Bill ending religious exemptions to school vaccines makes headway
JAMM AQUINO / 2022 A house bill aims to end religious exemptions for school immunization requirements. Vaccine vials and empty syringes are seen during a booster vaccination clinic at 'Iolani School.
A House bill proposing an end to religious exemptions for school immunization requirements is making headway in the state Legislature.
, which is part of the governor's package, passed its third reading in the House Committee on Judiciary and Hawaiian Affairs on Friday, and is poised to cross over to the Senate in March.
The measure passed the committee on a 5-3 vote, including two votes with reservations.
Democratic Rep. David Tarnas, the committee's chair, voted for the measure, saying he was concerned with the growing rate of nonmedical exemptions in Hawaii.
'While immunizations reduce risk of severe illness for everyone, ' he said, 'this trend is especially concerning for students with medical conditions who are unable to be immunized and must rely on their vaccinated peers to prevent the introduction for vaccine-preventable diseases in their schools.'
Republican Reps. Diamond Garcia and Garner Shimizu and Democratic Rep. Amy Perruso cast the three opposing votes.
Don 't miss out on what 's happening !
Stay in touch with breaking news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. It 's FREE !
Email 28141 Sign Up By clicking to sign up, you agree to Star-Advertiser 's and Google 's and. This form is protected by reCAPTCHA.
Garcia said he thought the bill was 'clearly unconstitutional ' and that an overwhelming majority of the testimony received was in opposition to it.
Hawaii state law requires students to be immunized with a before attending public or private school, unless they have exemptions.
Required vaccines include those for diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis (DTaP ), hepatitis A, hepatitis B, measles-mumps-rubella, polio, meningitis and chickenpox for those in kindergarten through 12th grade.
Starting July 1, 2020, the state added human papillomavirus, or HPV, vaccines to requirements for seventh graders. The vaccination requirements do not include the COVID-19 or influenza vaccines.
HB 1118 would still allow for medical exemptions but repeal any new religious exemptions for vaccines, which are allowed when a parent or guardian writes that it conflicts with their 'bona fide religious tenets and practices.'
Any child already attending school with an already approved religious exemption, however, can remain exempt.
Heated debate The vote came after hours of testimony, and debate over the safety and efficacy of vaccinations, religious freedoms, parental rights, bodily autonomy and constitutional rights.
The Aloha Freedom Coalition, a grassroots organization started by former Republican candidate for governor Gary Cordery, held a rally Thursday at the state Capitol in opposition to the bill.
The state Department of Health, which supports the bill, says its purpose is to provide a safe and healthy learning environment for all children in the state.
Advocates for the bill are concerned that the number of students seeking religious or nonmedical exemptions in Hawaii.
In the 2023-24 school year, DOH said, the rate of nonmedical exemption more than doubled to 5.3 %, compared with 2.5 % in the 2015-16 school year.
Fifty-five out of 382 schools reported nonmedical exemption rates exceeding 10 % of their student population.
This trend, which began during the COVID-19 pandemic, is also occurring nationally, according to KFF, a health policy research group—and public opinion on vaccine requirements is becoming increasingly bipartisan.
In its latest poll, KFF found 1 in 4 Republican parents skipped or delayed some vaccines for their children.
The bill also was supported by the Hawaii chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics, Hawaii Pacific Health, State Council on Developmental Disabilities and American Atheists, among others.
Opposition to the bill came from mothers who testified in person that vaccines triggered autism in their child, as well as those who suffered from vaccine injuries.
Among those opposing the bill in written testimony were Kauai County Council member Felicia Cowden, along with groups such as the Hawaiian Islands Republican Women, Hawaii for Informed Consent and the Hawaii Christian Coalition.
Some testified that repealing religious exemptions was government over-reach and a violation of constitutional, parental and cultural freedoms. Some also said it would trigger legal challenges against President Trump's executive orders.
Risk of measles The bill contends that immunization requirements have been effective in improving coverage rates—and that vaccines prevent deaths, hospitalizations and illnesses.
DOH noted that all 50 U.S. states, including Hawaii, have school-entry vaccination requirements.
'If implemented now, ' DOH said, 'this measure can help us re-establish herd immunity to protect our community against life-threatening communicable diseases, hopefully before we experience a large-scale outbreak.'
