Never mind what you heard — the BRICS summit failed before it began
The promising economic group — originally comprising Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa — has increased both its membership and its internal rivalries. And the leaders of Russia and China, the group's two superpowers, are not expected to attend this weekend's Summit in Rio de Janeiro.
China's authoritarian government is going through a rough patch, and I'm not talking about the Chinese real estate crisis, its lack of purchasing power, its high youth unemployment, low population growth or the economic slowdown that makes its recent 10 percent annual growth feel like a distant memory.
No, the new crisis is linked to a strange earthquake prompted by President Xi Jinping, who often disappears for several weeks at a time and announces the renewal of an anti-corruption fight to purge 'undisciplined' military personnel or eliminate potential political adversaries.
Gen. Miao Hua, vice admiral the People's Liberation Army, is one of the latest top officials to be purged by the political and military architecture of the Communist regime. Miao was a senior admiral and the director of the political work department of the Central Military Commission, which helps ensure loyalty within the armed forces. Xi's political maneuvers also affect generals and scientists in missiles, nuclear programs and aerospace.
China plays a divisive and discordant role in BRICS. Its ambition for greater power and promotion of its geopolitical strategy against the West has led it to double the number of BRICS members, regardless of factors such as economic strength, political stability or positive contributions to the group. In this pursuit, countries such as Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Egypt, Indonesia, Ethiopia and Iran have joined as new members.
China has also weakened BRICS through its rivalry with India. China maintains close political, military and commercial ties with Pakistan, India's main adversary. Added to this, a silent trade war has deepened, in which China hinders India's industry, generating tensions between two countries.
The other BRICS members are not exempt from challenges and confrontations. After President Trump's return to the White House, the so-called leadership of the Global South appears divided and defeated. In April, the BRICS Foreign Ministers' Summit failed to pass a joint resolution, unable to reach agreements to promote the integration of Brazil and South Africa as permanent members of the U.N. Security Council. The meeting was a bust.
The BRICS conflicts do not end there. Vladimir Putin cannot attend Rio in person because there is an international arrest warrant out for him for war crimes in Ukraine. Iran and Saudi Arabia are not necessarily best friends; Ethiopia and Egypt have a tense relationship over the Nile. And the list goes on.
The host country, Brazil, also has its own valley of shadows. President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva has lost international support due to his radical pro-Iran and pro-Russia stances. Domestically, polls show Lula with only 28 percent approval. The Brazilian economy is a disaster, with high interest rates that make credit more expensive, reduce consumption and slow growth.
Brazil seeks to promote the candidacy of a woman for U.N. Secretary General and, at the local level, Lula has expressed potential interest in a fourth presidential term to 'prevent the return of the right.'
BRICS has utterly failed to break the hegemony of the dollar, and the New Development Bank is a white elephant that lacks the resources or financial strength of Western, U.S.-backed institutions such as the World Bank or the International Monetary Fund.
The BRICS summit has already failed before its launch. Perhaps we can expect some agreements on artificial intelligence, the promotion of renewable energy and a general, watered-down call for dialogue and peace in the Middle East and Ukraine. But there won't be much more than that — it's just another brick in the wall.
Arturo McFields is an exiled journalist, former Nicaraguan ambassador to the Organization of American States, and a former member of the Norwegian Peace Corps. He is an alumnus of the National Defense University's Security and Defense Seminar and the Harvard Leadership course.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
11 minutes ago
- Yahoo
BRICS finance ministers make unified proposal for IMF reforms
By Lisandra Paraguassu RIO DE JANEIRO (Reuters) -Finance ministers from the BRICS group of developing nations called on Saturday for reform of the International Monetary Fund, including a new distribution of voting rights and an end to the tradition of European management at the helm. The joint statement by the group's finance ministers marks the first time the BRICS countries have agreed on a unified position on the proposed reforms. They agreed to back the shared proposal at an IMF review meeting coming up in December, which will discuss changes to a quota system that defines contributions and voting rights. "Quota realignment should reflect members' relative positions in the global economy, while protecting the quota shares of the poorest members," the ministers wrote in their statement after meetings in Rio de Janeiro, adding that the new formula should increase quotas for developing countries. The BRICS ministers called for a new formula weighted by economic output and purchasing power, considering the relative value of currencies, which should better represent low-income countries, said a Brazilian official who followed negotiations. The ministerial meetings came ahead of a leaders summit in Rio for the bloc that expanded last year beyond Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa to include Egypt, Ethiopia, Indonesia, Iran, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. That has added diplomatic clout to the group, which aims to speak for developing nations in the Global South, urging reforms of institutions long dominated by traditional Western powers. "With full respect to a merit-based selection process, regional representation must be enhanced for the IMF management, overcoming the anachronistic post-World War II gentlemen's agreement that is unfit for the current world order," the finance ministers wrote. Their statement also confirmed discussions to set up a new guarantee mechanism backed by the NDB, a multilateral bank funded by the BRICS, which aims to lower financing costs and boost investment in developing economies, as Reuters first reported on Thursday. Sign in to access your portfolio
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
For the first time, Xi is missing a China-backed BRICS summit. Why?
