Families, kids most at risk of losing HUD housing with Trump's proposed time limits
That's according to new research from New York University, obtained exclusively by The Associated Press, which suggests the time restriction could affect as many as 1.4 million households helped by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
The NYU report also raises concerns about the largely untested policy, as most of the limited number of local housing authorities that have voluntarily tried the idea eventually abandoned the pilots.
'If currently assisted households are subject to a two-year limit, that would lead to enormous disruption and large administrative costs," for public housing authorities, the report said, adding that once the limit was up, housing authorities "would have to evict all of these households and identify new households to replace them.'
Defining temporary assistance
Amid a worsening national affordable housing and homelessness crisis, President Donald Trump's administration is determined to reshape HUD's expansive role providing stable housing for low-income people, which has been at the heart of its mission for generations.
At a June congressional budget hearing, HUD Secretary Scott Turner argued reforms like time limits will fix waste and fraud in public housing and Section 8 voucher programs while motivating low-income families to work toward self-sufficiency.
'It's broken and deviated from its original purpose, which is to temporarily help Americans in need,' Turner said. 'HUD assistance is not supposed to be permanent.'
Elderly and disabled people would be exempted, but there's little guidance from the agency on how time-limited housing assistance would be implemented — how it would be enforced, when the clock starts and how the exemptions would be defined.
The NYU researchers dove deep into HUD's nationwide data over a 10-year period, analyzing nearly 4.9 million households that have been public housing and Section 8 voucher tenants. Of that, about 2.1 million could be affected by the time limits because they include at least one adult who is not elderly or disabled and about 70% of those households had already been living on those subsidies for two or more years.
HUD spokesperson Kasey Lovett pushed back on the NYU study.
'There is plenty of data that strongly supports time limits and shows that long-term government assistance without any incentive disincentivizes able-bodied Americans to work,' Lovett said in a statement.
Working families most at risk
The time limits could displace more than a million children, as it would largely punish families who are working but still earning far below their area's median income.
'Housing assistance is especially impactful for children,' said Claudia Aiken, the director of new research partnerships for the Housing Solutions Lab at NYU's Furman Center who co-authored the study with Ellie Lochhead. Their health, education, employment and earnings potential can 'change in really meaningful ways if they have stable housing,' Aiken said.
Havalah Hopkins, a 33-year-old single mom, has been living in a public housing unit outside of Seattle since 2022, but now fears a two-year time limit would leave her and her teenage son homeless. The 14-year-old boy has autism but is considered high-functioning, so how HUD defines disabled and 'able-bodied' for the time limit could determine if their family will be affected by the restriction.
Hopkins, who does catering work for a local chain restaurant, pays $450 a month in rent — 30% of her household income — for their two-bedroom apartment in Woodinville, Washington.
Asked what she likes most about her home, Hopkins said: 'I like that I can afford it.'
Few successful examples
Of the 17 housing authorities that tried time limits, 11 discontinued the trial. None tried two-year limits — the most common policy was a five-year limit with the option for an extra two and the limits usually applied to specific programs or referrals.
Although there are over 3,000 housing authorities in the country, only 139 of them have ever been granted flexibility to consider testing a time limit while using federal funds for programs such as job training and financial counseling.
'Any conversation about time limits ends up being this really nuanced, hyper-local focus on what works for specific communities rather than this broad national-level implementation,' said Jim Crawford, director of the Moving to Work Collaborative which oversees that group of housing authorities.
Even with those supports, several housing authorities said rent was still too high and well-paying jobs were scarce, according to the study. Others said they didn't have enough capacity to provide enough supportive services to help households afford rent.
Shawnté Spears of the Housing Authority of the County of San Mateo in California said the agency's five-year time limits have 'given folks motivation' to meet their goals in tandem with self-sufficiency programs funded by dollars Donald Trump wants to cut. Time limits also give more households the chance to use vouchers, she said.
But with the Bay Area's high rents, some tenants still have to spend more than half of their income on rent once their time is up or end up back on waitlists.
