History in making as World Court to advise on climate
It's a punchy slogan that has been wielded successfully by young campaigners to build global momentum behind a landmark international climate case first conceived by a group of Pacific-based law students.
While not legally binding, Wednesday's long-awaited "advisory opinion" from the International Court of Justice will clarify the responsibility of nations to prevent climate harm and redress damage inflicted from spewing out greenhouse gases.
Cynthia Houniuhi, one of the 27 law students from a Vanuatu university who hatched the idea to seek legal opinion from the World Court, has experienced first-hand the impacts of climate change on her Solomon Islands homelands.
The president of Pacific Islands Students Fighting Climate Change remembers returning to her father's home on Fanalei Island, where she observed a very different landscape than she had on previous visits.
Fewer houses, no children playing soccer on the sand and posts sticking out of the ocean, leftover from buildings otherwise consumed by the sea.
Pacific Island nations are particularly vulnerable to rising global temperatures.
Fiercer storms and cyclones are wreaking havoc, sea-level rise is threatening low-lying coastal villages, and weakened marine ecosystems are posing challenges for communities that rely on the ocean for food and income.
Rich countries are not immune, but small islands and low-lying developing countries' contribution to the problem has been far less, despite having to bear more of the costs and having fewer resources to adapt.
It's this injustice that has climate-vulnerable states pushing hard for faster emissions cuts as well as compensation for the loss and damage they have done little to create.
Ms Houniuhi is not expecting the World Court's advisory opinion to solve the climate crisis but says clarity around state obligations to act would make the law a stronger tool for holding governments to account.
She imagines a favourable result informing domestic climate legal activity, such as the case recently led by two Torres Strait Islanders, Uncle Pabai Pabai and Uncle Paul Kabai.
Australia's Federal Court ultimately rejected the case, determining the Commonwealth did not have a duty of care to protect their Torres Strait homelands from the impacts of climate change.
"The response from one of the uncles, it broke my heart," Ms Houniuhi tells AAP.
Getting the world's highest court to deliver an advisory opinion was no simple task for the global network of young climate campaigners, with a majority vote at the United Nations General Assembly required for it to proceed.
Vanuatu, a climate change-vulnerable South Pacific island nation of roughly 335,000, was the first to take up the cause.
From there, momentum built until a coalition of 132 nations unanimously adopted a resolution in 2023 to refer the case to the World Court.
Vanuatu's Minister for Climate Change Adaptation, Ralph Regenvanu, says such a display of state solidarity is significant and unlikely to be repeated ever again.
Mr Regenvanu, the first government official to listen to the young activists, is "very hopeful" for a strong outcome at the Peace Palace following favourable results in similar climate cases put to other top courts.
A good outcome, in his view, will clearly state that states have obligations under international law to prevent climate harm and to redress harm that's been done, as well as consequences for failing to act.
"There's a readily identifiable group of states who are the main offenders," he tells AAP.
"They're the ones who are going to bear the consequence of not fulfilling what, we hope, will be their legal duty to prevent climate harm."
The landmark case concludes ahead of the next round of international climate talks in November and Mr Regenvanu expects to use the advisory opinion to influence negotiations at the summit in Brazil.
Australia is still bidding to co-host the 2026 event alongside the Pacific and while Mr Regenvanu says the region's leaders remain committed, he was critical of some of the bigger nations' recent actions.
"Particularly the continuing rollout of new fossil fuel projects for the export market," he says.
University of Melbourne environmental law expert Jacqueline Peel says the World Court's stance on the science of climate change will be carefully watched.
"Particularly in the current context, where we have countries like the United States, for example, taking a very hostile view on climate science," she tells AAP.
Australia was among the 132 nations that co-sponsored the request for a World Court opinion but its submission took a "fairly narrow view" of its international obligations, centred around those already spelled out in the Paris Agreement.
