Which way for the NPA?
The National Director of Public Prosecutions (NDPP), Shamila Batohi, faced an expectedly challenging appearance before the justice portfolio committee this week.
While the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) could draw some solace from last week's Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) ruling in its favour in the Nulane case, significant concerns remain.
Key issues include the NPA's mishandling of the rape case involving pastor Timothy Omotoso, as well as the Free State High Court's decision that the extradition of Moroadi Cholota - accused alongside former Free State Premier Ace Magashule in the asbestos corruption case - was unlawful.
Adding to these concerns is the slow progress in prosecuting state capture cases, a point of criticism that continues to linger.
With just six months remaining in Batohi's term before her expected retirement next year, questions are being raised about what lies ahead for the NPA. Notably, there has been little clarity or action from the Presidency on when the process to appoint her successor will begin.
In this week's Friday Briefing, we examine the state of the NPA under Batohi's leadership. Has she delivered on her promises for reform since stepping into the role?
News24's legal journalist, Karyn Maughan reflects on two cases where she argues the failure of NPA leadership to put out legal fires before they imploded fundamentally compromised the administration of justice.
Casac's Lawson Naidoo explains why he believes the NPA has made some headway under Batohi's tenure.
Additionally, News24's parliamentary reporter, Jan Gerber, evaluates Parliament's role in the NPA's challenges, including the impact of funding shortages on the institution.
We also feature a Q&A with DA MP and former advocate Glynnis Breytenbach on what must be done to reshape the institution and restore its credibility.
Lastly, advocate Lauren Kohn from the Law and Governance Academy of Southern Africa delves into the recent SCA Nulane judgment, shedding light on what it reveals about the current state of our judiciary.
You can explore these perspectives and contributions in full below.
Set up to fail or maliciously incompetent? What NPA losses tell us
Despite high-profile court losses, prosecutions boss Shamila Batohi insists the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) is doing a 'fantastic job'. But, Karyn Maughan writes that stance does not recognise how NPA leadership failures have jeopardised criminal accountability.
here.
Rebuilding justice: Nulane judgment offers redemption for the NPA
While the NPA has issues that need addressing, it is difficult to agree with those who wish to portray the NPA as an institution in crisis, in need of a root and branch overhaul, argues Lawson Naidoo.
Read the full contribution here.
NPA crisis: A chronicle of a snafu foretold
If you have been paying close attention to the National Prosecuting Authority's appearances before Parliament, as Jan Gerber has done, you wouldn't be surprised that the pawpaw has hit the fan at the prosecuting body.
Read the full contribution here.
Q&A with Glynnis Breytenbach | Saying NPA is 'doing a fantastic job' is 'bullsh*t'
As scrutiny on the NPA intensifies after it bungled a number of high-profile cases, in-depth writer Muhammad Hussain speaks to DA MP and former prosecutor Glynnis Breytenbach on what it will take to turn the leaky ship around.
Read the full contribution here.
SCA Nulane judgment vindicates the rule of law and NPA's important work
The real impediment to justice and equity was an affront to the rule of law perpetrated not by the National Prosecuting Authority in the Thabete case, but rather by the guardian of the rule of law itself, the judiciary – an affront that is now embodied for posterity in the Free State High Court's shockingly incorrect legal findings as set out in its judgment, writes Lauren Kohn.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Associated Press
17 minutes ago
- Associated Press
UN rapporteur calls for global action to stop 'genocide' in Gaza
BOGOTA, Colombia (AP) — The United Nations' special rapporteur for Gaza and the West Bank said Tuesday that it's time for nations around the world to take concrete actions to stop what she called the 'genocide' in Gaza. Francesca Albanese spoke to delegates from 30 countries meeting in Colombia's capital to discuss the Israel-Hamas war and ways that nations can try to stop Israel's military offensive in the territory. Many of the participating nations have described the violence as genocide against the Palestinians. 'Each state must immediately review and suspend all ties with the State of Israel ... and ensure its private sector does the same,' Albanese said. 'The Israeli economy is structured to sustain the occupation that has now turned genocidal.' The two-day conference organized by the governments of Colombia and South Africa is being attended mostly by developing nations, although the governments of Spain, Ireland and China have also sent delegates. Israel, which was founded in the aftermath of the Holocaust, has adamantly rejected genocide allegations against it as an antisemitic 'blood libel.' Analysts say it's not clear whether the conference's participating countries have enough leverage over Israel to force it to change its policies in Gaza, where more than 58,000 people have been killed in Israeli military operations following a deadly Hamas attack on Israel in 2023. The death toll comes from the health ministry, which is under Gaza's Hamas government and does not differentiate between civilians and combatants. The U.N. and other international organizations see its figures as the most reliable statistics on war casualties. 'The United States has so far failed to influence Israel's behavior … so it is naive to think that this group of countries can have any influence over (Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin) Netanyahu's behavior or on the government of Israel,' said Sandra Borda, a professor of international relations at Bogota's Los Andes University. She said, however, that the conference will enable some nations of the Global South to clarify their position toward the conflict and have their voices heard. The conference is co-chaired by the governments of South Africa and Colombia, which last year suspended coal exports to Israeli power plants, and includes the participation of members of The Hague Group, a coalition of eight nations that earlier this year pledged to cut military ties with Israel and to comply with an International Criminal Court arrest warrant against Netanyahu. For decades, South Africa's ruling African National Congress party has compared Israel's policies in Gaza and the West Bank with its own history of oppression under the harsh apartheid regime of white minority rule, which restricted most Blacks to 'homelands' before ending in 1994. South Africa's current argument is rooted in the sentiment that Palestinians have been oppressed in their homeland as Black South Africans were under apartheid. The gathering comes as the European Union weighs various measures against Israel that include a ban on imports from Israeli settlements, an arms embargo and individual sanctions against Israeli officials, who are found to be blocking a peaceful solution to the conflict. Colombia's Vice Minister for Foreign Affairs Mauricio Jaramillo said Monday that the nations participating in the Bogota meeting, which also include Qatar and Turkey, will be discussing diplomatic and judicial measures that can be taken to put more pressure on Israel to cease its attacks. The Colombian official described Israel's conduct in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank as an affront to the international order. 'This is not just about Palestine' Jaramillo said in a press conference. 'It is about defending international law… and the right to self determination.'
