
The mushroom poisoning trial captivated Australia. Why Erin Patterson did it remains a mystery
For more than two months, the triple-murder trial has gripped the public's attention with details of how Erin Patterson murdered three of her estranged husband's relatives by deliberately serving them a lunch of poisonous mushrooms.
It was no surprise that on Tuesday — the day after the guilty verdict was delivered by the court in Victoria — media websites, social media and podcasts were scrambling to offer analysis on what motivated her.
Newspaper headlines described Patterson, 50, as a coercive killer with narcissistic characteristics. ' Cold, mean and vicious,' read one.
Strict Australian court reporting laws prohibit anything that might sway jurors in a trial. Some news outlets had saved up thousands of words awaiting the verdicts: scrutiny of Patterson's past work history, behavior and psyche.
The coverage tried to explain why the mother of two meticulously planned the fatal lunch and lured three people she said she loved to their deaths. Any certain answer, for now, remains a mystery.
No motive
After a nine-week Supreme Court trial in the state of Victoria, it took the jury six days to convict Patterson. She was found guilty of murdering her parents-in-law, Don and Gail Patterson, and Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson, by serving them a lunch of beef Wellington pastries laced with poisonous mushrooms.
She was also convicted of attempting to murder Heather's husband, Ian Wilkinson, who survived the meal at Patterson's home in the rural town of Leongatha in 2023.
Patterson denied poisoning them deliberately and contended that she had no reason to murder her beloved, elderly in-laws. But the jury rejected her defense that the inclusion of toxic mushrooms in the meal was a terrible accident.
Prosecutors failed to offer a motive for Patterson's crimes and weren't required to do so.
'People do different things for different reasons. Sometimes the reason is obvious enough to others,' prosecutor Nanette Rogers told the jury. 'At other times, the internal motivations are only known by the person themselves.'
But Rogers gave hints. At one point, the prosecutor had Patterson read aloud scathing messages she'd sent which highlighted past friction with her in-laws and tension with her estranged husband, who had been invited to the lunch but didn't go.
'You had two faces,' Rogers said. Patterson denied it.
'She had a dilemma'
With guilty verdicts but no proven reason why, Australian news outlets published avid speculation Tuesday.
'What on earth was Erin Patterson's motive?' The Australian newspaper's editorial director Claire Harvey asked in a column. Harvey pointed at rifts in the killer's relationship with her estranged husband.
Chris Webster was the first medical doctor to speak to Patterson after her four lunch guests had been hospitalized and testified in the trial. He told reporters Tuesday that he became convinced she deliberately poisoned her victims when she lied about buying the foraged mushrooms she had served from a major supermarket chain.
'She had a dilemma and the solution that she chose is sociopathic,' Webster told Nine Network television.
Displayed no emotion
The outpouring of scorn for Patterson reflects a national obsession with the case and a widespread view that she wasn't a sympathetic figure.
It was an opinion Australians were legally required not to express in the media or online before the trial ended to ensure a fair hearing. But newspapers now don't have to hold back.
Under the headline 'Death Cap Stare,' The Age reported how the 'killer cook' didn't flinch as she learned her fate, but stared at the jury as they delivered their verdict.
Melbourne's Herald Sun newspaper's front page screamed: 'COOKED,' labelling Patterson 'Evil Erin' and a 'Cold-Blooded Killer.'
During the trial, Patterson chose to testify in her own defense, a tactic considered risky in the Australian justice system and one which most observers said didn't serve her well. She joked awkwardly at times and became combative with the prosecutor.
Journalist John Ferguson, who won a Melbourne Press Club award for breaking the story of the fatal lunch, said Patterson often cried or came close to tears during her trial. But when she was convicted, she displayed no emotion, he noted.
'What the court got on Monday was the full Erin. Cold, mean and vicious,' Ferguson wrote in The Australian Tuesday.
Drama series, documentary and books
The verdicts also prompted an online frenzy among Australians, many of whom turned citizen detectives during the trial.
By late Monday, posts about the verdicts on local Reddit pages had drawn thousands of comments laced with black humor, including memes, in-jokes and photographs taken at local supermarkets where pre-packaged beef Wellington meals were discounted.
Fascination about the case will linger. A drama series, documentary and books are planned, all of them likely to attempt an answer to the question of what motivated Patterson.
She faces life in prison, with sentencing to come at a later date. From then, Patterson's lawyers will have 28 days to appeal.
