Five Gisborne marae to move to safer ground with Govt support
The trustees of Puketawai, Hinemaurea ki Mangatuna, Okuri, Takipū and Rangatira Marae had made the "difficult decision" to relocate and re-establish their respective marae in new locations.
More than $136 million, which was allocated from Budgets 2023 and 2024 would fund the programme, including the costs to relocate owners of 24 whenua Māori properties, demolition of residential structures, and some assistance to support affected sites of cultural significance — principally urūpa.
Emergency Management Minister Mark Mitchell said the local council designated these marae as high risk and "not safe to occupy" because of "unacceptable risk to life from future extreme weather".
"Each of the marae have accepted the Crown's support package and have acquired new sites to relocate to. The new sites are in close proximity within, or close to, their respective tribal boundaries."
Mitchell said the impact of the severe weather on the marae was "devastating" for the many whānau, hapū, and the wider community connected to these marae.
"The decision to relocate is not an easy one and has come from the desire of the Marae Trustees to keep their marae, and their respective whānau, safe and secure, protecting the lives of those who might otherwise be at real risk from any future severe weather events."
Māori Development Minister Tama Potaka said relocating the individual marae would take time.
"We expect the relocation works, including the rebuild of wharenui and whare kai where required due to the damage, will take place over the next two or so years. For some of the marae, the project is a complete rebuild."
Of the five marae, three were located in the Uawa/Tolaga Bay area, with the other two in Te Karaka.
"The Crown is also working with two Kahungunu Marae, Tangoio and Petāne in Hawke's Bay with support packages available to both marae so they too can reestablish in safer locations," Potaka said, adding that reaching this point was a "significant milestone".
"Most importantly, it will provide affected whanau and hapu peace of mind, and will have the added benefit of creating opportunities for SMEs and jobs."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
a day ago
- 1News
Gisborne bach dispute: Resident fights council's red-sticker decision
A Gisborne resident is fighting to overturn the Council's decision to red-sticker her family's beachside property and deem it uninhabitable. High fences and danger signs line the outskirts of many properties along the eastern end of Makorori Beach Rd, including Amy-Kelly Clark's family bach, which she owns with her parents. Gisborne District Council says it will remove red-stickered placards when a property owner can prove that the damage has been fixed and the home is safe again. Clark said the family lived near the bach, which they used as a day house or to stay in during the summer. "Maybe if it's a cyclone, we won't stay there... or when it's pouring with rain for two weeks in the winter. ADVERTISEMENT "But they're just taking it away [with] no discussion or consultation." The property and some neighbouring ones were among the dozens of homes in the region assessed as category 3 after Cyclone Gabrielle in February 2023. It is the highest risk category under the Government's Future of Severely Affected Land (FOSAL) framework. Clark said the council did not list the house as category 3 until after a severe weather event in June 2023, four months after the cyclone. The council has made voluntary buyout offers for all category 3 properties, which are paid 50/50 by the Government and the council. Clark and her parents have refused the offer made to them. Category 3 means there is "an intolerable risk to life at the property," and that it is not possible to reduce the risk, the council says. ADVERTISEMENT However, Clark believes, after reviewing some of the reports the council used in its risk assessment, that there are ways to mitigate the risks of potential land movement. Local Democracy Reporting has seen a report from September 2023, commissioned by the council from GNS Science, that says a sudden, complete landslide is not expected. The report recommended further investigations and monitoring the area around Clark's home for further slope and dwelling movements, as well as consideration of conducting a mitigation assessment. LDR has seen a copy of a council report from May this year on the landslide risk to Makorori Beach Rd, which says the eastern end has "a high future threat to life with an annual probability of between 32 and 48%". It says that probability takes into account the physical parameters of the site, the collective views of experts over a long period, the landslide-inducing rainfall recurrence interval, the proximity of the dwellings and the demographic profile of likely occupants. The report has not been released to the public. A council spokesperson said the copy shared with LDR was not the most up-to-date version. Makorori Beach. (Source: Local Democracy Reporting) ADVERTISEMENT During a council meeting in December, Councillor Teddy Thompson asked