Development spending falls short
The government on Thursday released a new development report, revealing that it could hardly spend Rs449 billion during the first ten months of this fiscal year, which was Rs648 billion less than the planned spending and affected projects across all the sectors.
Such a low spending against an annual allocation of Rs1.1 trillion renders the entire exercise of approving large-size Public Sector Development Programme by the National Assembly to cosmetic. The Finance Ministry controls the spending as a tool to offset the negative impact of tax shortfall sustained by the Federal Board of Revenue.
The development came amid Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal's statement on Thursday that for the next fiscal year 2025-26, the Finance Ministry has indicated only Rs921 billion for the PSDP. The Rs921 billion indicative budget was only equal to 58% of the development needs of Rs1.6 trillion for the next fiscal year, he added.
The minister was speaking during the launching ceremony of the new series, the monthly Development Outlook. The first of its kind monthly Development Update report has been initiated by the recently appointed chief economist of Pakistan Dr Imtiaz Ahmad in line with his earlier report of monthly economic outlook that he began in the Finance Ministry.
While speaking at the occasion, Ahsan Iqbal admitted that the projects with inflated costs had been approved in the past and there were also leakages. Since 1997, Ahsan Iqbal has remained the Deputy Chairman of the Planning Commission for four times and chaired those meetings where these projects were approved.
The new report does not paint a rosy picture for the government and its narration underscores that the claimed fiscal stabilisation has been mainly achieved by containing the development expenditures.
The government had planned to spend the entire nearly Rs1.1 trillion development budget in the first 10 months of this fiscal year. "According to the SAP system, ministries, divisions have utilised Rs448.6 billion ie 50% of authorisation and 41% of allocation", according to the development outlook report.
The report further stated that based on the quarterly release strategy of the Finance Division, the Planning Ministry authorised a total of Rs894 billion (82% so far) including Rs229.5 billion during the fourth quarter in April, 2025. Further authorisation is being made on the basis of adjusted PSDP and satisfactory pace of utilization, it added.
For the sake of the International Monetary Fund (MF) programme, the Finance Ministry has squeezed the PSDP to achieve quarterly primary surplus targets. Both the Planning Ministry and the Pakistan Peoples Party have termed the next fiscal year's indicative less than Rs1 trillion budget insufficient.
While launching the first report, Ahsan Iqbal said that the ministry was strengthening mechanisms to stop the leakages and corruption in the development projects. He further said that in many sectors, the projects had been approved with the inflated cost. He said that with a shrinking fiscal envelope, it was now more important to save every penny from being misused.
The development report stated that during the first ten months of this fiscal year, 191 out of 240 projects have been monitored, while 27 of 32 projects have undergone formal evaluation. This project approach has contributed to notable cost savings, it added. In April 2025 alone, 20 mega projects were planned and another 20 were monitored, it added.
The report disclosed that the lower than the planned spending has impacted the projects across various sectors. It added the infrastructure sector was allocated Rs656 billion in the budget. The Rs27.4 billion was utilised during April 2025. Within this, the water subsector disbursements amounted to Rs19.7 billion till April, equivalent to 15.45% of its annual allocation of Rs127.6 billion.
The transport and communication sector received the largest yearly allocation of Rs271.6 billion but the expenditure remained low.
Despite thin fiscal space, the government was still adding either new projects or upward revising the cost of the already approved schemes. The report showed that in April alone, a total of 19 development projects were considered worth nearly Rs2 trillion. The key reason behind higher approval cost was the multiple fold increase in the cost of Dasu hydropower project.
Of these, 10 projects fell within the CDWP's financial approval authority, which is chaired by the Deputy Chairman Planning Commission. Nine projects exceeding the financial threshold were recommended to the Executive Committee of the National Economic Council (ECNEC) for final approval.
The report stated that these projects would generate 20,108 direct jobs and 100,690 indirect jobs. The water sector is claimed to contribute the highest share of employment opportunities, reflecting the labour intensive nature of infrastructure development.
In the domain of digital security and infrastructure, the CDWP granted in-principle approval to the "Gwadar Safe City Project", to bolster public safety and surveillance capabilities in the strategically significant Gwadar region.
The CDWP granted an in-principle recommendation for the revised "Dasu Hydropower Project at a staggering cost of Rs1.74 trillion, according to the report.
