Man (42) spared trial for threatening to slit throat of TD Paul Murphy's wife
Dublin District Court had sought fitness-to-plead psychiatric reports on the accused, and on Thursday, 42-year-old Joseph Cloherty's non-jury hearing was expected to go ahead.
Advertisement
Mr Cloherty, of no fixed address, had earlier indicated that he would contest the charge, requiring Murphy to come to court and testify.
However, Judge John Hughes heard that the prosecution was not proceeding and applying to withdraw the case.
Judge Hughes noted that this followed a letter being sent by Cloherty to the Dublin South-West TD, apologising to both him and his wife, councillor Jessica Spear, and explaining the incident happened when he was going through a psychotic episode.
The apology was acceptable to the TD, who was not required to give evidence and left the court as Judge Hughes struck out the proceedings.
Advertisement
Defence solicitor Emer O'Sullivan also furnished a medical report on her client, who pleaded guilty to unrelated public order offences, resulting in a one-month suspended sentence.
Cloherty had nine prior convictions, mainly public order and motoring offences.
The threatening encounter with the politician occurred after the politician canvassed about abortion laws in Tallaght on May 23rd, 2023.
Cloherty faced a charge under section 5 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act.
Advertisement
Mr Cloherty was accused of having, without a lawful excuse, made a threat to Paul Murphy, intending him to believe it would be carried out that he would kill or cause serious harm to Jessica Spear.
Earlier, the court heard that Mr Cloherty had been hospitalised involuntarily.
A preliminary hearing in January was told that he denied the charge that he threatened the politician to his face that his wife would be seriously harmed.
Ms Spear is a People Before Profit councillor for Tallaght Central.
Advertisement
The Director of Public Prosecutions directed summary disposal of the case at the District Court level.
Outlining the evidence, Garda Elaine Markham had said that the TD had set up a stall at Belgard Square.
He was giving out leaflets about a pro-abortion bill when the accused allegedly "walked up to Paul Murphy and threatened to slit his wife's throat".
Gardaí took statements from her and the TD.
Advertisement
"That's a lie," Mr Cloherty had told the court after it heard a summary of the evidence.
Mr Cloherty had said, "They were talking about killing babies."
On conviction, the threat could have led to a fine and a 12-month sentence.
On Thursday, Garda Sergeant Nigel Petrie gave evidence on the two remaining unconnected offences, the use of threatening, abusive, insulting behaviour in public and resisting arrest on January 9th.
Sergeant Petrie said he spoke to Cloherty near the Royal Canal Bank in Dublin and was about to arrest him over a warrant.
Cloherty angrily shouted, "You have now entered the arena; you don't know what you've just done".
Ireland
Limerick feud escalates: House demolished after bo...
Read More
He resisted gardaí handcuffing or putting him into a patrol car, but the sergeant volunteered that it ranked at two or three out of ten in terms of seriousness.
He stressed that Cloherty subsequently sought him out to apologise, adding that he is now a very different man from the agitated person he met on the date of the arrest.
Ms O'Sullivan, pleading for leniency, said Cloherty was in homeless accommodation but goes to his mother's house every day. She and Cloherty's brother-in-law came to court, and the solicitor emphasised that he had family support and was now on antipsychotic medication.
Noting his apology, medical report and mitigation plea, Judge Hughes suspended the one-month term on condition he does not re-offend for two years, stays off cocaine and cannabis, and continues to attend appointments with a mental health professional and follow their directions.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Dublin youth charged with raping female when he was aged 15
A youth has been charged with raping a female in a Dublin apartment when he was aged 15. The 18-year-old appeared at the Dublin Children's Court this week and was remanded on bail to appear again in September to be served with a book of evidence and sent forward for trial to the Central Criminal Court. Advertisement The offence allegedly occurred in late 2022 in the city's north side. The youth, who cannot be named for legal reasons, has yet to enter a plea. There was no objection to bail. The Children's Court, which has lesser sentencing powers, does not have jurisdiction to hear a rape trial. Legal aid was granted. Bail terms stated he must have no contact with the complainant, not leave the jurisdiction, surrender his passport, provide gardaí with a contact phone number, sign on once a week and remain out of the area where the alleged incident occurred.