Professor Peel says the advantage of Paris for big-emitting countries is that emission reduction targets and pacing are set by the nations themselves, rather than being subject to some broader international standard.
"Pacific countries would prefer that it's a broader approach that really emphasises the urgency of tackling the problems," she says.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
a day ago
- ABC News
Fiji's High Court finds nine men guilty in country's biggest drug bust
On the program this week: Fiji's High Court has found nine men guilty of various charges stemming from the country's biggest drug bust. Pacific countries spring into tsunami action plans following the massive eight point eight magnitude earthquake in Russia Tuvalu's Prime Minister visits Canberra following the first Tuvaluans being selected to migrate to Australia under the Falepili Migration Pathway Concerns around the skyrocketing rates of sexually transmitted diseases among PALM scheme workers Vanuatu marks 45 years of and celebrates the landmark advisory opinion passed down by the International Court of Justice.
Sky News AU
3 days ago
- Sky News AU
Firebrand politician Bob Katter reignites his war of words with Terri Irwin over his 'lazy' crocodile hunting push
Firebrand politician Bob Katter has reignited his war of words with Terri Irwin, the widowed wife of beloved Australian conservationist Steve Irwin, after she labelled his bid to legalise crocodile hunting 'lazy' and 'sloppy'. Dr Irwin, director of Australia Zoo, was among nearly 200 stakeholders who made submissions to the committee overseeing a controversial bill introduced by Katter's Australian Party to allow croc culling and egg harvesting to keep populations in check and make recreational waterways safer. 'The Crocodile Control and Conservation Bill 2025 will increase the probability of crocodile attacks on people and impact the overall health of Queensland waterways,' Dr Irwin said in her submission. 'More than sixty percent of the clauses in this Bill are exactly the same as previous versions. In fact, it is such a lazy and sloppy attempt to recycle old draft legislation that the Explanatory Notes refers to the Department of Environment and Heritage Protection – the department has not been called that since 2017.' Speaking to Sky News, Bob Katter vehemently defended criticisms from Dr Irwin and Australia Zoo. 'What the hell would they know about it? They live in Brisbane. All they know about is crocodiles in cages. They've never lived where the crocodiles are,' Mr Katter said. 'Even I don't want crocodiles in cages.' Sky News requested an interview with Dr Irwin but a reply has not been received. Mr Katter's Australian Party's bill, which proposes the establishment of a Cairns-based Queensland Crocodile Authority to oversee a permanent crocodile culling program, has been rejected by a parliamentary committee. The bill seeks to legislate licencing for crocodile farms and sanctuaries, safari-style hunting and egg harvesting as a means of controlling the reptiles' growing populations and making recreational waterways safer. But the Health, Environment and Innovation Committee overseeing the bill has recommended it not be passed. "The committee agrees that public safety should always be a paramount consideration but ultimately concluded that no amount of culling or management will ever fully erase the danger posed by crocodiles," the committee's report said. Mr Katter said growing crocodile populations and a geographical expansion of their habitat was the result of an 'imbalance' in Queensland waterways caused by a 1970s ban of crocodile culling and egg harvesting. Reintroducing the controversial practice would keep the populations in check and reduce the risks of attacks on humans, he said. 'Human beings took the eggs for 40,000 years. You've stopped the human being from taking the eggs,' he said. 'Not one single one of the 300,000 crocodiles in North Queensland has ever got shot. If I've got a crocodile on my cattle station, I'm not even allowed to remove them. 'They're territorial. The mother has 60 little crocodiles. Well, they got to find a home and all North Queensland is territorialised now, so all they can do is move south.' A suspected crocodile sighting in the Noosa River on the Sunshine Coast in July has reignited debate about crocodile management in Queensland. Images captured by local fisherman James Graham through a sonar fish-finder of a crocodile-like figure on the riverbed have gone viral and made national news headlines. 'If I was in my normal fishing spots, a couple of hundred meters north, that's what a croc looks like,' he said. 'The thought (of a crocodile in the Noosa River) is truly absurd.' Dr Ross Dwyer, crocodile expert with the University of the Sunshine Coast, said it would be possible for a crocodile to inhabit the Noosa River, but 'highly unlikely'. 'This would be the furthest south a crocodile has been spotted down here in over 100 years,' he said. 'During the 20th century, crocodiles were hunted so extensively they were pushed back in their range in Queensland, and what we're seeing is the crocodiles starting to expand back into that natural habitat again. 'The Noosa River could be good habitat if there wasn't all that built up area and the water was warmer. 'The crocodile population is expanding. The water is warming up and we are going to see more of them in these southern parts of the range. 'They do have an important role in these waterways and it's something that we need to be proud of in Australia.' Queensland Parks and Wildlife rangers shot a crocodile found in the Mary River near Maryborough in February. "(Shooting) is certainly one of the tools in the toolbox and we do employ it in situations where public safety (is affected by) the risk of the crocodile persisting in the area," a spokesman told the ABC.
