Dorset incinerator opposers 'devastated' over High Court ruling
Campaigners have said they are "devastated" after losing a court case against the decision to build an incinerator near Dorset's Jurassic Coast World Heritage Site.The High Court has dismissed an appeal for a statutory review into Powerfuel Portland's £150m waste incinerator planning application, which was given the go-ahead by the government in September, despite initially being refused by Dorset Council.The decision comes after a two-day hearing in March.The Stop Portland Waste Incinerator (SPWI) group said taking the matter to the Court of Appeal was its "one final chance".
The group's request for a statutory review was upheld on the grounds the Secretary of State's decision "does not satisfy" Dorset Council's Waste Plan.But Debbie Tulett, who heads up the campaign, described news of the latest decision as "devastating"."I am very disappointed that the judge was unable to see that the planned waste incinerator does not comply with our county's waste plan," she said."We do have one final chance left on the legal challenge side of things and that is to try and get our case heard at the Court of Appeal."
Ms Tullett said she believed the majority of those who were opposed to the incinerator "would like us to fight to the bitter end".She said after "nearly six years of full-time fighting against the waste incinerator, I am not ready to throw in the towel yet".Olympic sailor and Portland resident Laura Baldwin, who is also campaigning against the plans, described the decision as "deeply upsetting"."It is clear that it is no longer a financially attractive investment with the upcoming inclusion in the emissions trading scheme making it very much more expensive to burn waste," she said.While Olympic champion Ellie Aldridge said "no-one will want to train" at the National Sailing Academy if an incinerator was built nearby.
'Vital to port'
The Environment Agency (EA) granted Powerfuel Portland an environmental permit for the incinerator in February after concluding it had met all of its necessary criteria.At the time Dorset Council leader Nick Ireland called the announcement "extremely disappointing".He said the incinerator would be "throwing out nitrous dioxide, sulphur dioxide, arsenic, nickel, chromium" into the atmosphere, below the top of the island and opposite the beach, and harm the area's tourism industry.But Powerfuel Portland said the facility would have the capacity to process up to 202,000 tonnes of waste per year and create enough energy to power about 30,000 homes.It said hazardous or clinical waste would not be burned.Portland Port previously said the power plant was "vital to this port's future" by allowing it to offer shore power to docked cruise ships.
You can follow BBC Dorset on Facebook, X, or Instagram.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
a day ago
- The Herald Scotland
Tributes to athlete and Black Watch officer who served in the Troubles
Died: April 9, 2025 Lt/Col Andrew Ogilvy-Wedderburn, who has died aged 72, had a distinguished career with the Black Watch, was an Olympic bobsledder, a marksman and an all-round athlete. He was a formidable officer, respected and admired by both fellow officers and the men he commanded. He served in Northern Ireland during the Troubles, was present at the hand-over of Hong Kong and was in charge of the British Contingent of the Tripartite Guard of Honour during President Reagan's visit to Berlin in 1987. Andrew John Alexander Ogilvy-Wedderburn was born in Fareham, Hampshire. His father, Sir John, the 6th baronet, served in the Royal Navy and his mother was Elizabeth Katharine Cox. He succeeded to the baronetcy in 1977 on the death of his father. The baronetcy is an ancient title which was created in 1704, but forfeited in 1746 when Sir John Wedderburn was accused of high treason for supporting Charles Edward Stuart and executed in London. It was restored in 1803 for Sir David Wedderburn, a noted Scottish Tory politician. Ogilvy-Wedderburn was brought up at naval bases where his father served principally in Malta and Helensburgh; then in 1960 the family moved to Perthshire. He attended Gordonstoun and, after Mons Officer Cadet Training Unit, he joined the Black Watch in 1971 on a Short Service Commission. He became a Regular in 1975 and saw service in Northen Ireland during some of the most fraught years of the Troubles. But his service and devotion to The Black Watch (the Royal Highland Regiment) saw no bounds. His career involved such important commissions as adjutant, company commander, chief of staff and ultimately commanding officer of 1st Battalion. He upheld the history and traditions of the regiment with real pride. He served in Derry during the protracted and bloodiest of the Troubles and was officer in charge of the British Contingent of the Tripartite Guard of Honour during President Reagan's visit to Berlin in 1987. The ceremony was the highly sensitive and diplomatic visit by the President: he concluded his speech dramatically, 'Mr Gorbachev, tear down this wall.' In 1995 Ogilvy-Wedderburn received the Queen's Commendation for Valuable Service. Read more Jim Prime, widely admired keyboard lynchpin of Deacon Blue | The Herald Sea captain who oversaw dramatic launches and rescues dies | The Herald Tributes to senior figure in fire service whose great love was piping | The Herald Lt/Col Tim Coles spoke warmly of his time in The Black Watch with Ogilvy-Wedderburn. 