Those diseases include measles, which is highly contagious and currently rising in the U.S., according to Health Director Dr. Kenneth Fink, after it was officially declared eradicated in 2000.
The recent outbreak of measles in rural Texas—among mostly unvaccinated children—has now infected more than 120 and spread to New Mexico.
Texas has a statewide measles, mumps and rubella vaccination rate of 94.3 %, he said, and a nonmedical exemption rate of 3.6 %. By comparison, Hawaii has an MMR vaccination rate of only 89.8 % and a nonmedical exemption rate of 5.3 %.
'While we've not yet had a measles outbreak in Hawaii, we are at risk, ' he said. 'And digging into the data from Texas, I'm even more concerned about our risk.'
Fink said he understood that the measure is controversial, with compelling arguments for and against it.
'While we may disagree on how, I would like to believe that we all share the goal of keeping our keiki healthy and safe, ' he said during the hearing. 'Too often, it seems a crisis happens and then we react. We might ask ourselves, What could we have done to prevent it ? Now is the time to prevent a measles outbreak with the opportunity to be proactive and protect our keiki and community from vaccine-preventable diseases.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
22 minutes ago
- New York Post
Pairing cigarettes with this other habit ups your chance of oral cancer by 624% in the next 5 years
Smoking leaves more than just a bad taste in your mouth — it could be fueling your oral cancer risk. Studies have consistently reported that cigarette users are five to 10 times more likely to develop oral cancer than non-smokers. A new study out of UC San Diego suggests that a chronic weed habit carries a higher risk of oral cancer as well. Researchers determined that people who often smoke marijuana are 3.25 times more likely to contract the disease within five years compared to those without cannabis use disorder. Advertisement 3 Researchers determined that people who often smoke marijuana are 3.25 times more likely to develop oral cancer within five years compared to those without cannabis use disorder. Getty Images/iStockphoto 'Cannabis smoke contains many of the same carcinogenic compounds found in tobacco smoke, which have known damaging effects on the epithelial tissue that lines the mouth,' said Raphael Cuomo, an associate professor in the Department of Anesthesiology at UC San Diego School of Medicine and member of UC San Diego Moores Cancer Center. 'These findings add to a growing body of evidence suggesting that chronic or problematic cannabis use may contribute to cancer risk in tissues exposed to combustion products.' Advertisement Oral cancer encompasses cancers of the lips, tongue, gums and the lining of the cheeks and mouth. The American Cancer Society projects that there will be nearly 60,000 new US cases of oral cavity or oropharyngeal cancer this year and about 12,800 deaths. 3 Oral cancer encompasses cancers of the lips, tongue, gums and the lining of the cheeks and mouth. TommyStockProject – Known risk factors of oral cancer include tobacco use, chronic alcohol consumption and human papillomavirus (HPV) infection. Advertisement Cuomo's team analyzed health data from over 45,000 oral cancer patients, including 949 who had been formally diagnosed with cannabis use disorder. They accounted for age, sex, body mass index and smoking status. They calculated that tobacco smokers with a cannabis addiction are 624% more likely to contract oral cancer within five years compared to cigarette users not prone to smoking marijuana. The researchers posited that the inhaled smoke is to blame because it can damage mouth tissues. Advertisement Edibles and beverages infused with tetrahydrocannabinol (THC), the active ingredient in cannabis, don't seem to carry a similar oral cancer risk as smoking weed. 'Research is still evolving, so regular self-checks and dental exams remain wise for all cannabis users,' Cuomo told The Post. His findings were published in the September edition of Preventive Medicine Reports. 3 Studies have consistently reported that cigarette users are five to 10 times more likely to develop oral cancer than non-smokers. The risk goes up if cigarette smokers also smoke weed. Getty Images/iStockphoto The researchers emphasized that there should be more exploration of the long-term effects of cannabis, and oral health awareness should be highlighted in substance use disorder treatment and counseling. The UCSD study is not the first to sound the alarm about cannabis use and cancer. A 2024 study out of the University of Southern California linked daily marijuana use to a three to five-fold increase in the risk of head and neck cancers. Oral cancer is a type of head and neck cancer. Advertisement Cuomo suggests seeing a dentist or an ear, nose and throat specialist if you have a sore, ulcer or red or white patch in your mouth that has not healed after two weeks, especially if you have a lump, numbness, bleeding or pain when swallowing. 'Early evaluation is critical because oral cancers caught in the first stage are usually curable,' he said.
