Why Ireland selectors got it wrong against Georgia
This is not the type of soft-serve, summer jaunt usually associated with summer development tours. Georgia are a grizzled outfit, packed with players hardened by exposure to the Top14 and ProD2 leagues in France.
In their last four outings, they beat Tonga at home, lost by three points to Italy away, pushed Australia all the way in Sydney and beat Japan away. Paul O'Connell. Pic: INPHO/Ben Brady
They are a team built around the traditional brute force of their forwards but in recent years they have unearthed genuinely exciting young backs – including the highly regarded Davit Niniashvili, who has just joined Ronan O'Gara's La Rochelle.
But perhaps the most dangerous aspect of the Georgian side that takes on Paul O'Connell's youthful Ireland outfit tomorrow is the sense of grievance they carry with them.
Their head coach Richard Cockerill has never been backwards about coming forward (going right back to his confrontation with All Black Norm Hewitt in 1997) and has been beating the drum loudly heading into this fixture. Davit Niniashvili is highly regarded. Pic: Alberto Gardin/EurasiaWhat Cockerill and Georgian rugby want is a seat at the top table and he believes they are being deliberately kept on the outside looking in because it does not suit the powers that be to allow these 'rough and ready' upstarts into the Six Nations at the expense of one of the established, and well heeled, existing residents.
Cockerill wants a play-off with the bottom side in the Six Nations and it is a fair call — the problem is the Six Nations blazers are not as keen and cannot appear to consider the prospect of travelling to Tbilisi instead of Rome, or of Wales dropping to the second tier.
The longer Georgia are excluded, the more they are at risk of losing their government's funding because winning the second tier Rugby Europe competition is not enough to keep the tap on. Cockerill will have his Georgians target Sam Prendergast. Pic: Seb Daly/Sportsfile
It gives Cockerill's side a hell of an incentive to beat a top-tier nation like Ireland and they are going to throw everything at it. On that basis, it is more than a little surprising that Sam Prendergast has been lobbed in to start. It has been a tumultuous season for the young Leinster man, some sublime attacking play counterbalanced by defensive howlers.
Cockerill will have his Georgians target Prendergast directly whereas Portugal will be far less physical next week.
Starting Jack Crowley at 10 against Georgia and protecting Prendergast would have been the more pragmatic move — unless the intention, two years out from the World Cup, is to try to improve his defence the hard way. Leinster flyer Tommy O'Brien will be desperate to make a statement after a strong season with his province. Pic:It is a bit of a gamble because if Prendergast gets run over by the Georgians, it will further dent his confidence.
Elsewhere, Ireland have named six debutants in their match-23 with Leinster flyer Tommy O'Brien desperate to make a statement after a strong season with his province.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The 42
3 hours ago
- The 42
'You don't coach someone for 10 years and not have a relationship with them'
JOE SCHMIDT IS wearing a green tie and as he discusses a win over Fiji in his precise, well-pronounced way, you'd nearly think you were back in 2018. Mention of the Lions brings you swiftly back into the media room at MacDonald Jones Stadium in Newcastle, a couple of hours north of Sydney. Schmidt's Wallabies have just squeezed their way to a 21-18 victory over an exciting Fijian team, a late try from captain Harry Wilson sparing the hosts from defeat in their first Test of the year and their only game before the Lions series. The former Ireland head coach is relieved and frustrated. He knows his side haven't played well but is keen to stress that Fiji deserve respect. Schmidt mentions that England only just beat the Fijians in quarter-finals of the 2023 World Cup, a tournament in which Eddie Jones' Australia lost to Fiji. Schmidt admits that it was 'inevitable to a degree' that his Wallabies players have been thinking about the three-Test series with the Lions that lies ahead. Well, now there are no distractions as he and his players hone in on the first clash in Brisbane in two weeks. Schmidt will be up against many familiar faces, with his former Ireland assistant Andy Farrell leading a Lions coaching staff that includes Schmidt's old defence coach Simon Easterby and his former on-pitch talisman Johnny Sexton. Schmidt has already coached against Farrell and Easterby, with some success. It was impossible to miss Schmidt's fingerprints all over New Zealand's 2023 World Cup quarter-final win over Ireland when he was an All Blacks assistant. Schmidt's Wallabies also gave Farrell's side a serious test last autumn in Dublin. But Sexton being in the opposition coaching box is a new one for Schmidt. 