UK judge notes 'confidential impediment' in Nirav Modi extradition case
Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
A London High Court judge who refused Nirav Modi's latest bail application this week has taken note in his judgment of a " confidential impediment " in the long-drawn extradition proceedings against the imprisoned diamantaire wanted in India on fraud and money laundering charges Justice Michael Fordham on Thursday concluded at a Royal Courts of Justice bail hearing that there are substantial grounds for believing that if released on bail, the 54-year-old businessman would "fail to surrender" and his risk of absconding remained high.While Nirav's barrister argued in favour of his bail from London's Thameside prison based on the "long passage of time" without trial, the judge highlighted the constraints of a "confidential" process that prevented his surrender to the Indian authorities even though the legal process related to his extradition had "run its course"."There is a 'legal reason' which relates to 'confidential proceedings'. The nature of this is known to the applicant (Nirav Modi), and his lawyers; it is known to the Home Office, but apart from what I have recorded, nothing is known by the CPS [Crown Prosecution Service] or by the Government of India, nor by this court," Justice Fordham states.CPS barrister Nicholas Hearn, appearing on behalf of the Indian authorities, confirmed to the court that he "recognises and respects" the fact of the "existing confidential impediment" and the fact of its confidentiality, for "whatever reason it is being kept confidential"."It is appropriate, in the circumstances, that the court should proceed with the same recognition and respect. But the consequence is this: there is, as a result, a significant limitation to what this court can realistically assess, when considering the risks and implications in this case, and for that matter when considering how to characterise the now long passage of time," the judge concluded in his ruling.The confidential proceedings, alluded to at various previous court hearings linked with Nirav Modi, are believed to refer to an asylum application , but the exact nature of the matter is unclear.Meanwhile, Nirav has remained in prison in London since his arrest in March 2019 and has made at least seven previous bail attempts, which have all been rejected because he poses a flight risk.Justice Fordham said he considered the legal appropriateness for him to consider the latest bail application "afresh" and with a "clean slate"."I have had close regard to the points which have been made about the human cost of detention. That includes all of the points that have been advanced about physical and mental health, including in terms of deterioration and delays in treatment, and the concerns very properly raised in the clinicians' expert evidence," Justice Fordham's judgment said."I have also taken account of the evidence about assaults and threats and the prospect of coercion... But I am not able to conclude that, when put alongside the other relevant features of the case, they can serve to displace or undermine the assessment which I have described (against bail)," it said.There are three sets of criminal proceedings against Nirav Modi in India - the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) case of fraud in the Punjab National Bank (PNB), the Enforcement Directorate (ED) case relating to the alleged laundering of the proceeds of that fraud, and a third set of criminal proceedings involving alleged interference with evidence and witnesses in the CBI proceedings.In April 2021, then UK home secretary, Priti Patel, ordered his extradition to face these charges in the Indian courts after a prima facie case was established against him.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
14 minutes ago
- Time of India
Milky Mist files draft papers for $236 million IPO
Synopsis Milky Mist, a leading Indian dairy brand known for value-added products like cheese and paneer, has filed for a $236 million IPO.
India Today
14 minutes ago
- India Today
India-US trade deal stalemate continues, talks to resume in August: Sources
Negotiations between India and the US on a crucial trade pact remain at an impasse, with talks now expected to resume when a delegation from Washington visits Delhi in the second week of August, sources two nations are aiming to finalise a comprehensive bilateral trade agreement (BTA) by September or October. The latest round of talks, the fifth, saw the Indian negotiators in Washington attempting to break a deadlock over duties on auto components, steel, and agricultural products. These issues have emerged as key sticking points in the drawn-out the discussions remained inconclusive, and the Indian delegation returned home just days before US President Donald Trump's August 1 tariff pause deadline rolls around. Talks hit a snag after India drew a red line and refused to yield to US demands on agricultural access, particularly in the dairy sector, which employs more than 80 million Indians, many of them smallholder previously said that while the two countries were close to sealing a deal by the end of June, discussions fell apart before the July 9 deadline set by Trump. India's stand on protecting its dairy sector was a key reason the talks failed to cross the finish meanwhile, has repeatedly claimed that the BTA with India is almost done deal. Yet, he has also warned of sweeping new tariffs on imports from multiple countries, including members of the Brics bloc, of which India is a week, the US President reiterated that Brics nations could face 10 per cent tariffs if they dare to go the de-dollarization way. He also warned of 100 per cent duties on Russian goods and hinted at slapping secondary sanctions on countries buying Russian oil. India, the second-largest buyer of Russian fossil fuels, could be majorly impacted if such measures are at least 14 countries have received formal notices from Washington about impending tariffs ranging from 25 per cent to 40 per cent, India has not received such a letter. This has given hope that negotiations are still alive, albeit under growing outcome of the August round of talks may determine whether India can avoid punishing tariffs as high as 500 per cent and secure a long-pending trade pact with Washington, one that has remained elusive despite repeated assurances from both governments.- Ends