Bloomberg
an hour ago
- Bloomberg
FDA Chief Says He Wants Gene Therapy Head Prasad to Return
By and Skylar Woodhouse Save US Food and Drug Administration Commissioner Marty Makary said he's trying to persuade Vinay Prasad, the agency's former head of gene therapy and vaccines, to return to the FDA after his abrupt departure last week. Makary told reporters Monday that media reports suggesting that Prasad was fired after intervention from the White House are 'simply untrue.' He 'didn't want to be a distraction,' Makary said.
The Hill
2 hours ago
- The Hill
New Hampshire becomes first Northeastern state to ban gender-affirming care for minors
New Hampshire is the first Northeastern state to ban gender-affirming health care for minors after its Republican governor gave final approval to bills that will ban the use of certain prescription medications and surgeries to treat gender dysphoria beginning next year. Gov. Kelly Ayotte, a former U.S. senator who won New Hampshire's gubernatorial election in November, signed two bills Friday restricting access to transition-related care in the state, which already prohibits rare genital surgeries for minors to transition. House Bill 377 prohibits doctors from administering puberty blockers and hormones to transgender youth starting Jan. 1. Like a handful of other, similar measures adopted by nearly all Republican-led states, New Hampshire's prohibition includes a 'grandfather clause' that allows minors already receiving care to continue doing so even after the law goes into effect. The second bill, House Bill 712, builds on New Hampshire's existing restrictions on gender-affirming surgery. The measure, which will also take effect in January, bars adolescents younger than 18 from undergoing certain procedures when they are used to treat gender dysphoria, including facial feminization or masculinization surgery and 'transgender chest surgery.' In a statement, Ayotte said, 'Medical decisions made at a young age can carry lifelong consequences, and these bills represent a balanced, bipartisan effort to protect children.' The New Hampshire House approved HB 377 in June, with two Democrats, state Reps. Dale Girard and Jonah Wheeler, voting with nearly all Republicans to advance the measure. Eleven Democrats were excused from voting. New Hampshire senators approved the bill in a 16-8 party-line vote. Wheeler joined House Republicans again in voting to pass HB 712, and 11 Democrats again were excused. The state Senate approved the measure in June in another vote along party lines. New Hampshire state Rep. Lisa Mazur, a Republican and the prime sponsor of both bills, celebrated their approval Friday in a post on X. 'My two bills that will protect NH kids from irreversible harm were just signed into law by Gov. Ayotte. We are now the 1st state in New England the whole Northeast to do so. Go NH!!' Mazur wrote. In June, while defending House Bill 377, Mazur pointed to a recent Supreme Court ruling that upheld Tennessee's ban on gender-affirming care for minors. 'It is now legal and constitutional for states to regulate and or ban the use of these harmful drugs in minors,' she said. LGBTQ rights groups immediately condemned Ayotte's signature on the bills, which they said ignore testimony from transgender youth who have benefited from gender-affirming care and statements from major medical organizations that such care for transgender adults and minors is medically necessary and can be lifesaving. 'It is heartbreaking to witness lawmakers inserting themselves into deeply personal, private conversations between families, their doctors, and their children,' Julia Hawthorne, a board member of the state LGBTQ rights group 603 Equality, wrote on Facebook. Linds Jakows, the organization's founder, said transgender young people in New Hampshire 'are not only tangibly losing access to life-saving healthcare — but also receiving a disturbing message of rejection from their state government.' 'To youth impacted by these bills, please know: You are loved, you are worthy of respect and dignity, and there is a community here in New Hampshire and beyond that is ready to support you,' they said. The Campaign for Southern Equality, an LGBTQ rights group that has since 2023 distributed more than $900,000 in grants to families of transgender children needing to travel out-of-state for gender-affirming care, announced on Friday that it would expand its Trans Youth Emergency Project into New Hampshire. 'Every day I speak with families of transgender youth who are worried about the future. Many are panicking, unsure of where or when they'll get the medicine that their child needs to continue leading a healthy, happy life,' said Van Bailey, a patient navigator for the program. 'These laws are cruelly thrusting families into impossible choices, and it is deeply unfair.'