BreakingNews.ie
4 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Dublin man crashed €80k stolen car then tried to hijack another vehicle
A Dublin man who stole a car in order to get home from a day out with his girlfriend in Greystones, Co Wicklow, before crashing it and trying to hijack another vehicle has been jailed for five and half years. Alan Melia (31), of Cherry Orchard Avenue, Ballyfermot, pleaded guilty to the unauthorised taking of a vehicle as well as causing criminal damage to it to the value of €80,000 on February 9th, 2024. Advertisement He also pleaded guilty to a separate charge of attempting to hijack another vehicle on the same date. His girlfriend, Jade Burns (21), of Beatty Park, Celbridge, Co Kildare, separately pleaded guilty to charges of trespass and allowing herself to be carried in a stolen vehicle. A sitting of Wicklow Circuit Criminal Court heard that Melia had taken a brand new Toyota Land Cruiser from the driveway of a house at Blacklion, Greystones, Co Wicklow at around 7.30pm before crashing it a short distance away on Killincarrig Road, Greystones. Garda witnesses described how Melia drove forward and crashed the vehicle into a garden wall with Burns in the passenger seat after the owner of the vehicle, his wife and another male had attempted to stop him driving away. Advertisement They told prosecution counsel, James Kelly BL, that the other male was struck by an open passenger door as Melia then reversed out of the driveway. However, the owner of the Land Cruiser managed to get Burns out of the passenger seat from the vehicle before Melia made his getaway. The court heard he appeared to have lost control a short distance away and crashed into an ESB pole while driving 'at significant speed.' Gardaí said that Melia then attempted to hijack another vehicle from an eyewitness who had stopped his vehicle to assist the accused thinking he might have been seriously injured. Advertisement Evidence was given that Melia jumped into the rear seat of a white Mercedes-Benz before trying to climb into the driver's seat. A struggle ensued between the accused and the driver who managed to get out of the car with the keys of the vehicle. Melia was then detained by a number of individuals until gardaí arrived on the scene. The driver of the Mercedes-Benz told gardaí that Melia sounded incoherent and under the influence of something. Advertisement The accused was brought to St Vincent's University Hospital in Dublin for treatment but was discharged a short time later and brought to Bray Garda station. Melia, who was on bail at the time, made full admissions to gardaí when interviewed the following morning apart from disputing that he was trying to steal the Mercedes-Benz. The court heard he had 112 previous convictions. Melia is already serving a six and a half years prison sentence imposed by the Court of Appeal over an incident in which he rammed Garda vehicles while driving the wrong way down the M1 motorway after robbing a petrol station in Northern Ireland on August 23rd, 2020. Advertisement Burns, who had no previous convictions, was also cooperative although she did not identify Melia to gardaí and could not remember the incident. In a victim impact statement, the owner of the Toyota Land Cruiser, said it was an incident he wanted to forget and his child still had nightmares about it. The man said he had also suffered financially as he was out of work for weeks without his vehicle, while his motor insurance costs had also increased. Under cross-examination by counsel for Melia, Colman FitzGerald SC, gardaí acknowledged that the defendant wanted to take the jeep to drive home to Ballyfermot and agreed that it was not 'a planned enterprise.' Mr FitzGerald told Judge John Martin that the accused had very significant difficulties in his life from a young age and was 'caught up in a flurry of drug-taking and criminality.' 'There is a chaotic and criminal rhythm to his life,' Mr FitzGerald noted. Counsel for Burns, Comfort Odesola BL, said she was deeply remorseful and embarrassed about her actions. Ms Odesola said the accused had been brought up in foster care but had turned to drug abuse after she was 18. She told the court that Burns was hanging out with her boyfriend on the day before they decided to go to Greystones and there was no intention to commit any burglary. The barrister said what happened had been a catalyst for Burns to make changes and to take life more seriously. She noted that the accused was assessed at being at a moderate risk of reoffending due to being unemployed but stressed that she had 'cleaned up her act' and had been drug-free since the incident. Judge Martin said the evidence about Melia was 'most unimpressive' and noted that he had threatened a prison governor while in jail. Commenting on a report from the prison governor where he was described as 'nothing but trouble', the judge said he had 'never seen one like it.' He also observed that Melia was 'no stranger' to the unauthorised taking of vehicles. 'It was appalling behaviour. There is no other word for it,' said the judge. He claimed Melia had shown a persistence in attempting to take the vehicle and was 'determined to drive it like a dodgem.' The judge imposed sentences of six and a half years imprisonment for the criminal damage to the vehicle, four years for stealing it and four years for the attempted hijack with all terms to run concurrently. Judge Martin said he would suspend the final 12 months of the sentence for a period of two years to encourage rehabilitation and on condition that Melia places himself under the supervision of the Probation Service on his release and attend addiction counselling. Ireland Tributes paid to 'lovely quiet man' (26) who died... Read More He sentenced Burns to 18 months in prison for being carried in a stolen vehicle and six months for the trespass offence but suspended both sentences fully on condition she places herself under the supervision of the Probation Service for a period of two years. Addressing Burns the judge remarked: 'You got in with a bad lot and they have brought you down.' He also observed that she might not be in court if she had been in the stolen vehicle with Melia after he drove away. On her relationship with her co-accused, he advised: 'Maybe you could do better for yourself.'
