Little evidence of success for schools' truancy fund, data analysis shows
Seventeen schools received funding from the scheme. (File photo)
Photo:
123RF
Data-matching found little evidence of success from a fund which gave schools $10-million a year
to tackle truancy
.
The then-Labour government set up the Regional Response Fund in mid-2022 as a four-year, $40m initiative to support school-driven initiatives to
deal with poor attendance
and the current government ended it in this year's Budget.
A Ministry of Education report on the fund said schools reported moderate and even high improvements in attendance from initiatives paid for with the extra money.
But it found little evidence of improved attendance when it used national student numbers to monitor changes in attendance among students targeted by the scheme at 17 schools.
"For the most part we see no real change in mean year on year attendance of the selected cohorts from before and after the RRF funding, or, where there is change, this change likely reflects the higher-level change in the national average.
"The one possible exception is one school cohort that may be worth continued review, as the data indicates that average attendance for the selected cohort has started to improve in 2024," the report said.
The 17 schools received amounts ranging from $1000 to $17,000 and used them for initiatives including a kapa haka attendance programme, 10-week attendance and engagement projects, and a walking bus and breakfast club.
However, the report also said the fund's support was short-term and schools said they needed long-term commitments to improve attendance.
"Short-term funding cycles created challenges in sustaining successful interventions," it said.
The report concluded the fund had improved attendance with 74 percent of schools that responded to a survey saying it had a high or very high benefit for participating students and 64 percent reporting increased attendance.
"Numerous reports from RRF recipients in the RRF survey responses have indicated positive outcomes and benefits to student engagement and attendance resulting from RRF initiatives.
"This was further evidenced through in-depth reports from case study participants," it said.
One group of schools said: "We have seen a huge shift in the engagement of our Pacifica learners - at the start of the year, 24.7 percent of our Pasifika learners were chronically absent, and now only 11.03 percent of our Pasifika learners are chronically absent".
The report said the accounts of positive outcomes were valid, but the ministry was "unable to validate the extent of increase to attendance rates against individual initiatives funded through the RRF and as a result cannot make judgements on attribution or causation".
The report said the fund was a high-trust programme aimed at supporting locally-led and responsive initiatives.
They included hiring staff to visit families at home, running community events to build a sense of school community, and paying for specialists like counsellors, social workesr and nurses.
Some schools used the funding to help familes find financial or social and health support, and to drive students to school.
In its first year, the fund supported 432 projects in 738 schools, and in its second year 450 projects in 842 schools.
The ministry's evaluation was undertaken in 2024 and covered projects run in the first two years of the fund.
The report said schools' initiatives were tackling "complex barriers" to school attendance and achievement such as disconnection from school and unmet wellbeing and learning support needs.
It said the fund's support was short-term so schools tended not to use the money for the most chronic truants.
"RRF recipients noted that they wanted to avoid letting vulnerable students and families down, because the RRF was short-term funding and could not support the kind of relational commitment that is required to address the underlying issues effectively," it said.
