logo
Soccer has changed, but the drama and dynamics of penalties remain

Soccer has changed, but the drama and dynamics of penalties remain

The Guardian6 days ago
England's victory over Sweden at the women's Euros came after one of the worst penalty shootouts in history (or at least, worst in terms of how many penalties were missed; in terms of drama, it was arguably one of the greatest ever). Of the 14 penalties taken, only five were scored. That led, predictably, to the usual tedious criticism of the women's game and suggestions that the penalty spot should be moved closer to the goal.
Which is, of course, nonsense. Four of the five penalties that were scored were excellent, hit firmly into the corners, and the other, the kick that turned out to be the winner, was smashed sensibly and without fuss, straight down the middle by Lucy Bronze as the goalkeeper Jennifer Falk dived out of the way. Two nights later, as Germany beat France in a shootout, 12 of the 14 penalties were scored. In the Women's Super League last season, 90.32% of penalties were converted. Nobody has used those examples to suggest moving the penalty spot further away to give goalkeepers more of a chance.
Sign up to Soccer with Jonathan Wilson
Jonathan Wilson brings expert analysis on the biggest stories from European soccer
after newsletter promotion
It is one of the great fascinations of soccer that, since penalties were introduced in 1891, the spot has remained 12 yards from goal as the size and shape of the penalty area has changed. It turns out that being one-and-a-half times further from the goal than the distance between the posts creates a scenario that feels fair and has a remarkable balance. That may in part be the result of familiarity, but at almost every level of the game in the 135 years since, roughly three-quarters of penalties have been scored. That is to say, the contest between striker and goalkeeper remained constant – a relative lack of power in the striker at junior level, for instance, matched by a lack of size in the goalkeeper.
Before the Germany v France shootout on Saturday, only 12 of 29 penalties had been scored at the Euros – 41.38%. After the shootout, that percentage had risen to 57.14%. With small datasets there's always a danger of interpreting random variations as patterns, but it did seem that panic had set in. Even before the high tension of England against Sweden, Norway's former Ballon d'Or winner Ada Hegerberg had missed two penalties in the tournament, including, critically, in her country's quarter-final defeat to Italy.
That, perhaps, was enough to plant a seed of doubt, which blossomed in England and Sweden's shootout, when both sides suffered a collective loss of nerve. Anxiety is contagious and far from unknown in penalty shootouts: it happened, for instance, to Barcelona as they missed four out of four in a shootout against Steaua Bucharest in the 1986 European Cup final, and to Manchester United as they missed four out of five against Sunderland in the 2014 League Cup semi-final. The England-Sweden contagion then seemed to escape the confines of its own shootout, as Spain missed two penalties in beating Switzerland on Friday and Germany missed a penalty against France in the 90 minutes.
The shootout is perhaps the area of soccer in which psychology matters most. In the 2006 World Cup, Germany's goalkeeper Jens Lehmann made great play of consulting notes he had scribbled on hotel notepaper and hidden in his sock before each Argentina penalty in the quarter-final. It turned out that, of the seven players he had jotted down, only two actually took penalties, but the belief he had specific knowledge was enough to unnerve Argentina, who lost the shootout 4–2.
Goalkeepers increasingly have data to help inform their decisions. Germany's keeper on Sunday, Ann-Katrin Berger, had notes taped to her water bottle. On TV, the names of only two French players were clearly visible: Amel Majri and Alice Sombath. In both cases, Berger was advised to dive left. She did and on each occasion saved the kick. Given Berger's notes were shown clearly several minutes before the end of normal time, could somebody have informed the French staff who could then have passed on the message for at least some of their takers to change plan? Or would asking a player to vary from their preferred method of conversion itself make them more likely to miss? That's part of the glorious game theory of penalties.
At the moment, it feels like an arms race. VAR set goalkeepers back for a time, denying them the skip forward they habitually took as the penalty was taken. But goalkeepers have now worked out how to advance with one foot, the other remaining in contact with the goalline. As strikers have learned how to stagger their run to wait for the keeper to move first, so keepers have more data and can predict such subterfuge.
In the Premier League last season, 83.13% of penalties were converted, which is on the high side historically, but actually a drop of just over 6% from the previous season. The season before that, only 74.75% were scored. In fact, what is striking when looking at penalty conversion rates over the past three decades is how little pattern there is – from a low of 65.75% in 2001–02 to the high of the season before last, and all points in between.
Penalties are missed, penalties are scored, the taker's cause is developed, and then the keeper's, and sometimes panic sets in, yet somehow the proportion of penalties scored largely remains at 75-80%. Balance remains.
This is an extract from Soccer with Jonathan Wilson, a weekly look from the Guardian US at the game in Europe and beyond. Subscribe for free here. Have a question for Jonathan? Email soccerwithjw@theguardian.com, and he'll answer the best in a future edition.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

