Karen Read's defense rests its case in her retrial for the death of her police officer boyfriend
Judge Beverly Cannone indicated closing arguments will begin Friday, with jurors expected to begin deliberating thereafter.
Prosecutors have accused Read of hitting John O'Keefe with her SUV in January 2022 during a wintry night out drinking with friends – alleging she struck the off-duty officer while driving in reverse and left him to die outside a home in Canton, Massachusetts.
Read's defense has claimed she is the victim of a cover-up, alleging other off-duty law enforcement inside that home killed O'Keefe, placed his body on the lawn and conspired to frame her. But their case during the retrial – the first ended with a hung jury – appeared more focused on sowing doubt in jurors' minds about the quality of the investigation, rather than substantiating the theory of a third-party culprit.
Both sides have concentrated on the forensic evidence, with expert witnesses for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts and Read's defense offering conflicting theories about what caused O'Keefe's fatal injuries.
The Commonwealth presented testimony and evidence it said showed O'Keefe was hit by Read's vehicle around 12:30 a.m. on January 29, 2022, pointing to data taken from his phone and Read's SUV, as well as fragments of the vehicle's taillight found scattered across the scene. In prosecutors' telling, the collision threw O'Keefe to the cold ground, causing blunt force injuries to his head that left him incapacitated as the snowfall buried him.
Prosecutors also presented evidence suggesting the couple was at odds leading up to O'Keefe's death. That included text messages indicating they were fighting on January 28. In the hours after prosecutors say O'Keefe died, Read called him dozens of times, testimony showed, leaving eight scathing voicemails. 'F**k yourself,' Read said.
Read's attorneys challenged this theory: Their experts testified some of O'Keefe's injures – specifically cuts and scratches on his arm – were caused by a dog, and that the damage to Read's taillight was inconsistent with it striking a person.
The defense also worked to undermine confidence in the investigation, highlighting sexist and offensive text messages the lead investigator, Michael Proctor, sent about the defendant, which ultimately led to his dishonorable discharge from the Massachusetts State Police. Proctor, however, was never called to testify.
Read also chose not to take the stand. Throughout the prosecution's case, the Commonwealth played numerous clips taken from interviews Read provided news outlets and documentary film crews, using her own words to highlight inconsistencies in her account and refute the defense's arguments.
'I didn't think I hit him, hit him,' Read said in one clip taken from her October 2024 interview for NBC's 'Dateline.'
'But could I have clipped him? Could I have tagged him in the knee and incapacitated him? He didn't look mortally wounded as far as I could see,' Read said, 'but could I have done something that knocked him out and, in his drunkenness, and in the cold, (he) didn't come to again?'
Asked Tuesday if she would testify, Read confirmed she would not, nodding to the many clips played in court, according to CNN affiliate WCVB.
The jury, she said, has 'heard my interview clips. They've heard my voice. They've heard a lot of me.'
This story has been updated with additional information.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
a day ago
- CBS News
Massachusetts State Police trooper still in ICU 33 days after he was nearly killed in Revere hit-and-run
A Massachusetts State Police station commander is still in intensive care, more than a month after he was nearly killed in a hit-and-run outside of the Revere Barracks. Lieutenant Donald Bossi was struck by a stolen motorcycle in front of the barracks on Revere Beach Boulevard back on June 23. He was thrown 40 feet down the street. Investigators said 18-year-old Akram El Moukhtari of Revere hit Bossi, got off the motorcycle and ran away. He turned himself in to police later that night. Bossi was rushed to Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston in critical condition. El Moukhtari hid in court the next day as he pleaded not guilty to several charges at his arraignment. He's been held since then on $50,000 cash bail. He was brought back to court Friday to face an additional charge of illegal possession of ammunition, after police said they found 100 rounds of ammunition in his bedroom during a search after his arrest. During the arraignment, prosecutor John Verner had an update on Bossi's condition. "He suffered catastrophic injuries, 33 days and counting in the ICU with no end in sight, potentially two more months in the hospital. He's been battling infections, kidney problems, internal organ problems, his pelvis was broken. Just really, really bad injuries," Verner said Friday. "It's a miracle Lt. Bossi is still with us." The judge ordered $3,500 to be added to the original $50,000 cash bail, based on the new ammunition charge. "It's a bail that his family can't make," El Moukhtari's attorney said of the new $53,500 total. El Moukhtari's next hearing in the case is scheduled for August 22 via Zoom.
Boston Globe
2 days ago
- Boston Globe
I was a bar advocate for 27 years. Here's why I had to quit.