Indian Express
14 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Rosneft-backed Nayara Energy slams EU sanctions, says ‘actively exploring' legal options
Nayara Energy on Monday slammed the European Union's imposition of sanctions on the company, saying that the decision was a unilateral move 'founded on baseless assertions' and one that ignores international law and India's sovereignty. The refiner, which owns and operates a 20-million-tonnes-per-annum oil refinery in Gujarat's Vadinar and has a network of around 6,800 fuel retail outlets, is 'actively exploring all legal and appropriate avenues to address the situation'. Nayara added that all aspects of its business continue to function normally, and has taken measures to ensure seamless continuity and stability across all its business verticals. The EU on Friday announced that it was sanctioning Nayara, in which Russian oil giant Rosneft holds 49.13 per cent stake, as part of its tranche of actions in the latest bid to force the Kremlin's hand to end the war in Ukraine. The EU also banned import of fuels made from Russian crude and coming from third countries and lowered the price cap on seaborne Russian crude from $60 to $47.6 per barrel in an effort to curtail Russia's revenue from oil exports. The package includes sanctions and other actions targeting Russia's energy, shipping, banking, and military industry sectors. The energy sector is a key focus area of the package as oil exports account for a third of Russia's revenue. Reacting to the EU sanctions, External Affairs Ministry Spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said Friday that India does not subscribe to any unilateral measures. 'We are a responsible actor and remain fully committed to our legal obligations. Government of India considers the provision of energy security a responsibility of paramount importance to meet the basic needs of its citizens. We stress that there should be no double standards, especially when it comes to energy trade,' he said in a statement. 'Recently, Nayara Energy has come under international scrutiny, facing political pressures and the imposition of sanctions by the European Union which have no legal basis. We categorically state that this unilateral move by the European Union is founded on baseless assertions, representing an undue extension of authority that ignores both international law and the sovereignty of India. It is to be noted that while many European countries continue to import Russian energy through various sources, they take a high moral ground by chastising and sanctioning an Indian asset for processing Russian crude largely used by its domestic population of 1.4 billion Indians and businesses,' the refiner said in a statement on Monday. Rosneft had slammed the EU's action on Sunday, terming it 'unjustified and illegal'. The sanctions would mean that Nayara Energy would not be able to export petroleum fuels and products to Europe, and potentially hit any of its dealings with European companies. It could also hit Rosneft's plan to exit Nayara as the EU sanctions could spook prospective investors. The company, formerly Essar Oil, was earlier part of the Essar group. It was renamed as Nayara Energy after a group of investors including Rosneft acquired it from the Essar group. Like Rosneft, Kesani Enterprises—a consortium led by Italy's Mareterra and Russia-based United Capital Partners (UCP)—hold 49.13 per cent stake in the company. While owned by a group of international investors—mainly from Russia—Nayara said that it is an Indian company governed by Indian law. 'Nayara Energy strongly condemns the European Union's unjust and unilateral decision to impose restrictive measures on our company. Nayara Energy operates in full compliance with the laws and regulations of India. As an Indian company, we are deeply committed to supporting the nation's energy security and fostering economic growth. Our organization is governed by Indian law and proudly serves as a vital contributor to the country's energy infrastructure,' the refiner said. 'Such actions not only undermine India's interests, but also risk disrupting the uninterrupted supply of petroleum products that are essential to millions of Indian citizens and industries. We remain steadfast in our role as a reliable energy partner for India, and we urge all stakeholders to respect the principles of sovereignty and fair international conduct. We are actively exploring all legal and appropriate avenues to address this situation and to protect the interests of our operations, employees, and our stakeholders,' it added. The company said that it is committed to ensure that there is no disruption to its daily operations or its long-term strategic objectives, adding that it 'firmly' believes that there is 'no impact whatsoever' on the company's interests. Nayara accounts for around 8 per cent of India's total refining capacity and 7 per cent of the country's fuel retail network. It has over 55,000 direct and indirect employees across India. 'A major tax payer in India, Nayara Energy since August 2017 has contributed over Rs 2.5 lakh crore in cumulative direct and indirect taxes to help build India's growth story. As a responsible corporate entity, we uphold the highest standards of compliance with all applicable laws and regulatory frameworks. Transparency, legal accountability, and constructive stakeholder engagement are cornerstones of our operations,' the refiner said, adding that it has invested over Rs 14,000 crore in various projects over the past eight years and will continue to invest over Rs 70,000 crore over the coming years in segments like petrochemicals, ethanol production, and fuel marketing. Sukalp Sharma is a Senior Assistant Editor with The Indian Express and writes on a host of subjects and sectors, notably energy and aviation. He has over 13 years of experience in journalism with a body of work spanning areas like politics, development, equity markets, corporates, trade, and economic policy. He considers himself an above-average photographer, which goes well with his love for travel. ... Read More