The Advertiser
3 days ago
- The Advertiser
'These are distressing times': call for faster mining approvals following Dartbrook job cuts
New England MP Barnaby Joyce has called for the accelerated approval of Upper Hunter mining projects in order to offset the job losses at Dartbrook coal mine. Dartbrook, an underground thermal coal joint-venture by Australian Pacific Coal and Tetra Resources, went into external administration and receivership earlier this month after failing to meet its obligations for a $174 million loan to Singaporean commodities giant Vitol. The mine's receivers, FTI Consulting, terminated 104 miners or more than two-thirds of the workforce, earlier this week. It said in a statement making the mass terminations "wasn't an easy decision" but it was "necessary for Dartbrook's long-term future". Mr Joyce, whose New England electorate now incorporates Muswellbrook, said the job losses were not the result of a downturn in the coal industry. "Structurally, there's nothing wrong with it (Dartbrook), it's just carrying too much debt," Mr Joyce said. "People should not read the issues of Dartbrook as issues with the coal industry; the issues are with its internal financial management." "The guys who have lost their jobs shouldn't have lost their jobs because there's nothing fundamentally wrong with the market that they're in." He called on the state government to fast-track approvals for other mining projects in the region. "We have to make sure that the other mines in the area get their approvals," Mr Joyce said. "That's how we are going to absorb these jobs. There is absolute capacity in other precincts to absorb these jobs overnight. But if you are being forced to wait seven or eight years for approval, then unemployment is going to rise as people wait. "The Hunter Valley is the money bag for NSW, but if we take too long to open zippers, you are not going to have any money." In a statement, Muswellbrook Council said it was deeply concerned about how the job losses at Dartbrook Mine would affect workers, their families and the community. "Our thoughts are with those impacted, including local businesses owed significant amounts that compromise people's livelihoods. These are distressing times. The effects are felt by our whole community," the statement said. "Muswellbrook Shire Council's role is defined: to advocate for residents and workers in our Shire and ensure that decisions are transparent, accountable and prioritise our community. Council is pursuing every avenue to help those affected, directly and indirectly." The Mining and Energy Union (MEU) said it would fight for workers in the Fair Work Commission. Minutes from a creditors' meeting held earlier this month showed that at least 51 companies claimed they were owed money. The total debts exceed $202 million. The largest creditor was UK-based non-bank loan agency, Global Loan Agency Services (GLAS), which claimed it was owed more than $800 million. The mine restarted last year after being in care and maintenance for 17 years. The Independent Planning Commission approved an amended application to reopen the mine in 2019, despite community opposition. The conditions stipulated that the mine would have to use the Hunter Tunnel rather than transport coal by truck. It must also use existing processing infrastructure and cannot mine the Piercefield Seam to reduce groundwater impact. New England MP Barnaby Joyce has called for the accelerated approval of Upper Hunter mining projects in order to offset the job losses at Dartbrook coal mine. Dartbrook, an underground thermal coal joint-venture by Australian Pacific Coal and Tetra Resources, went into external administration and receivership earlier this month after failing to meet its obligations for a $174 million loan to Singaporean commodities giant Vitol. The mine's receivers, FTI Consulting, terminated 104 miners or more than two-thirds of the workforce, earlier this week. It said in a statement making the mass terminations "wasn't an easy decision" but it was "necessary for Dartbrook's long-term future". Mr Joyce, whose New England electorate now incorporates Muswellbrook, said the job losses were not the result of a downturn in the coal industry. "Structurally, there's nothing wrong with it (Dartbrook), it's just carrying too much debt," Mr Joyce said. "People should not read the issues of Dartbrook as issues