'I believe the program is very helpful in getting folks prepared but there lies this really, really significant rent burden here in our county,' said Spears. 'When folks do leave our time-limited program, they are facing an uphill battle.'
___
Kramon reported from Atlanta.
___
Kramon is a corps member for The Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues.
Solve the daily Crossword
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 minutes ago
- Yahoo
US auto safety agency shedding more than 25% of employees
WASHINGTON (Reuters) -The U.S. auto safety agency is shedding more than 25% of its employees under financial incentive programs to depart the government offered by the Trump administration, according to data provided to Congress seen by Reuters. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, part of the Transportation Department, is shrinking from 772 employees as of May 31 to 555 under the program. The Federal Highway Administration and Federal Transit Agency are also both losing more than 25% of their staff. Representative Rick Larsen, top Democrat on the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, expressed concerns about the cuts, questioning how USDOT can "expedite project delivery and advance safety with a decimated workforce." Error while retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data
Yahoo
2 minutes ago
- Yahoo
The next Fed chair's dilemma: Maintain Fed independence while pleasing Trump
It is becoming clear what the major challenge will be for Jerome Powell's successor: Maintaining the Fed's independence while keeping President Trump happy. Even if the president doesn't remove Powell before his term is up in 10 months, he has made it clear that he wants the next Fed boss to do what he wants: Bring interest rates down. "I'm only interested in low-interest people," he said Wednesday, while denying reports that he intended to fire Powell yet leaving the door open to doing so for "fraud." The various candidates who are being considered by Trump have all expressed a support for lower rates, including National Economic Council Director Kevin Hassett, former Fed governor Kevin Warsh, Fed governor Christopher Waller and Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent. Trump "is putting somebody in place who he says he expects to cut interest rates very aggressively," StoneX senior adviser Jon Hilsenrath told Yahoo Finance. "Whoever becomes the next Fed chair is going to have some implicit promise to live up to.' Media reports this week suggested that Hassett is now rising as a leading candidate. He benefits from being close to Trump, having worked for the president during both of his terms, but whether Wall Street will view that as a shot to central bank independence remains an open question. 'Kevin has the qualifications to get the Fed job because he is close to the president,' Hilsenrath added. 'In terms of doing the Fed job well, I think it will be a real challenge.' Hassett told NBC Wednesday evening that "everybody at the White House understands the independence of the Fed is super important." When central banks lose their independence, Hassett said, 'it's bad for the economy and bad for markets.' Hassett did agree that rates should be lower than where they are right now, matching the easing cycles of other central banks around the world. And the fact that rates have not been lowered raises a "legitimate concern that independence of the Fed is not being respected by Fed members themselves." Another candidate for Powell's job, Warsh, told CNBC Thursday that 'history tells us that the independent operations in the conduct of monetary policy is essential.' 'But that doesn't mean the Fed is independent in everything else it does,' he added, while arguing that the Fed's reluctance to cut rates "is actually quite a mark against them." 'Fed independence is a myth' US history is full of examples where American presidents challenged Fed chairs, including a confrontation between President Johnson and Fed Chairman Bill Martin in the 1960s. President Nixon also leaned on former Fed Chair Authur Burns to bring rates down before the 1972 presidential election. Nixon's White House even leaked false stories about Burns seeking a pay raise as way of undermining his authority. 'What's currently unfolding before our eyes has been happening for decades behind closed doors,' wrote JPMorgan Chase's Ilan Benhamou said in a note Thursday that cited the Johnson-Martin clash. 'What's happening for everyone to see is definitely damaging for the institution, but let's be honest, the Fed independence is a myth,' Benhamou added. The pressure on Powell is not due to let up, with Trump and other White House officials continuing to raise questions about Powell's handling of a $2.5 billion renovation of the Fed's headquarters. 'It seems as though every single day now we have the White House beating up the Fed' and Powell 'in particular,' Yardeni Research president Ed Yardeni told Yahoo Finance. Some Republicans are supportive of a Powell firing but others in that party that now controls Washington are starting to warn that any removal of Powell would in fact deal a blow to Fed independence. 