why the council was pulling down "perfectly good" properties due to the Category 3 buyouts. "Even if you spent $300k on a retaining wall and saved the million-dollar house, aren't we better off doing that than spending $70k to pull it down?" Thompson said. Council chief executive Nedine Thatcher Swann said each house had been fully assessed by engineers and the council building team. "The qualification for being bought out was an intolerable risk to life," Swann said. The council said it issued red stickers to properties in emergencies after doing a Rapid Building Assessment (RBA) on the immediate risk. However, Clark says the council reapplied the red-sticker designation in January this year, when there was no emergency. She has challenged the decision through the Ministry of Business Innovation and Employment (MBIE), which has yet to make a ruling. ADVERTISEMENT In January, Clark used the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act to ask for reports on the bach. "Show us how our house is a threat to life, and a danger, because trust me, it's not," she said. The next day, a council staff member requested reports from the family's insurance loss adjuster for the third version of the risk assessment, she said. This assessment, which included private insurance information, was presented to a room of Makorori Beach residents. The family has made a complaint to the Privacy Commissioner. Council recovery manager Naomi Whitewood confirmed that another agency had advised the council that it may have disclosed personal information, in breach of the Privacy Act. "Council was requested to delete the disclosed personal information, which it did immediately." ADVERTISEMENT The privacy concerns had been appropriately addressed, Whitewood said. Of the latest red sticker, she said: "The council issues placards in emergencies after doing a Rapid Building Assessment to assess immediate risk. "A red placard means there was an immediate high risk to the property at the time of the RBA." The council was aware of Clark's concerns, including her belief that it had issued the stickers incorrectly, but it disagreed with this view. The council would remove red stickers only when a property owner could prove that damage had been fixed and that the home was safe again, Whitewood said. The type of information needed varied according to the risk but might include an engineering report showing no problem with slips, a structural engineering report showing the building was safe, or proof that a builder had fixed the problem. "Until that determination has been resolved, it would be inappropriate for the council to comment further on those matters." ADVERTISEMENT Clark said the family's next step would be to pay for a geotechnical engineer to rebut the council's report, which was costly. "If you don't have the time, money and resources to fight this, you're just going to get kicked out of your house," Clark said. The family did not dispute that there was a head scarp (a steep exposed slope at the top of a landslide) above their property. "But it's been there for [about] 50 years." LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
RNZ News
6 days ago
- RNZ News
More support for flood-affected farmers and growers as Motueka residents pick up the pieces
The government has unlocked extra support for flood-affected farmers and growers in Nelson, Tasman, and Marlborough, following last week's deluge. Agriculture Minister Todd McClay said it has been classified as a medium adverse event, as the weather damaged livestock fences, culverts, and tracks, and left pasture and orchards covered in silt and flood debris. The government is making up to $100,000 available to support and coordinate recovery efforts. The classification also unlocked further support like tax relief, and enabled the Ministry of Social Development to consider Rural Assistance Payments and activating Enhanced Taskforce Green. "Last week's deluge damaged infrastructure such as livestock fences, culverts, and tracks, and left pasture and orchards covered in silt and flood debris," McClay said. "The government is making up to $100,000 available to support and coordinate recovery efforts, including up to $20,000 for the Top of the South Rural Support Trust. The remainder of the funding will be made available to other organisations that work with farmers and growers on-the-ground." The funding is on top of $100,000 already contributed by the government to the Mayoral Relief Fund. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii It comes as Motueka Valley residents are clearing up properties, taking stock of damage and getting ready for the potential of another deluge of rain later this week. The area has been one of the hardest hit by flooding after the Motueka River burst its banks. Seventeen homes were deemed uninhabitable following the local state of emergency in Nelson and Tasman. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Scott Bowler was in his house bus named Tumbleweed near the Motueka River when a landslide came down on it during Friday night's storm. "It was a pretty scary experience actually because I thought my bus, my house and all that was going to be washed into the river," he said. Bowler had a pet goat named "Yeeetus" [spelt with three e's to mimic the sound he made] and a Great Dane named Ares. Yeeetus, caused a stir when the water started coming down. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii "The goat disappeared while we were all moving the cars and I thought oh here we go, the goat's gone," Bowler said. "But once we were all finished the goat came running back to the bus and he was happy as." He planned to move his bus closer to the coast in preparation for rain expected later this week. Ashton Wood owns an apple orchard near the Motueka River and said the water is the most he's seen during the 15-plus years he's been farming there. He called on authorities to bolster flood protection up the Motueka. Wood said that $2.2 million worth of work on the flood banks had been done from Woodmans Corner near the river to the township of Motueka. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii "That probably needs to be done the length of the river," he said. He lost one hectare's worth of apple trees and the water washed away fence posts and hundreds of storage bins. "I have never seen rain like it, in terms of a space of one hour the whole area was running with water," Wood said. He said he'd just have to see what happened with regard to more rain expected in the coming days. When RNZ arrived at Naomi Pickett's lifestyle property she was cleaning up items that had washed onto the land which included dead livestock, an exercise bike and crates. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Pickett spoke about how she felt when the water started rising on the weekend. "I felt like I was in Waterworld, you know the movie? Just like there above it all. "It was quite daunting really cause we have done this before, and we could see that there was a lot of silt in the water and a lot of stuff and that I was going to be a big clean up." She said the silt made her nervous about the prospect of more water later this week. "We are kind of concerned that because of the silt the water won't go in [to the land] and cause more flooding." Motueka Valley resident Bianca Fraser said the nearby river was loud when the rain was coming down on Friday. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii "It just sounded like the ocean was in our backyard." Fraser said her property was high enough above the river that she did not think she'd be affected by the additional rain forecast for Thursday, but she worried about her neighbours. There have been 373 weather-related insurance claims from Friday onwards across, home, contents, motor and commercial policies, with some claims as far north as Auckland. IAG executive general manager of claims, Stephannie Ferris, said with claims still to come through, she expected more homes would be deemed uninhabitable. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Scoop
6 days ago
- Scoop
Support For Flood Affected Farmers And Growers
Hon Todd McClay Minister of Agriculture Minister for Rural Communities The Government today classified the flooding across the Nelson, Tasman, and Marlborough regions as a medium-scale adverse event unlocking extra support for flood-affected farmers and growers Agriculture Minister Todd McClay, and Rural Communities Minister Mark Patterson say. 'Last week's deluge damaged infrastructure such as livestock fences, culverts, and tracks, and left pasture and orchards covered in silt and flood debris,' Mr McClay says. 'The Government is making up to $100,000 available to support and coordinate recovery efforts, including up to $20,000 for the Top of the South Rural Support Trust. The remainder of the funding will be made available to other organisations that work with farmers and growers on-the-ground. 'Today's classification unlocks further support for farmers and growers, including tax relief. It also enables MSD to consider Rural Assistance Payments and activating Enhanced Taskforce Green.' This funding is on top of $100,000 already contributed by the Government to the Mayoral Relief Fund. Mr Patterson is encouraging flood-affected farmers and growers to seek support if they need it and to monitor the weather forecast. 'It's important to help those farmers and growers and rural communities now facing a big clean-up effort, such as fixing damaged fences,' Mr Patterson says. 'The government, via Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) On Farm Support will continue to work closely with sector groups and the Rural Support Trust to determine where the need is and how the funding will be allocated. 'Farmers and growers will face many months of work to get back on track. We will continue to assess what further support is needed to assist recovery efforts. 'There is a risk of further rain this week. We are encouraging farmers to stay informed through MetService forecasts and to take necessary precautions, such as moving livestock to higher ground.' Farmers and growers who require support are encouraged to contact their local Rural Support Trust on 0800 787 254.