News24
3 hours ago
- News24
Sibiya asked to take leave; Standard Bank manager's bail bid: Today's top 7 stories in 7 minutes
News24 brings you the top 7 stories of the day. News24 brings you the top stories of the day, summarised into neat little packages. Read through quickly or listen to the articles via our customised text-to-speech feature. Lieutenant General Shadrack Sibiya asked to take leave of absence amid Mkhwanazi claims - Lieutenant General Shadrack Sibiya has been asked to take a leave of absence. - This follows allegations of links to criminal syndicates and interference in murder investigations. - The allegations were made by KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi. Tammy Petersen/News24 Standard Bank manager in R18m cocaine bust shares rags-to-riches story in bail bid - Raed Cupido, a bank manager and businessman, is charged with drug dealing and illegal gun possession after a bust at a storage unit containing cocaine, an AK-47, and other weapons. - Cupido portrayed himself as a successful citizen with multi-million rand properties, detailing his journey from a financially struggling student to a high-earning professional with a property portfolio and international travel. - Christopher Carelse, arrested as a co-accused, also intends to plead not guilty, stating he is a business manager with a family and property in Gauteng. Ashraf Hendricks/GroundUp Judge orders WhatsApp, Instagram to stop user posting sexual content of SA school kids - The Gauteng High Court ordered Meta to shut down WhatsApp channels and Instagram profiles sharing explicit content of South African schoolchildren and to identify the perpetrator. - The distribution of the material posed immediate harm, prompting 'extremely urgent legal action' to prevent massive release threats and protect children from irreparable damage. - The illegal accounts solicited explicit content from minors and distributed it widely, violating child rights and spreading defamatory claims tied to social media handles. Thulani Mbele/Gallo Images DA claims Trump administration denied Mcebisi Jonas' visa, rejected credentials - The DA claims the US denied President Ramaphosa's special envoy, Mcebisi Jonas, a diplomatic visa in May. - The DA says Ramaphosa was aware Jonas was not welcome in Washington and was urged to appoint an alternative envoy. - Ramaphosa appointed Jonas as a special envoy to the US in April to foster partnerships and advance South Africa's interests. WesBank, GWM in 'game-changer' deal that promises to cut car repayments - WesBank and GWM have agreed to a new vehicle finance partnership that will lower car prices and boost affordability for South African buyers. - GWM will take on more financial risk, allowing WesBank to offer better pricing and more flexible repayment terms to dealers. - WesBank expects more Chinese automakers to enter the South African market in 2025, increasing competition and further disrupting the market. Richard Huggard/Gallo Images Bok No 8 Jasper Wiese cops 4-game ban for headbutt - Jasper Wiese has been banned for four Tests after receiving a red card for headbutting an opponent in the Springboks' win over Italy. - He will miss the upcoming Test against Georgia and the first three Rugby Championship matches. - Wiese will be eligible to play in the Boks' last three Rugby Championship games.
News24
3 hours ago
- News24
Creecy dissolves board of Road Accident Fund amid governance failure
Minister of Transport Barbara Creecy has dissolved the board of the Road Accident Fund (RAF) after a litany of operational and governance failures at the entity. She has also asked the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) to request an expansion of the scope of its current investigation to cover the events of the last three months. The RAF is insolvent, with liabilities exceeding its assets. It also has chronic governance problems, which resulted in the suspension of its CEO, Collins Letsoalo, last month. In addition to the SIU investigation, it faces a probe by Parliament's Standing Committee on Public Accounts (Scopa). Several whistleblowers have made disclosures about corruption at the fund. Creecy said that among the reasons for the board's dissolution was its 'reckless' handling of Letsoalo's suspension, which has attracted a legal challenge and caused institutional uncertainty. Other reasons included: The RAF's protracted and costly litigation against the Auditor-General on the application of accounting standards. The occurrence of frequent default judgments against it. Deep divisions within the board, which reflect a lack of cohesion in critical decision-making processes. The board's failure to fill at least two executive positions, critical to the mandate of the fund, namely the chief claims officer and head of legal. Creecy said these factors had 'resulted in the loss of confidence in the board's ability to run the entity effectively'. In a statement issued on Tuesday, Creecy said that more than a month ago, she had allowed the board to make representations to her on why they should not be suspended. She had also asked the National Treasury to appoint an interim accounting authority while recruiting a new board. Creecy has also established an expert advisory committee to review the RAF's business processes and make recommendations. The panel's members will be announced in due course. She reiterated her department's intent to reintroduce a new version of the Road Accident Benefit Scheme (RABS) Bill, which failed to pass in the fifth Parliament under suspicious circumstances and amid heavy lobbying from the legal fraternity. 'The bill will introduce a no-fault system to make it easier for road accident victims to access benefits without costly legal bills,' said the statement.
