Former French officials cleared of accusations of pandemic mishandling
The decision comes five years after a top court in France opened an investigation into former Prime Minister Édouard Philippe, who stepped down in July 2020, as well as ex-health ministers Agnès Buzyn and Olivier Véran. They were accused of 'failing to fight disaster'.
Véran confirmed the decision in a post on the social media platform X.
'After years of proceedings, investigations, summonses, and public indictments, justice has spoken,' he wrote. 'We committed neither fault nor intentional failure'.
Véran replaced Buzyn as health minister in February 2020, when she resigned to run for mayor of Paris.
The Court of Justice of the Republic, the only French court that can investigate government officials while they are still in office, opened the case in July 2020 after receiving dozens of complaints from doctors, patients, law enforcement, and others about their response to the pandemic.
Chief among their complaints included shortages of masks and other equipment, as well as the decision to hold municipal elections on March 15, 2020, just a few days before French President Emmanuel Macron announced nationwide measures to prevent the spread of the virus.
Buzyn had also been indicted for endangering the lives of others in September 2021, but France's Court of Cassation dropped the charge in January 2023.
In his post on X, Véran said he had faced death threats and online misinformation during the probe into the 'hypothetical scandal'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
an hour ago
- LeMonde
EU prosecutors open probe into Le Pen's RN party and allies for misuse of funds
The European Union's prosecutor said Tuesday it has launched a formal investigation into a defunct far-right group, which included France's Rassemblement National (RN), over the alleged misuse of European Parliament funds. "The European Public Prosecutor's Office has opened an investigation," said a spokesperson for the agency that probes financial crimes against the bloc, said. A parliamentary report said the far-right Identity and Democracy (ID) political grouping, which was disbanded last year, was suspected of improperly spending 4.3 million euros ($5 million) between 2019 and 2024. The report was revealed earlier this month by Le Monde and its partners, German investigative television program Kontraste, the German magazine Die Zeit, and the Austrian weekly newspaper Falter. The ID group contained MEPs from a range of eurosceptic parties, including the RN of Marine Le Pen, the longtime standard bearer of the French far right, Italy's League and the Alternative for Germany. ID was formally disbanded after elections last year and was succeeded by a new grouping Patriots for Europe. The bulk of the allegedly misused funds benefited companies belonging to a former advisor to Le Pen and his wife. Le Pen ally Jordan Bardella, who now heads the Patriots group, said the probe represented a "new harassment operation by the European Parliament". The European Parliament said it "takes note of the decision" by the prosecutors to open the probe, first reported by Euractiv on Tuesday. "As always, parliament cooperates fully with national or European authorities if requested so," the parliament said. The investigation comes after Le Pen suffered a stunning blow in March when a French court convicted her and other party officials over an EU parliament fake jobs scam. The ruling, which Le Pen has appealed, banned her from standing for office for five years, which would scupper her ambition of taking part in the 2027 presidential vote.
Euronews
an hour ago
- Euronews
Marine Le Pen turns to European law in bid to overturn ineligibility ruling
Marine Le Pen has submitted a request to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) to examine the immediate application of the five-year ineligibility sentence she received after being found guilty in March of misusing public funds, an offence with estimated damages running into several million euros. The daughter of the far-right party's founder was sentenced to four years in prison, two of which are firm (but convertible into house arrest with an electronic tag), meaning she is unlikely to be incarcerated. She was also fined €100,000. In addition, the judge imposed a five-year ban from holding public office, which took immediate effect. Le Pen, who has announced she is appealing the ruling, has denounced the sentence as 'political' and 'unjust', criticising the immediate application of the ban as undemocratic. As it stands, she is barred from standing in the 2027 presidential election or even running as an MP if another snap parliamentary election were to be called. Being prevented from standing in upcoming elections represents a violation of human rights, the National Rally said in a statement. The party is calling for 'respect for the presumption of innocence' in Le Pen's case. Several like-minded political leaders, often critical of the European Union, have expressed their support for Le Pen: from former US President Donald Trump and Brazil's Jair Bolsonaro to Italy's Matteo Salvini and the Netherlands' Geert Wilders. Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán even posted 'Je suis Marine' on social media platform X, a reference to the 'Je suis Charlie' slogan that emerged in solidarity with French satirical newspaper Charlie Hebdo after the 2015 Islamist terror attack that killed 12 people. The ECHR is now expected to open an investigation to assess the legality of the immediate enforcement of Le Pen's ineligibility sentence.