England warrior reveals she played whole of Euro 2025 with brutal injury
England warrior reveals she played whole of Euro 2025 with brutal injury

Metro

time29 minutes ago

  • Metro

England warrior reveals she played whole of Euro 2025 with brutal injury

England legend Lucy Bronze revealed she played the entirety of Euro 2025 with a fractured tibia after the penalty shootout win over Spain in Sunday's final. The Lionesses bounced back from conceding a first half opener to Spain in Basel, with Alessia Russo scoring an equaliser just before the hour mark. The match was 1-1 at 90 minutes and remained so at the end of extra time, heading to a nerve-shredding penalty shootout. Both teams faltered, but England got over the line with a 3-1 victory, thanks to two saves from goalkeeper Hannah Hampton and a winning spot kick from Chloe Kelly. Bronze had to be taken off during extra time after suffering a knee injury and it must have been serious because she had already shown her immense toughness. The 140-cap full-back revealed that she has had a fractured tibia for the whole tournament, the tibia is sometimes known as the shin bone. 'I've actually played the whole tournament with a fractured tibia, but no one knew,' she told the BBC. 'And now I've just hurt my knee today on the other leg. 'I think that's why I got a lot of praise from the girls after the Sweden game because I've been in a lot of pain, but that's what it takes to play for England so that's what I'll do. 'They know that, I think we inspire each other by playing through things like that and it got to the end, in the end.' Asked how bad the pain has been, she said: 'Very painful.' The Lionesses have defended their European Championship title in extremely dramatic circumstances, having needed penalties to beat Sweden in the quarter-finals and extra time to get past Italy in the semis. Bronze stepped up to score one of the spot-kicks against Sweden and felt the resilience of the team throughout the tournament has been immense. 'We never lost belief in ourselves,' she said. 'I think there was a lot of noise on the outside but we just stuck together and dug deep. 'We showed that in all the knockout games, to go 120 minutes back-to-back-to-back is incredible. 'To win on penalties, two games, this team is so inspiring to be a part of. We just give each other energy I think what we've done today is just unbelievable.' She added: 'Today we've just shown resilience, the fight we've had through all the tournament. We've shown everyone to believe in yourself no matter what other people say about you and to believe in the people that give you that support. 'I think that's what we showed throughout the tournament. We showed that today and that's what's got us the trophy.' England's record goal-scorer, Ellen White, said of her former teammate: 'I mean this in the nicest way but she's not human. 'She's proper England. She's just won a major tournament on a fractured tibia, that's not normal, the pain must have been insane and she smashed that ball in the Sweden game. 'That's true to Lucy Bronze, she will give everything to play for England and win for England.' MORE: Hannah Hampton was told she would never play football due to a serious eye condition MORE: Hannah Hampton reveals message Sarina Wiegman gave England players before shootout drama MORE: Why Beth Mead was allowed to take penalty twice in England's Women's Euro 2025 triumph over Spain

Lucy Bronze played through pain of fractured tibia to secure Euro 2025 glory
Lucy Bronze played through pain of fractured tibia to secure Euro 2025 glory

The Independent

time29 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Lucy Bronze played through pain of fractured tibia to secure Euro 2025 glory

