Divisions emerge between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil over college fees
Fianna Fáil
and
Fine Gael
over the future of third-level fees, after recent suggestions from the
Minister for Higher Education James Lawless
that the end of
cost-of-living
packages would mean that the fees payable by students would increase.
Last night Tánaiste and Fine Gael leader Simon Harris sent a voice note to his party's TDs reassuring them that, contrary to the suggestions of the Fianna Fáil Minister, the budget would seek to reduce the costs of going to college.
'The budget will be agreed by Government with key input from the party leaders. But it does need to help families with the cost of putting a young person through college,' said Mr Harris.
'That's the programme for government that I've signed up for, it's the programme for government that Fine Gael has signed up for – one that commits to reducing fees.'
READ MORE
Mr Harris added: 'I know how middle Ireland is still really feeling the squeeze.'
The annual student contribution of €3,000 has been reduced by a €1,000 grant from the Government as part of its cost-of-living measures in recent budgets.
Mr Lawless said at the weekend that with no cost-of-living package due for this year, he will not have the funding to reduce the fees again, meaning that students could face a €1,000 increase next year.
On Monday a spokesman for the Minister said that he intended to reduce the cost of going to college as committed to in the programme for government.
'It is important to move on from temporary measures and into a more sustainable permanent system, but this may take a few budgets,' he said.
Sources said Mr Lawless intends to maximise assistance to those in need at the expense of universal benefits that all college students, including those from a wealthy background, receive.
But senior Fine Gael sources scoffed at the idea that Mr Lawless would reduce the cost of college by effectively increasing fees and warned that the party would insist that programme for government commitments were kept.
Fine Gael TD Maeve O'Connell said: 'Reducing the cost of education and helping hard-pressed families is important to Fine Gael and our party.
'Now is not the time to row back on commitments made by the party during the last election and by this Government,' she said, in an unusual criticism of a Minister by a Coalition TD.
Ms O'Connell contrasted the cost of cutting the college fees with the cost of social welfare increases.
'To put this in context, for every €1 increase in social welfare rates, the cost is approximately €75 to €80 million. A €1,000 reduction in the student contribution fee costs €99 million. These are the choices that the Government will need to make as part of the Budget,' she said.
Opposition TDs were quick to leap on the issue.
'It is incredibly unfair to leave students in limbo,' said Labour Senator Laura Harmon.
'College should not be a luxury. We need long-term thinking when it comes to education, not short-term accounting. This type of chaotic policymaking only adds to the stress already facing young people.'
Sinn Féin's Donna McGettigan said the 'Government's decision to hike up student fees by €1,000 is absolutely outrageous'.
Social Democrats spokeswoman Jen Cummins said: 'Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael need to get their act together and keep their commitments to students and families to reduce third-level fees'.
She said that Mr Lawless's comments were 'a bombshell' for students and parents.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Cork TDs clash over emigration figures as housing crisis forces more young people abroad
A war of words has erupted between two Cork TDs over the number of people emigrating as the housing crisis continues to take its toll. Colm Burke took exception to a speech made by Sinn Féin TD Thomas Gould at a housing rally in Cork where he told the crowd that "Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael have driven over 150,000 young people" out of the country. The Fine Gael TD responded with CSO figures which show that since 2020, 143,900 Irish citizens have left the country compared to 147,600 citizens who have returned. Looking solely at the number of people leaving the country and not acknowledging those who are returning does not give an accurate portrayal of the situation, Mr Burke said. There is also a need to look beyond the figures at the people included in them such as non-Irish citizens who arrived to study or work in Ireland on a temporary basis and are now returning home, he noted. In any country, you will have young people who move abroad to experience other cultures and those - for example, doctors and nurses - who get work experience abroad for a period of time before coming home, Mr Burke added. However, Mr Gould has said he stands over the figure he quoted at the rally saying he believes it was actually a conservative estimate. He cites data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics which showed over 103,000 Irish-born people were living there in June 2024. That figure does not take into account the number of Irish people who have moved to other countries around the world nor those who have moved to Australia over the past year. Mr Gould said he has young people in his constituency that are coming to him every week telling him that they are leaving the country because they cannot afford a home. One young working couple, for example, came to his office as they had received a notice to quit and are earning too much to go on the social housing list. Thomas Gould cites data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics which showed over 103,000 Irish-born people were living there in June 2024. "They have applied for affordable housing but there are so many people applying so they are going into a lottery and if they don't come out of the lottery, they are going to be homeless," Mr Gould said. Mr Burke said there is no question there are challenges in relation to housing that need to be resolved. "I have a very strong view that we should bring in tax incentives again to get money back into investment in housing," he said, although he would not like to see a re-introduction of incentives seen around 2008.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘Splitting' raises questions about oversight of Help to Buy scheme, says Simon Harris
