Supreme Court gender ruling sees clash at Stormont assembly
The Supreme Court ruling has significant implications for single-sex spaces in Great Britain, such as female changing rooms and toilets.The court had been asked to decide on the proper interpretation of the 2010 Equality Act, which applies across Great Britain but not in Northern Ireland.Northern Ireland's Equality Commission has said it aims to publish new formal guidance in June.Speaking in the assembly, Buckley welcomed the "unanimous, landmark ruling".He added: "How ridiculous have things become that it took the UK Supreme Court to rule on the definition of a woman - something that the vast majority of people already knew the answer to."The member of the legislative assembly (MLA) accused other Stormont parties of promoting a "warped and dangerous ideology" on gender issues.O'Neill called for "sensitivity" in the debate, saying that transgender people were "feeling quite attacked right now"."These are complex issues and we need to work our way through the outworking of the Supreme Court ruling," she said.The Sinn Féin MLA added: "We ourselves have sought advice from our own officials."We await the Equality Commission's ruling and guidance because I think that will be important for everybody in terms of how we would respond to this in a wider way."
Alliance Party MLA Nuala McAllister said the court ruling "must not be used to fuel division or hostility"."We have seen those divisive culture wars, filled with misinformation, result in real-world consequences, with hate crimes against the trans community rising in recent years across the globe," she said.McAllister said the ruling "has not provided clarity around its real-world implications"."Any response here in Northern Ireland should be carefully considered," she added.Ulster Unionist Party (UUP) Doug Beattie said the trans community remained a protected group under the law.He said the court ruling was about "privacy, safety and dignity" and "above all, it's about women's rights"."Women wanting their own space at sport, groups, refuges, hospital wards or toilets should never be viewed as controversial," he added.Beattie said "clear, detailed guidance" was now needed from the Equality Commission in Northern Ireland.Social Democratic and Labour Party (SDLP) assembly member Matthew O'Toole, leader of the opposition at Stormont, said the debate had become "tragically toxic".He said the "hard-fought rights of women" and those of the transgender community "do not have to be in competition or in opposition with one another"."That judgment does not render invisible or meaningless the lives and experiences of trans people," he added.He said some of the debate had "drifted into stigmatising and humiliating those people".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
5 hours ago
- NBC News
Trump administration shuts down LGBTQ youth suicide hotline
The Trump administration on Thursday afternoon officially terminated the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline's LGBTQ Youth Specialized Services program, which gave callers under age 25 the option to speak with LGBTQ-trained counselors. The announcement that the specialized service would be shuttered was made last month by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA). The agency said it would 'no longer silo LGB+ youth services' — notably removing the 'T' representing the transgender community — and would instead 'focus on serving all help seekers.' 'Everyone who contacts the 988 Lifeline will continue to receive access to skilled, caring, culturally competent crisis counselors who can help with suicidal, substance misuse, or mental health crises, or any other kind of emotional distress. Anyone who calls the Lifeline will continue to receive compassion and help,' the agency stated at the time. The 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline launched in July 2022, two years after President Donald Trump signed the National Suicide Hotline Designation Act, making 988 the universal number for the national suicide prevention line. The bipartisan legislation noted that LGBTQ youths 'are more than 4 times more likely to contemplate suicide than their peers and stated that SAMHSA 'must be equipped to provide specialized resources' to high-risk populations, including LGBTQ youths. The specialized LGBTQ hotline was rolled out in October 2022, initially as a pilot program, receiving between $29.7 million and $33 million annually, according to SAMHSA. Also known as the 'Press 3 option,' the program gave 988 callers the option to 'press 3' to connect with a counselor trained to assist lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer youths and young adults (they could also text 988 with the word 'PRIDE'). Nearly 1.5 million contacts were routed to the LGBTQ service since its launch, according to data available on the SAMHSA website. The Trevor Project, an LGBTQ youth crisis intervention and suicide prevention organization, was initially the sole provider of the specialized service, but eventually seven providers were part of 988's LGBTQ Youth Subnetwork. Jaymes Black, CEO of the Trevor Project, called the termination of the service 'unfathomable.' 'This administration has made a dangerous decision to play politics with real young people's lives,' Black said in a statement. 'The 988 Lifeline's Specialized Services Program was created to serve Americans at highest risk for suicide — including veterans and LGBTQ+ youth — with best-practice crisis care that meets these populations' unique needs.' The option for 988 callers to press 1 if they are veterans or service members seeking specialized services will remain in operation. 'Sadly, more children are going to die in America because of this cut.' Rep. seth moulton, d-mass. Rep. Seth Moulton, D-Mass., who co-sponsored the legislation that paved the way for the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, spoke about the termination of the LGBTQ youth service in an interview with MSNBC on Wednesday. 