Jailing is failing: youth prison numbers under scrutiny
A two-day Reintegration Puzzle Conference in Mparntwe/Alice Springs is being held as the Northern Territory government unrolls new measures in a $1.5 billion law and order crackdown.
But punitive approaches undermine children's human rights and makes contact with the justice system for vulnerable young people more likely, the NT Children's Commissioner Shahleena Musk says.
In her jurisdiction, 85 per cent of children who had previously spent time in custody were returned to prison within 12 months, Ms Musk said.
"If you're thinking sending a kid to prison will teach them a lesson that will stop them from committing a crime, well, the data shows otherwise," she told AAP.
Ms Musk and fellow children's guardians and commissioners from across Australia are urging federal, state and territory governments to address a "disturbing erosion of hard-won safeguards" as tougher youth crime legislation is introduced across the nation.
"These children don't belong in the justice system, which is punitive, focused on control and largely a product of harmful, custodial conditions like the use of restraint, like separation and isolation practices," Ms Musk said.
In Queensland, children as young as 10 can face adult jail time for a range of offences after the state government passed its second tranche of controversial youth crime laws.
The NT government recently passed tougher bail laws, leading to a surge in the territory's prison population.
The territory also plans to retrain dozens of public housing and transit officers as police public safety officers armed with guns, a move slammed by Indigenous and legal advocacy groups.
Tougher bail laws have also been introduced in Victoria and NSW, despite warnings from Aboriginal legal services more Indigenous young people would be imprisoned.
The NT's incarceration rate is reportedly the second-highest in the world, only behind El Salvador, Justice Reform Initiative chair Robert Tickner says.
"Almost unbelievably, governments in other parts of the country appear to be racing to catch up," he said in a statement.
Tyson Carmody, the founder and director of Kings Narrative, a support service for Aboriginal men, said punitive policies were not a solution.
"With the high rates of incarceration of Aboriginal adults and young people, the 'tough on crime' approach feels too much like a 'tough on Aboriginal people' approach," he said.
Catherine Liddle, chief executive for SNAICC, the peak body for Indigenous children, said criminalising young people does not address crime rates or create safer communities.
"The evidence is very clear that the younger a child is when they are locked up, the more likely it is that they will have ongoing criminal justice system involvement," she said.
Ms Liddle said investment in early intervention, prevention and diversion programs was proven to interrupt the cycle of crime and imprisonment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Advertiser
an hour ago
- The Advertiser
Australia urged to take key step to stamp out racism
Australia's race discrimination commissioner rejects the notion of "casual racism", warning prejudice is having a significant cost on the economy. "It's much more than skin deep, it can really scar you in on your soul," Giridharan Sivaraman told AAP. "It's in every aspect of our society." The commissioner said one way this manifested was in the workplace, with job hunters with Anglo-friendly names more likely to get a call back for a gig. People with qualifications from non-English speaking countries were more likely to be employed in jobs below their levels of experience, or in roles in entirely different fields. In an address to the National Press Club in Canberra on Wednesday, Mr Sivaraman will say Australia is at a "critical time" where a whole-of-government approach is needed to tackle racism. He will call on Labor to commit to the national anti-racism framework, handed down by the Australian Human Rights Commission last November. "It's the racism that's in our systems and institutions, it's stopping people from being able to thrive or simply be safe," he said ahead of his address. "Taking action against racism doesn't take anything from any person. It actually improves society for everyone." The commissioner said Australia needed to face the issue with "courage and honesty" as to why this keeps happening. "There needs to be fundamental change ... that's the real conversation that we should all be having," he said. Mr Sivaraman said the issue needed investment as opposed to the ad hoc and disjointed approaches from past governments. The voice to parliament referendum, held in October 2023, had led to an increase in discrimination and prejudice against Indigenous people, he added. "There can be no racial justice in this country without justice for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders, and that is abundantly clear," Mr Sivaraman said. The commissioner said different ethnic groups could also be targeted in Australia during points of rupture in society. He pointed to the "bile" that was directed towards people of Asian heritage during the COVID-19 pandemic, and most recently, soaring levels of anti-Semitism and anti-Palestinian sentiment fuelled by the war in Gaza. The Australian Human Rights Commission will next week launch an online survey to ask university students and staff across the nation about experiences of racism. Mr Sivaraman said this would be done to get a "baseline" of prejudice at the nation's higher education institutions. The survey will be distributed via email by universities and participants will remain anonymous. Australia's race discrimination commissioner rejects the notion of "casual racism", warning prejudice is having a significant cost on the economy. "It's much more than skin deep, it can really scar you in on your soul," Giridharan Sivaraman told AAP. "It's in every aspect of our society." The commissioner said one way this manifested was in the workplace, with job hunters with Anglo-friendly names more likely to get a call back for a gig. People with qualifications from non-English speaking countries were more likely to be employed in jobs below their levels of experience, or in roles in entirely different fields. In an address to the National Press Club in Canberra on Wednesday, Mr Sivaraman will say Australia is at a "critical time" where a whole-of-government approach is needed to tackle racism. He will call on Labor to commit to the national anti-racism framework, handed down by the Australian Human Rights Commission last November. "It's the racism that's in our systems and institutions, it's stopping people from being able to thrive