Lucy Bronze revealed she had played the whole of England's victorious Women's European Championship campaign with a fractured tibia. The 33-year-old full-back had played every minute of the tournament until she succumbed to a separate knee injury at half-time of extra time during Sunday's final in Basel. Speaking after their quarter-final penalty shootout triumph over Sweden, when Bronze scored a crucial spot-kick, England boss Sarina Wiegman said of the defender: 'I think the only way to get her off the pitch is in the wheelchair.' Bronze, now a two-time European champion with the Lionesses, opened up about her injuries following their 3-1 penalty shootout win over Spain. 'We never lost belief in ourselves. There was a lot of noise on the outside, but we just stuck together and dug deep,' she told BBC One. 'We showed that in the all the knockout games, to go 120 minutes and go back to back to back, is incredible. To win on penalties, in two games… this team is so inspiring to be part of. 'We give each other energy and what we have achieved today is incredible. 'Today we have just showed resilience, like we have through all the tournament. The want to believe in ourselves and believe in the people who give you support. 'I've actually played the whole tournament with a fractured tibia, but no one knew. And now I've hurt my knee on the other leg. 'I think that is why I got a lot of praise from the girls after the Sweden game because I'm in a lot of pain, but that's what it takes to play for England and that's what I will do. They know that and we inspire each other by playing through things like that, and it got us to the end in the end.' Chloe Kelly insisted she was never in doubt when stepping up to take the match-winning penalty. 'I'm so proud of this team, so grateful to wear this badge and so proud to be English,' Kelly said. 'I was cool, I was composed, I knew I going to hit the back of the net. I don't miss penalties twice. 'It's unbelievable, it's not just this team it's the staff behind us. Twenty-three players and all the staff behind us. Sarina Wiegman has done it again. It's unbelievable. 'It's going to be crazy. I hope the whole of England comes out to support us and show the love to all these girls because they deserve it.' Hannah Hampton admitted she 'lost track' of the scoreline during final's penalty shootout. 'This team is just unbelievable, incredible,' the England goalkeeper said. 'We've shown throughout the tournament we can come back when we go a goal back. We've got that grit, that English blood in us. We never say die, we keep going and we did that today. 'When Chloe stepped up I turned around to the fans, miming a kick and trying to ask if we score do we win, I'd completely lost track. 'They were just cheering at me so I didn't know what the answer was, but then I saw that run up and that was it, we've won. I can't believe it.'

England seize Euro 2025 glory over Spain after Chloe Kelly settles dramatic penalty shootout
England seize Euro 2025 glory over Spain after Chloe Kelly settles dramatic penalty shootout

The Independent

time29 minutes ago

  • The Independent

England seize Euro 2025 glory over Spain after Chloe Kelly settles dramatic penalty shootout

Substitute Chloe Kelly slammed home the winning spot kick for England in a dramatic shootout to complete a remarkable comeback to down world champions Spain 3-1 on penalties in the Euro 2025 final. The Lionesses stormed back in Basel after going behind in the first half through Mariona Caldentey's opener, with Alessia Russo's towering header levelling the match and forcing extra-time. And despite a scare in extra-time after Salma Paralluelo's miss from close range, Sarina Wiegman's side, playing their third successive major final, gained revenge on Spain after World Cup heartache in 2023 in Sydney. Hannah Hampton emerged as the player of the match after two spectacular saves in the shootout before Kelly, who had clinched glory at Wembley three years ago in extra time, held her nerve to blast past Cata Coll at St Jakob Park. "I am so proud of this team. So grateful to wear this badge. So proud to be English,' said the Arsenal star, who was only on the pitch after Lauren James hobbled off before half-time with an ankle issue. "I was cool, I was composed. I knew I was going to hit the back of the net. I don't miss penalties twice. "Unbelievable. All the staff behind us and Sarina Wiegman - she has done it again! Unbelievable. It is going to be crazy. I hope the whole of England comes out to support us and shows their love to these girls as they deserve it." England have started slowly throughout the tournament, but hit Spain hard early on and could have lead through Russo, whose shot from a narrow angle down the right forced Coll into a save, with James unable to connect with the rebound. Hampton was also in top form, denying Esther Gonzalez, before Laia Aleixandri's mistake allowed Lauren Hemp to intercept inside the penalty area, only for Coll to miraculously deny the Lionesses once again. After Kelly replaced James before the break, Hampton was forced into action to deny the reigning Ballon d'Or winner Aitana Bonmati and Caldentey, before Russo left her mark on goal to equalise. Both sides navigated a tense period of extra-time before Beth Mead missed first in the shootout with a retaken spot kick, only for Hampton to haul England back into the contest by denying Caldentey and Bonmati. Captain Leah Williamson missed immediately afterwards, with England only leading 2-1, but Salma Paralluelo missed the target, guiding her shot wide of the post to set up Kelly for a shot at glory once again. And her penalty landed in the roof of the net to spark wild scenes of celebration with Wiegman left stunned at a personal third successive European title after a spell with Netherlands before taking over England. She said: "No, I can't believe it! We said we can win by any means and that's what we have shown again today. I am so proud of the team and the staff. It is incredible. "I just can't believe it. I have a medal around my neck and we have a trophy. It has been the most chaotic tournament on the pitch - all the challenges we had on the pitch against our opponent. "From the first game it was chaos. Losing your first game and becoming European Champions is incredible. Football is chaos."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store