logo
The 100-year-old planning law that stopped this family building a home for their son

The 100-year-old planning law that stopped this family building a home for their son

When the Venkatesh Kumar family's application was debated at a meeting of the Cardinia Shire Council last week, councillors took less than 10 minutes to reject it unanimously. Councillors who spoke argued the covenant was an asset that protected the area from overdevelopment and excessive traffic.
Councillor Trudi Paton said changing the covenant to allow for a second dwelling on the property 'would cause harm both to the aesthetic character of the neighbourhood and to the property values of adjoining owners'.
She noted that while the application received just three objections, which would not normally meet the threshold for refusal, the covenant gave those objections more weight.
'I drove around the neighbourhood, I looked at this particular property, I saw all of the cream Colorbond fences that clearly marked that this was a special area,' Paton said.
'There was a unity to the style of dwellings and the spaces between them. So clearly most of the people who have bought into this area have bought it for the aesthetic and the benefits that it provides.'
A council officers' report noted objections were made on the basis that lifting the covenant would affect neighbourhood character, increase demand for on-street parking, lower property values, and involve the removal of habitat in the family's mostly treeless backyard.
Venkatesh Kumar Govinda Raju said he knew his home had a covenant when he bought it, but did not believe it was inviolable, given two other properties in the same estate have previously been subdivided and developed into multiple units.
He fears that his apprentice son and the son's partner will be priced out of Pakenham in their search for a home.
'There is a crisis in Melbourne, so I don't understand why the council is not giving me permission,' he said.
Loading
The council's general manager of community and planning services, Debbie Tyson, said numerous properties within the shire were subject to restrictive covenants, sometimes imposed through the planning process but often by developers and landowners under the Transfer of Land Act 1958.
Tyson said the two properties in the estate that have been subdivided were not subject to the covenant.
Planning reforms legislated in November 2023 to make it easier to build small second dwellings, or backyard 'granny flats' by removing the need for a planning permit did not include restrictive covenants.
'State and local governments do not create or enforce restrictive covenants. This is done by owners of the land who benefit from the covenant,' a government guide for home owners who want to build a small second dwelling states.
Loading
An Allan government spokesperson said the state's Planning and Environment Act – which sets the rules for housing development – was being rewritten this year to make it easier to build more homes, but did not address whether the reforms would seek to overturn Melbourne's many restrictive covenants.
'We know we need to make it easier to get more homes built across the state – that's exactly why we're completely rewriting the planning act, so good homes aren't blocked by red tape,' the spokesperson said.
'We're also reviewing how we can make it easier, faster and cheaper for Victorians to divide their blocks and build more homes.'
Townsend said it would be 'very easy' for the government to change the laws and make it easier for home owners to remove covenants when they modify the planning and environment act.
Venkatesh Kumar said he was considering appealing the council's refusal through the Supreme Court.
'It's going to be expensive, but not as expensive as, you know, buying land for $440,000,' he said. 'I've already spent $15,000 for the council to get the covenant removed. It didn't succeed, but I am a guy with hopes, I will be moving forward to my goal.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

BYD to start first car assembly in Pakistan by mid-2026
BYD to start first car assembly in Pakistan by mid-2026

Yahoo

time15 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

BYD to start first car assembly in Pakistan by mid-2026

China's BYD has announced plans to commence the assembly of its first electric car in Pakistan by July or August 2026, aiming to meet the increasing electric and plug-in hybrid vehicle demand in the region, a company executive said, according to Reuters. This development comes as part of BYD's strategic expansion in the Asia-Pacific market and follows the company's plan to initiate vehicle sales in Pakistan last year. Switch Auto Insurance and Save Today! Affordable Auto Insurance, Customized for You Great Rates and Award-Winning Service The Insurance Savings You Expect BYD Pakistan sales and strategy vice president, Danish Khaliq, revealed to Reuters that the new assembly plant, currently under construction since April near Karachi, represents a collaboration between BYD and Mega Motor Company, a subsidiary of Pakistani utility Hub Power. The facility is expected to have an initial production capacity of 25,000 units annually on a double shift schedule. However, he did not provide details on when the plant would reach full capacity or when mass production would start. Khaliq further explained that the plant would begin by assembling imported parts and locally producing non-electric components. The initial focus will be on supplying the domestic market, with the possibility of exporting to other right-hand drive countries in the region if it makes economic sense. BYD has already commenced delivering imported EVs in the country since March, with sales surpassing internal targets by 30%, although exact numbers were not disclosed. The market for EVs and plug-in hybrid cars in Pakistan is expected to grow significantly, with Khaliq anticipating a three to fourfold increase by 2025 from around 1,000 units last year. Khaliq noted that BYD is aiming for a 30-35% market share in this segment. According to a HUBCO filing, BYD Pakistan reported a profit of around PKR444m ($1.56m) in the March quarter of this year. The Pakistani market is set to welcome the upcoming launch of BYD's Shark 6 plug-in hybrid pickup truck. The Pakistani government is promoting EV adoption by reducing power tariffs for chargers by 45% in January and encouraging the establishment of private charging stations, addressing the current lack of infrastructure for all-electric vehicles. "BYD to start first car assembly in Pakistan by mid-2026 – report" was originally created and published by Just Auto, a GlobalData owned brand. The information on this site has been included in good faith for general informational purposes only. It is not intended to amount to advice on which you should rely, and we give no representation, warranty or guarantee, whether express or implied as to its accuracy or completeness. You must obtain professional or specialist advice before taking, or refraining from, any action on the basis of the content on our site. Sign in to access your portfolio

Caitlin Clark still has no timetable for return following further medical evaluation this week
Caitlin Clark still has no timetable for return following further medical evaluation this week

Yahoo

time15 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Caitlin Clark still has no timetable for return following further medical evaluation this week

INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Indiana Fever guard Caitlin Clark still has no time table to return, the team said Thursday following further medical tests this week. No further injuries were discovered during this week's evaluations. Clark has missed three games — including last weekend's WNBA All-Star Game in Indianapolis — since injuring her right groin July 15 against the Connecticut Sun. She traveled with her team to New York for their loss to the Liberty on Tuesday night. The Fever said Clark is continuing to work with team medical staff on her recovery and rehabilitation. Clark's current injury is the latest in a string of difficulties for the Fever star, which has included a left groin injury and a left quad strain earlier in the season. ___ AP WNBA:

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store