A summit of leaders from the BRICS group of major emerging economies kicks off in Brazil Sunday – but without the top leader of its most powerful member. For the first time in more than one decade of rule, Chinese leader Xi Jinping – who has made BRICS a centerpiece of his push to reshape the global balance of power – will not attend the annual leaders' gathering. Xi's absence from the two-day summit in Rio de Janeiro comes at a critical moment for BRICS, which owes its acronym to early members Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa, and since 2024 has expanded to include Egypt, the United Arab Emirates, Ethiopia, Indonesia and Iran. Some members are up against a July 9 deadline to negotiate US tariffs set to be imposed by US President Donald Trump, and all face the global economic uncertainty brought on by his upending of American trade relations – putting the club under more pressure show solidarity. Xi's absence means the Chinese leader is missing a key opportunity to showcase China as a stable alternative leader to the US. That's an image Beijing has long looked to project to the Global South, and one recently elevated by Trump's shift to an 'America First' policy and the US decision last month to join Israel in bombing Iranian nuclear facilities. But the Chinese leader's decision not to attend – sending his No. 2 official Li Qiang instead – doesn't mean Beijing has downgraded the significance it places on BRICS, observers say, or that it's less important to Beijing's bid to build out groups to counterbalance Western power. '(BRICS) is part and parcel of Beijing's effort to make sure it isn't hemmed in by the US allies,' said Chong Ja Ian, an associate professor at the National University of Singapore. But that pressure may have lessened with Trump in office, Chong added, referencing the US president's shake-up of relations even with key partners, and for Xi, BRICS may just not be 'his greatest priority' as he focuses on steering China's domestic economy. Beijing may also have low expectations for major breakthroughs at this year's summit, he said. Xi is not the only head of state expected to be absent in Rio. The Chinese leader's closest ally in the group, Russia's Vladimir Putin, will only attend via video link, for the same reason he also joined a 2023 BRICS gathering in South Africa remotely. Brazil, like South Africa, is a signatory to the International Criminal Court and so would be obligated to arrest Putin on a court charge alleging war crimes in Ukraine. The absence of two global heavy hitters leaves ample limelight for Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who will visit Brazil both for the summit and a state visit. South African President Cyril Ramaphosa is also expected to attend. Some new club members have yet to announce their plans, though Indonesia's Prabowo Subianto is expected in Rio after Southeast Asia's largest economy officially joined BRICS earlier this year. BRICS partner countries, including some who aspire to join the group, will also send delegations. Uncertainty remains over whether Saudi Arabia has accepted an invitation to become a full member. The sting of Xi's absence for Brazil's President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva may be blunted by the fact that the Chinese leader visited Brazil in November for the G20 summit and a state visit, when he and Lula inked a raft of cooperation agreements. The Brazilian leader also visited China in May, after attending a military parade in Moscow alongside Xi. That recent diplomacy, low expectations for major breakthroughs at this year's summit, and a heightened focus on domestic issues all likely factored into Xi's decision to send Li, a trusted second-in-command, observers say. China is facing steep economic challenges in the face of trade frictions with the US – and its leaders are busy charting a course for the five years ahead of a key political conclave expected this year. In Rio, Li will likely be charged with advancing priorities like shoring up energy ties between Beijing and BRICS' major oil-exporting members, while pushing for the expanded use of China's offshore and digital currency for trade within the group, according to Brian Wong, an assistant professor at the University of Hong Kong, who added that Xi's absence shouldn't be interpreted as a snub to BRICS. 'Whether it be the Sino-Russian partnership or Beijing's desire to project its purported leadership of the Global South, there is much in BRICS+ that resonates with Xi's foreign policy worldview,' said Wong, using a term for the extended group. Launched in 2009 as an economic coalition of Brazil, Russia, India and China before South Africa joined a year later, BRICS roughly positions itself as the Global South's answer to the Group of Seven (G7) major developed economies. It's taken on greater significance as countries have increasingly pushed for a 'multipolar world' where power is more distributed – and as Beijing and Moscow have looked to bolster their international clout alongside deepening tensions with the West. But BRICS' composition – a mix of countries with vastly different political and economic systems, and with occasional friction between each other – and its recent expansion have also drawn criticism as leaving the group too unwieldy to be effective. The