'If anybody thinks it would be a good idea for the Fed to become another agency in the government subject to the president, they're making a huge mistake,' GOP North Carolina Sen. Thom Tillis said Wednesday. Majority Leader John Thune of South Dakota added on Fox News Wednesday night that 'I think the markets want an independent Federal Reserve. I think they want a central bank that isn't subject to the whims of politics.' Even Democratic Sen. Elizabeth Warren, a past critic of Powell, said Wednesday that 'markets will tank' if Trump fires Powell. 'When his initial attempts to bully Powell failed, Trump and Republicans in Congress suddenly decided to look into how much the Fed is spending on building renovations,' she added. 'Independence does not mean impunity and I have long pushed for more transparency and accountability at the Fed. But give me a break.' Click here for in-depth analysis of the latest stock market news and events moving stock prices
Yahoo
2 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Four experienced candidates are vying to be the sole guaranteed new face on Spokane Valley City Council
Jul. 17—Regardless of the outcome of elections, a new face will join the Spokane Valley City Council next year in Position 1. Spokane Valley has what is known as a council-city manager model of government, with the city council made up of seven nonpartisan members. Unlike in Spokane, where the mayor has real power over the day-to-day operations of city government, Spokane Valley's mayor is a council member who oversees meetings. Also unlike Spokane, elections for city council positions represent the whole city, not just specific districts. Incumbent Rod Higgins, a former mayor and the longest-serving member of the council, opted not to run for re-election to Position 1 earlier this year. "I can tell you firsthand, no, I don't think I'm Joe Biden, at least not in that bad of shape yet," Higgins told The Spokesman-Review in May. "But I can feel that I'm losing a step and stuff, and it's time for somebody else to get in there." In the mix to be that "somebody else" are businessman and former state Senate candidate Mike Kelly; attorney Lisa Miller, who sits on the Spokane County Board of Equalization; mixed martial arts fighter and former firefighter Adam "Smash" Smith; and Kris Pockell, a software engineer who co-owns the Valley hot sauce producer Elixir Sauce Co. The two candidates to receive the most votes in the Aug. 6 primary will advance to the general election, and the winner will take office after the new year. None of the candidates is a stranger to the political process. Kelly ran for the state Senate seat representing the Valley and surrounding communities last year, but fell short after details of a drug conviction decades ago resurfaced, despite him earning endorsements from outgoing state Sen. Mike Padden and several prominent Republicans. Pockell also ran for the state Legislature in the same district last year, losing handily to incumbent Rep. Suzanne Schmidt. Smith has unsuccessfully run for the Spokane Valley City Council in 2019, 2021 and 2023, and Miller previously served two terms on a neighborhood council for the Valley Village Neighborhood Council in Los Angeles. On public safety The Spokane Valley City Council is amidst an ongoing effort to bolster the city's police services, which are provided by the Spokane County Sheriff's Office. The effort is inspired by the findings of an outside consultant tasked with analyzing the Spokane Valley Police Department and the city's law enforcement needs, with the final report calling for an additional two dozen deputies to be added to the force. The current council has made meeting the recommendations its No. 1 priority, and has approved, funded and filled 10 new positions. The board also placed a 0.1% sales tax measure on the Aug. 5 ballot, citing a need to secure funding for the remaining recommended positions. Kelly, Pockell, Miller and Smith largely agree that public safety should be the council's priority, and that the citizens of Spokane Valley should be given the power to decide whether they'd be willing to fund additional positions. Kelly said his concern as the effort moves forward is the bottom line. He said he understands it will be a tough budgeting year for local governments across the state, with many more to come as tax proceeds have stagnated, the state is facing budget cuts and federal assistance is becoming hard to come by. He also understands the concerns of some Valley residents who believe the city should be finding funding elsewhere in the budget. Kelly said he's interested in examining some of the indirect costs of the city's public safety contracts in the region to see where some money could be saved and efforts streamlined. "Someone who's more analytical and pays attention to detail, like myself, and who works with numbers, I mean, that's just the kind of thing that I would love to be able to tackle," Kelly said. Pockell also noted the tight budgeting years forecast to come. He said while there are other options available to the council, the sales tax will be the most impactful and ensure residents can continue to rely on other city services that could be on the chopping block to secure public safety funding if the measure fails. Pockell's supportive of co-responder programs that pair mental health officials with deputies and hopes the program grows . He views it as a cost-effective way for the city to manage policing resources, saying that the majority of mental health crisis calls are tied to a small percentage of city residents and that a co-responder can free up deputies for other calls when a police presence may not be necessary. "They have regulars that are constantly showing up so that co-response team will actually reach out to some of those people before it becomes a problem, and say, 'Hey, do you need anything? Are you able to access your medication?' " Pockell said. "All of these things before something happens and they need to respond." As an attorney, Miller said she has a unique perspective and a vested interest in public safety. She practiced primarily in the civil realm with expertise in administrative law, but also served as an arbitrator with the Securities and Exchange Commission's Finance Industry Regulatory Authority and the National Commodities Futures Trading Association. Miller said she's encouraged by the bolstering efforts, including remodeling the precinct's building, but believes there should be more funding and training to prepare deputies for the future. "Cybercrime has changed," Miller said. "It used to be impersonations, identity theft, online fraud. Now it's attacks on operating systems, it's attacks on energy, it's attacks on water. That is going to be causing crime in the streets, and our law enforcement in Spokane Valley needs the tools and the training to deal with the fallout." Smith spent nine years as a firefighter with Spokane County Fire District 4, two with Spokane County Fire District 10 and is a Washington State Criminal Justice Training Commission certified defensive tactics instructor for law enforcement. He said that lived experience will be a resource for the council. Although he "doesn't want to see any increase in taxes," he said he prefers the sales tax model to a property tax since Valley residents will not bear the sole burden . Visitors from throughout the region will contribute. "Public safety has got to be the No. 1 priority in a town," Smith said. "There's people who want to live safely, they want their children to grow up in a safe place, and that's not something that we can skimp on." On housing and economic development The candidates all have experience owning and operating a business, and have a broad range of ideas on how to help other businesspeople. . In addition to operating her own administrative hearing officer firm, Miller formerly held leadership roles on the Los Angeles County Small Business Commission, the small firm section for the California State Bar and the small firm section for the Los Angeles region. Miller is a steadfast advocate for small businesses, she said, and would like to examine how to streamline the process and lighten the administrative burdens of standing one up. She wants to pursue an app that would help visitors and residents alike get to know the shops, restaurants and activities available in Spokane Valley. Miller is a member of the Spokane Valley Homeless Housing Task Force and recently used her expertise to develop a contracting matrix for the city to follow when examining and awarding related service contracts. Spokane Valley is predominantly a contract city, meaning it does not have as many in-house employees and departments that most others do, so she expects the matrix to be transferable to other city business and result in cost savings for the city and taxpayers. "This is an example of how I work: I don't talk about buzzwords and I don't use dog whistles, I'm about substance and I'm about work," Miller said. "I saw a need, I saw that we perhaps wanted to go deeper into public contracting options, so instead of saying someone needs to do this, I just did it." Kelly sits on one of the council's citizen boards, serving on the city's planning commission since March 2024. He said there is a pressure to increase housing density and rely on public transit coming from outside the city's borders that does not match the desires of Spokane Valley residents. He would like to do his part to ensure the Valley maintains its character, which Kelly described as a "great mix" of industrial, agricultural and residential. "I see them trying to cajole us into density and to, like I said, rely on public transportation, which aren't necessarily bad things, but I think we need to be in control of what that looks like and also the cost involved," Kelly said. "We have to be able to go at our own pace in order to make sure that that's what we need and what we can afford." In addition to operating Smash Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu, which has training centers in Spokane Valley, Deer Park and Airway Heights, Smith also organizes tournaments and matchups through a nonprofit. He believes the Valley is missing out on opportunities to drive more economic activity to local businesses, and would like to bring more community events to the city. Smith pointed to the northeast corner of Valley Mission Park on East Mission Avenue as a possible location for an amphitheater to host festivals, live concerts and more. As for housing, he said supports streamlining the permitting process and working with the county to rezone areas to encourage more housing construction. "I think there's