logo
‘Black or white, as a South African you just want to leave home without worrying you're going to die'

‘Black or white, as a South African you just want to leave home without worrying you're going to die'

Irish Times03-07-2025
On a warm evening last December, Reason Khumalo was doing some last-minute Christmas shopping in Johannesburg when he noticed two apparently drunk strangers weaving towards him.
He did not think much of it: it was a public holiday and the streets in the inner-city Hillbrow district were busy with cheerful crowds. 'The next thing I knew, one of them drew a gun and everybody just scattered,' the 45-year-old Uber driver recalled, his voice still shaking months later.
Only after he had been running for a while did Khumalo look down and realise his shirt was soaked in blood. 'I've been shot' was his last thought before collapsing.
Khumalo, who woke from a coma in hospital days later, narrowly avoided joining almost 27,000 South Africans murdered last year – a toll that has received renewed global scrutiny in recent months.
READ MORE
Since taking office,
Donald Trump
has fixated on a false narrative that white South African farmers are the victims of a 'genocide', using a bruising Oval Office meeting with president
Cyril Ramaphosa
in May to reiterate the discredited claim.
South African leader Cyril Ramaphosa is confronted by Donald Trump at the White House in March. Photograph: Jim Lo Scalzo/EPA
Violent crime has become one of the biggest issues in post-apartheid
South Africa
, fuelling a vicious cycle that the World Bank says costs the economy at least 10 per cent of GDP annually. Law-breaking has seeped into much of South African society, from organised crime to petty looting; political assassinations to extortion rackets.
But contrary to the US president's 'genocide' contention, it blights the daily lives of all South Africans.
The reality is that three-quarters of homicide victims in the country – which at 45 per 100,000 citizens has one of the world's highest murder rates – are, like Khumalo, black or mixed-heritage men, who self-refer as 'coloured', living in low-income areas. South Africa is also afflicted by one of the highest global rates of femicide.
[
Debunking Trump's claims: Is there any evidence of white genocide in South Africa?
]
After taking office in 2019, Ramaphosa vowed that violent crime would be 'halved, if not eliminated' in a decade, only for murder rates to rise since then.
Public anger with the ANC's broken promises, including its pledge to curb crime, led to the party losing its parliamentary majority in elections last year, the first time since white rule ended three decades ago.
Guy Lamb, a criminologist at Stellenbosch University, said the Trump administration's obsession with the killing of white farmers – who make up a sliver of overall murder victims – risked 'distracting' authorities from taking the steps needed to tackle the broader epidemic.
'It means that government has to devote political and financial resources to respond because of the hype ... rather than devoting that to, say, a black woman murdered and raped in a poor area,' he said.
Every year South Africans read the statistics that tell us 20,000 black men have been murdered and they shrug their shoulders
The crime crisis gripping South Africa traces its roots in part to apartheid, when the state wielded its might to brutally suppress the non-white population, with the murder rate peaking at around 70 per 100,000 as the government cracked down on pro-democracy movements.
The murder rate dropped to its lowest-ever level once democracy began in 1994, only to climb again from 2011 as the economy stagnated and rampant corruption weakened the state's capacity to respond. Today, just one in 10 perpetrators of serious crime are caught or convicted.
'Every year South Africans read the statistics that effectively tell us that 20,000 or so black men have been murdered and they shrug their shoulders,' said David Bruce, a consultant on police research at the city of Pretoria's Institute of Security Studies.
The long trail of bodies has become one of the biggest blots of Ramaphosa's tenure.
In his first term, the South African president was hampered by infighting within the ANC following the ousting of his predecessor Jacob Zuma, a former intelligence chief whose allies were deeply embedded in the criminal justice and state security apparatus.
Police, prosecutors and financial watchdogs were all weakened in the so-called capture and looting of the state that became South Africa's biggest-ever corruption scandal before Zuma resigned in 2018.
The Scorpions – a widely respected specialised unit that investigated and prosecuted serious crimes, including corruption and organised crime – was disbanded.
'If you cut off the knees of your most elite crime-fighting units because they were too effective at going after high-profile criminals and targets, that trickles down to lower levels,' said Ziyanda Stuurman, an analyst at Africa Practice, who is also a policing consultant.
Top officials in policing, the criminal justice system and National Prosecuting Authority have remained toothless following policy indecision under Ramaphosa. Illegally owned small arms have also proliferated.
A national crime prevention plan, aimed primarily at bringing down violent crime and gender-based violence, was drawn up in 2022, but 'there hasn't been budgetary or political impetus behind this plan', Lamb said.
[
Trump's evidence of South Africa 'white genocide' contains images from DR Congo
]
He said a failure to reform the apartheid-era police had exacerbated the problem. 'During the apartheid era policing was quite aggressive, focusing on poor areas and had a strong racial connotation,' he said. 'Those practices and strategies have continued into the current years.'
The ANC-led national unity government that was elected last year said 'strengthening law-enforcement agencies to address crime, corruption and gender-based violence' would be one of its priorities. The coalition's Democratic Alliance Party has since introduced a Bill to set up an anti-corruption commission to investigate and prosecute 'serious corruption and high-level organised crime'.
The issue of violent crime against white Afrikaner farmers in post-apartheid South Africa has become a flashpoint in part by tapping into similar narratives among the far right in the US.
In South Africa there were 32 murders on farms last year, including of black and white people, said the Transvaal Agricultural Union, a private agricultural group. The figure accounts for less than 0.1 per cent of the total homicides, with most of those killed in rural crimes black farm workers and security guards.
But analysts say the outsized focus on crimes against white farmers highlights more broadly the way in which the social contract is fraying between the state and its citizens, who feel their basic right to safety is under threat.
Afrikaner-rights lobbyists 'tap into the feeling of 'you are being targeted',' said Stuurman.
'They give a bogus reason,' she said. 'But if we're all feeling unsafe and distrustful of each other, then it's human nature to ... gravitate towards somebody who recognises that anger and vulnerability.'
For those whose lives have been blighted by violent crime, the sense of insecurity cuts across the board.
Khumalo, the Uber driver who was shot, has since stopped working and he barely leaves his house, fearful because he has not heard back from the police despite repeatedly following up.
'At the end of the day, black or white or whatever colour,' he said, 'as a South African you just want to be able to leave your home and return safely without worrying you're going to die.' – The Financial Times
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