disparate group's efforts to speak with one voice distinct from that of the West often become mired in opposing views. A statement last month expressed 'grave concern' over the military strikes against BRICS member Iran, but stopped short of specifically naming the US or Israel, the two countries that carried out the strikes. Nonetheless, the US will be watching how the countries talk about one issue that has typically united them: moving their trade and finance to national currencies – and away from the dollar. Such de-dollarization is particularly attractive to member countries such as Russia and Iran, which are heavily sanctioned by the US. Earlier this year, among the goals of Brazil's host term, Lula included 'increasing payment options' to reduce 'vulnerabilities and costs.' Russia last year pushed for the development of a unique cross-border payments system, when it hosted the club. What's unlikely to be on the negotiating table, however, is the lofty goal of a 'BRICS currency' – an idea suggested by Lula in 2023 that has drawn ire from Trump even as other BRICS leaders have not signaled it's a group priority. The US president in January threatened to place '100% tariffs' on 'seemingly hostile' BRICS countries if they supported a BRICS currency, or backed another currency to replace 'the mighty U.S. Dollar.' As countries convene in Rio, observers will be tracking how strident their leaders are in promoting the use of national currencies at a meeting of a group where China is the leading member, but US global economic clout still looms large.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Iran's supreme leader appears in public for first time since start of conflict with Israel
Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei attended a religious gathering on Saturday, according to Iranian state media outlet Press TV, the first time he has appeared in public in several weeks. Khamenei had not made a public appearance since his country was plunged into conflict on June 13, when Israel unilaterally bombed Iranian military and nuclear sites. The US later joined in, bombing three key Iranian nuclear sites before US President Donald Trump declared a ceasefire. In video posted by Press TV on X, Khamenei waves to a crowd of black-clad worshippers marking the eve of Ashura, when Shia Muslims commemorate and mourn the death of the Prophet Muhammad's grandson Husayn ibn Ali. The crowd greeted the cleric in turn with cheers and chants. Khamenei, the longest-ruling leader in the Middle East, reportedly spent the 12-day conflict with Israel and the US hiding in a bunker with little access to outside communications. During the conflict, both Israeli politicians and Trump openly discussed overthrowing Khamenei's government and deposing him by force. After reportedly rejecting an Israeli plan to kill Khamenei, Trump stated in late June that the cleric was an 'easy target.' Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu did not rule out targeting Khamenei either, saying that his death would 'not … escalate the conflict,' but rather 'end' it. In a recorded statement posted from an undisclosed location days after the ceasefire began, Khamenei was defiant, declaring victory over both Israel and the US. Khamenei took time to respond directly to US President Donald Trump, who had called for Iran's 'unconditional surrender' shortly before ordering US airstrikes. 'This (conflict) is not about our nuclear program,' Khamenei said. 'This is about Iran surrendering … in his statement, (Trump) revealed the truth, he showed his hand. The Americans have had a fundamental issue with Islamic Iran since our revolution.' 'And it will never happen,' Khamenei said of Trump's demand. Nonetheless, the conflict with Israel and the US has likely bruised Khamenei's reputation in Iran, analysts told CNN in June. Israel's initial strikes were unprecedented in their depth, killing some of the country's top military leadership on day one. 'The Islamic Republic had one social contract with society, which is that it deprived them of all freedoms … in return for providing security,' said Ali Vaez, director of the Iran Project at the International Crisis Group. 'Now, that image has been shattered in the eyes of the Iranian people.' Khamenei's new public appearance comes a day after Trump told reporters aboard Air Force One that the US won't allow Iran to restart its nuclear program. 'If they did start, there'd be a problem. We wouldn't allow that to happen,' Trump said Friday. Trump said he would discuss the previous strikes with Netanyahu, who is due to visit Washington on Monday. The comments echo remarks made earlier on Friday by Israel's defense minister, Israel Katz, who said his country must maintain 'aerial superiority' over Iran to ensure it cannot rebuild its nuclear or missile production programs. Trump reiterated his claim that Iran wants to meet with the US for talks, a statement Iranian officials have repeatedly denied. The Trump administration has discussed possibly helping Iran access as much as $30 billion to build a nuclear program for civilian energy production, easing sanctions, and freeing up billions of dollars in restricted Iranian funds – all part of an intensifying attempt to bring Tehran back to the negotiating table, four sources familiar with the matter said.
