logo
The mushroom poisoning trial captivated Australia. Why Erin Patterson did it remains a mystery

The mushroom poisoning trial captivated Australia. Why Erin Patterson did it remains a mystery

Independenta day ago
The high-profile case of the so-called Death Cap Mushroom Cook is likely to remain a topic of conversation across Australia for years to come.
For more than two months, the triple-murder trial has gripped the public's attention with details of how Erin Patterson murdered three of her estranged husband's relatives by deliberately serving them a lunch of poisonous mushrooms.
It was no surprise that on Tuesday — the day after the guilty verdict was delivered by the court in Victoria — media websites, social media and podcasts were scrambling to offer analysis on what motivated her.
Newspaper headlines described Patterson, 50, as a coercive killer with narcissistic characteristics. ' Cold, mean and vicious,' read one.
Strict Australian court reporting laws prohibit anything that might sway jurors in a trial. Some news outlets had saved up thousands of words awaiting the verdicts: scrutiny of Patterson's past work history, behavior and psyche.
The coverage tried to explain why the mother of two meticulously planned the fatal lunch and lured three people she said she loved to their deaths. Any certain answer, for now, remains a mystery.
No motive
After a nine-week Supreme Court trial in the state of Victoria, it took the jury six days to convict Patterson. She was found guilty of murdering her parents-in-law, Don and Gail Patterson, and Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson, by serving them a lunch of beef Wellington pastries laced with poisonous mushrooms.
She was also convicted of attempting to murder Heather's husband, Ian Wilkinson, who survived the meal at Patterson's home in the rural town of Leongatha in 2023.
Patterson denied poisoning them deliberately and contended that she had no reason to murder her beloved, elderly in-laws. But the jury rejected her defense that the inclusion of toxic mushrooms in the meal was a terrible accident.
Prosecutors failed to offer a motive for Patterson's crimes and weren't required to do so.
'People do different things for different reasons. Sometimes the reason is obvious enough to others,' prosecutor Nanette Rogers told the jury. 'At other times, the internal motivations are only known by the person themselves.'
But Rogers gave hints. At one point, the prosecutor had Patterson read aloud scathing messages she'd sent which highlighted past friction with her in-laws and tension with her estranged husband, who had been invited to the lunch but didn't go.
'You had two faces,' Rogers said. Patterson denied it.
'She had a dilemma'
With guilty verdicts but no proven reason why, Australian news outlets published avid speculation Tuesday.
'What on earth was Erin Patterson's motive?' The Australian newspaper's editorial director Claire Harvey asked in a column. Harvey pointed at rifts in the killer's relationship with her estranged husband.
Chris Webster was the first medical doctor to speak to Patterson after her four lunch guests had been hospitalized and testified in the trial. He told reporters Tuesday that he became convinced she deliberately poisoned her victims when she lied about buying the foraged mushrooms she had served from a major supermarket chain.
'She had a dilemma and the solution that she chose is sociopathic,' Webster told Nine Network television.
Displayed no emotion
The outpouring of scorn for Patterson reflects a national obsession with the case and a widespread view that she wasn't a sympathetic figure.
It was an opinion Australians were legally required not to express in the media or online before the trial ended to ensure a fair hearing. But newspapers now don't have to hold back.
Under the headline 'Death Cap Stare,' The Age reported how the 'killer cook' didn't flinch as she learned her fate, but stared at the jury as they delivered their verdict.
Melbourne's Herald Sun newspaper's front page screamed: 'COOKED,' labelling Patterson 'Evil Erin' and a 'Cold-Blooded Killer.'
During the trial, Patterson chose to testify in her own defense, a tactic considered risky in the Australian justice system and one which most observers said didn't serve her well. She joked awkwardly at times and became combative with the prosecutor.
Journalist John Ferguson, who won a Melbourne Press Club award for breaking the story of the fatal lunch, said Patterson often cried or came close to tears during her trial. But when she was convicted, she displayed no emotion, he noted.
'What the court got on Monday was the full Erin. Cold, mean and vicious,' Ferguson wrote in The Australian Tuesday.
Drama series, documentary and books
The verdicts also prompted an online frenzy among Australians, many of whom turned citizen detectives during the trial.
By late Monday, posts about the verdicts on local Reddit pages had drawn thousands of comments laced with black humor, including memes, in-jokes and photographs taken at local supermarkets where pre-packaged beef Wellington meals were discounted.
Fascination about the case will linger. A drama series, documentary and books are planned, all of them likely to attempt an answer to the question of what motivated Patterson.
She faces life in prison, with sentencing to come at a later date. From then, Patterson's lawyers will have 28 days to appeal.
—-
Graham-McLay reported from Wellington, New Zealand.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Football pair plead guilty to match-fixing over yellow cards
Football pair plead guilty to match-fixing over yellow cards

