No slum dwellers' consent needed for 64 redevelopment projects on our land: BMC
The projects will unfold as per the usual model established by the Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA), under the provisions of 33(10) of the Development Control and Promotion Regulation (DCPR), 2034, except with the BMC as the implementing authority, said an official from the BMC's estate department. The cut-off date for eligibility and home sizes offered to eligible dwellers will also be as per SRA rules. On May 10, BMC opened the gates for developers to express their interest in developing the plots.
The majority of the 64 plots lie in the western and eastern suburbs, with most falling in Govandi followed by Malad East. In total, the BMC is seeking to develop around 400,000 square metres of slum land in the city.
On Tuesday, the civic body released a supplementary document and also extended the date for developers to submit bids till June 25. The bids will be opened on that very day, and technical scrutiny will begin.
The BMC made the lack of consent clear in response to clarifications raised in pre-bid consultations by interested developers, saying, 'As the BMC is the landowner, slum dweller consent is not required for redevelopment as per the provisions of Regulation 33(10), VI-1.15 of DCPR 2034.' Slum redevelopment projects typically require a majority consent from residents, but the DCPR makes an exception to the rule.
'While there is the question of carrying out slum redevelopment in a democratic manner, there is no doubt here that the BMC has administrative authority over municipal land and is empowered to initiate action for the removal of unauthorised structures and the eviction of their occupants, following due process,' explained Dhaval Parsana, principal architect at Project Maitree, which works in the field of redevelopment. In this way, at least the eligible slum dwellers are promised housing. Redevelopment may happen at a quicker pace than the prevailing practice, as there will be little scope of LOI (letter of intent) issues on the basis of their consent forms being traded from one developer to another for years on end, often jeopardising their chances of a home.
When asked if this was a way to lead to the promised slum-free Mumbai, Parsana did not hold his breath. 'A slum-free city is a distant dream that will take a long time to reach,' he said. 'To eradicate slums, Mumbai needs an affordable rental market that provides an alternative to people coming into the city. It is likely that those deemed ineligible in these slum redevelopment projects will revert to slum homes in other areas if left with no affordable alternative.'
Govandi, the area with the most slums in the city and the one that stands to be affected the most, has its roots in forceful evictions conducted when the suburbs of Bandra, Juhu and Andheri had begun being developed.
'This is a classic case of exclusion. You cannot make decisions affecting thousands of families on public land without consulting them. It's against the principles of democracy and natural justice,' said a vehement Faiyaz Alam, president of the Govandi-based NGO New Sangam Welfare Forum, who shot off a letter to the Maharashtra CM, BMC and other authorities. 'No community consultations, surveys or official notices have been issued to inform or involve residents in the decision-making process. The people are not going to be against redevelopment as it will only improve their area, but the process needs to be transparent so that they have the space and time to raise their concerns beforehand. The decisions cannot be made between the builder and BMC alone when it is the residents that stand to be affected.'
Parsana questioned what the BMC was offering in these projects to make it lucrative for developers to undertake the whole exercise: from surveying the site, communicating with the slum dwellers, preparing the annexures, providing them with rehabilitation homes, and providing additional housing to the BMC to get the edge over other developers.
After the developers are chosen, they will have to communicate with the residents on the project plan and survey them to create an annexure of eligible residents. The civic body has said it will assist in carrying out any necessary evictions.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
4 hours ago
- Indian Express
Three bids for BMC's Rs 2,368-crore waste cleanup, reclamation plan for Deonar
The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) has received three bids for the Rs 2,368-crore bioremediation of 185 lakh tonnes of waste and the reclamation of 110 hectares of land at the Deonar dumping ground. The land parcel, which currently contains mounds of untreated solid waste, will be cleaned through the bioremediation process within three years and then handed over for the construction of housing tenements under the Dharavi Redevelopment Project (DRP), a venture steered by the Adani Group and Maharashtra government's Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA). The SPV, Navbharat Mega Developers Pvt Ltd (NMDPL) — a joint venture between Adani Properties Pvt Ltd (80 per cent) and the state-owned SRA (20 per cent) — is executing the DRP. The deadline for submission of bids for the tender floated on May 14 was extended thrice, with the final deadline being Friday. Three bidders submitted their proposals. The names of the bidders have not been made public. The bids will be opened on July 8, after which the contract will be awarded to the bidder meeting all the required parameters. Bioremediation is a process involving treating garbage with the help of natural elements like air, sunlight and microorganisms. Over time, as the biodegradable waste decomposes, the remaining non-biodegradable extracts are either recycled or treated artificially. According to senior civic officials, during the pre-bid meeting which was convened earlier, at least 23 bidders had come forward and expressed interest. 'Considering the unique nature of the work, the conditions of the tender were very stringent. Furthermore, this is a very challenging task in which nearly 2 crore metric tonnes of legacy waste have to be cleared over a period of three years. With only a few companies having the experience of conducting such large-scale bioremediation in the past, we have received responses from three bidders to our tender,' a senior official told The Indian Express. According to civic data, of the 1.85 crore metric tonnes of waste currently stacked at the Deonar site, nearly 48 per cent comprises construction debris, 41 per cent is inert waste while 10 per cent is accounted for by dry, miscellaneous waste. Prior to initiating cleaning at the Deonar dumping ground, the BMC in 2018 had undertaken cleaning of the 60-acre dumping ground at Mumbai's Mulund area in the eastern suburbs that was operational from 1968 to 2018.