The Independent
4 hours ago
- The Independent
Detail still lacking ‘but Ireland would be worse off without EU-US deal'
A swathe of tariffs imposed on other nations show Ireland would be worse off if there was not an EU-US trade deal, the Irish deputy premier said. US president Donald Trump signed an executive order that sees tariffs of 15% or above imposed on trading partners including Brazil, Lesotho, Taiwan and Switzerland. The EU struck a trade deal with the US five days before Mr Trump said a 30% tariff would kick in for the bloc. The deal sees 15% tariffs on most EU goods including cars, semiconductors and pharmaceuticals entering the US. There are 'zero for zero' tariffs on a number of products including aircraft, some agricultural goods and certain chemicals – as well as EU purchases of US energy worth 750 billion dollars over three years. Simon Harris said on Friday after a meeting of the trade forum at Government Buildings that a lot of detail of the agreement still needs to be clarified as he defended the deal. 'Without a deal between the US and the EU, today would have seen 30% tariffs introduced by President Trump on the EU, and would also have seen very, very significant counter measures introduced by the EU to the tune of around 90 odd billion euro,' the Tanaiste said. 'There's absolutely no doubt that that would have been a moment of catastrophe in terms of our economic wellbeing as a country.' He added: 'We'd be in a very different and a much worse position I think if we were standing here today with no deal. 'You don't have to take my word for that, if you just see the executive order last night and all of the tariffs levelled in other countries, including countries that didn't have deals. 'They were generally much, much higher than the tariff rate for the European Union.' He said the EU tariff rate of 15% would come into effect from August 7. Tariffs on pharmaceuticals would remain at zero until the US administration concludes its Section 232 investigation, relating to imported goods of importance to national security, into the sector. Mr Harris said he was informed by Brussels that this is expected to conclude in around two weeks. Mr Harris also said 'there is too many variables' to yet know the effect of the tariff differential between Northern Ireland and Ireland. He said he spoke with Northern Ireland First Minister Michelle O'Neill, deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly, and the Economy Minister Caoimhe Archibald who agreed on this. 'So to give you an example, at the moment butter in Ireland already has a tariff of around 16% on it, pre-existing. 'It's had 10% on top of that since President Trump's last round, so that's meant butter in Ireland had a tariff of 26%. Under the new EU deal, that will fall to 16%. 'Butter in the UK, if I can use that as a comparison, will actually probably end up with 16%, plus 10%, so 26%. 'I'm just using a pound of butter as an example here, but if you look at it, you know, at a headline rate, you'd say 'Well, there'd be lower tariff on butter in the UK than Ireland', and actually that's probably not the case. 'So we need to tease our way through this. But there is no doubt that there will be challenges that will have to be worked through.' He said: 'I suppose the last point I'd make is that this is a subset of businesses. It's really a subset of a subset, because this will obviously only affect businesses that are doing cross-border trade and exporting to the United States of America. So it's not to be in any way dismissive of that, but it will obviously only affect that proportion of the business community. 'Pharma is another example. I mean, the EU seems to have a commitment in writing to 15% or less, no more than 15% for pharma. 'The UK language is much more vague. It doesn't have a number beside it, so we'll need to see where that brings us in the weeks ahead.'
