeth. I have a different smile so I was a different person, a more confident person.' Nashville non-profit provides a simple service with a meaningful impact Dr. Logan is now dental director at the MWCHC. 'I was too one of those families that needed help, so to be able to help other families like I was is amazing,' said Dr. Logan. 'I just want to be able to pour into the community as they poured into me.' The historical marker outside the building on 14th Avenue North and Jefferson Street states that Dr. Matthew Walker Sr. graduated from Meharry Medical College in 1934 and became chairman of the surgery department. 'He was known across the nation as a stellar provider,' Beard explained. 'He was also known as the ghost surgeon. He would be called in during the night to perform surgeries on individuals in hospitals that were white that didn't allow for Black physicians and surgeons. So he would come in the cover of night and perform these very difficult surgeries and save lives.' Dr. Walker was pivotal in securing a 1968 federal grant to start the Meharry Neighborhood Health Center. It was named after him a couple years later. 'I think the organization embodies his characteristics, his integrity, his vision,' said Beard. American Baptist College president retiring after Nashville HBCU's 100th anniversary MWCHC's breadth of services includes primary medical services, dental services, behavioral health services, lab services and radiology services, which includes mammography. The center also has an on-site pharmacy in Nashville. Additionally, MWCHC has a sliding fee program, which is based on household income and the number of living in a home, but they also accept insurance. 'It just warms my heart that we are able to help them when they come because sometimes they come and they say, 'Well, I know they're not going to help me,' recalled Dr. Logan. 'No, we are. We're going to help you and we're going to do the best we can do our ability.' Given all those services, the center also helps supply the workforce needed to support their patients and others. 'We probably train a couple hundred people in some discipline in some way through our various sites, and so we've held true to those tenants, providing quality healthcare and training the workforce forward,' said Beard. News 2 On Tour | Explore the communities that shape Middle Tennessee In addition to Nashville, MWCHC centers can also be found in Smyrna and Clarksville along with a mobile unit that goes out into the community. Beard told News 2 the center and its partners are working to provided all these services regardless of someone's ability, but added that work is getting harder. 'We've already lost about $600,000 of grant dollars that we had budgeted, and so that has caused a significant shift in the work that we thought we would be able to do,' said Beard. 'Although we're tracking along, we are tracking along cautiously, watching to see if there will be any other changes to our dollars, locally, statewide or federally.' On Aug. 7, the Dr. Matthew Sr. Legacy Breakfast will be held at the Cal Turner Family Center to benefit MWCHC. For more information about the event, call 615-340-1292 or email Cathy Hunt at chunt@ Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
