logo
VAT reversal: Govt's R75bn hole will affect essential services and developmental objectives

VAT reversal: Govt's R75bn hole will affect essential services and developmental objectives

IOL News24-04-2025
Government will now have to find some other way of plugging a revenue hole of at least R75 billion after bowed to pressure and scrapped an increase in VAT.
Government will now have to find some other way of plugging a revenue hole of at least R75 billion after it bowed to pressure and scrapped an increase in Value Added Tax (VAT), which economists said will have adverse effects on essential services such as teaching and nursing.
Seemingly overnight, National Treasury reversed course on a proposed 0.5 percentage point increase in VAT, which would have taken the tax to 15.5%.
Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana's reversal means that other measures to cushion the poor against the proposed hike will have to be reversed, while 'other expenditure decisions [will need to be] revisited,' the statement said.
Old Mutual chief economist, Johann Els, said the fact that VAT would not be increased 'was not necessarily a win because R75 billion needs to be made up in some other way'.
This, said Els, could take the form of 'significant cutbacks in spending that was planned, especially in terms of extra nurses and extra teachers, or some of the revenue components that were announced in terms of mitigating the pain of that for taxpayers'.
Els said some of the changes could include a petrol levy increase, while there might also be a reversal of additional goods being added to the VAT exempt basket.
In the March 12 National Budget – the second tabling of the revenue and expenditure framework after the February one wasn't passed – National Treasury said it would expand the list of VAT zero-rated food items to include more meat and vegetable products.
Casey Sprake, economist Anchor Capital, told IOL that scrapping the VAT increase introduced a range of fiscal and economic challenges. While welcome news for consumers, it resulted in a significant deterioration of South Africa's fiscal position, she said.
'Crucially, the social support measures that were designed to mitigate the regressive impact of the VAT hike – particularly for lower-income households – are now redundant and will likely be withdrawn. In their place, the government will need to identify alternative areas for fiscal adjustment, many of which may come at the expense of key developmental priorities,' said Sprake.
Sprake added that National Treasury will be compelled to implement expenditure cuts. These are most likely to affect frontline public services and infrastructure investment, which are sectors already under considerable pressure.
Els said that the proposed increase wouldn't have been materially negative in terms of consumer spending or inflation, given measures to assist the poor. However, Investec chief economist Annabel Bishop had worked out that a 50bps increase this year as well as one in 2026 would have increased inflation by 0.25 percentage points for each year.
Inflation was 2.7% in March, down from 3.2% in February as it continued a declining trajectory.
Sprake added that there would be hidden costs for businesses that had begun updating their pricing systems, financial models, and customer communication strategies to accommodate the VAT change. They would now need to 'undertake the same process in reverse,' she said.
'These operational disruptions translate into unnecessary compliance costs, lost productivity, and added complexity for the private sector; costs borne not by the state, but by the broader economy,' said Sprake.
The South African Chamber of Commerce and Industry said in a statement that 'we are not yet convinced that enough expert work has been undertaken to investigate and look at expenditure throughout the government service'.
Sprake added that 'this episode underscores a recurring concern: the economic cost of policy uncertainty and reactive governance.'
National Treasury's backtracking of an increase followed the start of a court case on Tuesday in which both the Democratic Alliance and Economic Freedom Fighters – political polar opposites – took Godongwana as well as the South African Revenue Service to court to get the increase reversed. The parties had argued that the increase would harm the poor.
IOL Business
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Haven't filed your tax return yet? Here's how to avoid mistakes
Haven't filed your tax return yet? Here's how to avoid mistakes

