
An actor turns the tables on a brutal critic in ‘Bring the House Down'
'Bring the House Down' plays out during the Edinburgh Fringe, the annual arts festival that comprises a dizzying range of actors, musicians, comedians and artists. Runcie, who is British, spent years as a journalist reviewing shows at the Fringe, and she channels her experience of the event in general and cutthroat criticism in particular in her accomplished novel.
Alex Lyons, chief theater critic at a London newspaper, is a man of extremes who awards shows either five stars or, as is more often the case, one star. 'Anything in between was air.' At the Fringe, he writes a lacerating review of American performance artist Hayley Sinclair's first-ever one-woman show, 'Climate Emergence-She.' Later on, Alex meets Hayley at a bar and takes her back to his place for a one-night stand — while conveniently neglecting to mention his hatchet job, which has gone to press.
When Hayley reads the review the next morning and discovers the man she slept with is its author, she fights back. Retitling her show 'The Alex Lyons Experience,' and repurposing it into an excoriating character assassination of the unscrupulous critic, Hayley immediately has a hit on her hands. As her story goes viral, her show expands to spotlight the widespread harm Alex has caused as both a critic and a philanderer, and to examine new ways of calling out and stamping out misogyny in the arts. Alex's colleague — and Runcie's narrator — Sophie Rigden looks on in awe as Hayley captivates her audience. 'It was like watching Botticelli's Venus come to life as a hipster enchantress,' she observes. 'She was essential, elemental, primordial with commanding rage.'
While Hayley enjoys, and harnesses, her newfound fame, Alex crashes and burns. At one pivotal moment, it looks like it might be more than his career that goes up in smoke. Sophie tries to offer him support, but soon she is buckling under the weight of her own problems. Her workload multiplies when she takes over Alex's duties. Her emotional strain intensifies: She is mourning her mother, desperately missing her young son at home in London, wrestling with conflicting feelings for her previously unfaithful partner and weighing up the consequences of a drunken encounter. Can she regain control and come out on top like Hayley, or is she destined for disaster like Alex?
This is a smart, sharp and compulsively readable first novel that provides food for thought on a variety of complex topics. A less skilled writer would have adopted a strident tone and resorted to speechifying during the passages that engage with themes such as male power and privilege, or publicity, notoriety and cancel culture. However, Runcie strikes a perfect balance, and instead of tub-thumping or finger-pointing, explores each issue with nuance and evenhandedness. She is especially insightful on both the criticism of art and the art of criticism. 'Personal recommendation has been replaced with consensus,' Sophie muses. 'We rely on there being hundreds of people rating everything, a critical mass of approval.'
A novel isn't carried by its big ideas alone. It needs strong characters to convey them and react to them. Fortunately, Runcie's creations are forceful presences, all the more so because they are intriguingly multifaceted and resist cut-and-dried classification. Hayley is hell-bent on getting justice, yet there is more to her than a woman scorned or an avenging angel. Similarly, Alex has harsh judgments and selfish motives, and is given to 'tricking women into thinking he could give them what they wanted, only to maim them emotionally the moment they opened themselves up,' but he is no mere one-dimensional hate figure. Sandwiched between the two is Sophie, at once a 'sarcastic, sceptical, media-savvy hack girl with a flip answer to everything' and a sensitive young woman with divided loyalties who refuses to cast aspersions on either party.
All of which sounds serious and thought-provoking. This is only partly true, for the novel is also fun and frequently witty. The dialogue sparkles. Alex's mother, acclaimed actress and 'national treasure' Dame Judith Lyons, steals scenes. Throughout, Runcie showcases the giddy whirl of the Fringe with its lively crowds, wild parties and madcap acts ('Hamlet' performed on a bouncy castle, confessions to the 'Chill Pope' conducted in portable toilets).
Alex justifies his brutal takedowns by arguing that 'people like reading bad reviews.' They also like reading good books. 'Bring the House Down' is one such book: not a one-star flop but a five-star triumph.
Malcolm Forbes is a freelance writer whose work has appeared in the Economist, Financial Times, Wall Street Journal and New Republic.
