Tien not on board with MTR over need for shutdown
Michael Tien said he didn't think it was necessary to shut down the entire Tseung Kwan O line on Thursday. File photo: RTHK
A lawmaker has questioned why the MTR Corporation had to shut down the entire Tseung Kwan O line last Thursday, when power and signalling failures halted services for five hours starting from the evening rush hour.
Roundtable's Michael Tien quoted the railway company as telling him that it couldn't switch to manual operation and use the one available track for trains to go both ways because the section was still running on the old signalling system.
Tien, who chaired the Kowloon–Canton Railway Corporation before the merger of the two rail companies, said he didn't find the explanation acceptable.
"When you look at the past two, three years, service disruptions didn't affect the whole Tsuen Wan and Island lines – with both of them also running on the old signalling system," he told RTHK's In the Chamber programme.
"They just switched to manual.
"The design is that, once the automated system isn't safe enough, you can go manual so that the trains would go at a slower speed."
The government has said the MTR has to spend more than HK$19 million on passenger rebates because of the service disruption.
As a result of the Tseung Kwan O stoppage and two others earlier in February and April, the MTRC will be having a day of half-priced fares on a Saturday or Sunday.
Tien said he found it "a bit funny" that passengers across the entire network would benefit, when it was mostly those taking the Tseung Kwan O line trains that bore the brunt of the shutdown.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTHK
25 minutes ago
- RTHK
Hang Seng Index joins region in profit-taking
Hang Seng Index joins region in profit-taking The Hang Seng Index lost 135 points to open at 25,531.59 on Friday. File photo: RTHK Regional shares eased from highs on Friday, with Japanese markets retreating from a record peak, as investors locked in profits ahead of a crucial week that includes US President Donald Trump's tariff deadline and a host of central bank meetings. In Hong Kong, the benchmark Hang Seng Index lost 135 points, or 0.53 percent, to open at 25,531. Across the border, mainland blue chips declined 0.2 percent. Japan's broad Topix index, which had jumped more than 5 percent over the previous two sessions to reach an all-time high, pulled back 0.7 percent. The Nikkei slipped 0.5 percent from Thursday's one-year high. Australian shares were headed for their worst week in months, dragged down by losses in gold stocks and miners, while markets awaited progress in US trade talks. The S&P/ASX 200 index lost 0.5 percent to 8,935 by midday local time, taking its decline to more than 1 percent so far this week and putting it on track for its steepest weekly drop since April 4. Next week, in the United States alone, investors need to contend with Trump's August 1 deadline for trade deals, a Federal Reserve policy meeting, the closely watched monthly payrolls report, and earnings from the likes of Amazon, Apple, Meta and Microsoft. The Bank of Japan has its own policy announcement on Thursday, and Prime Minister Ishiba's Liberal Democratic Party holds a meeting the same day. That's after the European Central Bank held rates steady on Thursday, pausing its easing campaign as it waits to assess any impact from US tariffs. (Reuters/Xinhua)
South China Morning Post
an hour ago
- South China Morning Post
As tourists return, Hong Kong has second chance at getting balance right
Between 2012 and 2018, Hong Kong experienced substantial growth, partly driven by a notable rise in tourism. During this period, Ocean Park often operated at full capacity, and the MTR was frequently crowded with travellers carrying suitcases. The streets of many neighbourhoods were transformed to provide goods and services mainly catering to mainland visitors. For some locals, daily routines were disrupted as queues formed at bakeries and popular spots, creating a mixture of emotions about the city's growing tourism sector. The dynamic that once defined local life was noticeably changing. Hong Kong established itself as Asia's 'shopping paradise' , attracting over 65 million visitors in 2018, with some 78 per cent coming from mainland China. While this brought prosperity to many businesses and landlords, the general public often bore the costs, such as overcrowded MTR stations and other public spaces. The growth of tourism was driven by increasing wealth on the mainland and policies like the Individual Visit Scheme , which made it easier to travel to Hong Kong from participating cities in China. Although the influx brought economic benefits, it also raised concerns about overcrowding, rising prices and the loss of neighbourhood character. The situation changed significantly after 2019, when social unrest and then the pandemic severely affected tourism. As borders reopened, economic and geopolitical issues influenced global travel patterns, and visitors were slow to return. A major factor was the strong US dollar that the Hong Kong dollar is pegged to, which reduced the city's competitiveness. But competition from mainland cities also grew. New theme parks and retail options in Shenzhen began attracting tourists who previously preferred Hong Kong's attractions, such as Ocean Park , forcing established venues to work harder to stay competitive.
HKFP
an hour ago
- HKFP
Allow ride-hailing services to operate only during peak hours, Hong Kong taxi union proposes
A Hong Kong taxi union has proposed that ride-hailing services be allowed to operate only during peak hours, as it welcomed a legislative proposal to regulate app-based booking platforms like Uber. The Hong Kong Taxi and Public Light Bus Association spokesperson Peter Yung told reporters on Wednesday that the union hoped it could be involved in the legislative process regulating online ride-hailing services. The union is of the view that traditional taxis should be the core providers of point-to-point services, while ride-hailing services should play merely an 'auxiliary' role, being allowed to operate only during peak hours, Yung said. In an earlier letter to transport chief Mable Chan, the association proposed allowing online ride-hails to operate only from 7am to 10am and 5pm to 8pm, Yung told reporters. Proposed regulations Last week, the Transport and Logistics Bureau submitted its proposal to the Legislative Council outlining a framework for regulating online ride-hailing services in Hong Kong. The government plans to cap the number of licences but has not given details of the specific limit. According to the proposal submitted to the Legislative Council's Panel on Transport, the government suggests issuing licences to ride-hailing platforms that would be valid for five years and renewable based on the platform's service performance. Chan had earlier said the authorities would take into consideration the public's convenience, the orderly development of the industry, the public transport system, and road-carrying capacity when deciding the number of licences. Asked how many licences the association believed should be in circulation, Yung did not state a number, only that it would depend on the government's data. Yung also said that the association had proposed issuing online ride-hailing licences through public tender, as is done for taxis. But the union is against allowing the licence to change hands, lest it become an investment tool. Ride-hailing services should 'co-exist' with the taxi trade to provide transport services, Chief Executive John Lee said. Ride-hailing apps currently operate in a grey area in the city, which requires vehicles offering hailing services to have a hire car permit. Private vehicle owners who provide hailing services on online platforms without a permit could face up to six months in jail and a HK$10,000 fine for the first offence. The popularity of services such as Uber has risen amid long-standing dissatisfaction with taxi service standards, while the cab industry is calling for tougher action against Uber and the like, saying that its livelihood has been adversely affected by ride-hailing services.
