What is inside the GHF aid box being distributed in Gaza
What's in the boxes?
Videos have circulated online of Palestinians showing the contents of the boxes, but the GHF has only shared images of them this week.Two pictures posted on X show mostly dried food items that require water and fuel to cook, including pasta, chickpeas, lentils, and wheat flour. Also included is cooking oil, salt and tahini, or sesame paste.
The GHF has said these boxes also contain some ready-to-eat food, like halva bars - a popular snack made from blending tahini or sesame paste and sugar.The organisation has provided us with a table of what it describes as a "benchmark" list of items in each box, with a calorie breakdown.A typical box contains 42,500 calories, and that "each box feeds 5.5 people for 3.5 days". according to the table.
It occasionally includes substitute items like tea, biscuits, and chocolate, and is also delivering potatoes and onions, but these are not included in the nutritional figures, the GHF has said.
'Serious weaknesses'
An international aid development professor from the London School of Economics analysed the list provided by the GHF to BBC Verify and said that while it could deliver sufficient calories needed to survive, it had "serious weaknesses"."In essence, this basket provides a full stomach but an empty diet," Prof Stuart Gordon said. "The biggest flaw is what's missing… This (is) very much a 'first aid' food basket, designed to stop the haemorrhaging effect that is acute hunger.""A diet like this over weeks would lead to 'hidden hunger', increasing the risk of diseases like anaemia and scurvy" he said.
Dr Andrew Seal, an associate professor of international nutrition at the University College London, said the food boxes were deficient in calcium, iron, zinc, and vitamins C, D, B12, and K. He added there was also a lack of foods to suit young children."Prolonged consumption of these foods, even if they were made available in adequate amounts, would lead to a range of deficiencies and serious health problems," he said.He added that unlike the GHF, agencies like the UN typically distribute food in bulk and supplement it with targeted nutrition for vulnerable groups. The World Food Programme (WFP) has said it also aims to deliver emergency supplies for young children and pregnant women.The GHF did not respond to BBC Verify's questions surrounding the advice it received about the nutritional contents of its aid boxes or whether it planned to address concerns raised by experts.
For those who manage to get hold of a box, they still need water and fuel to cook the dried goods, despite the water crisis and severe fuel shortage facing Gaza.The UN's Office of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) warned this week that the water crisis in Gaza was rapidly deteriorating. It also warned that families have had to resort to unsafe and unhealthy cooking methods, such as using waste materials.The WFP said in May that official supplies of cooking gas stopped and that it was being sold on the black market at prices up to 4,000% higher than pre-conflict levels.UN Secretary General António Guterres said this week Gazans were facing grave shortages of basic supplies and that malnutrition was "soaring".Almost one in three people in Gaza are going days without eating, the UN's food aid programme has warned."Malnutrition is surging with 90,000 women and children in urgent need of treatment," the World Food Programme (WFP) said on Friday.Additional reporting by Matt Murphy
What do you want BBC Verify to investigate?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
26 minutes ago
- Reuters
WFP urges quick approvals by Israel for trucks to move into Gaza
UNITED NATIONS, July 27 (Reuters) - The United Nations food aid agency needs quick approvals by Israel for its trucks to move into Gaza if it is to take advantage of Israel's planned humanitarian pauses in fighting, a senior World Food Programme official said on Sunday. Facing growing global condemnation as the World Health Organization said mass starvation had taken hold in Gaza, Israel said on Sunday it would halt military operations for 10 hours a day in parts of the enclave and allow new aid corridors. "We need not just words, but we need action there. We need to have really fast clearances and approvals," Ross Smith, WFP director of emergencies, told Reuters on Sunday. "If the waiting times are going to continue to be 10 hours, then we won't be able to take advantage of these pauses." COGAT, the Israeli military aid coordination agency, did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Since Israel lifted an 11-week blockade on Gaza on May 19 and allowed the U.N.-led humanitarian operation to resume limited deliveries, a key U.N. complaint has been lengthy delays by Israel in allowing convoys to leave the crossing points to transport aid to warehouses and distribution points inside Gaza. U.N. data shows that only less than 8% of 1,718 WFP trucks made it to their destination within Gaza in the nearly ten weeks since Israel lifted its blockade. The rest were looted by "either peacefully by hungry people or forcefully by armed actors during transit," according to the U.N. data. Israel requires the U.N. and other groups to offload their aid at the crossing point and then send trucks from within Gaza to collect it and transport it within the war-torn enclave, where some 2.1 million people remain. "Everybody can see them driving in, and so they know that food is about to be loaded on them, and they start to wait and crowd," said Smith, adding that some convoys can wait up to 20 hours before Israel gives them the green light to enter Gaza. "If they are sitting there for 10 hours, loading and waiting, then at that point you have 10,000 people crowding outside," he said. Israel controls all access to Gaza and says it allows enough food aid into the enclave, where it has been at war with Palestinian militants Hamas for nearly 22-months. It accuses Hamas of stealing aid, which the militants deny. The U.N. says it has not seen evidence of mass aid diversion in Gaza by Hamas. Jordan and the United Arab Emirates parachuted 25 tons of aid into the Gaza Strip on Sunday in their first airdrop in months, a Jordanian official source said, adding that the air drops were not a substitute for delivery by land. Smith said air dropping aid was "purely symbolic at the very best." The war in Gaza was triggered on October 7, 2023, when Palestinian militants Hamas killed 1,200 people in southern Israel and took some 250 hostages, according to Israeli tallies. Since then, Israel's military campaign has killed nearly 60,000 Palestinians, according to Gaza health authorities.