with the coal industry; the issues are with its internal financial management." "The guys who have lost their jobs shouldn't have lost their jobs because there's nothing fundamentally wrong with the market that they're in." He called on the state government to fast-track approvals for other mining projects in the region. "We have to make sure that the other mines in the area get their approvals," Mr Joyce said. "That's how we are going to absorb these jobs. There is absolute capacity in other precincts to absorb these jobs overnight. But if you are being forced to wait seven or eight years for approval, then unemployment is going to rise as people wait. "The Hunter Valley is the money bag for NSW, but if we take too long to open zippers, you are not going to have any money." In a statement, Muswellbrook Council said it was deeply concerned about how the job losses at Dartbrook Mine would affect workers, their families and the community. "Our thoughts are with those impacted, including local businesses owed significant amounts that compromise people's livelihoods. These are distressing times. The effects are felt by our whole community," the statement said. "Muswellbrook Shire Council's role is defined: to advocate for residents and workers in our Shire and ensure that decisions are transparent, accountable and prioritise our community. Council is pursuing every avenue to help those affected, directly and indirectly." The Mining and Energy Union (MEU) said it would fight for workers in the Fair Work Commission. Minutes from a creditors' meeting held earlier this month showed that at least 51 companies claimed they were owed money. The total debts exceed $202 million. The largest creditor was UK-based non-bank loan agency, Global Loan Agency Services (GLAS), which claimed it was owed more than $800 million. The mine restarted last year after being in care and maintenance for 17 years. The Independent Planning Commission approved an amended application to reopen the mine in 2019, despite community opposition. The conditions stipulated that the mine would have to use the Hunter Tunnel rather than transport coal by truck. It must also use existing processing infrastructure and cannot mine the Piercefield Seam to reduce groundwater impact. New England MP Barnaby Joyce has called for the accelerated approval of Upper Hunter mining projects in order to offset the job losses at Dartbrook coal mine. Dartbrook, an underground thermal coal joint-venture by Australian Pacific Coal and Tetra Resources, went into external administration and receivership earlier this month after failing to meet its obligations for a $174 million loan to Singaporean commodities giant Vitol. The mine's receivers, FTI Consulting, terminated 104 miners or more than two-thirds of the workforce, earlier this week. It said in a statement making the mass terminations "wasn't an easy decision" but it was "necessary for Dartbrook's long-term future". Mr Joyce, whose New England electorate now incorporates Muswellbrook, said the job losses were not the result of a downturn in the coal industry. "Structurally, there's nothing wrong with it (Dartbrook), it's just carrying too much debt," Mr Joyce said. "People should not read the issues of Dartbrook as issues with the coal industry; the issues are with its internal financial management." "The guys who have lost their jobs shouldn't have lost their jobs because there's nothing fundamentally wrong with the market that they're in." He called on the state government to fast-track approvals for other mining projects in the region. "We have to make sure that the other mines in the area get their approvals," Mr Joyce said. "That's how we are going to absorb these jobs. There is absolute capacity in other precincts to absorb these jobs overnight. But if you are being forced to wait seven or eight years for approval, then unemployment is going to rise as people wait. "The Hunter Valley is the money bag for NSW, but if we take too long to open zippers, you are not going to have any money." In a statement, Muswellbrook Council said it was deeply concerned about how the job losses at Dartbrook Mine would affect workers, their families and the community. "Our thoughts are with those impacted, including local businesses owed significant amounts that compromise people's livelihoods. These are distressing times. The effects are felt by our