Court awards R5.5million in damages after twin swop at birth
Image: Jacques Naude / Independent Newspapers
The consequences of a tragic incident more than 20 years ago, when two sets of twin girls were accidentally swapped at birth, unfolded in the Gauteng High Court, Pretoria, with the Gauteng MEC for Health ending up having to pay R5.5million in damages.
Judge Nomonde Mngqibisa-Thusi awarded damages to the biological mother of one set of twins - only identified as Mrs M, as well as to three of the other twins. The fourth twin did not form part of the litigation, brought on behalf of the plaintiffs by the law firm O Joubert Attorneys.
The four plaintiffs' claims follow a baby swap at the Heidelberg Hospital more than 20 years ago. Mrs M, a single mother, cared for what she thought were both her biological children, while another family, only identified as Mrs and Mr T, cared for what they believed were both their biological children.
One of each set of twins - which were separated at birth - were identical twins, but they grew up apart. The swap only came to light in 2018 after DNA testing was done, which concluded that each family had a child which was not their biological daughter.
This was discovered when one of the twins, who was still at school at the time, in 2016 saw another girl during a netball match with another school, which looked very similar to herself. Some of her teammates also became confused between the two.
The twin became suspicious and did some research on Facebook and later met the girl which turned out to be her identical twin. The DNA tests, which could only be done after the girls had turned 18, proved beyond a doubt that they were biological sisters.
Mrs M has since 2020 taken care of both the twins she raised, as well as her own, who grew up with the other family. It was said that the other family no longer wanted to take care of the twin which they thought was their own, when they discovered the truth.
It turned out that due to negligence on the part of hospital staff, Precious and Pretty were presented to Ms M as her daughters, and Mbali was presented to Mr and Mrs T as being their daughter.
Ms M and the three daughters now living with her are claiming damages for the trauma, pain, and suffering they had to endure since the discovery of the swap in 2018.
Ms M's claim included maintenance for raising a child all these years which was not her own. She is also claiming general damages for her suffering and pain. A psychologist also suggested that she, as in the case with the three twins, received long-term counselling.
It was said that the effect of living in the false belief that the parents who had raised them were not their biological parents had a devastating effect on the twins. Although three of the twins now live happily with Ms M, the court said the reality had a devastating effect on them.
It was also difficult for the twin who is the biological daughter of Mr and Mrs T, but grew up with Ms M, when the T-family did not want to have anything to do with her and were not interested in getting to know her. This was in huge contrast to Ms M, who did everything possible to get to know her biological daughter.
The court meanwhile granted R1.7-million in damages to Ms M and amounts varying from R1.3million to R1.8million to the three daughters.
zelda.venter@inl.co.za
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
13 hours ago
- The South African
New police minister warns against 'shoot to kill' tactics
Newly appointed Police Minister, Professor Firoz Cachalia, has warned against the abuse of police power and the use of deadly force, stating it could lead to tragic incidents like the Marikana massacre or the killing of Andries Tatane during a service delivery protest. Speaking shortly after his swearing-in at the Union Buildings in Pretoria on Friday, Cachalia rejected any 'shoot to kill' approach within the South African Police Service (SAPS). Cachalia, a constitutional law expert and former chair of the National Anti-Corruption Council, said he intends to serve with integrity and independence. 'I'm not driven by ambition or political ambition. I've been given a task, and I'm going to tackle that task without fear or favour, subject, of course, to the President's guidance as a member of Cabinet.' Cachalia faced political pressure and ongoing allegations of corruption within the SAPS but maintained a calm, resolute stance, saying external noise would not distract him. 'I understand the moment the country is in and the awesome weight of the responsibility I carry, along with others in government,' he added. Cachalia said a key part of his agenda would be addressing police conduct and reforming accountability systems. He intends to meet National Police Commissioner General Fannie Masemola on Thursday to discuss operational matters and existing task teams. 'It wouldn't be appropriate to speak before that discussion,' he said. As the outgoing chairperson of the National Anti-Corruption Council, whose term ends this month, Cachalia pledged to advance the council's recommendations in his new role. 'I'm now in a better position than I was as chairperson to take those recommendations forward, and I certainly will,' he said. He plans to bring the council and SAPS leadership together to align on reforms, particularly focusing on whistleblower protection and internal accountability mechanisms. Cachalia also plans to work closely with Justice Minister Ronald Lamola, stating that the fight against corruption must be a joint effort. 'The recommendations impact both of our portfolios,' he said. Cachalia addressed speculation about his status and confirmed, 'Today I was appointed minister, not acting.' Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
IOL News
15 hours ago
- IOL News