—-
Graham-McLay reported from Wellington, New Zealand.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
‘Naturally gifted' jockey, 18, tragically dies after dirt bike accident
Ngakau Halley sustained critical injuries when he was involved in a collision between a dirt bike and car at an intersection in Hamilton, New Zealand A 'naturally gifted' young jockey has died of his injuries after he was involved in a collision between the dirt bike he was riding and a car. Ngakau Halley, 18, was in the third season of his apprenticeship in New Zealand and had ridden 18 winners this term to take his total to 46. He was riding a dirt bike which was involved in a serious two-vehicle crash at an intersection in Whitoria, according to Waikato Police. 'Sadly, the rider of the dirtbike received critical injuries and was transported to hospital where they later died,' a statement said. 'Two young people in the car were transported to hospital with moderate injuries. The road was closed while the Serious Crash Unit conducted a scene examination. Enquiries into the circumstances of the crash are ongoing.' Halley was later named as the victim in the accident. 'It's tragic, words just can't describe it. I was talking with him on Monday and then this happens,' New Zealand Thoroughbred Racing Northern Riding Master Noel Harris told LoveRacingNZ. 'He was very polite and he was a very talented boy. You knew straight away when you saw him on a horse that he was a natural. From where he was brought up, they just jump on a horse and you are part of it.' Halley learned to ride from a young age but had ambitions to become a professional rugby league player, having played hooker for his local club and district. He later changed tack after riding track work and then took out his apprenticeship with trainer Debbie Sweeney 'He was a natural talent, and that is just what you want,' Harris said. 'It's tragic, he was a lovely boy.' Among many tributes, top Australia-based jockey Blake Shinn said: 'Such a devastating tragedy. Sending strength and sympathy to the family, friends and all in the NZ Racing community.' A fund-raising page has been set up for donations towards funeral costs.


The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
‘One in a million': teen surfer found on remote island 14km off Australian coast
A 19-year-old surfer is stable in hospital after being found safe on a remote island off the northern New South Wales coast of Australia in an outcome his dad described as 'one in a million'. Darcy Deefholts' family were 'fearing for the worst', his father, Terry, said in an urgent post to Facebook calling for rescue help on Wednesday night. The 19-year-old surfer had left his home in Wooli on a bike at about 2.30pm yesterday, heading towards Wooli beach, NSW police said. When he did not return home, his family contacted police. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email 'Following a land and water search around Wooli beach, including local police, PolAir, Marine Area Command and Marine Rescue, the man was located safe today on a small island off Wooli,' NSW police said. Police later confirmed the teenager was found in the North Solitary Island nature reserve, around 14km off the coast. In Terry Deefholts' post on Wednesday night, the teenager's father called on 'anyone with a seaworthy vessel to please meet me at the main Wooli boat ramp and take me to sea to help with the search'. 'HELP – I NEED BOATS, BEACH WALKERS, DRONES AND 4WDs and PLANES AT FIRST LIGHT,' he wrote. 'As far as we can tell, Darcy took a cream Malibu surfboard with him to One Tree at Wooli and went for a surf in very small swell some time around 4pm. We think he was wearing a dark rashy. 'Of course we are fearing the worst. We are overwhelmed by the community efforts in the search so far. There is only one thing we want now – our beloved boy to be found safe.' In a comment on the post, Terry said it was 'encouraging to know the water temp is 20 degrees and survivable'. A spokesperson for the Northern NSW local health district said Deefholts was in a stable condition under observation at Grafton base hospital, after spending the night on an island off the coast. 'The patient is in good spirits and is being supported by family,' they said. 'The family would like to thank emergency services and members of the community involved in the search, after the alarm was raised late yesterday when he failed to return home from a surf.' Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion In comments to the Daily Telegraph after Darcy's rescue, Terry said he was still processing everything and had not slept. 'I haven't had the chance to talk to him yet, I'm just so over the moon,' he said, adding that it was 'a one in a million miracle'. Terry told ABC he 'didn't give up hope, but jeez I was close'. 'It's kind of surreal. I was at the point of thinking the absolute worst,' he said. 'It's a one in a million. Who survives this?' Casey Meaker, who set up a Facebook group to find Darcy, announced that the teenager had been found in a post. 'After an incredibly long and cold night, Darcy was found this morning out on the islands off Wooli. He made it a long way out – but he's ALIVE, safe, and getting the care he needs,' Meaker wrote. 'We are absolutely blown away by the strength of this young man and the power of this incredible community.'


The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
Football pair plead guilty to match-fixing over yellow cards
Two professional footballers have admitted in court to engaging in betting corruption after they were paid by criminals to earn yellow cards during games. Ulises Davila, former captain of Australian A-League side Macarthur Bulls and midfielders Kearyn Baccus and Clayton Lewis were charged in May 2024 with manipulating yellow cards during games in 2023 and 2024. Davila, 33, allegedly acted as the contact between the southwest Sydney club's players and a criminal group in Colombia, organizing for the yellow cards to occur during particular games. Baccus, 33, and Lewis, 27, were allegedly paid up to 10,000 Australian dollars ($6,550) by Davila to deliberately try to receive the referee-issued cautions for foul play. Baccus and Lewis pleaded guilty in a Sydney court to engaging in conduct that corrupts the betting outcome of an event. A second charge of participating in a criminal group was withdrawn. Lewis had previously pleaded not guilty to both charges, but reversed his plea to one of the charges after negotiating with prosecutors. The pair will face sentencing in September. Davila has not yet entered pleas to the nine charges he faces. He will return to court next month. Police said the betting scheme led to hundreds of thousands of dollars being paid out in winnings. All players were stood down by the league. Davila's contract with Macarthur FC was terminated shortly after his arrest. Baccus was released by the Bulls during the 2024 offseason and Lewis remains suspended.