or simply be safe," he said ahead of his address. "Taking action against racism doesn't take anything from any person. It actually improves society for everyone." The commissioner said Australia needed to face the issue with "courage and honesty" as to why this keeps happening. "There needs to be fundamental change ... that's the real conversation that we should all be having," he said. Mr Sivaraman said the issue needed investment as opposed to the ad hoc and disjointed approaches from past governments. The voice to parliament referendum, held in October 2023, had led to an increase in discrimination and prejudice against Indigenous people, he added. "There can be no racial justice in this country without justice for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders, and that is abundantly clear," Mr Sivaraman said. The commissioner said different ethnic groups could also be targeted in Australia during points of rupture in society. He pointed to the "bile" that was directed towards people of Asian heritage during the COVID-19 pandemic, and most recently, soaring levels of anti-Semitism and anti-Palestinian sentiment fuelled by the war in Gaza. The Australian Human Rights Commission will next week launch an online survey to ask university students and staff across the nation about experiences of racism. Mr Sivaraman said this would be done to get a "baseline" of prejudice at the nation's higher education institutions. The survey will be distributed via email by universities and participants will remain anonymous. Australia's race discrimination commissioner rejects the notion of "casual racism", warning prejudice is having a significant cost on the economy. "It's much more than skin deep, it can really scar you in on your soul," Giridharan Sivaraman told AAP. "It's in every aspect of our society." The commissioner said one way this manifested was in the workplace, with job hunters with Anglo-friendly names more likely to get a call back for a gig. People with qualifications from non-English speaking countries were more likely to be employed in jobs below their levels of experience, or in roles in entirely different fields. In an address to the National Press Club in Canberra on Wednesday, Mr Sivaraman will say Australia is at a "critical time" where a whole-of-government approach is needed to tackle racism. He will call on Labor to commit to the national anti-racism framework, handed down by the Australian Human Rights Commission last November. "It's the racism that's in our systems and institutions, it's stopping people from being able to thrive or simply be safe," he said ahead of his address. "Taking action against racism doesn't take anything from any person. It actually improves society for everyone." The commissioner said Australia needed to face the issue with "courage and honesty" as to why this keeps happening. "There needs to be fundamental change ... that's the real conversation that we should all be having," he said. Mr Sivaraman said the issue needed investment as opposed to the ad hoc and disjointed approaches from past governments. The voice to parliament referendum, held in October 2023, had led to an increase in discrimination and prejudice against Indigenous people, he added. "There can be no racial justice in this country without justice for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders, and that is abundantly clear," Mr Sivaraman said. The commissioner said different ethnic groups could also be targeted in Australia during points of rupture in society. He pointed to the "bile" that was directed towards people of Asian heritage during the COVID-19 pandemic, and most recently, soaring levels of anti-Semitism and anti-Palestinian sentiment fuelled by the war in Gaza. The Australian Human Rights Commission will next week launch an online survey to ask university students and staff across the nation about experiences of racism. Mr Sivaraman said this would be done to get a "baseline" of prejudice at the nation's higher education institutions. The survey will be distributed via email by universities and participants will remain anonymous. Australia's race discrimination commissioner rejects the notion of "casual racism", warning prejudice is having a significant cost on the economy. "It's much more than skin deep, it can really scar you in on your soul," Giridharan Sivaraman told AAP. "It's in every aspect of our society." The commissioner said one way this manifested was in the workplace, with job hunters with Anglo-friendly names more likely to get a call back for a gig. People with qualifications from non-English speaking countries were more likely to be employed in jobs below their levels of experience, or in roles in entirely different fields. In an address to the National Press Club in Canberra on Wednesday, Mr Sivaraman will say Australia is at a "critical time" where a whole-of-government approach is needed to tackle racism. He will call on Labor to commit to the national anti-racism framework, handed down by the Australian Human Rights Commission last November. "It's the racism that's in our systems and institutions, it's stopping people from being able to thrive or simply be safe," he said ahead of his address. "Taking action against racism doesn't take anything from any person. It actually improves society for everyone." The commissioner said Australia needed to face the issue with "courage and honesty" as to why this keeps happening. "There needs to be fundamental change ... that's the real conversation that we should all be having," he said. Mr Sivaraman said the issue needed investment as opposed to the ad hoc and disjointed approaches from past governments. The voice to parliament referendum, held in October 2023, had led to an increase in discrimination and prejudice against Indigenous people, he added. "There can be no racial justice in this country without justice for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders, and that is abundantly clear," Mr Sivaraman said. The commissioner said different ethnic groups could also be targeted in Australia during points of rupture in society. He pointed to the "bile" that was directed towards people of Asian heritage during the COVID-19 pandemic, and most recently, soaring levels of anti-Semitism and anti-Palestinian sentiment fuelled by the war in Gaza. The Australian Human Rights Commission will next week launch an online survey to ask university students and staff across the nation about experiences of racism. Mr Sivaraman said this would be done to get a "baseline" of prejudice at the nation's higher education institutions. The survey will be distributed via email by universities and participants will remain anonymous.