'I'm sure I will have a coffee with them at some stage,' he says. 'You don't coach someone [Sexton] for 10 years and not have a relationship with them and the same with coaching with Andy. It's one of the things I love about rugby. Joe Schmidt and Johnny Sexton in 2016. Billy Stickland / INPHO Billy Stickland / INPHO / INPHO 'I caught up with Mick Byrne [the Fiji head coach] on Friday and some of the coaches, and it was great. Their analyst was our analyst at the Blues in 2007 so there is so much overlap between people that are good people, and you enjoy their company and you know not to talk rugby anyway.' Yet Farrell and Schmidt have spoken about rugby in recent times. It's understood they agreed that the Lions and Wallabies would do their utmost to keep the media chat to rugby during this series. No one wants a repeat of the toxic vibes of 2021 in South Africa. What they do want is a genuine battle in this series. The Lions are viewed as favourites, largely due to the Wallabies still being in recovery mode after the disastrous Eddie Jones experiment. The Australians improved under Schmidt last year but they are ranked eighth in the world. Their performance today against Fiji will only add to the sense that this is a prime opportunity for the Lions. Schmidt knows that his men are underdogs. 'It's not really a mindset that we've have time to consider, but I'm sure externally it'll look like that,' he says. Advertisement 'We didn't play well enough today for people to have expectation that we'll come bowling into Brisbane and knock the Lions over. 'I'm not sure that expectation was there before today, and so we're going to have to build that quiet resolve and inch by inch we can work our way towards that.' Schmidt and the Wallabies will be watching closely tomorrow when the Lions name their team to face the Brumbies in Wednesday's warm-up game in Canberra. 'I'll be interested to see who plays against the Brumbies because I think shaking towards the Test match that will give us a little bit more prediction in terms of who's going to be where and that will give us an indication of what might best help us to put pressure on them,' says the New Zealander. Schmidt was disappointed at how his Wallabies side became loose against Fiji, as well as missing a few key opportunities to score tries and give themselves breathing room on the scoreboard. Schmidt before today's game in Newcastle. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo He was happy to report that out-half Noah Lolesio should be OK. The Wallabies playmaker was carted off in a neck brace after suffering a head injury in the second half against Fiji, but Schmidt believes he will be fine. The Wallabies are due to name their squad for the Lions series on Friday and it sounds like Lolesio will be part of it. 'Noah's first question he asked me was, 'Did we win?' He was still very much focused on the game and appeared to be in good shape,' says Schmidt. 'That's the first thing and the most important thing. 'I think it was whiplash and his head hit the ground, so I'm hopeful that that's going to be something that will resolve itself reasonably quickly. But at the same time, we're going to make sure that he's OK and we don't take any risks we don't need to there, which is the same as Dave Porecki who came off with an HIA.' Schmidt is also hopeful that lock Will Skelton, back row Rob Valetini, and scrum-half Jake Gordon – who weren't involved in the Fiji game due to injury – will be back for the first Lions Test. Skelton and Valetini's directness was missed against the Fijians, as was Gordon's calm and accurate play at number nine. The reality is that Schmidt knows he needs everyone fit and firing if he's to pull off a series victory over the Lions. Asked about his confidence levels, Schmidt says he just wants to make Australian people proud. 'I'm not a really confident sort of person. There's not real confidence but there's a quiet resolve. 'And that quiet resolve, hopefully over the three-match series can build to something that will earn us the support of a very interested group. It's a great opportunity for us to bring the game back to the focus point that we'd love it to be in Australia. 'We've loved our week in Newcastle. People have stopped us in the street, they've taken a real interest in the game, they've milled around the team hotel and encouraged players in passing. You saw the crowd there today. 'If that's a taste of what's to come, I know that was a small bite and there's some big mouthfuls to come.'
