
Transgender murderer's criminal record ‘wiped clean' after he changed his name & started identifying as a woman
Alexandria Stewart was named Alan Baker when he was convicted of murdering of a man a decade ago - and is now serving time in a women's prison.
2
After transitioning and changing his name behind bars while serving a life sentence, disclosure checks show the 37-year-old no longer had a criminal record.
Police Scotland and the Crown Office are facing calls for an urgent review amid the major gaffe.
Campaigners have labelled the mishap a "dereliction of duty" by the authorities involved and demand to know how many others have been able to hide their convictions by changing gender.
It came to light after a solicitor requested a straightforward previous convictions disclosure from the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal's Service in relation to witnesses - all serving prisoners - involved in a case of alleged conflict inside HMP Greenock.
All such information on the lags was provided - apart from Stewart who's been able to distance himself from his past due to the name change.
Stewart was jailed for 19 years for knifing dad-of-two John Weir.
In 2016, it was revealed the prisoner was living as a woman and wearing a padded bra, make up and female wig.
It comes after the Supreme Court 's landmark ruling defining all people's sex by their biology.
Susan Smith, of For Women Scotland, said it is a "terrifying example of the sort of consequences which follow when people are allowed to lie about their sex".
Referring to the ruling, she added: "This was only picked up because of the obvious absurdity that an incarnated murderer had a clean rap sheet.
Moment gutted lag is arrested at prison gates as he LEAVES jail after drug-dealing from his cell
"But how many other former prisoners have been able to hide their criminal past in this way?
"We know that rapists and child sex offenders, who may have been released, have taken advantage of self-identification policies in prison.
"Women and parents will be horrified to learn that these men may, even now, be out in the community and taking advantage of their whitewashed record."
MSP Sharon Dowey, Scottish Conservative spokesperson for victims and community safety, has questioned whether Stewart's case is an "unacceptable blunder" or a more widespread issue.
She said: "We already have dangerous male offenders cynically gaming the system to serve their sentences in women's prisons, and that number is only likely to rise if they spot an opportunity of having their records wiped via this ruse.
"Scotland's justice system, like all our public bodies, has been in thrall to the SNP's reckless gender policy, which the Supreme Court has ruled unlawful.
"We urgently need a directive from John Swinney to public bodies telling them to uphold the Supreme Court ruling.
"The Alan Baker case represents a dereliction of duty by Police Scotland and the Crown Office.
"What has unfolded is not only deeply insulting to the victim's family, it lays bare again the stark reality of both the SNP's soft-touch justice agenda, which panders to criminals, and their unlawful gender self-ID policy."
A COPFS spokesman said: 'Although the initial witness check showed no previous convictions, on further inquiry by the Procurator Fiscal this was corrected prior to trial.'
The spokesman said talks would take place between both organisations.
A Police Scotland spokeswoman said: 'Work is ongoing to prevent something similar taking place.'
2
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Independent
27 minutes ago
- The Independent
Moment police snare suspects after £100k Apple device raid on phone shop
This is the moment police found a haul of Apple devices worth nearly £100,000 in the back seat of a car after masked raiders hit a phone shop in central London. Officers were called to reports of a burglary at the O2 store in Tottenham Court Road on 24 July, where a gang reportedly entered the shop wearing balaclavas and made off with around 100 iPhones and scores of Apple Watches. Three men aged 25, 24, and 18 were arrested on suspicion of aggravated burglary minutes later in nearby Cranleigh Street. A search on the car also uncovered a large machete. All three remain in custody.


