Zuma's Morocco visit sparks controversy over Western Sahara
Image: Independent Media
Former President Jacob Zuma's recent visit to Morocco has sparked controversy and divided opinions, with many calling it a "betrayal" of Western Sahara.
The discreet visit on July 15 came to light through social media posts from Moroccan officials and was confirmed by Youssef Amrani, the Moroccan ambassador to the US, on X.
During the trip, Zuma was photographed with Magasela Mzobe, Head of Presidency of the MK Party, and Moroccan officials, both South African and Moroccan flags prominently displayed.
This visit is seen as a significant shift regarding the Western Sahara conflict.
Critics argue that Zuma's support for Morocco's sovereignty over Western Sahara marks a betrayal of the African Union's (AU) long-standing position advocating for Sahrawi self-determination.
Floyd Shivambu, former Secretary General of the MK Party, responded sharply, describing Zuma's recognition of Moroccan sovereignty as 'opportunistic' and a departure from the anti-colonial and revolutionary principles that underpin many liberation movements on the continent
The controversy deepened when Fikile Mbalula, the ANC's secretary general, publicly called Zuma a 'sellout' during a televised interview and reiterated his disapproval on social media.
The Pan African Forum Ltd and Associates chair, Dr David Nyekorach-Matsanga, issued a formal condemnation on Sunday, describing Zuma's stance as a 'betrayal of African solidarity' and a violation of the AU's principles.
'It dishonours the legacy of the late Muammar Gaddafi, a key defender of the Sahrawi cause, which is a recognised member state of the African Union, and its right to self-determination is protected under Article 20 of the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights,' read the statement.
In response, Dr Magasela Mzobe, head of the presidency in the MK Party, said nothing stops Zuma from visiting other African countries.
'President Zuma and the MKP officials will soon take MK members and supporters into confidence about this historic visit to Morocco. We don't owe the ANC, DA, or any organisation answers but MKP members. The ANC doesn't speak on behalf of SA on international matters.'
Meanwhile, Zuma's previous support for the Sahrawi cause as President of South Africa was well-documented, including meetings with Sahrawi leader Brahim Ghali.
Critics now question whether this visit signals a significant policy shift within the MK party or a personal diplomatic move.
Political analyst Joe Mhlanga expressed concern about the internal discord within the MK Party, highlighting ongoing internal struggles and leadership issues.
'The party appears to lack a clear direction; this flip-flopping on key issues like Western Sahara undermines their credibility and raises questions about their stance on international justice.'
'This is not different from supporting Israel over Palestine, because history reminds us that Morocco is the oppressor who continues to illegally occupy the Western Sahara, which is still under occupation," said Mhlanga.
The MK Party released a policy position earlier this week explaining that they believe South Africa and the Kingdom of Morocco should be committed to strengthening their bilateral relations, grounded in shared principles of sovereignty, territorial integrity, and African unity.
'Both nations were shaped by their anti-colonial struggles, South Africa from apartheid and Morocco from French and Spanish rule." Get your news on the go, click here to join the Cape Argus News WhatsApp channel.