The Planning Ministry said that it is a strategically significant federal initiative, as the project is a cornerstone of Pakistan's energy security strategy, aimed at delivering low-cost, renewable hydroelectric power to support sustainable economic growth and reduce dependence on imported fuels.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Planning minister apprises World Bank official about India's ‘water weaponisation' designs
ISLAMABAD: Minister for Planning, Development and Special Initiatives Ahsan Iqbal called on the international community to ensure India adheres to the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT). He warned that water weaponisation and violations of the treaty could trigger global food and water crises, posing serious risks to regional stability, adding that such actions can imperil the world peace. The minister shared these views in a meeting with Vice President of the World Bank for the Middle East and North Africa Osman Dione, who called on him in Planning Ministry, Islamabad, on Friday. In the meeting, matters regarding strengthening the collaborative partnership between the World Bank and the Ministry of Planning came under discussion. The minister asserted that adopting an export-led growth model is indispensable for sustainable development. He reaffirmed Pakistan's ambition to increase exports from $32 billion to $100 billion, aiming to boost economic growth and sustainability. During the meeting, the World Bank vice president lauded Professor Ahsan Iqbal's significant contributions towards improving Pakistan's economy. He also highlighted the government's successful efforts in curbing inflation through tough policy measures, which have restored investor confidence and driven the Pakistan Stock Exchange beyond the 130,000-point mark. Professor Iqbal stressed the importance of revitalising the previously established partnership between the ministry and the World Bank to accelerate progress in national development projects. The minister noted that the global economy is transitioning from an industrial-based to a technology-driven model, underscoring the need for Pakistan to adapt accordingly. The minister further underscored the government's commitment to addressing child stunting issue, describing it as a serious national challenge requiring urgent and effective intervention. He added that education remains a priority, with rising enrollment rate of girls in higher education signalling positive progress. Professor Iqbal stressed the pivotal role of women in achieving development goals, affirming the ministry's commitment to fostering women's active participation in all socio-economic initiatives. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
NA body orders urgent steps to end BISP staffing crisis
ISLAMABAD: The National Assembly Standing Committee on Poverty Alleviation and Social Safety ordered immediate action to resolve the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP)'s staffing crisis, directing the Poverty Alleviation Ministry to urgently engage the Finance Ministry and lift the recruitment freeze hampering welfare operations. The committee ordered immediate action to resolve BISP's staffing crisis, directing the Poverty Alleviation Ministry to urgently engage the Finance Ministry and lift the recruitment freeze hampering welfare operations. The committee also expressed serious concern over the continuously resistance from commercial banks in opening accounts for beneficiaries, with Private Financial Institutions (PFIs) demonstrating marked preference for their conventional clients over welfare recipients. The committee met with Mir Ghulam Ali Talpur in the chair at the Parliament house on Friday. The committee was told that the BISP is facing a staffing crisis of a shortage of personnel at various levels. This shortage is impacting the programme's ability to effectively serve beneficiaries and manage its operations, leading to concerns about service delivery and potential hardships for those relying on BISP's assistance The secretary Ministry of Poverty Alleviation and Social Safety confirmed to the Committee that a draft National Poverty Alleviation Policy is ready for and they are currently awaiting provincial governments' feedback, with a federal-provincial Poverty Alleviation Coordination Council to be established upon final approval. Presiding over a contentious review of Pakistan's welfare system, Mir Ghulam Ali Talpur led committee members in exposing banking sector roadblocks to BISP implementation while demanding urgent reforms to protect vulnerable beneficiaries. The meeting commenced with an acknowledgment of the ministry's compliance with the committee direction from previous proceedings, while members expressed concerns regarding incomplete responses in the submitted compliance report, particularly concerning State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) and demanded that Ministry to take up this matter with SBP. In response, the secretary BISP provided detailed dual-track solution involving simultaneous physical BISP Sahulat and digital wallet account initiatives. He said that the physical account pilot would commence in Karachi on August 14, symbolically aligning with Independence Day to emphasise country's downtrodden women financial emancipation. He said that concurrently, a digital account system will utilise biometric verification (BVS) through CNIC-linked mobile SIMs, mandated by recent SBP policy reforms. Both pilots will operate for six months, with comprehensive evaluations expected by January 2026. The committee emphasised the necessity of beneficiary orientation programmes, particularly, in underserved regions, to ensure effective adoption of these financial mechanisms. The committee raised questions regarding BISP's role in addressing the humanitarian crisis following recent building collapse in Karachi that left numerous poor women homeless. The secretary Ministry Poverty Alleviation and Social Safety and BISP clarified constitutional limitations, noting that housing and shelter interventions fall under provincial jurisdiction. The BISP advertisement budgetary transparency emerged as another critical discussion point, with committee members demanding detailed expenditure reports for BISP's media campaigns for the FY 2024-25 and current FY 2025-26, having found initial submissions insufficiently comprehensive. Operational challenges received considerable attention, including measures to address disbursement delays through enhanced two-factor authentication at payment campsites. Contractual enforcement emerged as a key concern, with the committee noting the termination of Habib Bank Limited's contract due to non-compliance and plans for similar and even more