The Independent

time28 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Football pair plead guilty to match-fixing over yellow cards

Two professional footballers have admitted in court to engaging in betting corruption after they were paid by criminals to earn yellow cards during games. Ulises Davila, former captain of Australian A-League side Macarthur Bulls and midfielders Kearyn Baccus and Clayton Lewis were charged in May 2024 with manipulating yellow cards during games in 2023 and 2024. Davila, 33, allegedly acted as the contact between the southwest Sydney club's players and a criminal group in Colombia, organizing for the yellow cards to occur during particular games. Baccus, 33, and Lewis, 27, were allegedly paid up to 10,000 Australian dollars ($6,550) by Davila to deliberately try to receive the referee-issued cautions for foul play. Baccus and Lewis pleaded guilty in a Sydney court to engaging in conduct that corrupts the betting outcome of an event. A second charge of participating in a criminal group was withdrawn. Lewis had previously pleaded not guilty to both charges, but reversed his plea to one of the charges after negotiating with prosecutors. The pair will face sentencing in September. Davila has not yet entered pleas to the nine charges he faces. He will return to court next month. Police said the betting scheme led to hundreds of thousands of dollars being paid out in winnings. All players were stood down by the league. Davila's contract with Macarthur FC was terminated shortly after his arrest. Baccus was released by the Bulls during the 2024 offseason and Lewis remains suspended.

Eshays slammed over unbelievable act at a food court as locals fume over infuriating problem gripping their Sydney
Eshays slammed over unbelievable act at a food court as locals fume over infuriating problem gripping their Sydney

Daily Mail​

time2 hours ago

  • Daily Mail​

Eshays slammed over unbelievable act at a food court as locals fume over infuriating problem gripping their Sydney

A group of eshays have been labelled 'idiots' after footage emerged of them riding e-bikes through a busy food court. A shocked shopper filmed the outrageous act unfold outside George Street Event Cinemas, in Sydney 's CBD. The footage was shared to Reddit on Wednesday and showed four teens recklessly cruising past as shoppers looked on in muted astonishment. Social media users were unimpressed by the incident, taking aim at the infuriating abundance of e-bikes in the city. 'Am I the only person that really hates the things?' one said. 'They have made central Sydney look like a scrap dealer's yard.' 'As great an innovation that they are, e-scooters and bikes are going to cause more and more problems in the hands of idiots,' another said. The rise of share bikes and scooters in Australian cities in recent years has sparked concerns about cluttered footpaths, anti-social behaviour and safety of pedestrians. Last week, a 14-year-old boy died after he fell from an e-bike in Sydney, while accidents involving the modes of transport rose 300 per cent from 2023 to 2024. Lime is the company that operates the e-bikes and more than 1million of them and e-scooters are used by NSW locals, but the government is putting in place regulations after an inquiry looked at their use. It found that parking and pathway obstructions were increasing problems. NSW Transport Minister John Graham said last month that a set of rules would encourage the benefits of e-bikes and e-scooters while ensuring the safety of pedestrians sharing the paths and roads with them. 'We recognise the community's concerns, particularly around device modification, fire risk, discarded shared e-bikes and poor rider behaviour, which is why we're taking action,' he said. There's about 3,000 e-bikes for hire in Sydney while another 1,500 are being used for jobs like food delivery services. Some councils have already taken action due to safety fears with Waverley Council saying it would impound e-bikes if their operators did not reach an agreement to make their use safer and better regulated. Waverley Mayor Will Nemesh said at the time it was being proactive rather than waiting for an accident to happen before taking action. 'While share bikes are a State Government responsibility, Council will not stand by and wait for somebody to be injured,' he said. The riders who went through the food court on Wednesday were not going fast and some Aussies stuck up for the e-bikes. 'I love them. I don't have a car at the moment and getting up to the gym takes four minutes on the e-bike compared to 25 minutes on foot,' one person said. 'They'd be awesome in a country where the general population was mature though to handle it,' another said.