The Irish Times view on handling Donald Trump: a lesson on how to respond
The Irish Times view on handling Donald Trump: a lesson on how to respond

Irish Times

time3 hours ago

  • Irish Times

The Irish Times view on handling Donald Trump: a lesson on how to respond

For Donald Trump, the truth, more often than not, is beside the point. So powerful is the US president, and so accustomed are his interlocutors to his casual relationship with facts, that he is rarely challenge as he makes his long and rambling public pronouncements. So it was refreshing to see Jerome Powell, the chair of the US central bank, the Federal Reserve Board, shake his head and publicly correct the record in real time as he stood alongside the president at an event on Thursday. The backdrop was a lengthy campaign by Trump to force the Fed to lower interest rates and his outspoken attempts to try to get Powell to quit. As part of this campaign, the administration has weaponised a renovation programme at the Fed, which it claims is running way over budget. Standing beside Powell in his hard hat, Trump theatrically produced a piece of paper which he said showed that the $2.7 billion bill was now set to be $3.1 billion. Powell calmly studied the note and pointed out that this included the cost of another building that was already completed. 'It's a building that's being built, ' Trump responded. 'No, it was built five years ago,' said Powell. The exchange underlined how seldom Trump's 'facts' are challenged in public by those around him. Everyone wants to humour the unpredictable president. The irony is complete when he publishes posts on his 'Truth Social' channel, a name which carries echoes of the Ministry of Truth in George Orwell's 1984. READ MORE World leaders face the same dilemma as Powell did when they stand beside Trump. Most choose to grin and bear it. This is what the EU appears to have done in trade talks with the US, as they face Trump's chaotic mixture of fact and fiction. As the talks come to another crunch – and with the need for support on the Ukraine war in the background – the EU may concede Trump's call for 15 per cent tariffs. When you lead the world's biggest economic and military power, sometimes you get to choose your own facts. A quiet-spoken bureaucrat just gave the world a lesson in how best to respond.

Trump and von der Leyen to meet in effort to land trade deal
Trump and von der Leyen to meet in effort to land trade deal