This hourly rate barely covers the necessary expenses of the job: office rent (required by the Commonwealth), legal research subscriptions, administrative help, printing costs, and malpractice insurance. On top of these expenses, I often need to buy clothes for clients to wear at trial and personally pay for transportation costs to drug treatment facilities. Advertisement I write personal checks to fund my clients' constitutional rights, draining my savings so poor defendants can compete against well-funded prosecutors. Seventeen years ago, I carried $20,000 in IRS debt — money borrowed from my future to fund support for my clients. My husband has since paid that debt so I could continue the calling that was destroying me financially. I eventually stopped taking District Court cases because I was losing money on each case. Superior Court cases paid more, but the stress was much higher. These weren't simple matters — they were complex felonies involving thousands of pages of discovery, expert witnesses, and lengthy investigations. The higher pay barely covered the massive increase in work needed for a proper defense. After nearly three decades in the industry, I walked away from my three-year contract in February with Suffolk Lawyers for Justice because the work had become financially impossible. A recent work stoppage by defense attorney has forced the dismissal of numerous criminal cases, undermining public safety and the administration of justice. Advertisement The financial burden is only part of the story. The work itself is gutting and causes a psychological toll. Bar advocates visit prisons several days a week, often meeting with allegedly dangerous and mentally ill clients. For example, I once sat in a large cell at MCI- Cedar Junction Walpole's Disciplinary Unit interviewing a client chained to the floor, his body so restricted by restraints he could barely move. I remember him struggling to adjust his eyeglasses while wrestling with all the chains around his body. Correctional officers flanked each side of the room, their presence a constant reminder of the power imbalance that defines every aspect of the criminal justice system. Massachusetts, the second highest cost-of-living state, according to Forbes, pays court-appointed defense attorneys $65 an hour. New Hampshire, which isn't in the top 10 most expensive places to live, pays its attorneys $125 an hour. Maine pays its attorneys $150 an hour. Why is there such a big difference? This isn't just about wanting more money. It's also about whether Massachusetts is serious about equal justice. When defense attorneys are forced to choose between paying their bills and properly defending their clients, the constitutional foundation of our justice system crumbles. The Sixth Amendment right to counsel becomes an empty promise. The Massachusetts Legislature can address this crisis by amending the proposed compensation language in the bar advocate compensation bill filed by Representative Christopher Markey of Dartmouth: raise rates for homicide cases to $155 an hour, Superior Court non-homicide cases to $120 an hour, and District Court cases to $100 an hour. This increase would help the state retain experienced attorneys and ensure constitutional rights remain more than empty promises. Advertisement After 27 years as a bar advocate, I can say with certainty: Justice isn't just blind — it's also broken. Until Massachusetts pays what constitutional rights actually cost, the state will continue watching experienced defense attorneys abandon poor clients, leaving our most vulnerable citizens with lawyers who can't properly defend them. The choice is simple: Fund real justice or accept that equal justice is just empty courthouse decoration.
Axios
2 days ago
- Axios
Richmond-area immigrants face ICE arrests at routine check-ins
ICE agents are increasingly showing up at Richmond-area courthouses and arresting immigrants at routine check-ins once considered safe, local immigration lawyers tell Axios. The big picture: ICE arrests at the Chesterfield courthouse have put a spotlight on the county in the past month, sparking concerns from some county leaders and conservative Sheriff Karl Leonard, who told WTVR it's straining efforts to build trust with immigrant communities. But it's not happening only in Chesterfield. Henrico's Commonwealth's Attorney Shannon Taylor told Axios there have been three instances since June where federal agents showed up at Henrico's courthouse. While Richmond's Commonwealth's Attorney Colette McEachin told Axios that ICE hasn't been spotted at city courthouses yet, "victims have expressed concerns about coming to court." McEachin also says defense attorneys have begun calling her office asking if there are any ICE agents "in or near Richmond's three courthouses." Zoom in: Then there are the arrests happening at routine check-ins in ICE's Midlothian field office — something Richmond-based immigration attorney Miriam Airington-Fisher says she hadn't seen before in her 16 years of practice. These required check-ins are scheduled appointments for people with pending immigration cases where officers confirm their address and that they haven't had any criminal charges. Airington-Fisher says even people with no criminal history who have "done everything right" are getting detained. She's now advising clients to not attend these check-ins without an attorney. ICE did not respond to Axios ' requests for comment. Threat level: Airington-Fisher says she's seeing people withdraw their immigration cases even though many are still getting approved. And a longtime free legal clinic in Richmond that her firm hosts monthly has seen a decline in attendance. Victims of crime could also be impacted if undocumented witnesses are too scared to testify in court, says Jessica Wright, a Richmond-based immigration attorney. Wright says fear of these arrests have also created a ripple effect where clients have questioned whether to pull their kids from school, quit their jobs or call local police when needed. What they're saying: "I have grown men shaking in their boots, asking me to escort them from their car, straight into the courtroom and stand by their side all the way back to their car," Wright says. "It's so demoralizing."