Tánaiste Simon Harris has said the issue of 'splitting' a Help to Buy transaction raises important questions over the oversight of the Government scheme He was speaking after estate agent Sherry FitzGerald launched an internal investigation after a home buyer was offered a 'split' sale for a new-build property , in order for it to qualify for the Help to Buy scheme. The case was first reported in The Irish Times on Tuesday . Mr Harris reaffirmed the Government's commitment to the scheme for the lifetime of the Coalition, but he said that important questions had been raised by the issue of 'split' sales. 'When issues like that come to the fore it does raise important questions in relation to the oversight of the scheme,' he said. Mr Harris said he had total confidence in the Revenue Commissioners operation of the scheme but added that it was ultimately taxpayers money being used. READ MORE 'It's important that the integrity of the scheme is protected at all costs.' He said the Government would await any guidance or advice from the Revenue Commissioners or the Department of Finance in relation to the scheme. The Help to Buy (HTB) scheme is administered by Revenue and provides a refund on income tax of up to €30,000 to first-time buyers on new-build properties up to a value of €500,000. Social Democrats ' spokesman on housing Rory Hearne said it was 'alarming to see evidence of such blatant breaches of the scheme'. 'Questions need to be answered now about how widespread this issue is and if this case is just the tip of the iceberg,' the Dublin North-West TD said. The story 'shows that estate agents are playing a role in pushing for and facilitating higher house prices, which developers are also lobbying for'. [ The 'emotional toll' of buying a home in Ireland: 'split' deals and queueing for houses already sold Opens in new window ] 'The Government has done nothing to challenge the various market actors pushing up house prices, and has actually added to and facilitated house price inflation through the help to buy schemes. We need to see proper regulation and transparency in the house purchase market to stop the price gouging going on now,' Mr Hearne said. Mr Harris also spoke about the potential impact of trade tensions between the United States and the European Union as the clock ticks down on a 90-day tariff pause to charges announced by the White House earlier this year. The Tánaiste said this week would be an 'extremely intense' period in trying to secure a framework agreement between Brussels and Washington. He said that at the very least, the aim was to provide a sense of certainty where there was a 'vacuum' at the moment. He said the current situation was 'holding back people in terms of jobs decisions and investment decisions. We need clarity and certainty as to what the trade environment works like.' He said Europe and Ireland wanted to see 'zero-for-zero' tariffs as widely as possible and that the Dublin Government was working hard on the issue of pharmaceutical exports to the United States.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Ireland's water infrastructure now main block on growth, committee hears
Ireland's water infrastructure is now one of the main constraints on the economy, limiting the supply of housing and other infrastructure, the Oireachtas Committee on Budgetary Oversight was told on Tuesday. 'Ireland is a very heavy user of water and that's why we're struggling to keep up,' Irish Fiscal Advisory Council's (Ifac) chief economist Niall Conroy told the committee. Members of Ifac appeared before the committee on Tuesday to discuss the economy and other issues. 'When we looked at how Ireland's infrastructure compares to other countries in Europe, we actually found that Ireland, for water, was about average, which we were surprised at,' he said. READ MORE The problem lies more with demand, he said, noting the State's pharma, data centre and tech industries were big users of water. Uisce Éireann , formerly Irish Water, has already stated that it will not be able to support much more than 35,000 new house completions a year 'in terms of connecting them up' without additional funding, he said. [ Coalition spending overrun likely to be more than €2bn this year Opens in new window ] Ifac chairman Seamus Coffey said there was capacity within the economy to ramp up the production of the water infrastructure 'but it is certainly a bottleneck that is slowing down the economy'. In his opening address to the committee, Mr Coffey said Ireland's infrastructure was about 25 per cent behind its peers. 'Regardless of what happens to the international environment, these infrastructure deficits need to be addressed,' he said. 'If the economy weathers the changing environment, it will have high levels of employment and high demand for infrastructure,' Mr Coffey said. IATA Director General Willie Walsh on airline profits, air fares and why the Dublin Airport passenger cap makes Ireland a laughing stock Listen | 35:56 'If there is some form of downturn, then having adequate infrastructure would be key to restoring low unemployment and a prosperous society,' he said. Mr Coffey said the Government needed to ensure budgetary policy reduces the ups and downs of the economic cycle. 'This means showing restraint when the economy is strong and being more generous when the economy is struggling,' he said. Mr Coffey warned that overruns in day-to-day public spending are likely to top €2 billion this year. [ EU's new fiscal rules pose risk to public finances - Ifac Opens in new window ] 'The Government needs to improve how it forecasts spending. When formulating Budget 2025, the department didn't account for the money they were going to overspend in 2024 when planning for 2025,' he said. 'This created unrealistic budget figures from the beginning – a problem that keeps recurring. To avoid repeating this mistake, Budget 2026 and future medium-term plans must start with accurate baseline figures that includes all likely overspends in 2025,' he said. 'Otherwise, spending projections will be wrong from the outset,' he said. Ifac has previously criticised the Government for pursuing what it describes as an 'everything now' approach to spending by simultaneously presiding over tax cuts, higher day-to-day spending, a continued ramp-up in capital investment and for fuelling domestic price pressures by providing across the board cost-of-living supports. Mr Coffey also said Ireland currently had no effective framework for fiscal policy. 'The European fiscal rules don't work well for Ireland. They rely on GDP (gross domestic product) and ignore the risks linked to corporation tax,' he said. 'As a result, Ireland is unlikely to face external scrutiny at an EU level,' he said.