The 42
6 hours ago
- The 42
'As a player, you're not thinking about the crowd or furthering camogie, putting on a show'
THERE IS SO much to be positive about in camogie right now. Having Kilkenny and Tipperary facing off in a double-header involving hurling at Croke Park is a tantalising glimpse of an integrated future. Meanwhile, the game is played at an unprecedented pace and physicality that is showcasing the supreme skills of the players at a hitherto unprecedented level. This is attributable to the players' desire to maximise their potential but it would not be possible without elite mentorship and support services. Seeing Brian Dowling prove such a hit is welcome affirmation for the level of coaching available at inter-county level. It was Ann Downey – who else? – who co-opted the former Kilkenny hurler as coach, with succession in mind, having been impressed with what he had done with O'Loughlin Gaels. When he took over the reins in 2020, it was at a time when some big names called time on their stint in black and amber and the likes of current captain, Katie Power was injured. People wrote Stripeywomen off but they revel in making naysayers look stupid by the Nore. Dowling and a brains trust that included incumbent manager and coach, Tommy Shefflin and Pat O'Neill, introduced the likes of Katie Nolan, Mary O'Connell and Aoife Norris, with Aoife Doyle returning after period on the sidelines and Laura Murphy becoming more involved. They won the All-Ireland in that debut campaign, with a surreal final at an almost empty HQ in pandemic times. Two years later, there was more change. Murphy became firmly established along with the likes of the Fitzgerald sisters, Steffi and Tiffanie, and Michaela Kenneally. And the O'Duffy Cup made the trip to the Marble City once more. Dowling is now making waves as a hurling manager, after leading Kildare to the top tier after a stunning victory in the Joe McDonagh Cup. Murphy is a clubmate, who justified the faith placed in her with a series of excellent performances. Her stunning goal in the All-Ireland semi-final against Galway in 2022 will live long in the memory and having waited until she was 25 to become a regular, is now a totemic figure. Seeing Dowling flourish is a source of pride for her as a Gaels, Kilkenny and camogie player. Advertisement Former Kilkenny boss Brian Dowling is making waves with the Kildare hurlers. Bryan Keane / INPHO Bryan Keane / INPHO / INPHO 'It's actually incredible,' says Murphy. 'There was a lot of us up in Croke Park, we went in early to watch Kildare playing and to support Brian. We'd be very, very proud of him and his achievements, as I know he is when we're successful. 'What Brian did for Kilkenny camogie is incredible. He brought us, I think, to a new level, and to have someone of his standards involved with us, it does so much for camogie. And to see him go on then, and to have the success that he's had since, whether it is with St Kieran's (College) or Kildare, it does show you the calibre of person involved in camogie. 'It's the same with Tommy now, who was involved when Brian was there. He'd been involved with Ballyhale senior hurlers when they won All-Irelands. It's incredible to have people of that calibre involved. It can only bring the game forward.' For his part, Dowling told this writer before of his admiration for Murphy; her fastidious approach to preparation, complete dedication and commitment to self-improvement, living the emphasis on team over individual rather than just talking about it, and her complete absence of self-pity as she battled to break into the side. Such traits make her a natural mentor, and as the likes of the Walsh cousins, Miriam and Grace, and Julianne Malone retired this year, the Irish and history teacher at St Colmcille's Community School in Knocklyon, Co Dublin has progressed into a leadership role. The 28-year-old has even taken on freetaking duties, carrying on her form in that department as the Gaels won last year's county intermediate title, According to records maintained by @GaelicStatsman on X, Murphy was in the top ten scorers in the Glen Dimplex All-Ireland senior championship prior to yesterday's quarter-final between Waterford and Clare with 18 points, 13 from placed balls. 'There's a group of us around the same age, and we were lucky enough there was an older generation of players, the likes of Collete Dormer, Grace Walsh and Denise Gaule involved when we came in. 'That's how teams work. And that's just the evolution of it, where those girls move on, and people have to step up then. And I suppose that kind of happened gradually over the last number of years, and those leadership roles were there to be filled. There's a good core group of players now that were maybe fringe players a couple years ago, and that now stepped up to take on those leadership roles within the team. 'I would have been taking the frees at club level. We were lucky enough, we won the intermediate county final, so having a long run like that, hitting a good few of them, you'd be confident. And then when Aoife (Prendergast) was injured during the year, I was hitting him then for Kilkenny. 