logo
Tarnished Tassal brand targets WA barramundi

Tarnished Tassal brand targets WA barramundi

Embattled global fish farmer Tassal's proposal for a mega barramundi sea cage operation north of Broome comes promising jobs and fulfilment of market demand.
It would also bring up to 50 tonnes of dead fish in landfill a week, the 'smothering' of coral and potential spread of disease and pollution through a marine park.
Canadian-owned Tassal Group, Australia's largest seafood producer, recently bailed out the previously loss-making enterprise, acquiring from administration a relatively small, 32-cage operation in the Kimberley's Cone Bay, a zone previously sanctioned for aquaculture as less sensitive than the rest of the region.
Now the company proposes to expand across 50 kilometres of more sensitive areas in the Malaya Marine Park, part of the National Heritage-listed Buccaneer Archipelago, with 84 cages across seven sites, ultimately holding up to 17,500 tonnes of fish.
Broome-based conservation group Environs Kimberley's submission to the WA environment watchdog regarding the proposal has now emerged, highlighting details of the proposal from Tassal, just as the company faces escalating controversy over the $1.8 billion salmon sea cage industry in Tasmania, where it operates alongside Huon and Petuna.
Salmon farming in Tasmania has been blamed for antibiotics leaking into the food chain, algal blooms, endangered species impacts, mass fish escapes and finally an unprecedented kill of one million fish in April, resulting in erosion of consumer trust and revocation of RSPCA animal welfare certification.
Escalating 'salmon wars' played a key role in the 2025 federal election and the GoodFish guide has told shoppers to reject Tasmanian farmed salmon.
The WA sea cages proposed would be within the proposed general use zone of the marine park, which allows for aquaculture, but some would be close to sanctuary and cultural use zones.
Tassal, promising 140 jobs from the operation, aims to achieve no more than 15 per cent fish mortality, equalling up to 2625 tonnes of dead fish per annum, or 50 tonnes a week.
Tassal says it is exploring a number of 'mortality programs' for WA.
One involves mincing the fish and stabilising it with formic acid for livestock feed, a common global practice, with processing done in Derby.
The other option is landfill in Derby.
Also, in the event of a 'mass mortality' all stock would be transferred to a licensed Derby landfill.
The risks
Tassal's documents identify the major risks as:
Fish waste and uneaten feed settling on the sea-floor causing algal blooms and water deoxygenation around the sites.
'Smothering and/or shading' of the sea floor and the coral reefs fringing the archipelago's islands, models predicting losses of 1-16 per cent of coral reefs around some islands.
Potential algal growth around the reefs, affecting coral and reducing marine life, possibly affecting the Malaya people's hunting practices
Net damage from predators or weather events causing fish escapes, with possible 'significant impact on native barramundi' from swiftly spreading, generally fatal pests and diseases, or changes in their genetics.
The greatest risks were 'generally from bacteria' (the cause of the Tasmanian fish kill) usually associated with hot temperatures or the rapid salinity changes common to the wet season.
Vessel strike, noise and vibrations in a globally significant hotspot and refuge for sawfish, rays and sharks, critically endangered sea snakes and sea turtles
The pens causing an artificial reef effect that could attract other fauna, and therefore predators, leading to the predators' entanglement.
Tassal was unable to comprehensively survey the Buccaneer Archipelago area and so while it was unsure about whether the area's marine turtles nested near its sites, there was a possibility light pollution would disorient turtle hatchlings en route to the ocean.
Tassal wrote of its rigorous testing and vaccination program in which imported hatchlings had to be disease free to a '95 per cent degree of confidence', and said it avoided 'where possible' managing outbreaks with chemicals, except in 'extreme cases'.
It acknowledged a dugong hotspot was near the proposal area with little known about important feeding, breeding or movement areas.
It noted the three of the proposed sea cage sites fell within a biologically important area for nursing, calving and resting for the largest population of humpback whales in the world.
The whole area was also important habitat for Australian snubfin, Australian humpback and spotted bottlenose dolphins.
Tassal also said in a statement to this masthead that the project was an exciting opportunity for the Kimberley and with it came a commitment to grow local jobs and invest in local suppliers and communities, while sustainably managing the environment.
The elephant in the room
Environs Kimberley is concerned Tassal's proposal fails to list climate change as a risk in a region recently hit by coral-bleaching marine heatwaves.
They say warming oceans, severe weather and reduced ecosystem resilience will make it hard to avoid significant 'unplanned' impacts including fish kills, infrastructure damage, escapes and diseases.
Executive director Martin Pritchard said Tassal's document glossed over the 220,000 barramundi killed at the existing Cone Bay operation in 2019, only noting the cause: an algal bloom caused by a combination of warm seas, warm air and pollution flushed by rain from rivers to the sea. In naming this cause it cited a report into the incident commissioned by and for the previous operator, which was not publicly released.
Environs Kimberley voiced a 'strong concern' that the Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development, as primary regulator, was 'an active promoter of sea cage fish farming' and did not investigate the 2019 fish kill, perceiving a conflict of interest, especially as WA Premier Roger Cook last year called the Tassal plan 'great news' and awarded the company a $5 million incentive.
The department's Fisheries and Aquaculture executive director Nathan Harrison said after the 2019 Cone Bay fish kill, its testing confirmed the cause of death to be the algal bloom, so further investigation was not required.
'DPIRD continues to closely monitor and respond to environmental changes that affect fisheries and aquaculture, including marine heatwaves,' he said.
WA Environmental Protection Authority chair Darren Walsh visited the region last month as part of the public environmental review.
He said the proponent would be required to address all relevant issues raised during the public review. The EPA expected to publish those responses by the end of the year.
Pritchard said the landfilling aspect was also concerning.
'Which facilities in Derby have the capacity and appropriate licencing to safely dispose of this quantity of dead and rotting fish, let alone huge quantities arising from a mass death event?' he said.
He said the impacts and risks of intensive industry should not be spread across wide areas of a globally significant and unique marine park.
He said Tassal downplayed the potential impacts but it was evident some level of pollution was expected and the risks were unacceptable, especially when heightened by climate change, and in the context of Tassal's track record in Tasmania.
'Because of its remoteness, high tides, fast currents, narrow channels and cyclones, if there is a major event like mass fish escape or mass disease and death event, it will be logistically very difficult to address,' he said.
He said this proposal was one of several industrial projects under way or proposed in the Buccaneer Archipelago, representing the potential for significant, cumulative, long-term impacts.
Environs Kimberley submitted to the watchdog that such industries should be on land, close to population centres, as with barramundi farming in the Northern Territory, so impacts could be contained and rapid support provided during incidents.
A Tassal spokesperson said the company removed around 400 hectares from the proposal previously submitted by the past operators, recognising concerns of traditional owners and recreational fishers.
'If approved, we will grow the operations cautiously and sustainably, in line with market demands,' they said.
'We are proud and humbled to have secured the consent for the project via a voluntary Indigenous Land Use Agreement … we welcome the passion for the local environment from groups like Environs Kimberley, something we share, and hope they'll take up our offer to engage with us directly on this project.'
They supplied a document outlining why barramundi was considered a climate-resilient aquaculture species.
The Shire of Derby/West Kimberley acknowledged the public interest in the proposal and said it had confidence in the EPA process and was engaging with the regulator to better understand the project.
Loading
'The shire would work with Tassal to assess and potentially accommodate waste disposal; however, if the volumes were beyond the capacity of local infrastructure, alternative arrangements would need to be found,' it stated.
In December, before the Tasmanian fish kill, in giving consent to enter into the Indigenous Land Use Agreement, Mayala traditional owners said they felt Tassal would be able to manage any environmental issues. Mayala Inninalang Aboriginal Corporation was contacted for updated comment.
The federal environment department is running its own public environment review parallel to the state process, with a public comment period yet to open.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