'Kids are going to die,' Moulton said when asked about the termination's effects. 'This is actually the kind of thing Republicans should care about if they really care about American kids, because an extraordinary percentage of the people who call this lifeline in a moment of crisis say that it saved their lives.' 'As a veteran, I know how much it means to my fellow veterans to be able to push a button when they call 988 and get connected directly to a veterans crisis counselor — someone who's trained to deal with veterans. Well, LGBTQ kids need that, too,' he added. 'Sadly, more children are going to die in America because of this cut.' It wasn't just Democrats who criticized the decision to shutter 988's LGBTQ youth service. At a press conference outside the Capitol on Thursday, Rep. Mike Lawler, R-N.Y., joined several of his colleagues from across the aisle to speak out against the program's termination. 'This lifeline has provided help — it has connected young people with trained professionals who understand what they are going through, and in many cases, it has saved lives,' Lawler said. 'Cutting a program that is working, that is meeting a real and growing need, just does not make sense.' When asked for comment about the termination of the LGBTQ service and critics' claims, a SAMHSA spokesperson pointed NBC News to the agency's June statement announcing the service's forthcoming termination. A spokesperson for the Department of Health and Human Services, of which SAMHSA is a part, said the Press 3 option had run out of congressionally directed funding and added that continued operation of the specialized service would have required reallocating funds away from the main 988 Lifeline, possibly resulting in massive reductions in service. While 988 has discontinued its LGBTQ youth service, LGBTQ youths and young adults seeking specialized crisis intervention and suicide prevention help can still contact the Trevor Project for such services by calling 1-866-488-7386, texting START to 678678 or visiting Some states are also planning to help fill the gap left by the termination of 988's specialized service for LGBTQ youth. California Gov. Gavin Newsom announced Wednesday that the state's Health and Human Services Agency would partner with the Trevor Project to provide the state's 988 crisis counselors with enhanced competency training in addition to the training they already receive. 'While the Trump administration continues its attacks on LGBTQ kids, California has a message to the community: we see you and we're here for you,' Newsom said in a statement. 'We're proud to work with the Trevor Project to ensure that every person in our state can get the support they need to live a happy, healthy life.'
Belfast Telegraph
5 hours ago
- Belfast Telegraph
An Open and shut case: Stormont leaders ducking questions is just par for the course
We were all teed up for a rare chance to question Stormont's leaders — but in the end everyone was left feeling distinctly under par. While Michelle O'Neill and Emma Little-Pengelly were all smiles at The Open, media outlets were far from impressed after a promised press conference was pushed back, and back, and back — and then cancelled.
ITV News
7 hours ago
- ITV News
Little-Pengelly ‘saddened and disappointed' by cancellation of sport summer camp
North Down Cricket Club has said its decision to cancel a children's camp in Comber involving young people from East Belfast GAA was not influenced, and had been taken before, any comment from Goldsprings Orange Lodge. In an updated statement on Thursday afternoon, the club said concerns were raised with it privately and later publicly on social media. Posting on Facebook today, the lodge said it supports cross-community initiatives but suggested the GAA "remains overtly political in its constitution". Cricket Ireland has made alternative plans for the camp, which was due to take place tomorrow. Earlier the Deputy First Minister, Emma Little-Pengelly, has expressed her disappointment at the cancellation of the cross-community sports camp. First Minister Michelle O'Neill also reiterated her dismay. On Wednesday, Cricket Ireland announced it plans to step in to arrange a similar sports camp at Stormont later this month. Speaking during a visit to the Open in Portrush on Thursday, Ms O'Neill and Ms Little-Pengelly both expressed disappointment at what had happened. Ms Little-Pengelly said 'while there are legitimate questions to be asked of the GAA around their lack of inclusion, this is not the time or place'. 'Sport can be a great unifier,' she said. It's been really disappointing, very saddened to see that the club felt that they had to cancel this particular summer camp. 'I've reached out, and I've been speaking to the North Down Cricket Club. 'Of course, there are legitimate questions to be asked of the GAA around their lack of inclusion and the barriers that many feel to participation, but this is not the time or place. The time and place for that is not a children's summer camp. 'Cricket has been a great unifier right across all different types of religions, races, politics, we see that play out every single week, and I think it's really disappointing that these young people won't get that opportunity to play cricket at that summer camp but I'm continuing to work with the club, and with others, to see what the opportunities may be in the future.' Michelle O'Neill said: 'I was so deeply disappointed that anyone thought it was appropriate to advocate that these kids should not be invited along. 'For kids to come together through the medium of sport. It's just something that should always be a positive experience. So it makes me really sad to actually hear that someone doesn't want those kids to be invited. 'It's just totally not acceptable. Young people should play sport together, young people from all different backgrounds should always be encouraged to come together.' Ms O'Neill added she was 'quite dismayed by the fact that somebody thought it was appropriate to actually advocate against that'.