"Furthermore, funding recipients expressed that tackling chronic absence requires building relationships and trust over time, and sustained investment to allow for initiatives to embed and overcome any early implementation improvements."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Teenagers who gain work experience at school more likely to be employed by age 20
Gateway supported short-term, work-based placements while Trades Academies provided learning in trades-related. (File photo) Photo: Supplied/ UCOL Teenagers who gain trade and workplace experience at school are more likely to get a qualification and complete apprenticeships, a report finds. A Ministry of Education report said students who participated in the Gateway and Trades Academy programmes were also more likely to be in substantial employment by the age of 20 than other students with similar characteristics. The report considered the cohorts that participated in the programmes in 2014 and in 2018 and compared their education and employment outcomes with similar students who did not participate. It said Gateway was set up in 2001 and supported short-term, work-based placements while Trades Academies had provided learning in trades-related fields since 2010. "Both programmes increased the likelihood of students staying in education at age 17 and achieving a Level 2 or higher qualification by age 18. "These effects were consistent across genders and ethnic groups," the report said. "Men in both programmes were more likely to enrol in and complete apprenticeships, though rates remained lower for Māori and Pacific men. Women's apprenticeship participation remained low. "Both programmes reduced the likelihood of being in limited employment and increased students being in substantial employment, particularly for men. "Gateway had a stronger effect than Trades Academies in reducing limited employment for women, especially Māori and Pacific women." The report said 87-90 percent of Gateway and Trades Academy students had a level two qualification by the age of 18, compared with 78-79 percent for similar students who had done neither programme. It said 10-12 percent had completed an apprenticeship by age 24, compared with six percent for similar students. About a quarter of the group of similar students were in limited employment when they were 18, compared to 16-19 percent for the cohorts that had participated in the programmes. By age 20, 46-53 percent of the Trades Academy and Gateway cohorts were in substantial employment, compared with 35-38 percent for the group that had done neither programme. The report said the programmes appeared to have "a protective role for educational participation and achievement during the pandemic". Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
Ratepayers foot bill for rubbish dumped along South Wairarapa coast
The local council described the dumping as "enormously irresponsible and disappointing". Photo: Emily Ireland Ratepayers will foot the $145,000 bill to to remove 26 tonnes of illegally dumped rubbish along on the South Wairarapa Coast. Environmental Protection Authority, police and specialist contractors needed more than two weeks to clean up waste dumped along the coast, which included 3.7 tonnes of scrap metal - bikes, whiteware and even a car. The clean-up was an urgent recommendation from the Environmental Protection Authority. "The overall cost came in at approximately $145,000, which is about $50,000 less than originally forecast," said South Wairarapa District Council chief executive Janice Smith. Rubbish is removed from the South Wairarapa coastline. Photo: Supplied/SWDC Smith said people dumping this amount of rubbish was "enormously irresponsible and disappointing", as items like bikes and whiteware can be disposed of at transfer stations for no cost. The council said illegal dumping was a serious issue, as it could pose a serious health issue, when it contained harmful materials, such as glass, metal and hazardous matter. It said the clean-up process also ended up being expensive for both the council and ratepayers, and on the environment, with abandoned waste damaging ecosytems, polluting airways and harming wildlife. The site is now permanently blocked off, with security cameras in place to monitor it. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
17 hours ago
- RNZ News
Clutha council confident Mt Cooee Landfill won't run out of room
Mt Cooee Landfill. Photo: Facebook/Wasteco The Clutha District Council is confident a solution will be in place at a local landfill before it runs out of room. In February, the council reported the Mt Cooee Landfill area was critically close to capacity - it could need to stop accepting waste by August - and could cost an estimated $157,000 a month to ship waste elsewhere. Work has been underway to reduce, mitigate or eliminate that risk. That work included a 3D survey to figure out how much capacity was left and how long it would take to fill up and plans to build a general waste transfer pad so waste could be moved out of the district to another landfill until a decision was made about building a new landfill at Mt Cooee. The pad was expected to be finished by early September. "At this stage, council staff are working to define the detail designs required for the transfer station and then go out to tender for this urgent work," the council said. The council acknowledged it had not been smooth sailing as councillors expressed serious concern at the early advice. "Staff worked in the background on the risk and were successful in the various risk elimination measures," the council said. "Council is very confident that a solution will be in place before it is needed." The resource consent for the continued operation, expansion and progressive rehabilitation of the Mt Cooee Landfill was signed off by the Otago Regional Council in May. Work to enable an extension of the current landfill cell was nearly done, but existing cell had about 15 months of capacity left, the council said. The extension was expected to cost about $200,000. The total budget available for Mt Cooee upgrades was $7.1 million, which also included the transfer station and a possible resource centre. Building a new landfill cell was also a possible option. "Staff are intending to bring back to council a decision over the economics of operating Mt Cooee versus operating a transfer station as the long-term solution." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