The Citizen

time13 hours ago

  • The Citizen

Haven't filed your tax return yet? Here's how to avoid mistakes

Tax season does not have to be a stressful time if you approach it the right way and ensure you do not make common mistakes. It is tax season, which means it is time for taxpayers to stress about getting their tax return right to ensure they do not pay too much tax or too little and maybe, just maybe, get a few rands back from Sars. This year, Sars' tax systems and officials are expected to be more efficient and focused on collecting revenue, which means you must be sure you included everything in your return, tax manager at Allan Gray, Meagan Fraser, says. 'For the majority of South Africans, the reversal of the proposed 0.5% VAT increase earlier this year provided a sense of relief in terms of their monthly budgets. However, the loss of the anticipated revenue from this proposed increase resulted in a R75 billion shortfall in the national budget.' This, she points out, resulted in a renewed drive on the part of Sars to ensure that outstanding taxes are accurately and efficiently collected. 'Its efforts during tax-filing season will therefore be focused on taxpayer compliance and collecting outstanding taxes.' ALSO READ: Common pitfalls to avoid this tax season However, she says, this does not necessarily mean you will pay more tax. 'Sars cannot collect more tax from you than you owe. As a taxpayer, you have the right to consistent and impartial application of the law, but you also have the obligation to submit your return with complete and accurate information to Sars on time.' How to make sure your auto-assessment is correct However, not everyone has to submit a tax return. If you earn below R500 000 a year and have no deductions and only one employer, you are exempt from filing a tax return. According to Sars, 5.8 million taxpayers are auto-assessed this year, which means they do not have to prepare their own returns. However, she warns that you must still carefully check the assessment. 'Sars uses the data they received from employers, financial institutions and medical aid schemes to pre-populate amounts on behalf of taxpayers. 'The intention is to improve the accuracy and verifiability of the amounts completed on returns and to assist Sars in issuing estimated assessments for taxpayers who have relatively simple tax affairs.' Fraser says if you were auto-assessed, Sars will notify you via SMS or email. 'It is up to you to ensure that the information Sars used in your return is accurate and complete by cross-checking it against the tax certificates your service providers issued. 'If you disagree with any amounts Sars used, you must query the amounts directly with the relevant third-party data providers and request that they resubmit the corrected information to Sars.' This would be amounts such as your salary and medical aid payments. ALSO READ: Beware of these scams during tax season If you have any additional income or deductions not included in your return, you will have to add the relevant information manually. If you accept your auto-assessment, Sars will pay you any money it owes you within 72 hours. Getting your tax documents ready If you are not auto-assessed, you have to complete your tax return. The first step is to get your tax documents ready. Fraser says this include an IRP5 from your employer, an IT3(b), IT3(c), IT3(s) and a retirement annuity fund contribution certificate from your investment manager, your medical scheme tax certificate and proof of qualifying medical expenses, as well as documents related to any rental properties. 'Remember, you are required to keep copies of all supporting documents for five years from the date of submitting your return, as Sars may request these documents to verify the information you declared.' ALSO READ: Tax season: Here is why you need to prioritise filing for returns With tax season in full swing, Fraser urges taxpayers not to wait until the last moment to submit their return to avoid incurring penalties. 'It is important to ensure you comply by filing your income tax return accurately and by the set deadline, as well as settling any outstanding taxes in full and on time.' Most frequent error taxpayers make Adriana Taljaard, an accountant from AT Accounting & Taxation Solutions, who works with Procompare, an online platform that connects South Africans with local professionals, says the most frequent error taxpayers make is forgetting to add their medical-aid deductions. Procompare's analysis of thousands of requests for accountants reveals a key taxpayer challenge: Sars auto-assessments shows these key insights:

Employed South Africans working hard for financial freedom
Employed South Africans working hard for financial freedom

The Citizen

time15 hours ago

  • The Citizen

Employed South Africans working hard for financial freedom

South Africans are known for their resilience which is confirmed by a survey that shows they still work hard for their financial freedom. Employed South Africans are working hard for their financial freedom according to a new survey that shows their resilience and renewed sense of optimism despite the persistent pressures of a challenging economic climate. According to the 2025 Old Mutual Savings & Investment Monitor (OMSIM), many consumers are not only hopeful about the future but are also taking deliberate steps to improve their financial wellbeing. The OMSIM is an annual study that tracks the financial attitudes, behaviours and priorities of working South Africans earning a minimum of R8 000 per month. It serves as a barometer for the country's financial health, capturing the lived experiences and evolving behaviours of the middle-income market. The 2025 findings tell a story of adaptation, resourcefulness and a steady shift from crisis management to more forward-looking financial behaviour. ALSO READ: South Africans experiencing less financial stress, but still under pressure — survey Finances still difficult for working South Africans despite progress Vuyokazi Mabude, head of knowledge and insights at Old Mutual, says this year's report is a reflection of a turning point. 'The results show that while life is still difficult for many people, working South Africans are making tangible progress. 'There is a notable increase in income, confidence and an entrepreneurial spirit, particularly among the youth. People are taking control of their finances, seeking out additional income sources, managing their debt more intentionally and placing greater importance on saving,' she says. One of the standout findings is the marked improvement in financial sentiment, Mabude points out. A remarkable 75% of respondents believe their personal financial situation will improve in the next six months, the highest recorded since the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020. 'This level of optimism is most pronounced among the Gen Z market, with 89% anticipating improvement in their finances. Confidence in South Africa's economic direction is also improving, although consumers are still cautious. 'The number of people who expressed confidence in the economy has grown to 42%, building on the slow but consistent recovery seen since 2023.' ALSO READ: Survey shows how economic distress erodes South Africans' savings culture Income of working South Africans improving as well She says alongside improving sentiment, income growth is becoming more evident, where 44% of respondents reported earning more than they did a year ago, with income increases especially common among the youth (55%) and those in higher income brackets (57%). It is clear from the survey that South Africans are not simply working one job anymore, with 'poly-jobbing' the new normal now. The report shows that side hustling and entrepreneurship have become deeply embedded in the financial lives of working South Africans. The number of 'poly-jobbers', who earn income from multiple sources, remains high at 57%, rising to 75% among the youth between the ages of 18 and 29. In fact, Mabude says, the report shows that almost half of working South Africans (48%) now own or part-own a business. 'This entrepreneurial spirit is not just a trend. It is proving to be a vital coping mechanism and a source of financial empowerment. People are using their skills and passions to diversify their income streams, often out of necessity, but increasingly also as a means to build wealth.' ALSO READ: Tips on how to build your savings and become financially resilient Working South Africans struggle with debt and gambling However, with all the good news there is bound to be bad news. South Africans are struggling with debt and gambling. Debt continues to feature prominently in household financial management, but it is encouraging that 57% of respondents say they reduced their debt compared to a year ago. A growing number (32%) proactively engaged with creditors to renegotiate repayment terms. However, there are areas of concern, Mabude says, pointing out that 52% of working South Africans reported that they gamble, with 40% admitting they do so in hope of covering expenses or repaying debt. 'This trend suggests that while some are making proactive choices, others remain vulnerable and are turning to risky behaviour to bridge financial gaps.' The report also shows some lag when it comes to long-term savings. Although South Africans continue to show strong short-term saving habits with an average of 22% of household income being allocated to savings, retirement planning remains on the downside. While 96% agree that saving for retirement is important, only 28% made it a top priority. 'It is also encouraging to note that fewer people are prematurely accessing investments or retirement funds, while informal savings vehicles, such as stokvels remain popular and trusted,' Mabude says. ALSO READ: Only 8% of women are confident about retirement – are you one of them? Optimism for the future She says the report tells a story of progress, empowerment and possibility. 'While challenges remain, mainly due to the cost of living, OMSIM 2025 shows a trajectory of optimism looking into the future. 'The report shows that South Africans are not passively waiting for change, but instead are actively creating it by embracing entrepreneurship, making smarter money decisions and seeking out alternative ways to achieve some level of financial freedom. 'Every year, OMSIM gives us deep insight into how people are coping and adapting when it comes to their finances. This year, more than ever, we see an encouraging collective step forward,' Mabude says.