By Charlotte Runcie
Doubleday. 304 pp. $28
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


New York Times
43 minutes ago
- New York Times
Laurie Metcalf to Star in ‘Little Bear Ridge Road' on Broadway
'Little Bear Ridge Road,' Samuel D. Hunter's acclaimed small-cast play about loneliness, compassion and a search for connection between an aunt and her nephew in rural Idaho, will come to Broadway this fall in a production starring Laurie Metcalf and Micah Stock. The production, directed by Joe Mantello ('Wicked'), will mark the return to Broadway of the producer Scott Rudin, who in 2021 paused his producing activities and resigned from the Broadway League amid reports of bullying behavior toward assistants and others. Rudin is producing the show with Barry Diller, the billionaire media mogul who has frequently backed his shows. The play is scheduled to begin previews Oct. 7 and to open Oct. 30 at the Booth Theater for an 18-week limited run. Hunter, the playwright, is best known for 'The Whale,' which was adapted into a 2022 film. He was raised in Idaho and many of his plays are set there and feature socially isolated working-class characters. This will be Hunter's first play staged on Broadway. 'My initial impulse for writing the play — which I told to Joe and Laurie, and I credit them that they still had faith in me after I said this — is that I wanted to write a play about people watching television,' Hunter said in a telephone interview. 'That was the platform for the play, but the play became this story of this aunt and this nephew who have almost no relationship, and a lot of painful history between them, hunkering down together during the pandemic, and both of them trying to figure out a path forward in a deeply complicated reality.' Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Prince Harry Won't Include Meghan Markle in His Efforts Towards Royal Reunion, Says ‘Source'
is reportedly planning to mend his tumultuous relationship with the royal family, but without his wife, , by his side. A source exclusively told RadarOnline that the Duke of Sussex is arranging a solo trip to the U.K. for the royal reunion. However, he has reportedly realized that he can only fix the fractured bond with his family members without involving Markle. The couple stepped down from royal duties in 2020 and have settled in California. Prince Harry and Meghan Markle's fallout with the royal family has been a topic of significant media coverage over the years. Amid the couple's strained relationship with the monarchy, the Duke of Sussex is reportedly looking to mend burned bridges with his family members. According to RadarOnline's exclusive report, he will not be involving Markle in it. Sources close to Prince Harry told the outlet that the years-long fallout has only left him sad and shocked. One insider claimed that he didn't expect the problems to 'drag' for so long. As per the source, the Duke of Sussex realized that involving his wife might only add fuel to the fire. The insider further claimed that although Prince Harry isn't happy about the situation, facing the royal family alone 'might be the only option for now.' The report suggested that he is open to video calls, mediation, or one-on-one conversations with the family members. The individual shared, 'He's finally realized that the way he handled things before hasn't brought any progress, and this marks a genuine shift in how he's trying to move forward.' Prince Harry's move to build a relationship with his family has reportedly been 'incredibly hard.' The source claimed that he cares about his wife but is also ready to accept the reality. According to the insider, if the duke has any hopes of reuniting with the royal family, 'he knows he has to try without her.' The decision also comes because the Duke of Sussex has been 'feeling totally lost' with his life in the U.S. The source expressed that he was living in a world that belonged to his wife, but not to him. Meanwhile, Markle is 'reluctant' to go to the U.K. but is supportive of her husband's decision to resolve issues on his own. The post Prince Harry Won't Include Meghan Markle in His Efforts Towards Royal Reunion, Says 'Source' appeared first on Reality Tea.


Forbes
an hour ago
- Forbes
A Promising Update On ‘Heads Of State 2' On Amazon Prime Video
Heads of State Amazon has found an original hit movie in the form of Heads of State, which isn't in theaters but airing on its streaming platform with an array of big-name stars. Heads of State stars John Cena, Idris Elba, Priyanka Chopra-Jones and Jack Quaid, as the UK prime minister (Elba) and US President (John Cena) join forces in a comedy action film that would make Harrison Ford blush in Air Force One with their combat prowess. Here's the synopsis: The film has performed well, planted at #1 on Amazon Prime Video, and naturally, conversation has turned toward a potential sequel. In an interview with Screenrant, director Ilya Naishuller (formerly of Hardcore Henry, an amazing overlooked action movie) talked about a sequel: 'If [people] watch the movie and enjoy it, and Amazon feels like it makes sense to do a second one, absolutely. I'd love to get more of Jack in there [and] more of Marty.' He really likes Jack Quaid: 'If it's not Heads of State 2, I will be bugging Jack to work together again,' the director said, 'because he comes in, he knows what he's doing, he's an incredible energy in terms of his positivity and the desire to not just be here and do a great job, but to go above and beyond.' Heads of State 2 How likely is this? The concept lends itself to more adventures, as does its clearly solid viewership. That said, this isn't a sure thing, and while a number of Amazon Prime Original sequels are in development, only a few have been released. Those would include Road House, The Tomorrow War and Red, White and Royal Blue, among others. So if Heads of State 2 is announced, expect it to be in development for a long while like these other films. Given the viewership and audience response, it would make sense for the film to get a sequel. But until that happens I would 1,000% recommend you watch Ilya Naishuller's Hardcore Henry which may lack star power, but is one of the most memorable, thrilling action films I've ever seen, and totally unique in the genre. Check it out. Follow me on Twitter, YouTube, Bluesky and Instagram. Pick up my sci-fi novels the Herokiller series and The Earthborn Trilogy