logo
The 100-year-old planning law that stopped this family building a home for their son

The 100-year-old planning law that stopped this family building a home for their son

When the Venkatesh Kumar family's application was debated at a meeting of the Cardinia Shire Council last week, councillors took less than 10 minutes to reject it unanimously. Councillors who spoke argued the covenant was an asset that protected the area from overdevelopment and excessive traffic.
Councillor Trudi Paton said changing the covenant to allow for a second dwelling on the property 'would cause harm both to the aesthetic character of the neighbourhood and to the property values of adjoining owners'.
She noted that while the application received just three objections, which would not normally meet the threshold for refusal, the covenant gave those objections more weight.
'I drove around the neighbourhood, I looked at this particular property, I saw all of the cream Colorbond fences that clearly marked that this was a special area,' Paton said.
'There was a unity to the style of dwellings and the spaces between them. So clearly most of the people who have bought into this area have bought it for the aesthetic and the benefits that it provides.'
A council officers' report noted objections were made on the basis that lifting the covenant would affect neighbourhood character, increase demand for on-street parking, lower property values, and involve the removal of habitat in the family's mostly treeless backyard.
Venkatesh Kumar Govinda Raju said he knew his home had a covenant when he bought it, but did not believe it was inviolable, given two other properties in the same estate have previously been subdivided and developed into multiple units.
He fears that his apprentice son and the son's partner will be priced out of Pakenham in their search for a home.
'There is a crisis in Melbourne, so I don't understand why the council is not giving me permission,' he said.
Loading
The council's general manager of community and planning services, Debbie Tyson, said numerous properties within the shire were subject to restrictive covenants, sometimes imposed through the planning process but often by developers and landowners under the Transfer of Land Act 1958.
Tyson said the two properties in the estate that have been subdivided were not subject to the covenant.
Planning reforms legislated in November 2023 to make it easier to build small second dwellings, or backyard 'granny flats' by removing the need for a planning permit did not include restrictive covenants.
'State and local governments do not create or enforce restrictive covenants. This is done by owners of the land who benefit from the covenant,' a government guide for home owners who want to build a small second dwelling states.
Loading
An Allan government spokesperson said the state's Planning and Environment Act – which sets the rules for housing development – was being rewritten this year to make it easier to build more homes, but did not address whether the reforms would seek to overturn Melbourne's many restrictive covenants.
'We know we need to make it easier to get more homes built across the state – that's exactly why we're completely rewriting the planning act, so good homes aren't blocked by red tape,' the spokesperson said.
'We're also reviewing how we can make it easier, faster and cheaper for Victorians to divide their blocks and build more homes.'
Townsend said it would be 'very easy' for the government to change the laws and make it easier for home owners to remove covenants when they modify the planning and environment act.
Venkatesh Kumar said he was considering appealing the council's refusal through the Supreme Court.
'It's going to be expensive, but not as expensive as, you know, buying land for $440,000,' he said. 'I've already spent $15,000 for the council to get the covenant removed. It didn't succeed, but I am a guy with hopes, I will be moving forward to my goal.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

South Padre Island Board of REALTORS® Partners with iHomefinder to Equip Agents for the Future of Real Estate
South Padre Island Board of REALTORS® Partners with iHomefinder to Equip Agents for the Future of Real Estate

Yahoo

time3 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

South Padre Island Board of REALTORS® Partners with iHomefinder to Equip Agents for the Future of Real Estate

New Member Benefit Brings Industry-Leading Tools for Visibility, Lead Generation, and Long-Term Growth EUGENE, Ore., July 25, 2025 /PRNewswire/ -- The South Padre Island Board of REALTORS® (SPIBOR) today announced a new partnership with iHomefinder, the leading provider of real estate growth technology designed to help agents thrive in an increasingly competitive and fast-evolving market. This partnership gives SPIBOR members exclusive access and preferred pricing on iHomefinder's complete platform providing smart lead generation, marketing automation, and a proven system for building long-term pipeline in a market where visibility is no longer optional. "We've seen the real estate landscape change dramatically in recent years," said Lindsey Martinez, Association Executive at SPIBOR "Buyers and sellers aren't waiting to raise their hand—they're starting their journey earlier and online. This partnership ensures our members have the modern tools they need to stay visible and grow in this new environment." A New Way to Stay Visible—and Win in a Changing Market This partnership comes as iHomefinder sharpens its positioning around solving what it calls the "lead deficit"—a widespread issue where agents rely on moment-of-intent lead capture and miss out on the 95% of buyers and sellers who begin their decision-making process long before reaching out. iHomefinder's platform is designed to help agents become what it calls Visible Agents—professionals who show up early, earn trust, and build long-term client pipelines by leveraging the right mix of content, automation, and tech. "Today's most successful agents don't wait for leads—they build pipelines. And visibility is the key," said Bryson Womack, Vice President of Sales at iHomefinder. "We're thrilled to partner with SPIBOR to help their members stay competitive, even as the market continues to shift." SPIBOR Members Now Have Access To: AI-Powered Marketing Automation – Personalized email and SMS nurture flows based on lead behavior High-Intent Seller Leads – Including equity estimates, ownership history, and likely-to-sell scoring IDX Website + CRM Integration – Tools that track, score, and convert buyer and seller activity Mobile Lead Management – Stay responsive with full-featured mobile access to your database A Proven System to Generate 50+ Nurture Leads/Month – Built on daily visibility, content, and CRM signals Members also gain access to iHomefinder's exclusive Visible Agent Playbook—a modern blueprint for turning online presence into real-world closings. Why This Matters Now With fewer listings, rising competition, and buyer attention spread across dozens of channels, today's agents need more than just a website or an IDX feed—they need a growth engine that helps them stay visible, build trust early, and move buyers and sellers toward action with less manual effort. This partnership reflects a shared vision from both SPIBOR and iHomefinder: to equip agents for the next era of real estate success. SPIBOR members can get started today by visiting: 👉 About iHomefinderiHomefinder is a leading provider of real estate growth solutions that help agents, teams, and brokerages grow through visibility, automation, and client engagement. With more than 20 years of experience, iHomefinder supports thousands of agents across North America with powerful IDX tools, high-intent lead generation, and a modern Growth Operating System. Learn more at View original content: SOURCE iHomefinder Inc. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

