Indonesian governor's vasectomy-for-welfare proposal sparks intense debate
West Java Governor Dedi Mulyadi reportedly suggested sterilisation in exchange for access to social welfare, electricity connections, food aid, scholarships and public housing.
In an April 28 speech, Dedi questioned why poor families often have many children, saying, 'Stop having children if you can't provide for them well,' the SCMP reported.
'I don't know why poor families generally have many children, while rich people have difficulty having children, even after paying two billion rupiah (RM517,900) for IVF,' he was quoted as saying.
Religious leaders swiftly condemned the idea, with Cholil Nafis of the Indonesian Ulema Council reportedly saying Islam forbids permanent sterilisation and that poverty should be addressed through employment opportunities.
Indonesia's Social Minister Saifullah Yusuf also rejected the proposal, calling it 'not relevant' and impractical, according to the report.
Rights advocates and academics reportedly described the plan as coercive and discriminatory, with Singapore-based scholar Sulfikar Amir calling it a 'blatant form of body politics' and warning that it wrongly assumes poverty results from large families rather than structural economic inequality.
Public reactions online were mixed, with some supporting the proposal and others labelling it 'fascist,' the SCMP noted.
The debate comes amid new World Bank data showing that 60.3 per cent of Indonesians — or roughly 171 million people — live below the updated poverty threshold of US$6.85 (RM29.23) per person per day.
This figure contrasts sharply with Indonesia's official poverty rate of 8.57 per cent, based on older national standards.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
3 hours ago
- The Star
Prabowo in Brussels to seal European Union deal amid US tariff threat
JAKARTA: With trade tensions between the United States and its partners on the rise, President Prabowo Subianto arrived in Brussels over the weekend in a bid to finalise Indonesia's most ambitious trade pact yet, the Indonesia-European Union Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (IEU-CEPA). The trip follows the completion of substantive negotiations between Jakarta and Brussels, with both sides now preparing to sign the deal in Jakarta later this year. Coordinating Economic Minister Airlangga Hartarto, speaking from Brussels, said that 'all issues have now been resolved' and called the deal 'a milestone' that could reshape Indonesia's trade orientation in an increasingly uncertain global environment. 'This is certainly a milestone amid the uncertainty between Indonesia and the EU. Our products can now enter Europe at zero tariffs,' Airlangga told reporters in a video interview issued in Jakarta on Sunday (July 13). He added that the agreement's final signing is expected in the third quarter of 2025, pending a formal announcement from the President. The IEU-CEPA spans 21 areas of cooperation, including trade in goods and services, investment, customs procedures, digital trade and sustainable growth. Key sectors like textiles, garments and fishery products are expected to benefit from reduced barriers. Prabowo's visit to Brussels officially begins on Sunday, and includes scheduled meetings with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and European Council President António Costa, as well as King Philippe of Belgium. Airlangga emphasised that 'shifting global geopolitics', a likely reference to Washington's protectionist tariff hikes, has made Europe a more attractive alternative for Indonesian exports. He also pointed to Indonesia's bid to join the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) as one reason why Brussels now views Jakarta as a 'like-minded' and strategic partner. Trade Minister Budi Santoso, also in Brussels, echoed that sentiment, saying that Indonesia had gained leverage during the final stretch of negotiations. 'When IEU-CEPA neared completion, the EU started to soften on things like the deforestation regulation,' he said. 'They too want to work with us going forward.' The visit of the high-level Indonesian delegation comes just weeks after the EU reclassified Indonesia as a 'standard-risk' country under its deforestation regulation (EUDR), which had long been a sticking point for EU-bound palm oil shipments from Indonesia, the world's largest producer and exporter of the commodity. Budi also noted that Europe presents a more sizable and potentially stable market amid growing uncertainty. 'EU imports are about US$6.6 trillion globally, compared to around $3.3 trillion for the US. If we can grow our exports to the EU, that's a strong alternative market for us,' he said in a separate video interview. The EU is currently Indonesia's fifth-largest trading partner, with bilateral trade reaching $30.1 billion in 2024. The CEPA deal, once ratified, is expected to boost Indonesian exports to the EU by up to 50 percent due to lower tariffs and non-tariff barriers and attract more investment in key sectors such as electric vehicles, semiconductors, renewable energy and palm oil processing. While full ratification may not occur before 2027, Indonesian businesses are already aligning with EU partners to prepare supply chains ahead of its entry into force. 