Mental Health Bill may delay treatment for teenagers, Oireachtas committee hears
Shortages of specially trained authorised personnel to assist patients in crisis were also discussed by An Garda Síochána, in light of a new project in Limerick.
This was the committee's first sitting since the November election, and their first opportunity to scrutinise a bill that could be in place for the next 25 years.
Committee chair Pádraig Rice expressed his 'frustration' with the timing. Normally, there would be a gap between the committee and Dáil discussions, but this Bill will go before the Dáil just hours later.
The Government tabled 298 amendments on Tuesday afternoon.
'I don't think it's in line with best practice and I don't think it's the way to deal with a Bill of this scale,' he warned.
Speakers raised concerns about gaps in crisis care for teenagers aged 16 to 18. Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (Camhs) supports patients up to 18, but paediatric emergency departments stop at 16.
Committee chair Pádraig Rice expressed his 'frustration' with the timing. Picture: Niall Carson/PA Wire
Irish Medical Organisation Consultant Committee Chair Dr Matthew Sadlier described a case where a 17-year-old spent a week in an emergency department.
'We couldn't admit them to the acute adult unit because we were too scared we going to get given out to and told we were torturing somebody and abusing their human rights,' he said. '
There was no bed available in the child unit, now where was the most suitable place for that child, a 17-year-old, to be?'.
Answering questions about South Kerry Camhs, the focus of critical reports including the Maskey review, he said the Bill does not address staffing gaps that led to these problems.
Recruiting for isolated rural services in Kerry or Donegal is more difficult than in cities, so discussions with staff and employers must come first, he explained.
The Mental Health Commission welcomed the expansion of its remit in some areas under the Bill but supported calls from two Garda speakers for more attention to the authorised persons issue.
Assistant Commissioner Paula Hilman said a pilot programme in Limerick, run jointly by Gardaí and the HSE, has helped 'over 40' people avoid arrest or detention by offering support services. None of them needed to go to the Limerick ED.
However, she raised serious concerns that the Bill will worsen national shortages of trained staff.
'It is the experience of our CAST team that there is a need for a 24-hour, seven-day-a-week service to support delivery in this area,' she said.
She added: 'We further contend that only allowing Authorised Officers to make an application, could add to the already adversarial and structured process – and potentially cause significant delays to a person receiving treatment.'
Dr Brendan Kelly, also of the IMO, warned of ongoing concern that the criteria for involuntary admission and treatment differ. This could result in someone being admitted but not receiving treatment, he explained.
Mental Health Reform interim CEO Philip Watt said: 'The key thing really is definition, so no matter what term is used there has to be clarity on the definitions'.
There are approximately 2,000 involuntary admissions each year in Ireland.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
a day ago
- Irish Examiner
Number of festivals to have HSE's harm reduction initiative is halved ahead of drugs strategy review
The HSE harm reduction initiative will be at two festivals this year with officials saying they won't expand the programme any further pending a review. The operation of the HSE Safer Nightlife Programme at two festivals in 2025 compares to four festivals in 2024 and three in 2023. In a statement, the HSE said the programme cannot be expanded in its 'current format' and that it was due for a review in 2026, which will determine the 'next phase'. The HSE has recommended that changes to current policy 'should be considered' to 'improve engagement' with people using drugs. It said the HSE was hopeful that the next National Drugs Strategy, due later this year, will have 'clear recommendations'. It is understood that the number of festivals they work at depends on various factors, including the resources it has and the number of trained volunteers at their disposal. Priority is also placed on targeting the right audiences and ensuring health interventions are of high quality. The HSE statement said: 'The HSE will be at Ireland's largest festival Electric Picnic, and Ireland's largest dance event 'DX'." These events are at the end of August and September. The statement said: 'Back-of-house testing and outreach will be provided over three days of Electric Picnic, and two days of DX to support and identify risks for people who use drugs. The HSE is working with event organisers and gardaí to provide a health-led setting to ensure a safe space for people to discuss any difficulties or concerns they may have and to surrender drugs if they wish.' Back-of-house testing involves the authorities checking drugs that have been discarded by festival goers into official 'surrender bins' at the HSE tents and medical tents. Checks can also be conducted on drugs connected with a person brought to a medical tent. The HSE Programme operates with the formal agreement of An Garda Síochána as well as concert promoters. If scientists identify a trend of concern, the HSE issue alerts via social media, through volunteers and through digital billboards and signs. On potential expansion, the HSE said: 'In the current format, the HSE Safer Nightlife Programme cannot be expanded and is subject to review in 2026 to identify the next phase for this programme. 'The HSE recognises the need to expand the project to help identify drug trends on an annual basis. In its current format, 'back-of-house' analysis is not suitable for small venues such as pubs or venues, and it is not viable to expand to these settings. 'Policy amendments should be considered to identify how to improve this approach, remove service barriers and improve engagement with people who use drugs across Irish society in preparation for emerging drug threats. 'The HSE is hopeful that clear recommendations in relation to this area are included in the forthcoming drugs strategy.' Last May, the HSE warned users about new versions of the increasingly popular hallucinogenic drug, ketamine, and high-strength ecstasy pills, crystals, and powders.
