Intrigue surrounds US suspect in Mike Gaine case who has moved to Tralee
Janice Gaine carries a photograph of her husband Mike at his funeral in Kenmare on Saturday. Photo: Mark Condren
In the week where two probes were launched into the garda investigation of the Mike Gaine case, Michael Kelley kept a low profile in Tralee.
Mr Kelley has made a complaint to Fiosrú, formerly known as the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission (GSOC), about his treatment by gardaí. Meanwhile, Garda Commissioner Drew Harris confirmed Mr Gaine's killing is the subject of a peer review, saying lessons can be learned from homicides that begin as missing persons cases.
Before people knew his name, many in Kerry only knew of Michael Kelley as 'the Yank'.
When farmer Michael Gaine first went missing, many locals spoke of 'a Yank living on the farm', curious about what he was doing there and where he had come from.
Mr Kelley's arrest last month and the subsequent public admission that he was questioned by gardaí on suspicion of murdering Mr Gaine have enhanced the intrigue surrounding him. Mr Kelley was released without charge after being questioned for 24 hours. He denies having any involvement in Mr Gaine's murder.
Michael Gaine's remains were found at his farm
Kenmare pauses to say farewell to Mike Gaine
People in Kenmare said Mr Kelley and Mr Gaine met a few years ago. One source said Mr Gaine was out hunting and found Mr Kelley sleeping rough in a remote area outside Kenmare. Mr Gaine offered Mr Kelley some work on his farm and the use of an old house there, they said.
The house provided basic living. People in the area said they believe it had no electricity and they were uncertain if it had running water. It had not been lived in for years before Mr Kelley moved in. Mr Gaine lived elsewhere, not too far from the farm.
Mr Kelley remained at the old farmhouse until Mr Gaine's death and for a short time afterwards while searches were conducted to try to find the farmer.
He relocated from the farm to Tralee shortly before Mr Gaine's remains were found. Intrigue followed Mr Kelley there too.
He currently lives in the town centre, and while he spent some time during his early days there busking in the square, people living and working in Tralee say they have not seen him play music for a couple of weeks. Others did not realise he had been busking.
He's a big man, long hair. He's distinctive, so it's hard to miss him, but he seems to keep to himself
'He's out most in the mornings. He often goes down to the supermarket and then goes back to where he's staying. We don't see much more of him than that, really,' one woman working near Mr Kelley's home said last week.
She said he does not appear to talk to anyone, and few people make moves to interact with him.
Janice Gaine carries a photograph of her husband Mike at his funeral in Kenmare on Saturday. Photo: Mark Condren
'He seems fine and keeps to himself,' a man said.
People are curious because of how he has found himself at the centre of a murder case that has gripped the nation.
One person working near Mr Kelley's new home said they noticed a delivery van two weeks ago outside the building he lives in. It was delivering beds and other furniture.
'I presume it was for the Yank, he's the only new person in there I think. Maybe that means he'll be here for a while,' they said.
'We don't see much else happening, although people are definitely interested in him. He's a big man, long hair. He's distinctive, so it's hard to miss him, but he seems to keep to himself.'
Another man said: 'The only people I have seen him talking to are a couple of reporters.
'There were a few reporters here for days trying to speak to him, but he hasn't been out much. He was out one day in a pair of wellies and waterproof pants. Last week he was out in a pair of sandals talking to reporters.
'Other than that, you don't really see him.'
Michael Gaine's remains were found at his farm
Today's News in 90 Seconds - 08 June 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
7 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Man, 50s, arrested in connection with death of Josephine Ray in Tipperary
A man has been arrested in connection with a Garda investigation into the death of an 89-year-old woman in Tipperary last year. Josephine 'Josie' Ray, a widow who lived in St Joseph's Park in Nenagh, was found dead in her home on Sunday, August 4 2024. Ms Ray, a mother of five, had lived in the area for more than 50 years. On Thursday, gardaí arrested a man in his 50s as part of their investigation into Ms Ray's death. He is currently being detained under the provisions of Section 4 of the Criminal Justice Act, 1984. Two other people, a man and a woman both aged in their 50s, were arrested on August 9 last year for questioning in relation to Ms Ray's death. They were later released without charge. That same month, an interaction between gardaí and Ms Ray was sent to the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission (Gsoc) for examination. A garda spokesperson said the force "continue to investigate all the circumstances" surrounding Ms Ray's death. "Investigations are ongoing," they said.