RBA mulls more rate cuts as world prepares for Liberation Day 2.0
RBA mulls more rate cuts as world prepares for Liberation Day 2.0

The Age

timean hour ago

  • The Age

RBA mulls more rate cuts as world prepares for Liberation Day 2.0

The Reserve Bank is poised to deliver its fastest cut in interest rates since the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic as it seeks to protect the economy from the fallout of US President Donald Trump's latest tariff war and encourage households to open their wallets. But the impact of the Trump plan may turn out to be a small positive if United States-based manufacturers leave America in favour of other nations with lower tariffs such as Australia, according to the independent Productivity Commission. The Reserve Bank's monetary policy board started its two-day meeting on Monday. Financial markets and most economists expect it to back a further quarter percentage point cut in the official cash rate. Following its May rate cut, interest rates would be at a two-year low of 3.6 per cent. It would be the first time the bank has delivered back-to-back rate cuts since March 2020 when the RBA sought to protect the country from the fallout of the pandemic. On a $600,000 mortgage, a rate cut on Tuesday would be worth $100 a month and take to $300 the monthly savings since the Reserve Bank started easing monetary policy in February. Loading Lower inflation, which fell to 2.1 per cent in May, and sluggish economic growth combined with the potential fallout from the Trump tariff agenda have all driven up expectations of a rate cut on Tuesday with a high chance of another rate reduction in August. An ongoing concern has been the continuing strength of the jobs market. Unemployment has remained about 4.1 per cent for the past year with the country adding almost 330,000 jobs. The latest ANZ-Indeed measure of job ads, released on Monday, lifted by 1.8 per cent in June to be at its highest level in a year.