Footage emerges of terrifying crash that brought the Sydney Harbour Bridge to a standstill - as collision reignites calls for huge change
Footage emerges of terrifying crash that brought the Sydney Harbour Bridge to a standstill - as collision reignites calls for huge change

Daily Mail​

time4 hours ago

  • Daily Mail​

Footage emerges of terrifying crash that brought the Sydney Harbour Bridge to a standstill - as collision reignites calls for huge change

Terrifying footage has emerged of the horrific four-vehicle crash that shut down the Sydney Harbour Bridge as locals reignite calls for movable safety barriers. The cars collided on the southern side at about 8am on Wednesday, with two people rushed to hospital and four of the six lanes closed. Traffic backed up for kilometres, with queues reaching suburbs as far as Artarmon, Drummoyne and Woolloomooloo, as well as the Anzac Bridge. Dashcam footage showed a Kia hatchback driving northward before it drifted into the oncoming lane and clipped a blue Mitsubishi SUV. The SUV hit the vehicle beside it while the Kia collided head-on with another vehicle, immediately bringing traffic to a standstill. Separate footage from the scene showed a man on a stretcher being placed into the back of an ambulance after paramedics treated three patients at the scene. One was rushed to St Vincent's Hospital, while another was transported to Royal North Shore Hospital. Both were in stable conditions with minor injuries. The multi-vehicle crash has prompted locals to demand safety changes to the reversible lane system on the bridge and the installation of movable barriers. The calls were first made following a fatal crash in October when two men died after colliding head-on in the infamous 'suicide lane'. Jamal Choukri, 44, who was on his way to work in Botany in Sydney's south, at the time. A 51-year-old driver of a Hyundai i30, who was driving in the northbound lanes, crossed over into traffic in the southbound lanes before colliding with a Mercedes. The vehicle then hit Mr Choukri's Hyundai Accent and the two drivers died on impact. Sydneysiders have raised concerns about safety on the bridge and the digital direction signs that allow the flow of traffic to change directions on the interior lanes. The direction of lane four, better known by locals as the 'death' or 'suicide' lane, is often reversed after peak-hour traffic each morning, before servicing northbound lanes in the afternoon. Many agreed that concrete crash barriers or bollards needed to be installed on the bridge between the northbound and southbound traffic. Others wanted the reversible lane system done away with entirely. 'Variable lanes without a concrete physical barrier like they do on Victorian roads are simply dangerous,' one woman wrote online. The crash on Wednesday led to locals renewing calls for safety barriers. 'It's stupid: there's not a barrier between the opposing lanes. We have that on the Westgate Bridge and the Bolte Bridge,' one wrote. Another added: 'It's either physical barriers or it's bigger, brighter arrows.' 'I never understood why they are not using the Movable Lane Barrier like on the Auckland Harbour Bridge. I think the Kiwis had it for 35 years,' a third wrote. Transport for NSW said in October it would be considering the findings of a police investigation. 'In 2022, Transport installed clearer signage for motorists on the Bridge following a speed zone and signage review,' a spokeswoman said. 'The Sydney Harbour Bridge is not wide enough to fit a movable barrier system and retain all lanes in what is Sydney's most important traffic route. 'In 2015, following a serious collision, the use of a 'zipper' machine, similar to that used on Victoria Road at Drummoyne to move the barrier, was considered. However, it was found not to be suitable as it would force the removal of one lane from the bridge, reducing traffic capacity by 15 per cent.' Daily Mail Australia contacted Transport for NSW with regard to Wednesday's crash.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store