High Court rules Isham Jalil's judiciary remarks on Najib's SRC, 1MDB trials not contemptuous
Judge K. Muniandy dismissed committal proceedings brought by the Attorney General's Chambers (AGC), finding that Isham's statements did not pose a real risk to public confidence in the judiciary, according to a report in the New Straits Times today.
He said the comments did not directly concern the specific courts that heard and ruled on the 1MDB and SRC International Bhd cases, which had already been concluded.
'What could be regarded as scandalous or interfering with the course of justice earlier may not be so today,' said Muniandy.
He added that vague allegations claiming Isham had scandalised the judiciary lacked context and failed to demonstrate actual harm to the administration of justice.
The judge stressed that the law of contempt aims to protect the public's interest in a functioning justice system, not to shield judges from criticism.
'With the advent of social media, criticisms against a judge and his decision is commonplace,' he said, adding that judges must remain impartial and resilient in the face of external pressure.
Muniandy also affirmed that judgments in Najib's corruption trials were grounded in facts and law, not influenced by emotion or public sentiment.
He acknowledged that while freedom of speech is vital to democracy, it must be exercised with respect for the judiciary's role and responsibility.
'Contempt powers should only be used where there is a real risk of undermining the administration of justice, not merely to silence uncomfortable or critical opinions,' he said.
The AGC filed the contempt application on December 28, 2023, following Isham's remarks during an interview titled 'Townhall For Justice: Keadilan Sebenarnya Untuk Siapa?', which aired on The Malaya Post's Facebook page on September 30, 2023.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
14 minutes ago
- Free Malaysia Today
FMM presses govt to urgently secure deferral on 25% US tariff
The Federation of Malaysian Manufacturing said its members were already struggling under a previous 10% US tariff and rising domestic costs. (Bernama pic) PETALING JAYA : The Federation of Malaysian Manufacturing (FMM) has urged the government to secure an immediate deferral of the 25% blanket tariff imposed by the US on all Malaysian products. FMM president Soh Thian Lai said the latest move under the US's reciprocal tariffs, set to take effect on Aug 1, came as a surprise given the intensive and ongoing negotiations coordinated by the investment, trade and industry ministry (Miti). 'This latest escalation risks further destabilising an already fragile industrial landscape, severely impacting export competitiveness and placing additional strain on manufacturers,' he said in a statement. Miti earlier said Putrajaya remained committed to continued engagement with the US on a 'balanced' and 'mutually beneficial' trade agreement despite the announcement of the 25% tariff on Malaysian goods. Soh said manufacturers were already struggling under a previous 10% US tariff and rising domestic costs, including the expanded sales and service tax (SST) and electricity tariff revision. He said feedback from manufacturers during the initial implementation of the 10% tariff already pointed to serious concerns over the sustainability of export operations. 'Many warned that further tariff hikes would result in significant declines in shipments and severe erosion of profit margins.' The 25% tariff, he added, was expected to intensify these pressures, particularly for companies operating on thin margins or bound by long-term contracts. While some critical products such as semiconductors were exempted, Soh noted that the broader ecosystem supporting the semiconductor industry – such as suppliers of parts, machinery and services – remained exposed to disruption. He also expressed concern over Malaysia's growing disadvantage in the evolving tariff landscape, pointing out that Vietnam had secured a bilateral arrangement reducing its rate from 45% to 20%. 'These disparities risk diverting US sourcing to lower tariff alternatives and eroding Malaysia's market share. 'Our compliance record, investment linkages and value-added contribution should form the basis for seeking targeted relief or differentiated treatment to prevent long-term structural damage to Malaysia's export position,' he said. Soh said it was critical that Malaysia's case be urgently and clearly elevated at the highest levels of US policymaking, supported by strong data and strategic positioning to highlight the nation's role in global supply chains. Domestic measures needed Soh also said domestic countermeasures must be rolled out to support affected industries, including targeted financial relief, strengthened export promotion, and fast-tracked structural reforms to enhance cost efficiency and competitiveness. 'The long-term solution must be the creation of a tax framework that fully removes the tax-on-tax element and restores neutrality across the manufacturing supply chain,' he said. Beyond immediate reforms, Soh urged for structural interventions to strengthen trade competitiveness and resilience, including enhanced export facilitation, incentives for branding and digital access, and tax breaks for investments in automation and robotics. 'To build long-term supply chain resilience, a National Supply Chain Council must be swiftly established,' he said, adding that Malaysia should lead efforts under its Asean chairmanship to create a regional Supply Chain Coordination Council.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Scramble to assess broader damage from 25% US tariff