RBA mulls more rate cuts as world prepares for Liberation Day 2.0
RBA mulls more rate cuts as world prepares for Liberation Day 2.0

Sydney Morning Herald

timean hour ago

  • Sydney Morning Herald

RBA mulls more rate cuts as world prepares for Liberation Day 2.0

The Reserve Bank is poised to deliver its fastest cut in interest rates since the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic as it seeks to protect the economy from the fallout of US President Donald Trump's latest tariff war and encourage households to open their wallets. But the impact of the Trump plan may turn out to be a small positive if United States-based manufacturers leave America in favour of other nations with lower tariffs such as Australia, according to the independent Productivity Commission. The Reserve Bank's monetary policy board started its two-day meeting on Monday. Financial markets and most economists expect it to back a further quarter percentage point cut in the official cash rate. Following its May rate cut, interest rates would be at a two-year low of 3.6 per cent. It would be the first time the bank has delivered back-to-back rate cuts since March 2020 when the RBA sought to protect the country from the fallout of the pandemic. On a $600,000 mortgage, a rate cut on Tuesday would be worth $100 a month and take to $300 the monthly savings since the Reserve Bank started easing monetary policy in February. Loading Lower inflation, which fell to 2.1 per cent in May, and sluggish economic growth combined with the potential fallout from the Trump tariff agenda have all driven up expectations of a rate cut on Tuesday with a high chance of another rate reduction in August. An ongoing concern has been the continuing strength of the jobs market. Unemployment has remained about 4.1 per cent for the past year with the country adding almost 330,000 jobs. The latest ANZ-Indeed measure of job ads, released on Monday, lifted by 1.8 per cent in June to be at its highest level in a year.

BMG unlocks Wiluna Mining processing option for Wiluna gold
BMG unlocks Wiluna Mining processing option for Wiluna gold

West Australian

time6 hours ago

  • West Australian

BMG unlocks Wiluna Mining processing option for Wiluna gold

In a transformational move, BMG Resources has executed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) clearing a path to toll treatment of its Abercromby gold ore at Wiluna Mining Corporation's Matilda plant. Wiluna Mining's fully operational conventional carbon-in-leach (CIL) gold ore processing facility is 20 kilometres northeast of BMG's project and is well-suited to process the company's Abercromby ore. The well-credentialled operation processes Wiluna Mining's ore and accepts third-party feed. The MoU lays out a structure for the two companies to enter an ore toll treatment arrangement to mill and process the Abercromby ore. It offers an ideal processing solution to support BMG's mine development scoping study for Abercromby to deliver a practicable financial model. BMG has worked up a handsome resource at Abercromby comprising 11.12 million tonnes averaging 1.45 grams per tonne (g/t) gold for 518,000 ounces of the precious metal. The resource comprises open pit and underground inferred resources totalling 353,000 ounces of gold, while indicated open pit and underground resources make up a further 165,000 ounces of gold. Metallurgical testwork has shown Abercromby's near-surface, free-milling ore to be amenable to conventional CIL processing. BMG says the global resource features high-grade gold zones, including 935,000 tonnes at 5.06g/t gold for 150,000 ounces, which could be selectively mined in an earlier stage of mine development. BMG envisages delivering ore to the Matilda run-of-mine pad. Wiluna Mining will crush and process the ore, then deliver the gold to a yet-to-be-agreed refinery. BMG anticipates retaining title to the ore during the process. The processing fee will likely be based on a fixed rate per tonne of ore processed, subject to adjustments. Abercromby offers BMG advantages beyond its favourable compatible metallurgy. The project is on a granted mining lease, which eases the mine permitting process, and it is close to infrastructure, including grid power and trafficable roads and at 20km from the Matilda plant, it is within close ore-hauling distance. The soaring gold price also supports BMG's plans to advance its commercial strategy for accelerating Abercromby to near-term development and early exploitation. The new MoU and imminent finalisation of a toll-treating arrangement represent a giant step towards the company's transition from developer to producer. BMG is now pressing ahead with a scoping study to evaluate Abercromby's best low-capex, high-margin options for a potential earliest possible mining venture. Is your ASX-listed company doing something interesting? Contact:

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store