'After Indonesia, countries like Malaysia and Thailand are lining up. We are now the front-runner in forging deeper cooperation [with Europe],' Airlangga said. The US tariff threats, pegged between 20-40 percent for countries in Southeast Asia, have prompted Asean economies to diversify trade partners and bolster their domestic supply chains. Of Asean's current 10 member states, only Vietnam has signed a deal with the US to mitigate the tariff threat. In an attempt to appease the region, US Secretary of State Mark Rubio argued last week that 'many of the countries in Southeast Asia are going to have tariff rates that are actually better than countries in other parts of the world,' news wires reported. In response to a question on the ongoing Indonesia-US negotiations, Airlangga claimed that the US had agreed to a 'pause' on imposing tariffs for the next three weeks to allow for the fine-tuning and completion of the tariff deal. - The Jakarta Post/ANN
Daily Express
3 days ago
- Daily Express
RM10 billion allocated for new entry points along Malaysia-Kalimantan border
Published on: Friday, July 11, 2025 Published on: Fri, Jul 11, 2025 By: Chia Wan Rou, FMT Text Size: Saifuddin said the ministry was in the process of appointing the vendor to conduct the registration of refugees, adding that it would be done using the ministry's existing infrastructure. - Bernama pic Kuala Lumpur: The home ministry will soon begin registering refugees in order to obtain 'trustworthy' data. Home minister Saifuddin Nasution Ismail said refugees were currently registered with the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), but the process of data sharing was taking a long time. 'The National Security Council (MKN) has asked the home ministry to lead the process of registering refugees,' he said on the sidelines of an event in Bukit Kiara here. Saifuddin said the ministry was in the process of appointing the vendor to conduct the registration of refugees, adding that it would be done using the ministry's existing infrastructure. He said this would include the immigration department's infrastructure, adding that it had more than 70 offices across the country. 10 new entry points along Kalimantan The minister also said Putrajaya had allocated RM10 billion to develop various infrastructure and facilities for the setting up of 10 new entry points along East Malaysia's border with Kalimantan, Indonesia. This will go towards the development of police and army control posts, basic infrastructure like roads, as well as customs, immigration, quarantine and security complexes. He said the current priority was to develop the entry point at Serudong in Tawau, Sabah, as there were several unresolved issues with the Indonesian authorities. The Malaysia-Indonesia land border on the island of Borneo spans 1,881km. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available. Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia
The Star
3 days ago
- The Star
Rare earth may help Indonesia persuade US to lower reciprocal tariffs, but experts remain sceptical
JAKARTA: Even as Indonesia's lead negotiator intensified lobbying efforts for a lowering of America's reciprocal tariffs this week, analysts remain sceptical that talks will make headway even if Jakarta attempts to leverage the nation's rich mineral resources as a bargaining chip. They said the US' apparently adamant rejections to Indonesia's proposals to balance trade were politically motivated, hence any offers, even those that offer economic benefit, will not make them budge. Still, plans to meet with members of the Trump administration in Washington this week went on, as Coordinating Minister for Economic Affairs Airlangga Hartarto pressed on with negotiation meetings even hours after the Monday (July 7) letter that put Indonesia's tariff rate unchanged at 32 per cent. In a text reply to The Straits Times on July 7 night, Airlangga hinted that Indonesia would continue dialogue up to Aug 1, the latest tariff deadline set by the US. He didn't elaborate. Indonesia has offered to cut tariffs on the US imports to near zero, especially for agriculture and industrial items, committed to buying US aircraft, procuring energy commodities such as natural gas and opening up to the US investment opportunities in nickel and copper smelting. These proposals have not gone anywhere. Analysts do not expect much to come out of the ongoing talks, given that there are other political and American domestic considerations. Analyst Henry Pranoto said that the tariff rates for Indonesia are largely motivated by Trump's plan to bring manufacturing jobs back to the US. 