PETALING JAYA: Malaysian businesses and national-level economic groups are scrambling to assess the broader damage from the United States' 25% tariff on Malaysian products that is set to go into effect on Aug 1. The tariff is part of a wider US push to reshore manufacturing and limit dependence on strategic imports. In addition to electrical and electronic (E&E) products, sectors likely to be affected include rubber gloves, semiconductor components, industrial machinery and palm oil derivatives. Penang Chinese Town Hall president Tan Sri Tan Khoon Hai warned that the sudden move would undercut Malaysia's cost competitiveness in the US market. 'This move may strain Malaysia-US trade ties and shake investor confidence, especially among foreign investors who use Malaysia as a manufacturing base to access American markets,' he told theSun. He said exporters risk losing market share to countries such as Vietnam and Thailand, which are not facing similar tariff pressures. The higher landed cost of Malaysian goods, he added, could price local products out of the US market and divert future investments elsewhere. Tan highlighted that the E&E sector – Malaysia's top export to the US – will be hit hardest, with glove and machinery producers also vulnerable due to thin global margins. Calling for immediate federal action, Tan urged a delay in expanding the Sales and Service Tax and postponement of the electricity tariff hike, warning these would add to producers' burden. He also suggested Bank Negara Malaysia consider lowering the base lending rate. He further proposed creating a 'tariff buffer fund' offering tax deductions over three to five years for companies importing key machinery. Tan also called for deeper Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership integration and proposed transforming Penang into a regional semiconductor hub, backed by university partnerships and a Penang Talent Reskilling Fund focusing on artificial intelligence, green technology and automation. Senior fellow at the Malay Economic Action Council (MTEM) and executive council member of Dewan Perniagaan Melayu Malaysia Datuk Yazid Othman stressed that the government must confront the reality of shrinking national revenue and act swiftly. 'The government must accept the reality that national revenue projections will decline and respond appropriately by focusing on further strengthening the domestic economy and alternative markets, while at the same time protecting SMEs from becoming victims of dumping of cheap imports,' he said. Yazid also called for a recalibrated fiscal policy to stimulate economic activity and raise household income.
Free Malaysia Today
2 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
SRC board, not Najib, responsible for company's funds, says ex-PM's lawyers
SRC International is suing ex-prime minister Najib Razak (left) and former CEO Nik Faisal Ariff Kamil for US$1.18 billion. KUALA LUMPUR : The High Court here was told today that SRC International Sdn Bhd's board and management had exclusive control of the company's operations and loan funds received from Retirement Fund Incorporated (KWAP). Lawyer Farhan Shafee Abdullah – representing former prime minister Najib Razak in SRC International's US$1.18 billion civil suit against him and former SRC CEO Nik Faisal Ariff Kamil – submitted that his client had no control over the company. Farhan said all transactions were carried out by the board, which also bore responsibility for overseeing the company's affairs. 'If any misappropriation occurred, it was the result of the board's own decisions. 'Even taking Najib's alleged instructions at their highest, responsibility ultimately rested with the board to properly manage the funds within those parameters,' he said. Farhan also dismissed SRC International's claim that Najib acted as a shadow director or the de facto controller of the company. He submitted that Najib was not part of the company's governing board and did not assume the fiduciary duties of a director. 'The evidence shows the SRC board exercised independent judgement and was not accustomed to act on Najib's instructions,' he said. Farhan added that SRC International had not produced any instance of Najib issuing a binding directive to the board on operational matters. He said the company's own witness, former BSI Bank wealth management head Kevin Swampillai, had testified that he did not receive, see or become aware of any instruction from Najib directing the transfer or investment of SRC International's funds. 'All instructions for the movement of funds came from Jho Low (Low Taek Jho) and SRC officers, including (former director) Suboh Yasin – not Najib. This is a striking admission from the plaintiff's own witness. 'Despite Najib's position, no directive from him was ever communicated to the bank handling the money,' he said. The hearing before Justice Ahmad Fairuz Zainol Abidin will continue at a later date. SRC International is suing Najib and Nik Faisal – who remains at large – for allegedly misappropriating company property and conspiring to convert it for their own use. Judgment in default of appearance has been entered against Nik Faisal. The suit originally included former SRC International chairman Ismee Ismail and former directors Suboh, Shahrol Azral Ibrahim Halmi, Azhar Osman Khairuddin and Che Abdullah @ Rashidi Che Omar as co-defendants. SRC International later dropped the case against them, but Najib named them as third parties in his defence. Najib is currently serving a jail sentence in Kajang prison for misappropriating RM42 million from SRC International.