S&P 500, Nasdaq close at records; Deckers soars on UGG demand
S&P 500, Nasdaq close at records; Deckers soars on UGG demand

Yahoo

time3 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

S&P 500, Nasdaq close at records; Deckers soars on UGG demand

STORY: U.S. stocks gained on Friday, as the Dow added almost half a percent, and the S&P 500 and Nasdaq reached more record high closes, climbing four-tenths and about a quarter of a percent, respectively. The indexes were lifted on hopes the U.S. could reach a trade agreement with the European Union as soon as this weekend, when President Trump meets in Scotland with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen. That's a sharp contrast to the market turmoil triggered by Trump's so-called "Liberation Day" tariffs, notes Brad Bernstein, managing director at UBS Private Wealth Management. "When we initially saw the 2-day, 10% sell-off, the markets really priced in worst-case scenarios and a lot of what Trump had said on Liberation Day being real. Since then, we've had this incredible recovery, now at all-time highs, close to 6400 today on the S&P, because the markets see that he's really negotiating with foreign countries. The markets are seeing that we've had an incredibly resilient economy. The markets are seeing we've had really no material impact on inflation, so far, into the data. And we've had a lot of positive events, such as the extension of the Trump tax cuts." Related Videos How meme stock mania is a 'sign of the times' 'We ask for more data' than FICO: VantageScore CEO Exciting Time, Data Center Construction Booming: Aon CFO Liquid Death CEO on energy drink push, consumers, & growth Stocks on the move Friday included Deckers Outdoor, which soared 11% after the maker of UGG boots and Hoka sneakers beat quarterly estimates. Shares of Intel tumbled 8.5% after the chipmaker forecast steeper quarterly losses than expected and announced plans to slash jobs. :: Charter Communications Shares of Charter Communications slumped more than 18% after the cable giant reported a deeper-than-expected broadband subscriber loss. And Paramount Global's stock dipped more than one and a half percent after U.S. regulators approved its $8.4-billion merger with Skydance Media. Investors next week will focus on the U.S. Federal Reserve, with policymakers on Thursday expected to hold interest rates steady as the central bank weighs the impact of tariffs on inflation. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

Ben Stiller to Explore His Parents' Legacy in New Documentary, Set for October Release
Ben Stiller to Explore His Parents' Legacy in New Documentary, Set for October Release

Yahoo

time3 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Ben Stiller to Explore His Parents' Legacy in New Documentary, Set for October Release

Stiller called it a "great honor to celebrate" his parents, adding that he has "come to know them in new ways through the making of this film" Ben Stiller is bringing his parents' story to life in a personal new project. The 59-year-old actor and director is joining forces with Apple Original Films to direct and produce a documentary titled Stiller & Meara: Nothing Is Lost, which will chart the lives of his famous parents Jerry Stiller and Anne Meara. 'I feel very fortunate to be partnering once again with the incredible team at Apple TV+, this time on a project that is very personal to me and my family," Ben said in a statement. "It's exciting to finally get to share it with audiences; and a great honor to celebrate my parents, both as I knew them growing up, and as I've come to know them in new ways through the making of this film.' Stiller & Meara: Nothing Is Lost will premiere in select theaters on Oct. 17, before coming to Apple TV+ on Oct. 24. Ben's film explores his parents' "impact on both popular culture and at home, where the lines between creativity, family, life and art often blurred," per Apple's logline. Jerry and Meara worked as a comedy act before pursuing solo careers in the 1970s. Jerry went on to star in hit projects such as The King of Queens and Seinfeld. As for Meara, she appeared in Awakenings in 1990, and several TV shows, including Archie Bunker's Place, Oz and Sex and the City. Both stars shared the screen with Ben over the years, with all three appearing in 1995's hit Heavyweights. Meara joined forces with her son on 2006's Night at the Museum, and Jerry's final acting projects involved collaborations with his son in 2016 on Zoolander 2 and the animated TV movie Zoolander: Super Model. After meeting a year prior, Jerry and Meara tied the knot in 1954. They welcomed their daughter Amy Stiller in 1961. Four years later, they gave birth to Ben. Anne died at 85 in May 2015. Jerry followed almost exactly five years later in May 2020 at 92. Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. Appearing on the Today show after his father's death, Ben expressed joy that his parents were able to reunite in the afterlife, saying, "They found each other and they were there for each other." He continued, "Not to get too sappy, but I feel like they're connected again." During a June 2024 appearance on the Hey Dude…The 90s Called! podcast, Ben said that he had "amazing memories" with his parents, recalling time spent no sets and "going with my parents whenever they would go out and do, you know, do nightclubs or go to see them in the theater." He added that he "loved" being on set with his parents, explaining how much he enjoyed "just to see the behind-the-scenes of what they were doing. I realized pretty young that I loved directing and movie making and was fascinated by that and wanted to learn about that." Ben previously worked with Apple TV+ on Severance. He is an executive producer on the show and has directed several episodes. Read the original article on People

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store