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
Police ombudsman investigating circumstances of Evan Fitzgerald's death
Officials from Fiosrú, the Police Ombudsman, are investigating the circumstances around the death of Evan Fitzgerald, who took his life in a Carlow shopping centre last month. Investigators from the ombudsman's office are in close contact with the Fitzgerald family and providing them with regular updates, sources said. The investigation is mandated under law as the 22-year-old from Wicklow had interactions with the gardaí around the time of his death, which occurred on June 1st in Fairgreen Shopping Centre. Mr Fitzgerald fired several shots into the air using a stolen shotgun before turning the gun on himself. However, Fiosrú also confirmed it is not investigating two other referrals relating to the actions gardaí took while investigating Mr Fitzgerald for possession of firearms last March. READ MORE Politicians have accused gardaí of attempting to 'entrap' the young man during the investigation and of misleading a judge. An Garda Síochána has strongly denied the accusations and said it used standard, internationally accepted tactics to protect the safety of the public. On Monday, Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan declined to comment on the matter until two linked court cases are completed. A spokesman for the Minister said he has been briefed by Garda Commissioner Drew Harris on the case 'both orally and in writing'. Speaking to The Irish Times on Monday, a spokeswoman for Fiosrú detailed its activity in relation to the case. She said on the day after Mr Fitzgerald's death, it received a referral from a Garda superintendent under section 203 (1) of the Policing, Security and Community Safety Act 2024. [ Carlow gunman Evan Fitzgerald had other weapons Opens in new window ] [ How 'controlled deliveries' are used in Garda sting operations Opens in new window ] This mandates that An Garda Síochána must refer any case to the Ombudsman where it appears 'that the act or omission of a member of garda personnel may have resulted in the death of, or serious harm to, a person'. Mr Fitzgerald took his life after armed gardaí arrived on the scene in response to reports of gunfire. Gardaí did not fire any rounds. Fiosrú confirmed it has appointed a senior officer to conduct the investigation. 'This matter remains open and under investigation. Fiosrú has and will continue to liaise with Evan Fitzgerald's family in this regard,' the spokeswoman said. Separately, she said the ombudsman received 'a notification of an incident of concern' on May 21st relating to the case. It is understood the referral related to allegations that gardaí had mislead a District Court judge during a previous bail hearing for Mr Fitzgerald. During the hearing, the judge was told gardaí were still investigating the source of the firearms Mr Fitzgerald had in his possession when he was stopped by members of the Emergency Response Unit in March. It later emerged that undercover gardaí sold him the two guns after being tipped off that Mr Fitzgerald was attempting to source weapons on the internet. Both weapons had been decommissioned by gardaí. One of them was a G3 assault rifle stolen by the IRA from Norwegian reserves in 1984 and recovered more than 20 years ago. Labour TD Alan Kelly and Independent senator Michael McDowell have characterised the operation as 'entrapment' of Mr Fitzgerald. Fiosrú said that on receiving the complaint it had requested further information from gardaí. After examining this, it opted not to open an investigation. Last Wednesday, Fiosrú received a further referral relating to An Garda Síochána action, this time from the commissioner. Mr Harris made the referral after politicians accused the force of misleading the court. Again, the ombudsman's office decided the matter did not warrant a full investigation. 'As the matters concerned were the same in substance as those outlined in the previous notification of 21st of May 2025, there was nothing further to be considered by Fiosrú,' the spokeswoman said, adding that it cannot, by law, make any further comment for the moment. Speaking last week, the commissioner defended An Garda Síochána's actions in the case and raised the recent school shooting 'by a lone gunman' in Austria, which left 11 people dead. 'This is sadly a more frequent occurrence,' he said. 'There is very insidious material on the internet which seeks to radicalise young people. We have to look at the individual and the threat to the general public and deal with that appropriately. 'I have to say, this was a very successful operation in that we made sure a threat to the public did not arise from the circumstances we were dealing with.'
Sunday World
3 days ago
- Sunday World
Gardaí believe Mike Gaine was killed with a sword-type weapon, not a chainsaw
Detectives had earlier seized three chainsaws from Kerryman's farm Gardaí investigating the murder of Kerry farmer Mike Gaine are working on the assumption he was killed with a sword-type weapon rather than a chainsaw. Sources said 'all the forensic indications' point to his death and dismemberment being the result of a blade rather than chainsaw injuries. Detectives had been exploring a theory that the 56-year-old was dismembered with a chainsaw, with three seized from his farm after his disappearance. However, it is understood that an examination of his remains indicates a 'non-chainsaw type blade' was used. In terms of the implement or implements, they could be anywhere 'Gardaí do not believe at this stage that a chainsaw was used in this case,' a source said. 'Some form of large knife, blade or sword is what has been indicated was used. There is an issue in that gardaí do not have in their possession the blade-type implement used in this murder. 'Michael Gaine's murder happened on his farm, which is on 1,000 acres of land, so in terms of the implement or implements used to end his life, they could be anywhere. A significant amount of that area is marsh and swamp land.' Mr Gaine was last seen in Kenmare on Thursday, March 20, and was reported missing the following day. His bronze Toyota Rav4 was found in his farmyard — off the N71 at Carrig East — with his wallet and phone inside. Michael Gaine was reported missing in Kenmare in March Today's News in 90 Seconds - June 30th On April 29, Mr Gaine's disappearance was upgraded by gardaí from a missing person case to a homicide investigation. Human remains were discovered on Mr Gaine's farm on May 16, when one of his nephews and a neighbour were spreading slurry on fields. The farm was sealed off and declared a crime scene. More human remains were later found in a slurry spreader and in a slurry tank on the farm in the following days. Gardaí later confirmed DNA tests proved the remains were those of Mr Gaine. The piece of land where parts of Michael Gaine's body were discovered A specialist examination of the slurry tank on Mr Gaine's hillside farmyard days after he disappeared did not uncover his dismembered remains. Questions have since been asked as to how they went undetected by gardaí. However, sources have said Mr Gaine's remains had been dismembered to such an extent that the small pieces of his body somehow went unnoticed during a specialist search by gardaí and members of Kerry County Fire Services on March 24. On May 18, Michael Kelley (53), from Maine in the US, was arrested over the murder. He was questioned for 24 hours before being released without charge. He has denied any knowledge or involvement in the murder to gardaí as well as in a series of media interviews. Michael Kelley Mr Kelley has outlined how he was living and working on Mr Gaine's farm at the time of his killing. A family member of Mr Kelley living in the US previously told this newspaper: 'The Michael I knew was not capable of murder, but we haven't spoken in years.' They described him as a 'gentle lion', and said he is 'highly intelligent' and is 'always generous with people in need'. Separately, court documents obtained regarding a case in the US several years ago detail how a judge said Mr Kelley has 'questionable ability' to 'determine fact from fiction'.