Irish Times

time6 hours ago

  • Irish Times

Trump and von der Leyen to meet in effort to land trade deal

European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen and United States President Donald Trump are to meet in Scotland on Sunday, in an effort to get a deal on tariffs over the line. The planned meeting followed a phone call between the head of the EU's executive and the US president, after several days of intense negotiations between officials to hammer out an agreement that would head off a trade war. 'We have agreed to meet in Scotland on Sunday to discuss transatlantic trade relations and how we can keep them strong,' Dr von der Leyen said in a post on X. EU negotiators have been pushing to finalise a deal that would avert higher rates of import duties which Mr Trump has threatened on goods coming from Europe. READ MORE Speaking before departing for a golf trip to Scotland, Mr Trump said there was a '50-50″ chance a deal would be agreed. 'I would say that we have a 50-50 chance, maybe less than that, but a 50-50 chance of making a deal with the EU,' Mr Trump told reporters on Friday. The US president said negotiators from both sides were working 'closely' together. 'I think the EU has got a pretty good chance of making a deal,' Mr Trump said. The current outline of a draft agreement would see the EU accept blanket tariffs of 15 per cent on future trade with the US, up from a 10 per cent levy Mr Trump introduced in early April. Speaking earlier on Friday, Taoiseach Micheál Martin said an EU-US tariff deal would 'hopefully be signed off before the weekend is over.' Work was continuing to get a 'framework agreement' over the line, which would comprise the broad outline of a tariff deal, allowing further details to be worked out later. [ What would a 15% tariff deal mean for Ireland? Opens in new window ] 'We're certain there will be detailed discussions afterwards in respect of line by line, in terms of many, many products. And so this will continue notwithstanding a framework agreement, [which] hopefully will be signed off before the weekend is over,' he said. 'Part of the reason for the intensity of those negotiations is to try and tie up as much as we can,' he said. The current outline of a draft agreement would see the EU accept blanket tariffs of 15 per cent on future trade with the US, up from a 10 per cent levy Mr Trump introduced in early April. How will the updated National Development Plan shape Ireland in years to come? Listen | 35:59 The European Commission, the EU's executive arm leading the negotiations, wants any future tariffs on pharmaceuticals to be capped at that level. The EU is also seeking to have higher 25 per cent tariffs the US has put on EU-made cars to be reduced to that rate. National governments appear willing to stomach an across-the-board tariff of 15 per cent, to end the uncertainty Mr Trump's threats of potentially much higher levies has caused the European economy, or an escalating trade war if no deal is agreed. 'There has been a degree of volatility in all of this, which has been unsettling for investment and that's a concern I have,' Mr Martin said. The EU wanted to secure some 'certainty' around US tariffs targeting specific sectors, outside of the blanket rate, he said. The EU was not anxious to have to turn to possible retaliation, such as counter-tariffs on US products, he said. Speaking in Luxembourg, the Fianna Fáil leader said he hoped 'sense will prevail' in the ongoing negotiations concerning pharmaceutical products. The sector has avoided US tariffs to date, though Mr Trump previously promised they are coming in a bid to force companies to relocate manufacturing capacity and jobs to the US. Getting a deal on pharma products was 'of equal significance' to the US side, he said. Any 'significant disruption' of the heavily intertwined pharma supply chains would be damaging to the US, and potentially lead to shortages of medicines, Mr Martin said. Access to the European market had been of huge benefit to US pharma multinationals, he said. 'It's a two-way street ... unilateral action on the part of one [side] could ultimately damage the companies themselves and patients and consumers,' he said. Europe had to look at what it could do to increase trade within the bloc, to compensate for the knock-on impact of US tariffs on transatlantic trade, he said.

Hopes for trade framework deal between EU and US this weekend
Hopes for trade framework deal between EU and US this weekend

Irish Examiner

time8 hours ago

  • Irish Examiner

Hopes for trade framework deal between EU and US this weekend

There is fresh hope that a trade framework agreement between the EU and the US will be reached over the weekend, Government sources have confirmed. It comes ahead of the tariff deadline on August 1, which could see Irish and EU goods entering the US hit with 30% tariffs. The original deadline of July 9 was extended by three weeks as US president Donald Trump also increased his proposed tariffs from 20% to 30%. Government sources told the Irish Examiner that there is an expectation, belief, and hope that a deal will be agreed between the US and the EU in the coming days. However, they also sounded a note of caution as they stated there was a 'flurry of activity' earlier this week after several news outlets in Europe reported that a deal was imminent, only for it to be rebuffed by White House officials. There were also suggestions earlier this month that a framework agreement was ready to be signed off, but this also never materialised. In Luxembourg, Taoiseach Micheál Martin told reporters that he was 'hopeful' a preliminary deal could be reached over the weekend. However, he also warned that it would be 'foolish' to bet on it. 'We're certain there will be detailed discussions... in terms of many, many products,' he said. 'This will continue notwithstanding a framework agreement, [which] hopefully will be signed off before the weekend is over. "Part of the reason for the intensity of those negotiations is to try and tie up as much as we can.' The Taoiseach also said there are 'intensive' conversations ongoing and that the EU does not want a 'retaliatory scenario'. On Thursday, EU members agreed to introduce €93bn worth of counter tariffs against the US if an agreement was not reached. The measures would take effect by August 7, but only if a deal is not struck. The package is a consolidation of two separate tariff packages — one in response to US steel and aluminium valued at €21bn, while the second was compiled earlier this summer. Tánaiste Simon Harris, who is also trade minister, said it was 'long past time for a deal'. 'While we were successful in removing some key Irish sensitivities following intensive consultation with the European Commission, this package of rebalancing measures, if implemented would have an adverse effect on European and Irish business,' he said. Read More Consumer sentiment slips in July amid concern over cost pressures and tariff threats, survey shows

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store