The Guardian
27 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Devon and Cornwall crime commissioner sorry for multiple bodies claim
A police and crime commissioner has apologised for claiming that multiple human remains had been discovered in woodland in Cornwall at the centre of a murder investigation. Alison Hernandez told a meeting of the Devon and Cornwall police and crime panel that 'dead bodies' had been found at Sticker, near St Austell, and investigations were continuing to establish exactly how many. Devon and Cornwall police said in response that the body of one man had been recovered from woods and no other remains had been found. Police and forensic experts have been carrying out extensive inquiries in the woodland since the discovery of the body of 43-year-old Daniel Coleman. James Desborough, 39, is accused of murdering Coleman, from St Austell, between 2 June and 7 July. He is due back before Truro crown court next month. Hernandez said on Friday evening: 'In trying to be helpful I responded to an operational question at the police and crime panel, however, I was not fully up to date with the facts of the investigation. 'I apologise for any alarm this may have caused. The police have operational primacy over these matters.' Det Supt Jon Bancroft, with Devon and Cornwall police, said: 'We currently have three separate murder investigations being conducted in the Cornwall area. 'I have oversight of all of these investigations at this time, and can confirm they are being carried out independently of each other and are not believed to be linked. 'I can categorically state that we have recovered remains believed to be those of Daniel Coleman only from an area of woodland in Sticker.' Police are also investigating the discovery of the body of Lee Hockey, 50, who was found in separate woodland between Truro and Probus on 1 July. A third murder inquiry is under way after a fatal fire at a residential property in Newquay on 22 July. The body of a man in his 30s was found in the property, with a 33-year-old man arrested on suspicion of murder.


Daily Mail
27 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Police chief apologises for claiming multiple bodies had been found in a murder probe after two bodies were discovered within 10 miles of each other
A police and crime commissioner has apologised after claiming multiple bodies had been found in a murder probe after two bodies were discovered within 10 miles of each other. Two murder investigations were launched in Cornwall after two bodies were found in separate woodlands. Earlier this month, Daniel Coleman's remains were found in Paramoor Woods near the Cornish village of Sticker. Officers had been scouring the area for several months - aided by specialist teams from the National Crime Agency - when they found the 43-year-old's remains. Mr Coleman vanished last month from St Austell and is thought to have died between June 2 and July 7. A man has been charged with his murder. The body of Lee Hockey, 50, was also found in a nearby woodland between Truro and Probus on July 1. Alison Hernandez, Police and Crime Commissioner for Devon, Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly, previously told a panel several bodies were discovered as part of the investigation into Mr Coleman's death. 'We've found dead bodies in that wood,' Ms Hernandez said, adding that officers were trying to work out 'how many were there'. The Police and Crime Commissioner has since issued an apology after these claims were refuted by the local police force. Alison Hernandez, Police and Crime Commissioner for Devon, Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly, said: 'In trying to be helpful I responded to an operational question at the Police and Crime Panel today, however, I was not fully up to date with the facts of the investigation. I apologise for any alarm this may have caused. 'The police have operational primacy over these matters. Any investigation will unfold rapidly and I was not in possession of all the facts at that time.' Detective Superintendent Jon Bancroft previously confirmed Mr Hockey's death is being investigated separately. 'We currently have three separate murder investigations being conducted in the Cornwall area,' Mr Bancroft said, referring to a third inquiry which was launched after a fatal fire at a residential property in Newquay on July 22. He continued: 'I have oversight of all of these investigations at this time, and can confirm they are being carried out independently of each other and are not believed to be linked. 'I can categorically state that we have recovered remains believed to be those of Daniel Coleman only from an area of woodland in Sticker. No other remains have been located at this scene to date.' It comes after Ms Hernandez said it had been necessary to bring in extra support to aid the investigation. 'Some of the elements of that operation I can't speak about but some of the things are very obvious,' she said. 'As you know there is a large crime scene that has been identified in Cornwall that is requiring a lot of effort to even scene guard the area. 'The level of expertise, some of the mutual aid we've brought in, is expertise in specific types of investigations that we didn't have. 'The National Crime Agency is supporting the organisation at the moment. 'I want to thank all the other forces that are coming in at a very busy time for themselves to offer mutual aid. It's largely investigative mutual aid that we've brought in. 'Until some of those elements have been established of exactly what we're dealing with there, it will be made public at that time. 'I know there's been some information in the media. We've got a huge forensic tent down there.' Mr Coleman was reported missing on June 1. James Desborough, 39, of Lower Sticker, has been charged with his murder. Desborough has since appeared before Bodmin Magistrates' Court and was remanded in custody. He is due to appear before Truro Crown Court on August 8. When asked 10 days ago about 'multiple bodies' in the search area, Devon and Cornwall Police said they were working to recover Mr Coleman's body and that forensic investigations of the site related to him. The third murder inquiry follows a fatal fire at a residential property in Newquay on July 22. The body of a man in his 30s was found in the property and a 33-year-old man from Bolton was arrested on suspicion of murder.