'The higher tariffs are meant to offset the gap in the minimum wages between the US and the developing countries,' said Henry, who works at a Jakarta-based investment bank. Meanwhile, Dr Nasir Tamara, a former visiting senior research fellow at ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute, noted that Indonesia's recent entry into Brics, a grouping of countries that include China and Russia, could also weigh on the negotiation process, as Trump has threatened an additional 10 per cent tariff on those that aligned with the 'anti-American' grouping. Still, officials are not giving up. A government official who is familiar with the negotiation, told ST that Jakarta is planning to dangle its rich, undeveloped rare earth elements (REEs) reserve as part of negotiations to reduce the 32 per cent reciprocal tariff rate set by the US as the August deadline looms. 'Twenty days is not a lot of time, but we have two things that the US really wants. One of them is rare earth,' said the official who spoke on condition of anonymity, adding that this would be Indonesia's third formal proposal to the US. He declined to provide further information on the second aspect that Indonesia was looking to leverage on. The Indonesia negotiation team had submitted in the second week of April a comprehensive letter to start negotiation, following Trump's Liberation Day tariff speech on April 2. It was addressed to the US Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick, containing a list of what Indonesia could do to balance trade and what the US could do in exchange. In 2024, Indonesia ran a US$17.9 billion (S$22.9 billion) trade surplus with the US. This compares to Vietnam's trade surplus at US$123 billion, Thailand's at US$45.6 billion and Malaysia's US$24.8 billion. The negotiations progressed, and Indonesian officials told reporters that the US would agree to sign a US$34 billion pact on July 7. The deal would purportedly include a pledge by Indonesian state oil and gas company Pertamina to buy significantly more fuel from the US, as well as the purchase of 75 Boeing aircraft by state-controlled airline Garuda Indonesia. As part of the deal, Indonesia would also pledge to buy more agricultural products from the US such as soybean, and its newly-formed sovereign wealth fund would invest in the oil and gas sector in Alaska. Meanwhile, US companies, such as Apple, would have easier access to sell telecommunication products in Indonesia. US firms would also have more opportunities to invest in nickel smelters to make raw materials to produce electric vehicle batteries. But the expected signing of the July 7 pact did not happen. Indonesia's rare earth industry is relatively nascent and underdeveloped, but it has potential beyond its current stated reserve, according to observers. The government is also looking to open up the industry by exploring rare earth mining permits. Rare earth – used in high-tech, energy and defence applications including missiles – was previously deployed as a negotiating weapon by China, the world's top supplier, in its trade talks with Washington. China, which controls 70 per cent of global rare earth production, had restricted the export of some rare earth minerals on April 4 – a move seen as part of its retaliatory measures against the US' tariff hikes that were announced that same month. This affected ongoing trade talks between the two superpowers. Talks later resumed, and they reached a deal in June after China agreed to release the flow of rare earth shipments while the US lifted its export countermeasures over chips, jet engines and aerospace components. Among the regions rich in rare earth in Indonesia are Humbang Hasundutan in North Sumatra province and Mamuju in West Sulawesi province. The Mamuju mine has been touted to be the first in Indonesia that would get a rare earth mining permit from the government. It contains up to 6,000 parts per million (ppm) of rare earth elements, which is roughly 0.6 per cent of the amount of earth mined. Indonesia, however, has not done as much geochemical mapping, or exploration for rare earth as China or Australia, hence a full picture of its reserve is not available, Fabby Tumiwa, executive director of the Institute for Essential Services Reform, a Jakarta think tank, told ST. But rare earths in Indonesia have also been found in tailings, or waste materials from mining operations. Indonesia's state mining holding company MIND ID said on April 24 that it is working on a pilot project to extract and process rare earth elements found in the tin-mining waste produced by PT Timah, its subsidiary, in Tanjung Ular, Bangka Belitung province. The company is seeking a foreign partner that has an advanced technology to help process monazite found in the tailings into mixed rare earth carbonate that can be further processed into pure rare earth oxides such as neodymium and praseodymium. These two rare earth elements, if combined, would become the strongest permanent magnet that is used in electric vehicles, smartphones and military equipment. - The Straits Times/ANN
