Egg Drop Challenge: Physicists surprise in finding on how eggs break

Yahoo

12-05-2025

Is a raw egg more fragile when it falls upright or lying on its side? It's a question that's relevant not only for kitchen mishaps, but above all for anyone taking part in the so-called Egg Drop Challenge.
This popular classroom experiment is often used in physics lessons. The challenge: students are tasked with using everyday items like straws, paper and string to build a protective capsule for the egg, allowing it to be dropped from various heights without breaking.
To aid students, a team of researchers from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) in Cambridge have officially addressed the question of whether an egg breaks more easily when it falls upright or sideways. To investigate, they dropped eggs 180 times from different heights.
The findings, published in May by the team in the journal Communications Physics, reveal that eggs are - counter to physics classroom teachings - less fragile when they fall horizontally rather than vertically.
"We contest the commonly held belief that an egg is strongest when dropped vertically on its end," the authors write, arguing to have disproved what they say is a widespread assumption found in tutorials and physics teaching materials.
In the experiment, more than half of the eggs that fell upright from a height of eight millimetres broke, regardless of which end of the egg was pointing downwards. In contrast, fewer than 10% of the eggs that fell from a horizontal position broke.
Even at slightly greater heights, the proportion of broken eggs was significantly smaller when the eggs were aligned horizontally. The team also conducted additional tests using a specialized device to determine the amount of pressure required to break the eggs.
The researchers explained the observed effect by noting that eggs are more flexible in the middle, allowing them to absorb more energy before breaking.
On average, eggs can absorb about 30% more energy when falling horizontally, according to the study. This essentially makes them more durable, by the study's definition.
The team believes this confusion between physical properties is one reason for the common misconception that eggs are more stable when oriented vertically.
Most physics teachers understand that an egg is stiffer in one direction, the authors say. "But they equate this with 'strength' in all other senses. However, eggs need to be tough, not stiff, in order to survive a fall."
Humans know this only too well, if only instinctively, when jumping from a height.
"When we fall we know to bend our knees rather than lock them straight, which could lead to injury. In a sense, our legs are 'weaker', or more compliant, when bent, but are tougher, and therefore 'stronger' during impact, experiencing a lower force over a longer distance."