Perth Now
2 hours ago
- Perth Now
Australia urged to take key step to stamp out racism
Australia's race discrimination commissioner rejects the notion of "casual racism", warning prejudice is having a significant cost on the economy. "It's much more than skin deep, it can really scar you in on your soul," Giridharan Sivaraman told AAP. "It's in every aspect of our society." The commissioner said one way this manifested was in the workplace, with job hunters with Anglo-friendly names more likely to get a call back for a gig. People with qualifications from non-English speaking countries were more likely to be employed in jobs below their levels of experience, or in roles in entirely different fields. In an address to the National Press Club in Canberra on Wednesday, Mr Sivaraman will say Australia is at a "critical time" where a whole-of-government approach is needed to tackle racism. He will call on Labor to commit to the national anti-racism framework, handed down by the Australian Human Rights Commission last November. "It's the racism that's in our systems and institutions, it's stopping people from being able to thrive or simply be safe," he said ahead of his address. "Taking action against racism doesn't take anything from any person. It actually improves society for everyone." The commissioner said Australia needed to face the issue with "courage and honesty" as to why this keeps happening. "There needs to be fundamental change ... that's the real conversation that we should all be having," he said. Mr Sivaraman said the issue needed investment as opposed to the ad hoc and disjointed approaches from past governments. The voice to parliament referendum, held in October 2023, had led to an increase in discrimination and prejudice against Indigenous people, he added. "There can be no racial justice in this country without justice for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders, and that is abundantly clear," Mr Sivaraman said. The commissioner said different ethnic groups could also be targeted in Australia during points of rupture in society. He pointed to the "bile" that was directed towards people of Asian heritage during the COVID-19 pandemic, and most recently, soaring levels of anti-Semitism and anti-Palestinian sentiment fuelled by the war in Gaza. The Australian Human Rights Commission will next week launch an online survey to ask university students and staff across the nation about experiences of racism. Mr Sivaraman said this would be done to get a "baseline" of prejudice at the nation's higher education institutions. The survey will be distributed via email by universities and participants will remain anonymous.
Perth Now
8 hours ago
- Perth Now
Pauline Hanson's wild ceremony claims
One Nation senator Pauline Hanson believes teaching children to acknowledge country in school will condition people not to feel like they are part of Australia, and leave the nation defenceless in the face of war. Speaking on 10 News+, Senator Hanson said she wouldn't defend the country if she felt like the land belonged to one race of people. The One Nation leader defended her decision to reject Welcome to Country ceremonies in the Senate when she was questioned why her party's senators were present during ceremonies when they did not have to be there. Pauline Hanson has defended her decision to reject Welcome to Country ceremonies in an interview on 10 News+. Supplied / Channel 10 Credit: Channel 10 One Nation senators were called out by their Labor and Greens counterparts over 'childish stunts' and 'hurtful' behaviour when they turned their backs during proceedings. Senator Hanson said they had a right to be there and the new senators wanted to experience the opening of the Senate. 'But it's also to be a voice for the Australian people that have had a gut full of it and don't want to hear Welcome to Country anymore,' she said. 'It is showing leadership, that you don't have to go along with this. 'When our kids have been taught in school to put their hand on the ground and say, you know, acknowledge the land is Aboriginal, we're not making people feel part of this country. Senator Pauline Hanson said she would not defend Australia if she thought the land belonged to another race of people. NewsWire / Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia 'And I'll ask the question, if we ever have war that touches our shores here and we've conditioned the people think this is not our land, it belongs to another race of people, how many Australians are going to get up and fight to defend it? 'I won't.' The Queensland senator hopes her legacy will be that people thought she did her best to stand up for a fair go for all Australians, without fear or favour, and promised to run again in three years time. 'I think that's important, people want that from their politicians,' she said. 'But I'm a conviction politician and I've had so much thrown at me – I've have been to prison, had everything bar the kitchen sink thrown at me. 'Guess what, I'm still standing, the problem is people have underestimated me.'