stricter penalties against such underperforming contracting private banks. The committee members also highlighted the outdated nature of the 2019 Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI) data shared by Ministry of Planning Development and Special Initiatives, directing them to produce updated and comparative analysis of the metrics in the next meeting. The committee was informed by the Pakistan Poverty Alleviation Fund (PPAF) about their foreign-funded projects worth Rs11.7 billion that are currently operating across 253 union councils, covering diverse initiatives from livestock value chains to micro-hydel and nutritional programmes. It is pertaining to mention here that the projects are focusing on poverty reduction and sustainable development in Pakistan. These projects, supported by organizations like the European Union and the Kreditanstalt für Wiederaufbau(KfW), target diverse areas such as agriculture, rural development, and access to energy. The Kfw is a German state-owned development bank, originally established after World War II. The KfW supports various development goals, including those related to climate action, energy efficiency, and sustainable development. The committee was briefed on the continuation of the National Poverty Graduation Programme with new donor agency, now expanded to include five additional districts alongside the original twenty, though procedural issues have temporarily excluded it from PSDP allocations. This comprehensive session underscored the committee's commitment to rigorous oversight of social safety initiatives while highlighting both institutional progress and systemic challenges requiring continued attention. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
PIDE holds seminar: Country's macro-economic indicators show signs of improvement
ISLAMABAD: Economists at a seminar while highlighting key economic challenges of Pakistan have said that the country's macroeconomic indicators have shown signs of improvement, such as declining inflation which is below five percent and a recent upgradation of credit rating by S&P from CCC+ to B-. Speaking at an event organised by Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE) here on Friday, they, however, emphasised the need to transition from mere stabilisation to robust growth to benefit the common people. The event brought together senior officials from the Ministry of Planning, Development and Special Initiatives, researchers, and economists to engage in a rigorous policy discussion. Speaking on the occasion, Dr Haider Ali explained that the seminar aimed to deliberate on aligning short-term macroeconomic stabilisation efforts with long-term sustainable growth strategies under the URAAN Pakistan framework. URAAN Pakistan is a strategic initiative by the Planning Commission built on the '5Es': Exports, E-Pakistan (digitalization), Environment, Energy, and Equity. Dr Khurram Ejaz presented a comprehensive overview of the current economic context and proposed strategies to move towards a stable growth path under URAAN Pakistan. He noted that Pakistan's economy has faced a multitude of external and internal shocks, including post-pandemic disruptions, the Russia-Ukraine conflict, and the devastating 2022 floods. These factors pushed the country toward fiscal and balance-of-payment crises, culminating in the signing of an Extended Fund Facility (EFF) with the IMF in September 2024. The IMF programme emphasised restoring macroeconomic stability through fiscal tightening, monetary policy, and external sector stabilisation. While it succeeded in curbing inflation and modestly reviving growth estimated at 2.7 percent, it limited the fiscal space for development spending capped at 2.6 percent of GDP. Dr Ejaz contrasted this with the ambitious targets of URAAN Pakistan, which envisions 6 percent GDP growth by 2029 with significantly higher employment generation. He acknowledged a critical financing gap between what is possible under the IMF framework and what URAAN Pakistan aspires to achieve. He proposed following five initial strategies to bridge this gap: (i) repositioning Development Finance Institutions (DFIs) to fulfill their core mandate rather than investing in low-risk securities; (ii) migrating suitable PSDP projects to Public-Private Partnership (PPP) mode to crowd in private capital; (iii) issuing diaspora, green, and SDG-linked bonds to unlock innovative financing; (iv) devolving social sector expenditures to provinces in a phased manner, and (v) reducing losses from state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and monetising non-strategic public assets such as ports under a structured asset recycling programme. Dr Nasir Iqbal questioned the underlying assumption that low growth is due to limited PSDP spending and argued that productivity, export orientation, and youth engagement are more critical to sustained growth than merely increasing public investment. He recommended establishing village-level economic zones, leveraging idle public infrastructure, and simplifying business registration to boost local entrepreneurship. Dr Karim Khan emphasized that IMF programmes and growth are not inherently contradictory and that sustainable growth must be private sector-led. He urged leveraging CPEC Phase-II and capitalising on productive investment avenues. Dr Shujaat Farooq added that governance reform and performance-based budgeting are crucial. He highlighted a disconnect between planning and finance ministries and stressed the need to engage provinces, whose PSDPs now exceed the federal government's in size. Dr Muhammad Zeshan noted the inefficiencies within PSDP allocations and tariff structures that perpetuate rent-seeking and protect low-productivity sectors. He advocated enabling emerging industries such as halal meat exports, seafood, and IT, and preparing for the Fourth Industrial Revolution through digitization, cloud infrastructure, and robotics. Shaaf Najib questioned the long-term impact of PSDP spending, citing studies that showed limited sustainability. He called for improving PSDP efficiency, prioritizing completed projects, and redirecting funds toward sectors with higher fiscal multipliers. Dr Mehmood Khalid appreciated the absence of tax rhetoric in the presentation but criticised the lack of growth diagnostics and the absence of evidence from existing research. He emphasised grounding all strategies within the URAAN Pakistan 5Es and aligning projections with realistic economic modeling. Dr Iftikhar echoed these sentiments, warning against public investment that crowds out private sector liquidity and highlighting inconsistencies in SEZ policies, HEC funding, and NFC allocations. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