Court hears shocking testimony against Phoenix tavern owner in unrest trial
A warehouse in Durban was burnt and items looted during the July 2021 unrest. Image: Doctor Ngcobo / Independent Newspapers A State witness has identified a Phoenix tavern owner in video footage as the one who gave instructions to someone to put pallets on top of the July unrest victims who had been allegedly assaulted and placed next to their burnt taxi. The pallets were intended to aid in burning the victims alive. The witness pointed this out during re-examination at the Durban High Court on Friday. Four men, Ravine Naidoo, Trevor Gopal, Tyreece Govender, and Timothy Govender, are on trial for murder, two counts of attempted murder, public violence, and malicious property damage. Gopal, the owner of Tees Tavern, is also charged with incitement to commit public violence. During court proceedings, video footage introduced to the trial by the defence was played. The State witness, whose name cannot be revealed for security reasons, told the court that Gopal in the video was giving instructions. He stated that a man in a blue T-shirt, positioned on the ground floor, received instructions from Gopal, who was upstairs with others. He pointed out the man in a blue T-shirt, looking up at Gopal. After that, the man disappeared from the video footage and appeared again carrying pallets, which he placed on top of the victims, Njabulo Allen Dlamini, Nkosikhona Madlala, and Sandile Sambo. Next to the victims was the burnt taxi that they were driving. The three victims and two others had come in a taxi to Phoenix to buy from Gopal's tavern. According to the two males and one female who alighted from the taxi and went to the tavern, they came back running. They got into their taxi, which was bearing the logo Touch Africa. The witness said a lot of cars came at this stage, and Gopal's brother blocked the taxi, and its occupants were told to get out of it. He said one male and one female were able to run away, but the three others were caught by the crowd that was incited by Gopal to put the heat on black Africans coming to Phoenix. He reported that the victims were assaulted, with Tyreece and Timothy striking Dlamini on the head with a hammer and a rock. Dlamini later died due to blunt force head injuries. Before the witness gave the court this information, there had been numerous objections from the defence counsels, citing that the conduct of the State prosecutor, advocate Thabani Buthelezi, was unacceptable as he asked the witness leading questions. Gopal's counsel, advocate Jimmy Howse SC, said the State was given the video footage, but it did not use it. 'The State cannot ask questions that did not arise from the cross-examination,' Howse objected. He said the State was now seeking to lead evidence in re-examination, which is not allowed. The trial continues on Monday. [email protected]
IOL News
15 hours ago
- IOL News
Missing for 529 days: What's next in the Joshlin Smith investigation?
Western Cape police descended on Middelpos informal settlement in Saldanha Bay pursuing emerging information as part of the investigation into the disappearance of seven year old Joshlin Smith. Image: Supplied As police pursue leads in the Joshlin Smith case, the nation awaits potential sanctions against the State's star witness in two weeks. This follows searches conducted in the Middelpos informal settlement in Saldanha on July 25, based on untested information. Joshlin, now seven, disappeared on February 19, 2024, while living with her mother, two siblings, and her mother's boyfriend in a shack in Middelpos While police were tight-lipped on the new lead they were following, they assured the public that Joshlin's disappearance remained a priority in the Western Cape and that the investigation was never closed. 'SAPS teams led by detectives with K-9 members, search and rescue teams, and local police have been scouring an identified area in Saldanha Bay. Whether the ongoing search will yield any success remains to be seen. It is worth reiterating that police have an obligation to follow up and test all information that is brought to their attention,' police said. Jacquen Appollis, Steveno van Rhyn and Kelly Smith were sentenced in May. Image: Ayanda Ndamane/Independent Newspapers Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Next Stay Close ✕ Speaking to IOL, Candice van der Rheede, Director and founder of the Western Cape Missing Persons Unit (WCMPU) said this lead is not new. 'We told the investigating officer (the first officer, Sergeant Meyer Milstein Vredeburg Family Violence, Child Protection and Sexual Offences (FCS) Unit), that Kelly was looking for a portable toilet that week Joshlin went missing. We had a witness come forward, but instead, they treated our witness like a criminal. The witness worked at the site. Kelly asked him where the portable toilets were that had been removed,' she said. WCMPU has been pivotal when searching for missing persons across the Metro and has worked closely with authorities to solve cases. 'We told him, but he ignored it. Why would one be looking for a specific portable toilet?' van der Rheede asked. The shack Joshlin Smith and her two siblings lived in with mom Kelly Smith in Middelpos. Image: Robin-Lee Francke When IOL reached out to police regarding an update after their search, the provincial police spokesperson, Lieutenant Colonel Malcolm Pojie, said: 'There is no new development to report. Joshlin is still regarded as a missing person. All leads and information will be pursued'. During the landmark trial, the State relied on former accused turned state witness, Laurentia Lombaard's testimony to seal the deal. Lombaard admitted to originally being part of the conspiracy after she heard Kelly's plan to sell Joshlin for R20,000.
