Indigenous 2SLGBTQ+ advocates brace for changes under Trump
Indigenous people who advocate for 2SLGBTQ+ communities are questioning how their rights may change under the Trump administration in the U.S.
In January, U.S. President Donald Trump signed an order that the United States will recognize only two sexes, male and female, that are unchangeable.
Alex Wilson from Opaskwayak Cree Nation in Manitoba, an activist for queer, transgender, and two-spirit rights, said she sees growing anti-transgender sentiments brewing south of the border.
"It's a cycle that happens when there's policy that allows for the continuation of violence or that kind of condones it, then we see people picking it up and acting out those behaviours," Wilson said.
"They're not acknowledging that there is a gender diversity or even sexual diversity. And we're seeing that trickle over here, too."
Wilson sees these policies as a danger to Indigenous sovereignty.
"It negates the reality that we have had many genders, not just two, three, but many understandings of gender and many sexualities in our nations since the beginning. And it's even part of some of our creation stories."
Montana bill ruled unconstitutional
David Herrera, co-founder and executive director of the Montana Two Spirit Society, is of Mestizo and adopted Blackfeet background and an advocate and educator for 2SLGBTQ+ communities.
In 2023, the Montana Two Spirit Society along with members of the transgender, intersex community filed a lawsuit in Missoula County District Court challenging Montana Senate Bill 458, which would define "male" and "female" as binary based on the presence of XY or XX chromosomes.
They argued it would infringe on the rights of members of the 2SLGBTQ+ community, as well as the cultural and spiritual importance of two-spirit people. Last month, the plaintiffs won and the bill was declared unconstitutional.
"It's definitely part of the colonization that has occurred and the attempt to erase the two-spirit culture," said Herrera.
He said policies like these are nothing new and have played a culturally detrimental part in colonial history that has tried to erase Indigenous 2SLGBTQ+ identities.
"We are not going to go away. We are going to continue," said Herrera.
Charlie Amáyá Scott grew up in the Navajo Nation and now works as an educator focusing on what it means to be queer, trans, and Indigenous.
"I think what I'm seeing within my community is that there is a lot of fear of what this really means in the long run," Scott said.
"There's a lot of fear of the violence that could occur, whether it's being detained at the borders, whether it's being questioned about who you really are or whether it's you're being arrested, which all of that specifically would lead to incarceration."
Her focus is ensuring that people and their stories are protected.
"If I'm being quite frank, my concern is about myself right now and has been about my community ensuring their survival. I have been really focused on ensuring that my trans siblings and my relatives, whether they're two-spirit or part of the LGBTQ community, survives," said Scott.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Vancouver Sun
6 hours ago
- Vancouver Sun
B.C. NDP has promises to keep, but no money to spend
VICTORIA — The New Democrats face increasing pressure to live up to their commitments on long-term care for seniors, child care for families, and safeguards for children in government care. The most recent push came this week from the B.C. seniors advocate, Dan Levitt. He warned that seniors on the waiting list for long-term care facilities are clogging hospital beds and ER waiting rooms. The number of seniors on waiting lists for publicly funded long term care has tripled under the NDP, from 2,381 the year before they took office to 7,212 currently, Levitt reported. A daily roundup of Opinion pieces from the Sun and beyond. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Informed Opinion will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. Premier David Eby defended the government's performance, saying the New Democrats had added 5,500 spaces since taking power. Yet Levitt provided a scorecard on NDP election promises. The party's 2020 election platform promised 3,315 new beds and replacements for 1,755 others. To date, it has only delivered a fraction, 380 net new beds in all. The advocate identified the current shortfall at 2,000 beds. Eby professed to welcome the findings and conceded, given an aging population, 'we have to build faster, we have to build more and we have to build it more affordably to meet the demand that's out there,' Earlier this summer, the Coalition of Child Care Advocates lamented B.C.'s faltering progress on $10-a-day child care, a key promise in NDP election platforms going back to 2017. 'In 2018, because of $10-a-day advocacy, B.C. became a national leader in child care,' said spokesperson Sharon Gregson in a June 24 news release. 'That progress has now stalled. With just three years remaining in the government's 10-year plan, the province has flatlined provincial child care funding in the last two budgets, with no new provincial funds committed to achieving the promise of quality, universal $10-a-day child care by 2028.' Joining Gregson in the call was former NDP MLA Katrina Chen, who served as the NDP's minister of state for child care under Premier John Horgan. 'We need to get child care back on track in B.C.,' she said. Three weeks later came a survey from the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives which found that B.C. had the most expensive child care in the country. Only 10 per cent of the province's licensed spaces met the $10-a-day standard promised by the NDP. Also in mid-July, the child and youth representative, Jennifer Charlesworth, provided a one-year update on the recommendations in Don't Look Away, her report on the horrific case ofYou saw there is a correction Colby. Colby is the name the representative gave to the 11-year-old Indigenous boy, tortured to death by the extended family members into whose care he was placed by the government. While acknowledging the province had made 'significant progress in some areas,' the representative said it still fell well short of where it needs to be in safeguarding children in care. 