Euronews
3 hours ago
- Euronews
Danish PM scolds fellow EU leaders for forgetting climate change
Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen on Tuesday scolded fellow EU leaders who have chosen to put aside the fight against the climate crisis for the sake of boosting competitiveness and cutting red tape. "It seems to me that because there are so many other things on the table and so many challenges that some colleagues are starting to forget that fighting climate change should be one of our top priorities," Frederiksen said in Strasbourg. Her reproach comes as Denmark assumes the rotating presidency of the EU Council, giving the country an enlarged role in the bloc's decision-making process, including the negotiations on a proposed target to slash carbon emissions by 90% by 2040. The talks will be heavily influenced by the growing right-wing backlash against the Green Deal, which has put Copenhagen in a shrinking minority of capitals that still believe the transition to net zero can be a driver of economic growth and high-quality jobs. "Unfortunately, I think all green decisions are going to be difficult in the next half a year. And I say unfortunately because I really believe we have to fight climate change," Frederiksen told reporters in the European Parliament. "We will do our best, but it looks difficult." The United Nations warns the world is getting "perilously close" to exceeding the Paris goal of limiting the rise of global temperatures to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels. "Of course, a new target when it comes to 2040 is important, but it's also important that we get rid of Russian oil and gas. For me, these two things are interlinked," the premier added, referring to the proposed phase-out of Russian fossil fuels by 2027, which Hungary and Slovakia vociferously oppose. "I want Europe to be independent from all angles, including energy." In recent months, a growing chorus of voices, such as Germany's Friedrich Merz, Italy's Giorgia Meloni and Poland's Donald Tusk, have become increasingly comfortable with their criticism against the Green Deal, arguing environmental laws should be drastically simplified – or, in some cases, outright repealed – to alleviate burdens for companies. French President Emmanuel Macron, a centrist who championed green policies in France and Europe, suggested the approval of the 2040 climate target should be delayed. "We must give ourselves the means to do so and make (the target) compatible with our competitiveness," Macron said at the end of an EU summit in June. The open contestation has left Ursula von der Leyen, the president of the European Commission, caught between the Green Deal, a key landmark of her first term, and mounting pressure to cut red tape as fast as practically possible. Von der Leyen has embraced a simplification agenda while insisting the objectives enshrined in the Green Deal, namely climate neutrality by 2050, would remain intact. But the backlash has also rattled the Commission, which last month unexpectedly announced the withdrawal of the Green Claims Directive, a draft law meant to combat "greenwashing" in advertising, and later reversed the move. The perceived backtracking has angered the socialists and the liberals in the Parliament, fuelling tension within the centrist coalition that re-elected von der Leyen. Standing by Frederiksen's side, European Parliament President Robert Metsola acknowledged the political arithmetic had shifted compared to the previous mandate, when most of the laws featured in the Green Deal received broad cross-party support. Conservative MEPs have set their sights on the 2035 ban on the combustion engine, the anti-deforestation law and green requirements in the Common Agricultural Policy. "I want to prove that Europe and this Parliament remain resolute in that direction of tackling climate change. What we also have to recognise is that this Parliament is different to the previous one," Metsola said. "There is an increasing number of members who, when they look back at what has been decided by the chamber, (believe) it's a symbol of having gone too far, too fast." Metsola's remarks came just hours after it was decided that the Parliament's rapporteur for the 2040 climate target would be assigned to the far-right Patriots for Europe (PfE) group, a selection that progressive forces immediately decried.