Cape Argus
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
5 minutes ago
- IOL News
How BRICS is fostering dialogue and addressing global challenges
The Valdai Discussion Club, in partnership with the South African Institute of International Affairs, hosted the 3rd Russian-African Conference titled 'Realpolitik in a Divided World: Rethinking Russia-South Africa Ties in a Global and African Context' in Pretoria. Image: Oupa Mokoena / Independent Newspapers The role of BRICS in the world has been hailed as a positive force driving dialogue and creating strategic conditions for development, rather than opposing any particular nation, including the United States (US). This message was delivered at the Russia-Africa conference, co-hosted by the Valdai Discussion Club and the South African Institute of International Affairs in Pretoria. The conference, titled 'Realpolitik Responses in a Fractured World: Rethinking Russia-South Africa Ties in Global and African Context', brought together top government officials and academics to share their perspectives on 'G20 and BRICS: Assessing Strategic Roles in an Evolving Global Order'. Dmitry Birichevsky, director of the Department of Economic Cooperation at the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, noted that the BRICS leadership cycle in the G20 has coincided with a strengthening of its economic positions. 'The mounting influence of BRICS has asserted itself as a centre for growth, innovation and one of the main pillars of a new and more just world order,' he said. He added that BRICS' principles of consensus, equality, and mutual consideration of each other's interests resonate with the growing number of countries in the Global South. Key issues on the BRICS agenda include making economic governance more democratic and bridging the digital and ecological divide between the Global North and the Global South. Birichevsky reiterated Russia's support for the South African presidency, saying it has predictably placed G20 emphasis on the African agenda amid the alarming development in the global economy. Philani Mthembu, executive director of the Institute for Global Dialogue, noted that the recent presidencies of BRICS and G20 have coincided with a rapidly shifting geopolitical landscape, which has heightened the focus on these forums. He stressed that the low level of participation or absence of the United States should not be the only thing on their radar. 'The participation of the US will not make or break South Africa's G20 presidency. The US must be seen in a broader context where the US is pursuing what it views as America first,' he said. Mthembu added that BRICS should aim to reform international institutions from within while also applying external pressure. Elena Maslova, associate professor at MGIMO University's Department of Integration Studies, recommended that BRICS delve into issues such as climate change. Image: Oupa Mokoena / Independent Newspapers Elena Maslova, associate professor at MGIMO University's Department of Integration Studies, suggested that BRICS should explore topics such as climate change, highlighting the declaration on climate finance as a significant step forward. 'BRICS is gradually becoming a key platform for climate dialogue as well. BRICS should strive to create its single space for climate finance implementation to make it possible to reduce emissions,' she said. Maslova emphasised that BRICS is not a confrontational tool, but rather a valuable platform for tackling global challenges. Nourhan ElSheikh, professor of International Relations at Cairo University, stated that the Global South's influence has surged over the past decade, largely due to BRICS and G20, which are driving forces behind the emerging new world order. 'The Global South matters a lot not only for competition among colonial powers but also as a global player in international politics,' she said. ElSheikh remarked that the Global South has matured to the point where it can identify its own interests, rather than automatically aligning with the US, which is still trying to maintain its global dominance. 'Now we have the Global South saying 'no' and that this is not in our favour or interest and we have the right to choose our way,' she said. [email protected]
TimesLIVE
35 minutes ago
- TimesLIVE
Emma Powell steps down as DA's international relations spokesperson
'Many of these regimes are more closely enmeshed with government leaders and the department of international relations & co-operation than the public realises,' she said. Powell's resignation comes after Sowetan revealed she had been accused of spreading disinformation that 'contributed to the negative perceptions' of South Africa's foreign policy. Government sources said a report put Powell at the centre of organising an 'unauthorised' trip to the US that included former deputy minister of trade and industry Andrew Whitfield. Insiders said the report suggested that Powell allegedly used her travel to the US to spread an antigovernment agenda, despite her party being a key member of the government of national unity. Powell recently issued a statement claiming President Cyril Ramaphosa's envoy to the US, Mcebisi Jonas, had been denied entry to the US and that the country had refused to accept his credentials. The Presidency, through spokesperson Vincent Magwenya, responded in a strongly worded statement, accusing the DA of 'positioning itself as part of a right-wing nexus' that aimed to undermine the country. On Monday, Powell said as a woman in politics, she understood viscerally the cost of standing up to bullies and the pressures that came with public life. 'In an environment that rewards expediency, truly principled leadership is rare and often costly. I am profoundly grateful to every South African, diplomat and colleague who has supported me along this journey. This world is full of remarkable, principled people who know that the cost of silence is far greater than the risk of confronting tyranny when the stakes are highest. 'Given the complexities of our fragile government of national unity, I have achieved what I can for and in this moment. We must each do what is possible to tip the world's axis towards freedom, but good leaders know when it is time to step back and allow others to carry the baton forward,' Powell said. She said she would continue to use her time in parliament to serve the country.
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
Floyd Shivambu now slams MK Party as Jacob Zuma 'family stokvel'
Former MK Party secretary-general Floyd Shivambu has denounced the uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party under Jacob Zuma as a 'family stokvel,' accusing its leadership of looting party coffers for personal gain. Shivambu, who is now the national convenor of the Mayibuye Consultative Process, had previously describing joining the MK Party as the best decision ever. After allegations he plotted against Zuma, Shivambu refused to resign and launched the Mayibuye consultation process to engage traditional and civic leaders across South Africa. He was speaking in Mpumalanga this weekend when he denounced the MK Party, the ANC and the EFF.