'We said in our report Colby's death was entirely preventable and without significant change future deaths are entirely predictable,' Charlesworth told Simi Sara on CKNW. 'Important changes have been made. But we are still in a very precarious state in child well-being and we've got a lot of work still to do before I can say with confidence that it's extremely unlikely that this kind of horrific situation would not happen again.' Charlesworth credited the New Democrats with good intentions in their response to the report. But she also flagged the main reason for the lack of sufficient progress on her recommendations. 'I am very concerned that with fiscal limitations, these good intentions will not translate into timely on the ground improvements,' the representative told Ashley Joannou of The Canadian Press. 'The government has a significant deficit, there are fiscal reviews underway, and what we worry — because we have seen it many times — that what gets cut are social programs.' One could readily adapt the same excuse for the NDP failure to deliver on child care, long-term care and any number of other programs and priorities. Premier David Eby referred this week to the 'fiscal challenges' facing his government, an understatement if ever there was one. The government is budgeting for an $11 billion deficit this year and shortfalls of $10 billion each of the next two years. Moreover, with the economy slowing and revenues faltering, the fiscal situation could get worse. In his time as premier, Eby has failed to manage the budget or set realistic priorities, instead spending as if there were no limit. Now, when he's run out of money, he faces the challenge of satisfying the expectations he and the New Democrats themselves have raised. In a column Friday on the LNG Canada terminal in Kitimat, I wrote that an LNG Canada spokesperson said 'a new facility of this size and scope may face operational setbacks.' The quote marks wrongly gave the impression of a direct quote from the company. Rather, it was a paraphrase from a story by the Reuters news agency. An LNG Canada spokesperson says the company told Reuters: 'A new facility of the size and complexity of LNG Canada requires a break-in period to stabilize, which is normal in new LNG facilities.' vpalmer@
9 hours ago
Preferential treatment for northerners key for trade zone between territories: N.W.T. premier
The N.W.T.'s premier says an eventual trade zone between Canada's three territories will ideally make sure northerners benefit from economic activity in the North. The three territorial premiers announced Tuesday that they had signed a memorandum of understanding to create a territorial trade zone. In a joint news release, Yukon Premier Mike Pemberton, N.W.T. Premier R.J. Simpson and Nunavut Premier P.J. Akeeagok said the memorandum — which is non-binding — would help improve both the economy across the North and labour mobility, and would include a shared credential registry so workers can move more freely between the territories. It was signed in Huntsville, Ont., last week when the premiers were attending a three-day meeting of the Council of the Federation (new window) . In an interview with CBC, Simpson said territory-and province-specific laws about goods and services are inefficient and costing our economy money. He added efforts to break down those barriers in the North have to be tempered by other considerations, though. What we don't want to do is drop all of our trade barriers and become, essentially, a colony for the South again, where companies from southern Canada would come up here, extract resources and then leave and not leave anything in the territory, he said. We want to be able to give preferential treatment to northern businesses to ensure that there's benefits for northerners when there is activity in the North. The agreement also allows the northern governments to co-ordinate efforts to lobby the federal government and the private sector for investment. Tuesday's news release mentioned that any agreement must respect land claims agreements and other deals governments have made with Indigenous nations and organizations, along with actively supporting Indigenous participation in the economy. CBC News has requested an interview with Pemberton, whose office first announced the deal on Monday. Akeeagok was not made available for an interview prior to publication. Cautious optimism among industry The deal is still in its early stages. Simpson said he doesn't expect N.W.T residents to see any immediate impacts from this, saying it's more of a longer-term vision. In Nunavut, Tony Rose, the executive director of the Baffin Regional Chamber of Commerce, said it's too soon to speculate on the potential impacts, but that the organization will be getting input from its members about the proposed trade zone. Enlarge image (new window) Tony Rose is the executive director of the Baffin Regional Chamber of Commerce. He says the memorandum allows them to communicate with the incoming Nunavut government to discuss the priorities of businesses in the territory. Photo: CBC / TJ Dhir This is a very interesting time for this to be happening, because there's a brand new government coming in the fall, Rose said, referencing Nunavut's upcoming territorial election. For us, this represents a really interesting opportunity to communicate with that incoming government to discuss the priorities of businesses, both within the Baffin region and throughout the rest of the territory. The Yukon will also be having a territorial election this fall. This theme of cautious optimism was echoed by at least two companies that have a major presence in the North. In respective statements, Agnico Eagle Mines said they welcome regulatory reform that can help streamline processes and support a stronger Canadian economy, while Northwestel said the trade zone is a positive step for private businesses operating across all three territories. Both of them added that they would be following any developments before commenting further. The memorandum comes amid national economic uncertainty, as the federal government continues to negotiate a new trade deal with the United States under the threat of more tariffs. The deadline before tariffs kick in automatically is this Friday. With files from Lawrence Nayally