smart ways to look at areas where we can change the zoning, multifamily, residential, mixed zonings, so that we can increase housing," Smith said. "In order to get housing prices down, we've got to get, obviously, more houses out there." Pockell said the city has done a good job at promoting itself as a business-friendly environment and also in managing the growth that's come along with it. He would like to steward the city through the growth still to come, with a focus on increasing affordable housing stock, preventing urban sprawl and helping the relatively young city build an identity. Pockell is also interested in the city's infrastructure. He'd be interested in taking a leadership role in managing the system, advocating for state or federal funding and identifying projects that will directly improve the quality of life for Valley businesses and residents. "I really do think it's a special place, and I want to maintain what we have," Pockell said. On navigating council relations Despite the flurry of activity encompassing public works improvements, public safety and the rest of city business, dysfunction between sitting members has been the overriding theme of Spokane Valley City Council meetings for more than a 1 1/2 years. The tension has consistently led back to Councilman Al Merkel since he was sworn into office in January 2024, either in arguments he picks himself or is dragged into by his peers or members of the public who disagree with his approach, ideas and behavior. A pair of workplace investigations conducted by third-party attorneys found he harassed city staff and violated city policy and state law regarding public records. The council moved to sue Merkel over the latter earlier this year, saying he is not complying with state or city standards. The candidates all expressed confidence in being able to navigate the personalities and disagreements on council, if elected. Smith went as far as to name easing the tension as one of his main motivations for running, and a top priority once on the council. He said his experience working with a broad range of students, leading classes and negotiating with local groups for his events will prove useful in that effort. "When I looked at the people that were running for the position, and I look at the current city council now, I don't feel like anyone running for this position would help mend the problem that they have currently, which is a big communication problem," Smith said. "They're not cohesive, and that's very detrimental to any form of leadership." Pockell began attending city council meetings regularly last year, and has met with the current iteration of the council in one-on-one meetings to get up to speed on the city's pressing issues and to begin building relationships early. He said he believes strongly in the value of having different voices in the council, but is an avid believer of civil reciprocity. "People want to see their leaders working together more than, you know, the fighting," Pockell said. "I'm the type of person that I'm willing and happy to work with everybody, and I think that one of the best parts of our system of government, both at a local level and nationally, is that it incorporates different viewpoints. I think that's really critical to finding the best path forward." Miller said navigating conflict is right in her wheelhouse as an arbitrator, and that her history of leadership and experience in administrative law could help set the proper tone at Tuesday meetings. She said overseeing a hearing is not unlike running or participating in a council meeting: One must ensure everyone is heard, respectful and doing their homework on the issues. "If you don't, business does not get done, business does not get accomplished," Miller said. "I have a lot of experience leading processes that are adversarial, and I lead them by being a respectful listener; by being truly unbiased and open-minded; by honestly, sincerely considering all points of view and consuming vast quantities of data and other information." Kelly said disagreements will happen on the board, but it's important not to "get into petty differences." He noted the tensions go beyond just the council, as some members of the public have been vocal critics in recent years over what they feel is a lack of transparency from the council and administrators regarding city business. He'd like to assuage some of those concerns by establishing a policy of providing a brief overview of agenda items as they come up at the meetings. "I think some of that comes from the fact that, if you go to a council meeting, and I know this is an experience that I've had, you can sit down and they'll start talking about things, and you can tell that they've already had discussions," Kelly said. " "As the public, you're like, 'OK, what are we talking about? Why are we talking about this? What is our objective? Where does this come from?'" While the agendas for the meetings include some of that background checks information, Kelly said most folks do not have the time or knowledge to find and peruse the packets. "It makes it difficult for the for the public to know, and so they fill in the gaps," Kelly said. "And usually, it's in a way that leaves them with a bad taste in their mouth about it." Solve the daily Crossword