Indian Express
5 hours ago
- Indian Express
What is BMC's new waste collection plan and why labour unions are opposing it
The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation's (BMC) Rs 4,000 crore tender to overhaul Mumbai's waste collection and transportation facilities through a 'service-based waste management system' has run into trouble with the labour unions who have threatened to stage a strike in protest. Floated on May 14, the tender seeks to rope in private contractors to carry out cleaning and collection of waste through a fleet of new waste collection trucks across 22 wards. However, the proposal has sparked concerns among unions who fear that the appointment of private contractors will jeopardise the jobs of permanent as well as contractual conservancy workers, including over 7,000 motor loaders. At present, waste compactor vehicles are hired and run through contractors while the waste is collected through the BMC's own body of permanent as well as contractual conservancy workers. In a tender floated on May 14, however, the civic body has proposed a plan that seeks to outsource the entire work of collecting door-to-door waste as well as clearing garbage lying in the open while also transporting the civic municipal waste collected to the disposal or processing facilities. As per the clause, only new and closed body eco-friendly trucks with a post January-2025 registration will be permitted to ply in these wards for collection and transportation of all waste. Essentially, the appointed contractors will be given charge of providing the new waste collection trucks, drivers as well as staff for collecting the waste. Furthermore, the contractors will also have to provide and maintain litter bins across the wards, while also replacing the damaged community waste collection bins. With the civic body eyeing to eventually phase out open dumping and achieve the goal of 100 per cent door-to-door garbage collection in the city, the contractors have also been given the target of eliminating waste bins from the second year of their five-year contract period. Currently, the civic body plans to implement this model through contractors across 22 of Mumbai's 25 wards with the civic body categorising these wards in eight groups. In three wards — L, M/West and M/East wards — the BMC will continue to operate its own fleet of garbage trucks through its own staffers. For the unions, the plan to hire private contractors has raised concerns that permanent motor loaders and contractual workers may lose their jobs. According to Ashok Jadhav, president of Municipal Mazdoor Union in Mumbai, of the 14,000 workers, nearly 7,000 are motor load workers who tip garbage into the trucks and these workers will then be redirected into the work of collecting garbage on the streets. 'This will create an excess of work force for one task and in the future, they will then be redirected into carrying out other jobs. If the municipal body brings tenders for area-based privatisation then and threatens the job of permanent workers, no worker will tolerate,' added Jadhav. The union bodies have convened public meetings since June 30 and are slated to hold a vote on July 8 to determine whether they will continue their protest and stage a strike. Even as the tender has ruffled feathers among the unions, the BMC will continue to with the bidding process, whose deadline has now been extended to July 18. Ashwini Joshi, Additional Municipal Commissioner, said that at least 48 companies have expressed interest in the plan while 996 queries have been raised for the plan. Allaying fears of the conservancy workers, Joshi maintained that the motor load workers will not be bereft of work as they will be rerouted towards carrying out sweeping in the second shift. At present, the conservancy workers carry out one round of sweeping in Mumbai, with the second round generally carried out through sweepers hired on a contractual basis. Meanwhile, the assistant engineers across the wards have been directed to communicate with the sanitation staffers at an individual level to counter the unions' stance.
Time of India
7 hours ago
- Time of India
Three bids received for Mumbai municipal corporation's Deonar dumping ground bioremediation tender
Mumbai: Three bids received for BMC's tender for bioremediation of legacy waste at Deonar dumping ground Mumbai: Three bids were received for BMC's Rs 2,368 crore tender for bioremediation of 185 lakh tonnes of legacy waste, along with the disposal of excavated, processed, and segregated material at the pre-independence era Deonar dumping ground. This comes despite that 21 bidders showed interest in the bioremediation tenders during the pre-bid meeting held in May. Officials said that considering the stringent tender conditions involved, such as no joint ventures being allowed and the requirement to clear 185 lakh tonnes of legacy waste, they did not expect a very large response. You Can Also Check: Mumbai AQI | Weather in Mumbai | Bank Holidays in Mumbai | Public Holidays in Mumbai The bids are expected to be opened next week, and the lowest bidder will be shortlisted. It was on May 14 that the BMC floated the tender, after which three extensions were given. The contract period for the work is set for three years, which includes the time for mobilisation and the monsoon period. This is among the largest tenders floated in recent years by the BMC for solid waste management. It also comes at a time when BMC's liabilities are at an all-time high. Currently, the BMC's liabilities stand at Rs 2.32 lakh crore.