CBC
16 hours ago
- CBC
Some Ontario 2SLGBTQ+ summer camps at risk of closing down as corporate donors withdraw funding
Social Sharing On the shores of Lake Huron, Harry Stewart and his husband Chris Southin sway back and forth in their rocking chairs on a wooden deck, watching dozens of youth play and laugh around them at Rainbow Camp. "People say that we're the two old guys from the balcony of the Muppet Show, and that is what it feels like," Stewart said. "It's so rewarding to see everything that you've worked so hard to make happen." Since 2012, the couple have been running a sleepaway summer camp in Thessalon, Ont., about 200 kilometres west of Sudbury, aimed at creating a safe space for 2SLGBTQ+ youth across Canada and the United States. But this year, they are grappling with a critical drop in funding while struggling to meet a surge in demand from youth hoping to attend the camp. Stewart said the camp has lost about 25 per cent of its funding this year. Many corporate donors with ties to the U.S. have withdrawn amid concerns that supporting a 2SLGBTQ+ organization would spark repercussions from President Donald Trump's administration, which has been targeting diversity, equity and inclusion programs. Those corporate donors previously sponsored camp fundraisers or youth for whom registration and transportation costs posed a barrier to attending camp, said Stewart. Even some Canadian companies, such as law firms with American clients, are now "very wary" of sponsoring the summer camp, he said. "They've stopped because they're being monitored on the whole DEI issue in the States," he said. "They realize they are being watched and screened." Rainbow Camp aiming to fundraise $100K this summer Demand for Rainbow Camp's 50 spots a week has never been higher, Stewart said, but the camp is at risk of closing if it does not reach its $100,000 fundraising goal this summer. Many campers looking to attend the summer refuge have faced extreme bullying and live in rural communities where they feel isolated or unsupported in embracing their identities, he said. "Especially around campfires, when you really start to hear some of the stories," Stewart said. "You get out the tissue paper because you're crying. It's just so sad to see how lonely these kids are." Camp Ten Oaks, a 2SLGBTQ+ summer camp run by the Ottawa-based organization Ten Oaks Project, said some donors have also pulled their support this year amid increased political tensions south of the border. "We've definitely seen some of our third-party fundraisers who have historically supported us in the past ... choose a different organization to support that maybe doesn't have specifically as queer of a mandate as our organization," said Kymani Montgomery, executive director of Ten Oaks Project. While the funding drop hasn't yet affected finances at Camp Ten Oaks, Montgomery said a surge in interest has forced them to put at least 100 kids on the wait list each year for the past three summers. If Rainbow Camp is forced to shut its doors, Montgomery said Camp Ten Oaks will likely see even more interest as families move from one camp to the other. With 2SLGBTQ+ camps being relatively scarce in Ontario, organizers said campers frequently travel from all over the province — and sometimes from across the country — to attend the camps. "That means there is going to be even more youth who aren't going to be able to experience the magic of a camp that is affirming for them," Montgomery said. Funding cuts are 'dispiriting,' advocate says While corporate funding withdrawals aren't affecting all 2SLGBTQ+ groups, advocates say the effects on summer camps are rippling across the community. Curran Stikuts, director of advocacy and strategic communications at Toronto-based community organization The 519, said it's "dispiriting" to see other 2SLGBTQ+ groups struggling to receive the funding they need to run youth programs. WATCH | Funding shortfall may require scaled back Toronto Pride in 2026: Pride Toronto links funding woes to Trump's anti-DEI agenda 2 months ago "We see the deep need for responses that are specifically tailored to the lived realities of 2SLGBTQ folks ... and anything that makes meeting that need more challenging is pretty unfortunate," he said. Alberta Sen. Kristopher Wells, a longtime advocate for 2SLGBTQ+ rights, said summer camps for 2SLGBTQ+ youth are "critical long-term investments" and consequences would be "devastating" if such spaces could no longer exist. "It's really short-sighted to see people wanting to cut funding, because we're going to be paying for it through the health-care system and downstream in our communities, as these young people grow up and have to overcome discrimination, prejudice and trauma," he said. Wells, who is also a co-founder of Camp fYrefly, a 2SLGBTQ+ sleepaway camp in Alberta that has been operating for over 20 years, said he's witnessed the "life changing" impacts of these summer camps first-hand. He said the 2SLGBTQ+ community tends to find its strength by looking inward for support, rather than relying on funding from outward groups such as corporate donors. "Twenty years ago, we weren't getting large amounts of corporate funding for our organizations," he said.