'But, again, look, it's hard to get into that role… when the likes of Denise Gaule and Anne Dalton were there, that was their job. And then Aoife filled Denise Gaule's boots but just when Aoife got injured, I started hitting a few.' Murphy was a part of the annual Hurling For Cancer match last year, a charity event organised by horse racing legends, Jim Bolger and Davy Russell, which has raised more than a €1.6m for cancer research and takes place this year on August 18 at Netwatch Dr Cullen Park. Sharing the pitch with hurling luminaries like TJ Reid, Tommy Walsh, Patrick Horgan, Tom Morrissey, Peter Duggan and Con O'Callaghan to name just a few, and being surrounded by legendary figures such as Brian Cody, Jimmy Barry Murphy, Cyril Farrell and Liam Griffin, as well as personalities from other sports such as Bernard Dunne, Willie Mullins, Sonia O'Sullivan, Rachael Blackmore and Shane Long was a wonderful experience, and all while raising huge money for a fantastic cause. 'It was brilliant. It's just such a nice thing to be a part of. It's a lovely occasion, and even meeting the rest of the people involved, the hurling players, but even people from different sports. It was great to be there and then to help raise money and awareness for the cause, it was great.' Murphy in action against Tipp last summer. James Lawlor / INPHO James Lawlor / INPHO / INPHO The vibe will be very different at Croke Park today. Kilkenny lost to Waterford in the first round of the group phase and also fell to Galway, but exacted revenge over a Dublin side that beat them at this quarter-final stage of the championship 12 months ago to cement their progression to the knockout stages. And it is border opposition lying in wait for the 2.30pm throw-in [live on RTÉ2]. With the hurling semi-final also on the programme, it has heightened the sense of anticipation. 'There's a real rivalry there with Tipp given they're our neighbours. When Limerick were beaten in the hurling, the possibility arose that it was going to be Kilkenny-Tipp in the semi-final. I think the last time they met was in the 2019 All-Ireland final. 'And it's brilliant for camogie that it's a double header with the same two teams. Hopefully there'll be a great crowd and people will come in for it and support the two camogie teams as well. 'As a player, you're not thinking about the crowd or about furthering camogie, putting on a show or anything like that. The whole year, your job on the day is trying to focus on getting over the line. You do need to separate those two things. 'But all of the work that goes into trying to promote the game, it's great to see something like this come together. And that the supporters will get to see the camogie and the hurling, not have to miss out on one. That's great for the families and for young girls especially.'
Irish Daily Mirror
6 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Cork stars share special moment with their kids after All-Ireland semi-final win
Cork's hurling heroes shared a special moment with their children on the Croke Park pitch after advancing to the All-Ireland Senior Hurling Championship on Saturday. The Rebels cruised past Dublin with a fantastic performance as they ran out winners by 7-26 to 2-21. They will face either Kilkenny or Tipperary in the final on Sunday, July 20. A number of the players' kids came on to the pitch following the full-time whistle to celebrate the victory with their fathers. Patrick Horgan shared an embrace with his son Jack, while Declan Dalton also celebrated with his son DJ. Despite the big winning margin, Cork manager Pat Ryan stated after the game that he believes his side can get even better. He said: 'We left a few scores behind us and are annoyed to have coughed up two soft goals. Yet we also got a lot right. 'I am delighted for the boys because 51 weeks ago we lost an All-Ireland final and it is a long way back from that. 'I am glad to have gotten back into the position we are in. It is a special place to be, in an All-Ireland final, looking forward to a big day out.' Irish Mirror sport Solus embed Ryan continued: 'I was very pleased with our attitude. Our preparation over the last four weeks has been excellent. 'There was a huge focus on what we wanted to do after the Munster final so I would like to pay credit to the players and to their spouses, girlfriends and families for giving the lads space to prepare in those four weeks. 'We will watch the Kilkenny-Tipp game with a lot of interest. We target goals all the time. The lads were really clinical in terms of goals. I am delighted with our fellas. They showed a lot of character to get themselves back into an All-Ireland final." Cork's Patrick Horgan celebrates with his son, Jack, after the game (Image: ©INPHO/Leah Scholes) 1 of 9 Cork's Declan Dalton celebrates with his son DJ (Image: ©INPHO/Ryan Byrne) 2 of 9 Cork's Patrick Horgan celebrates with his son, Jack, after the game (Image: ©INPHO/Leah Scholes) 3 of 9