'I served with Andrew throughout our time in 'The Watch' which for me was since 1974 when we were platoon commanders. In Ireland we saw service mainly in West Belfast and County Downe. 'We had to be watchful everywhere and we were always on our guard. Andrew always looked out for other people and helped wherever and whenever he could. The Jocks and brother officers adored and admired him.' In 1993 Ogilvy-Wedderburn (Ogg Webb, as he was affectionately known in the Battalion and Oggy by fellow officers) was received at Clarence House by the late Queen Elizabeth The Queen Mother, Colonel-in-Chief, The Black Watch, upon becoming Commanding Officer of the Regiment. But Ogilvy-Wedderburn also pursued a remarkable career in sports. His excelled in bobsleigh trials and races at the highest level. His passion for the sport dated from the early Seventies when he travelled in an old van to compete in bobsleigh competitions in the Alps. He was in the team that won the British Bobsleigh Championship in 1976-77 and competed at the Winter Olympics at Innsbruck in 1976 and at Lake Placid, New York State, in 1980 when he crewed as brakeman. In his youth he had played rugby for Panmure and he was also a remarkable shot. Ogilvy-Wedderburn lead the 1st Battalion Black Watch Sniper Team which won the School of Infantry Shield at Bisley and won the Army Sniper Shield in 1979. In retirement he became a passionate gardener and a devoted environmentalist campaigning to preserve the wildlife of his beloved Perthshire. Lt/Col Tim Coles told The Herald, 'After retiring from active service, he was appointed director of the Scottish Army Benevolent Fund and later commander of recruiting in Scotland. Throughout his career he was absolutely loyal, disciplined and vigilant about procedures. Andrew was one hell of a man.' His duties on behalf of the Scottish Army Benevolent Fund were considerable and he devoted his energies to raising funds with his accustomed zeal. He travelled widely in Scotland but was particularly proud to accept a cheque from the local Ballumbie Primary School, Dundee for their efforts to raise funds for Help for Heroes. L/Col Sir Andrew Ogilvy-Wedderburn married first, in 1984, Gillian Adderley; the marriage was dissolved in 2014. He married, secondly, Fiona (Fi) Beaton, who survives him with a daughter and two sons from his first marriage. Another son died in infancy. His son Peter (born 1987) succeeds in the baronetcy. Alasdair Steven At The Herald, we carry obituaries of notable people from the worlds of business, politics, arts and sport but sometimes we miss people who have led extraordinary lives. That's where you come in. If you know someone who deserves an obituary, please consider telling us about their lives. Contact
BBC News
2 days ago
- BBC News
Portland incinerator: Campaigners welcome Court of Appeal hearing
Campaigners have said they are "delighted" after being granted permission to take their case against the decision to build an incinerator near Dorset's Jurassic Coast World Heritage Site to the Court of April, the High Court dismissed an appeal for a statutory review into Powerfuel Portland's £150m waste incinerator planning application was given the go-ahead by the government last September, despite initially being refused by Dorset Stop Portland Waste Incinerator (SPWI) group has argued the incinerator would cause air pollution and damage the local tourism industry. The incinerator is expected to be able to process up to 202,000 tonnes of household, commercial and skip waste a year, creating enough energy to power about 30,000 site for the incinerator is on land owned by Portland Port, which previously said the plant was "vital to this port's future" by allowing it to offer shore power to docked cruise applied for permission for a Court of Appeal hearing after the High Court failed to grant a statutory review of the campaign group has said the Secretary of State's decision "does not satisfy" Dorset Council's Waste Plan and did not properly apply local planning policy, which requires any waste incineration to be in the most appropriate Debbie Tulett said: "I am absolutely delighted that our argument that the Dorset Waste Plan has not been complied with has finally been recognised and I have been vindicated for pushing this point all the way to the Court of Appeal." Opponents of the scheme include Olympic champion Ellie Aldridge, who said "no-one will want to train" at the nearby National Sailing Academy if an incinerator was Council leader Nick Ireland has also previously said the incinerator would be "throwing out nitrous dioxide, sulphur dioxide, arsenic, nickel, chromium" into the atmosphere and harm the area's tourism Environment Agency granted Powerfuel Portland an environmental permit for the incinerator in February after concluding it had met all of its necessary waste management company has said the facility would not burn hazardous or clinical waste. You can follow BBC Dorset on Facebook, X, or Instagram.