whole community," the statement said. "Muswellbrook Shire Council's role is defined: to advocate for residents and workers in our Shire and ensure that decisions are transparent, accountable and prioritise our community. Council is pursuing every avenue to help those affected, directly and indirectly." The Mining and Energy Union (MEU) said it would fight for workers in the Fair Work Commission. Minutes from a creditors' meeting held earlier this month showed that at least 51 companies claimed they were owed money. The total debts exceed $202 million. The largest creditor was UK-based non-bank loan agency, Global Loan Agency Services (GLAS), which claimed it was owed more than $800 million. The mine restarted last year after being in care and maintenance for 17 years. The Independent Planning Commission approved an amended application to reopen the mine in 2019, despite community opposition. The conditions stipulated that the mine would have to use the Hunter Tunnel rather than transport coal by truck. It must also use existing processing infrastructure and cannot mine the Piercefield Seam to reduce groundwater impact. New England MP Barnaby Joyce has called for the accelerated approval of Upper Hunter mining projects in order to offset the job losses at Dartbrook coal mine. Dartbrook, an underground thermal coal joint-venture by Australian Pacific Coal and Tetra Resources, went into external administration and receivership earlier this month after failing to meet its obligations for a $174 million loan to Singaporean commodities giant Vitol. The mine's receivers, FTI Consulting, terminated 104 miners or more than two-thirds of the workforce, earlier this week. It said in a statement making the mass terminations "wasn't an easy decision" but it was "necessary for Dartbrook's long-term future". Mr Joyce, whose New England electorate now incorporates Muswellbrook, said the job losses were not the result of a downturn in the coal industry. "Structurally, there's nothing wrong with it (Dartbrook), it's just carrying too much debt," Mr Joyce said. "People should not read the issues of Dartbrook as issues with the coal industry; the issues are with its internal financial management." "The guys who have lost their jobs shouldn't have lost their jobs because there's nothing fundamentally wrong with the market that they're in." He called on the state government to fast-track approvals for other mining projects in the region. "We have to make sure that the other mines in the area get their approvals," Mr Joyce said. "That's how we are going to absorb these jobs. There is absolute capacity in other precincts to absorb these jobs overnight. But if you are being forced to wait seven or eight years for approval, then unemployment is going to rise as people wait. "The Hunter Valley is the money bag for NSW, but if we take too long to open zippers, you are not going to have any money." In a statement, Muswellbrook Council said it was deeply concerned about how the job losses at Dartbrook Mine would affect workers, their families and the community. "Our thoughts are with those impacted, including local businesses owed significant amounts that compromise people's livelihoods. These are distressing times. The effects are felt by our whole community," the statement said. "Muswellbrook Shire Council's role is defined: to advocate for residents and workers in our Shire and ensure that decisions are transparent, accountable and prioritise our community. Council is pursuing every avenue to help those affected, directly and indirectly." The Mining and Energy Union (MEU) said it would fight for workers in the Fair Work Commission. Minutes from a creditors' meeting held earlier this month showed that at least 51 companies claimed they were owed money. The total debts exceed $202 million. The largest creditor was UK-based non-bank loan agency, Global Loan Agency Services (GLAS), which claimed it was owed more than $800 million. The mine restarted last year after being in care and maintenance for 17 years. The Independent Planning Commission approved an amended application to reopen the mine in 2019, despite community opposition. The conditions stipulated that the mine would have to use the Hunter Tunnel rather than transport coal by truck. It must also use existing processing infrastructure and cannot mine the Piercefield Seam to reduce groundwater impact.