Reuters
7 hours ago
- Reuters
Jordan and UAE drop aid into Gaza in first airdrop in months, Jordanian source says
July 27 (Reuters) - Jordan and the United Arab Emirates parachuted 25 tons of aid into the Gaza Strip on Sunday in their first airdrop in months, a Jordanian official source said. The official said the air drops were not a substitute for delivery by land.
South Wales Argus
7 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
I tried a World War II cake recipe from Marguerite Patten
These often turn out wonderfully, and it got me thinking what it would be like to try a wartime recipe using the same ingredients that people would have been restricted to during rationing. Rationing was a system implemented to make sure everyone got their fair share of food during national shortages in wartime. This was exacerbated by enemy ships and submarines attacking imports of food, which caused a greater reliance on items produced in the UK. Marguerite Patten was one of the earliest celebrity chefs, presenting a popular BBC radio programme during World War Two, in which she shared recipes for cooking with wartime rations. Here she is demonstrating how to make an Easter cake back in 1950.#ThrowbackThursday — BBC Current Affairs (@BBC_CurrAff) April 9, 2020 Several foodstuffs, such as sugar, meat, fats, bacon, eggs and cheese, were rationed, which caused a great impact. After doing a bit of research for wartime cake recipes, I was recommended by my mum to check out recipes from Marguerite Patten. She was one of the earliest examples of a celebrity chef and became famous during World War II, where she shared recipes on BBC radio that could work within the limits of rationing. It sounded like the perfect thing to explore, and I found her recipe for a Vinegar Cake, which was a fruit cake that used vinegar instead of eggs. This can be seen in her book Feeding the Nation, and is notable for using vinegar instead of eggs as a main component. How to make a World War II-era light fruit cake Making the cake will not require too many ingredients (Image: Newsquest) In terms of ingredients for the fruit cake recipe you will need 6oz of self-raising flour 3oz of margarine 3oz of sugar 1/4 pint of milk 1 tablespoon of vinegar 1/2 teaspoon of bicarbonate of soda 3-4oz of mixed dried fruit Meanwhile, for equipment, you will need: a decent-sized mixing bowl large basin scales sieve measuring jug a teaspoon a tablespoon larger spoon (for mixing) 7-inch baking tin Baking cakes is not something I do very often, so I made it with my Mum overseeing things to make sure I didn't mess up anywhere. The first step involves creaming the margarine and sugar together (Image: Newsquest) Firstly, we creamed the margarine and sugar together and made sure it was well-combined. After that, the recipe recommends pouring the milk, vinegar and bicarbonate of soda into a "large basin". It was quite a vague term, so we combined the elements into a large measuring jug as it would supposedly froth up quite a bit. The recipe involves 3-4 ounces of mixed fruit (Image: Newsquest) However, this didn't happen in practice, so any worries of creating a mess were quickly alleviated, at least. We then poured that mixture into the mixing bowl with the creamed margarine and sugar, before sifting the flour into it. After mixing that, we then added the dried fruit, which was a combination of raisins, peel and cherries. All the ingredients will eventually be mixed together into the bowl (Image: Newsquest) Finally, after briefly mixing together, we then poured it into a seven-inch baking tin. The recipe recommends flouring and greasing the tin, but if you have a cake case to hand, you can line the tin with that. All there is to do after that is to pop it in a "moderate oven" (approximately 170-180C) and bake it for an hour. The verdict Once the hour was up, I took the cake out of the oven and was pleased to see that, at least aesthetically, it had turned out quite well. The cake certainly looked the part coming out of the oven (Image: Newsquest) It had a nice golden-brown colour with bits of dried fruit popping through the outer layer. All that was left to do was to try it, and I was pleasantly surprised with the results. I'd seen from other people trying the recipe that it had turned out really crumbly, but in this case it held its shape perfectly. The cake had a light and fluffy texture (Image: Newsquest) Having it warm was certainly a bonus, and it had a delightfully fluffy and light texture. Recommended reading: It also wasn't overly sweet and balanced all the flavours remarkably well. Due to how relatively few ingredients this requires and how it doesn't take too long to make, I would highly recommend giving this a try. While rationing is, of course, something nobody ever wants to go back to or experience in the first place, it is somewhat comforting to know that with a bit of adjustment, people were still able to enjoy some treats like this.