Metro
3 days ago
- Metro
Spies, arrests and kissing Trump - meet the world's #1 Kim Jong Un impersonator
To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Being followed home, having his house raided, getting his hair cut weekly and being deported from Vietnam are all occupational hazards for Howard X. When Kim Jong Un first entered the scene in 2011, taking over the role of supreme leader of North Korea from his father, Howard immediately thought 'he looks a lot like me'. 'Other people started saying the same thing, and I thought I should do something with this,' Howard explained, and so in 2013, using a suit he already owned he took pictures of himself as Kim Jong Un pointing at various items in supermarkets. He uploaded them to a Facebook page, which exploded in popularity, and within two weeks he'd booked his first professional gig as an impersonator and was flown out to Tel Aviv Howard, who is in his mid-40s and originally from Hong Kong, had been interested in global politics, especially that of dictatorships like North Korea, for many years. Combined with his enjoyment of satire and comedy, the music producer realised that becoming a Kim Jong Un impersonator was his ideal job. Speaking to Metro, Howard said that while interest in his work fluctuates depending on current events, he can see himself continuing his activism for many years to come. 'Whenever Kim launches a missile, my phone is ringing off the hook,' he explained. 'But I don't wait around for him to do something. I've noticed that the best way for me to get work is to do my own projects. 'I've always been political, I've always gone to protests for various causes I believe in, and I found that this is a very useful tool to satirise dictators.' Howard spoke to Metro from The Hague where he protested outside the Nato summit venue earlier this week. Posing with an inflatable nuke with 'Europe, my troops are already in Ukraine. Where are yours?' written on the side, it's safe to say his political views are clear. Howard said: 'People enjoy my satirical take on world events, and being in The Hague with all the action happening here it's been good for my career – unfortunately.' But this has got him in trouble in the past. After taking part in the Umbrella Movement in Hong Kong in 2014 as Kim Jong Un, Howard's house was raided and he was arrested. Although the charges were dropped, he felt he had to leave Hong Kong for his own safety. From Donald Trump's inauguration to Olympic opening ceremonies, Howard has been all over the world to make a statement, but not everything has gone smoothly. He has previously been deported from Vietnam and detained in Singapore for his protests, and he says he was even followed and assaulted by North Korean agents. Thankfully, as he has Australian citizenship, he's been able to set up a secret base down under. In fact, the most bookings he's ever had came after he documented being kicked out of Vietnam. Howard explained: 'I knew my notoriety in the press would give me some protection, and even when the cops came in Hong Kong they said 'we're big fans, but our boss told us that we had to come'. 'I had to leave a life behind in Hong Kong, I miss getting some proper dim sum, but I have the privilege of being an Australian citizen, so I figured that since I have this privilege, I need to use it to speak up. 'We have two dictators now basically controlling the world, we've got Trump on one side and Xi Jinping on the other side, and everybody else is caught in the middle. 'I think for a lot of people who are not Trump supporters, they get sad and frustrated when every time they turn on their TV they see this idiot spouting his garbage. 'That's why I decided to satirise it, because the only way you can deal with that psychologically is to point out how ridiculous it is and make a joke out of it, which is extremely easy.' From Sacha Baron Cohen's The Dictator to political satire show Spitting Image, Howard has a wide variety of influences. He also rates Frank Sanazi, a comedian who impersonates Adolf Hitler singing the songs of Frank Sinatra. But how effective is satire at bringing about change? Howard argues it's vital. 'If I was just one protester with a sign, I would be ignored, it wouldn't have much of an impact, so I decided to use this impersonation to draw eyeballs to the cause of democracy, and it's very effective,' he explained. 'I think that's why dictators are so sensitive about it. All dictators fear being made fun of. 'A lot of protesters will be very angry, and a lot of people will get very turned off by that very aggressive way of protesting. 'If you're making a joke out of it, it's a gut reaction so people cannot look away, and the people you're making fun of, they feel they lose face. More Trending 'If you can make people laugh, it takes away the fear. 'I've even made supporters of China laugh, and as a protester and political activist, you not only want to get your side to be united but you want to change the minds of the supporters of the dictatorship, so I think it's very useful.' And if he was to ever come face to face with Kim Jong Un, he already knows what he'd say to the dictator. 'I'd say 'go kill yourself and make me the leader, I'll free your country',' he said. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: 'Epic' sci-fi series returns to streaming — and four more shows to binge in July MORE: We fear for the life of waterslide tourist who nearly soaked Kim Jong Un MORE: Favourite British comedian forced to cancel shows after saying he's quitting stand-up