More Than Insurance—180 Years of Standing by South Africans
More Than Insurance—180 Years of Standing by South Africans

eNCA

timea day ago

  • eNCA

More Than Insurance—180 Years of Standing by South Africans

At Old Mutual, we know that life doesn't always go according to plan. When the unexpected happens, what matters most is having a partner you can trust. For the past 180 years, that's exactly what we've been to South Africans—a consistent, dependable presence in uncertain times. From our very first policy issued in 1845 to paying out more than R14.7 billion in claims in 2024, we've stood firmly beside individuals, families, and communities, helping them protect what matters most. And as we mark this incredible milestone, our promise to support you remains as strong as ever. Claims that Make a Difference Take Delwin, for example. At just 29, his wife Marece was diagnosed with stage 3B lung cancer—just a month after taking out life and severe illness cover with Old Mutual. Despite the shock, she lived for more than two years and continued to care for her family. The cover enabled them to afford essential treatments, including an ±R800,000 surgery, which significantly eased their financial burden. Marece's story is a powerful reminder that illness can strike at any age—and that having the right cover, with the right advice, can make all the difference ' Our role is to help customers through tough moments—and we take that responsibility quite seriously,' says Kavir Ramjee, Head of Protection at Old Mutual. In 2024, we saw clear trends in the claims landscape that show just how unpredictable life can be: 73% of severe illness claims were for the 'Big Four': cancer, coronary artery bypass graft, heart attacks and strokes. * 85%of disability claims came from customers aged between 30–60. More than half (51%) of disability income claims were for Musculo-skeletal disorders. Most severe illness claims stemmed from non-communicable diseases (NCDs) —chronic conditions not caused by infection but influenced by the environment and lifestyle. While genetic risk factors can't be changed, we can reduce environmental risks like poor diet, inactivity, smoking and alcohol use. To help you understand what others like you have faced—and how you can prepare—we've created the Old Mutual Claims Tool. It gives you the power to explore real claims data from people in your age group and gender, across death, disability, and illness, over. With this insight, you can make more informed decisions about the protection that truly matters to you. These insights not only show how we support you, but they also highlight the importance of planning ahead and being financially prepared when life happens. Why Financial Advice Matters More Than Ever Our ability to pay billions in claims year after year isn't just about our financial strength. It's rooted in the quality of advice and the personalisation of each plan. Choosing the right cover isn't one-size-fits-all. It depends on your life stage, your job, your goals, and your financial responsibilities. That's where our advisers come in. At Old Mutual, advisers don't simply sell insurance. They help you understand your risk, tailor your plan, and choose the benefits that matter most, so that when life changes, your cover doesn't fall short. With the right advice, and customised risk plan, you are not just buying cover -you're building security and peace of mind. Recognised for Strength, Built for the Future In 2024, Old Mutual was honoured to be: News24 Long-Term Insurer of the Year, an award we received again in March of this year. * Top 10 Brand Finance South Africa's Strongest brands across all sectors.* These awards reflect what drives us most: serving customers well and building a more secure future for all. The Next 180 Starts with You We're incredibly proud of our legacy. But we're even more excited about what lies ahead. We're investing in smarter technologies, more personalised support, and more accessible solutions to meet your needs—today and tomorrow. Because at Old Mutual, we don't just sell cover. We build confidence. We help you protect what matters. And we're just getting started. Old Mutual. A certain friend in uncertain times. That's our 180-year promise to you. Speak to a trusted financial adviser today or visit to learn more about how we can help you protect your future. Sources: Old Mutual Claim Stats Report, 2025 Brand Finance South Africa 100, 2025

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store