RTÉ News
4 days ago
- RTÉ News
Inquiry begins into prescribing of anti-epilepsy drug
An inquiry has begun into the historical prescribing of an anti-epilepsy drug which can cause birth defects if used during pregnancy. The non-statutory inquiry into the use of sodium valproate, sold under the brand name Epilim, is scheduled to last between 12 and 18 months. It is estimated over 1,000 children have been impacted in Ireland since the 1970s. The inquiry, which will be chaired by barrister Bríd O'Flaherty, will be divided into a number of strands. The first will be the review phase, which will establish a timeline of the use of the drug including information on safety and regulation. The Department of Health said the inquiry will have responsibility to request documentation from a range of stakeholders and will be obliged to record any difficulties where such requests are refused. The second phase will be made up of oral statements from affected families. These sessions will be held in private. Other phases will focus on assessing the health services' current capacity to respond to safety issues related to the use of anti-seizure medications in women. The department said necessary data regulations were passed last week in the Dáil and Seanad. Families have been campaigning for years for an inquiry to be held and have welcomed the fact that it began today. The department has previously said sodium valproate is an effective medication for some and those taking it should not make any changes to treatment without first discussing it with their doctor. The department has also previously said while sodium valproate is an effective and essential treatment for some patients, it can cause birth defects, neurodevelopmental disorders and autism in children whose mothers take such medicines during pregnancy.
Extra.ie
4 days ago
- Extra.ie
Cutting costs: Vasectomies could soon be free across Ireland as men urged to 'step up'
Vasectomies may soon be offered for free across the country, the Health Minister has confirmed. Jennifer Carroll MacNeill was responding to a question by Labour's Marie Sherlock TD, who told the Dáil that it was time for men to 'step up' and stop relying on women to use contraceptives. Responding to a parliamentary question from Ms Sherlock, Ms Carroll MacNeill agreed that there was 'significant inequity of access' to vasectomy, both geographically and based on ability to pay, and that the Government is now considering free access to vasectomies across the country. Jennifer Carroll MacNeill. Pic: Stephen Collins/ Collins Photos She said that the Department of Health's National Sexual Health Strategy is 'committed to scoping the potential for expanding access to male and female sterilisation', including vasectomies for men. The Minister also said that a strategy will be created 'as soon as possible in 2025.' Vasectomies are currently available without cost to some medical cardholders. Ms Sherlock told the Dáil: 'The responsibility for family planning shouldn't just fall on the woman's shoulders. There's a simple, relatively pain-free procedure that a man recovers from within a very few short hours, but obviously it has a transformative impact on the family. Marie Sherlock. Photo: RTÉ. 'We have to make sure in the whole family planning conversation that men step up and take their responsibility seriously. There's a real inequality of access to the service, and particularly outside of the main urban areas,' she said. 'There's a crucial issue here about how we encourage and incentivise doctors to take on the service, and crucially, then from the department of health perspective, that there is a decent geographical spread of these services across the country.' However, Aontú leader, Peadar Tóibín, last night questioned whether the Government should be offering free vasectomies while Ireland's fertility rates continue to plunge. Peadar Tóibín. Pic: Fran Veale Mr Tóibín said: 'There are major questions in relation to where the Government is going in relation to this. So what we've seen in the last decade is a collapse in the fertility levels. They're lower now than the replacement rate, which means there's going to be significantly fewer children in future than there were in the past.' The fertility rate for 2024 stood at 1.5, a decrease of 0.5 from the 2014 fertility rate of 2.0. This is still higher than the European average, which stands at 1.38 births per woman in the EU. In Malta, the fertility rate stands at 1.06, compared to 1.81 in Bulgaria. Mr Tóibín warned that Ireland will create 'lopsided demographics, which means there will be fewer young people to be able to work, to provide the taxes to pay the pensions for people into the future. 'Good governance means a balanced demographics, and actually, at this moment in time, that means encouraging families to have more children. 'There's no doubt that the housing crisis is hammering families. They're delaying having children, and they're living, oftentimes, young couples in their parents' box room, which means that they can't have children and it's later and later until people are getting mortgages.' He went on: 'The cost of childcare is prohibitive for many, many people, and also the abortion rates have increased from about 3,000 abortions a year in 2018 to spiking well over 10,000 now.' 'All of these issues are pushing down the number of children that have been born. We should be giving families the economic confidence to be able to raise their children, to be able to have children, and so that we have a vibrant society and economy into the future.' Ryan Murphy, the operations manager at Sandyford, Dublin-based clinic said that vasectomies could not be accessed in multiple areas of the country, creating a 'two-tier system'.
